• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Lobellia Sackville-Baggins

How do you feel about Lobellia?

  • I love her! She has spunk.

    Votes: 2 5.4%
  • I like her

    Votes: 3 8.1%
  • She amuses me.

    Votes: 17 45.9%
  • I'm indifferent.

    Votes: 5 13.5%
  • I pity her.

    Votes: 8 21.6%
  • I dislike her.

    Votes: 7 18.9%
  • I hate her and that's that.

    Votes: 6 16.2%
  • I hate her. She has spunk.

    Votes: 2 5.4%
  • Who are we talking about again?

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    37

HLGStrider

All Knowing Magic Cat
Joined
Dec 17, 2001
Messages
7,750
She's always intrigued me. I love to hate her. I find her very funny. ..how do you feel about Lobellia? Do you like her? Hate her? Loathe her? Pity her?

In some ways I pity her. . .but mostly she just amuses me.

You?

Personally my favorite bits are when she yells out "I'LL GIVE YOU SHARKY!"

My least favorite is where she decides to make off with a few items from Bag End. . .but even that is funny.
 
Lobelia is one of several hobbits that are less than perfect. It's fun to read about all the little evils before you get into to the serious quest and GOOD vs. EVIL.
 
I like her... from a safe distance :D. In the book she always amuses me. In real life I'd probably laugh a lot at her...
 
Awesome poll ideas, this together with Bilbo's Presents, HLGStrider! :)

Lobelia makes me chuckle, remembering a little old neighbor-lady I once knew. This endearingly snoopy woman had earned quite a reputation for the following types of doings:

A) putting out buckets to catch rain water so she wouldn't have to pay the city for water

B) in exchange for having the lane shoveled out after a snowstorm, paying the shoveller a grand total of one dime and a half-eaten box of junior mints

C) alternately putting her hand to her mouth as though it were the horn of Gondor and then waving it about to get your attention if you were on the other side of the street, all the while calling out, "Yoo hoo! Oh, yoo hoo !!"

..... and yes, she was quite an avid mushroom hunter! :)

Lobelia Sackville Baggins, however, has a darker, malignant, dangerous side that fortunately I never detected in my neighbor.
 
Yeah, Lobellia amuses me to a certain extent. I sure wouldn't want her as a relative of mine, however ;)
 
I could handle her as a boss . . .she's probably make a very good restaurant manager.
 
Haha she greatly amuses me (although I forgot to check the box) And I feel pity that she got such embarasing presents from Bilbo!!
 
For pitying her I was thinking her sad end, dying alone after being arrested, her only child, as miserable a child as he was, dead, her husband dead, etc. . .she seemed a lot nicer in the end too.

If less interesting. .. .


Oh, and I forgot to say Welcome to GandalftheGray. An Americanized GandalftheGrey no doubt. ;)

You can call me Elgee. . .and as I say to all newbies, I'm EVERYWHERE!
 
"For pitying her I was thinking her sad end, dying alone after being arrested, her only child, as miserable a child as he was, dead, her husband dead, etc. . .she seemed a lot nicer in the end too."

Yeah... Put that in my response too... :D
 
It's fun to read about all the little evils
Lobelia Sackville Baggins, however, has a darker, malignant, dangerous side that fortunately I never detected in my neighbor
Personally, I've never really seen Lobelia as "evil", persay. I see her as one of the more "human" hobbits, and I can empathise with her because of that. She is greedy and rude, but I get the feeling she's mostly just scared and jealous of the fun, simple times the other hobbits are having.

Lobelia strikes me as one of those old people who moan about "young 'uns" and "how it was in my day", but actually just long for a chance to be young themselves again. Lobelia is greedy because wealth is a way of replacing this empty feeling she feels now she is no longer centre of attention. One can imagine, a long time before Bilbo was born, he being a beautiful, fun loving young hobbit, courting Otho (is that her husband's name?).

At the very end, where she mellows out after Otho dies, is when she finally accepts her own mortality and shortcomings. I find it a really sad and poignant part of the story.
 
Originally posted by Rhiannon
At the beginning I hate her. At the end I pity her.
Yeah,I would say I agree with you.You managed to compile all your feelings towards her in two sentences.Two sentences which best describe my feelings too.
 
She amuses me. Even the little not-so-nice things that she does amuse me.
 
In the beginning (and in the Hobbit) I loathed her. Absolutely loathed her. What a little *****. :D
But after I began to understand the reasons and motivation for her sour behaviour, I began to pity her. And in the Scouring of the Shire (which I am furious about because it won't be in the movie!!!! :mad:) she has such courage and strength of will that I actually begin to like the old dingbat. :)

But Lotho was a bas**** to the end.
 
Basket only has three stars, Lanty ;)

To be fair, Lotho was greedy for power, but he did try to pay people back when Sharky's men first started. He was just a low grade criminal with a conscience. Lobelia - now I think there is a Lobelia in every family. Lobelia is the one who is aggrieved at every reading of a will because of the miserable portion she receives; but continues to receive only token legacies because no-one can stand her and would rather leave the lot to a cats home.

Tolkien's Lobelia eventually learns her true priorities, though, when she learns of the death of her beloved Lotho, and Bag End is no longer important to her, or even desirable.
 
Heck, I have nice relatives and it would still be tempting to leave my money to a cats' home. . .got to love kitties!
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top