• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Most evil person in LotRs?

Which villian do you "love to hate" the most?

  • Sauron

    Votes: 9 19.1%
  • Saruman

    Votes: 8 17.0%
  • Witch-King

    Votes: 6 12.8%
  • Gollum

    Votes: 4 8.5%
  • Balrog

    Votes: 1 2.1%
  • Shelob

    Votes: 6 12.8%
  • Barrow Wights

    Votes: 3 6.4%
  • The Undead (of the paths of the dead)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Gríma Wormtongue

    Votes: 7 14.9%
  • Other

    Votes: 3 6.4%

  • Total voters
    47
I never disliked any of the characters on the poll. The ones I really hated are the filthy pointy ears! ;)
 
Wow, this poll has been up for 4 and a half hours, and I'm the first to vote for Sauron? :eek:

Am I mistaken in voting for Sauron? Coz' I thought that this was the dude who made everyone else evil. :confused:

BTW, why is PJ included in this poll? For one thing, I don't quite remember him being in the Lord of the Rings.
 
I chose Shelob cause I don't like spiders.

Well, the pole said, which one do you "love to hate" most not which was was most evil. I dislike Shelob even more than Sauron, because Sauron at least is mighty, is strong, has a pride aura about him. Shelob on the other hand has all its thoughtses on food, yesss precioussss.
 
Sauron was a too clear-cut personification of evil; Melkor was cool, and the epitome of evil, but Sauron didn't quite pull it off for me. Well he did of course, exclelently, but not in the same way as Melkor did. ("You're the only one!" :D)
I was and still am fascinated with the Barrow-Wights, and their tragic history, and their unspecified natures.. They are, for me, the personification of fear in the novel. Of course the Nazgûl do this too, but the Barrow-Wights are just this sort of legendary mist, which is very real nonetheless! Love those guys. :D
 
Saruman, because there's nothing quite so dark and treacherous as a good guy gone irrevocably bad.
 
Gildor said:
Saruman, because there's nothing quite so dark and treacherous as a good guy gone irrevocably bad.
I think along the same lines! The worst hate for a person you can develop is one who has betrayed your trust. Especially if this person is one you idolize, or recognize as your superior.
 
ok, why is peter jackson in this poll???? HE sways the votes!!!! Recount!!!
 
Peeeeeter Jackson would slay all the baddies by gathering them to watch the Two Towers repeatedly. This is the new bad guy in Tolkiens unrealeased book titled " The War of the Marshmellow Man." Two Towers film very bad. :mad:
 
meneldor said:
Peeeeeter Jackson would slay all the baddies by gathering them to watch the Two Towers repeatedly. This is the new bad guy in Tolkiens unrealeased book titled " The War of the Marshmellow Man." Two Towers film very bad.
Personally, I'd like to congratulate PJ for getting more people to read the books.

At any rate, I'm voting for the Witch-King. The Nazgûl are simply my favorite evil characters.
 
Come to think of it, I never really hated any of the evil characters except Grima, he just got on my nerves. Most evil people are cool unless they are cowards.
 
I agree, Grima was the worst, I don't know why, but I just hate him the most, so I chose "other".
 
The pollmaster speaketh to ye!

Sauron was a too clear-cut personification of evil; Melkor was cool, and the epitome of evil, but Sauron didn't quite pull it off for me.

RE: I didn't include Melkor-Morgoth, Eol, Glaurung, etc. Because the poll is about The Lord of the Rings, NOT all of Middle-Earth's histories, and mythologies and tales. Though I would've gladly tried if I could've had 2 score poll options! LOL​

Come to think of it, I never really hated any of the evil characters except Grima,...
RE: DDDOOOO'HHHHHHHH!!!! I knew I forgot someone!!!:(​

I'm glad most of ye readeth the line of "love to hate" as I reckon that one of "most evil person" would have been made long ago.

Lomin...
 
Very well then, firstly, I voted for Sauron, because he had this way of making you believe he was behind all the other villians even if he wasn't, like in the case of Shelob. You could never help wondering what passed through that foul mind, what treachery was contemplated there; feeling somehow that he must know your every thought and there could be no escape from him.

Secondly, however, Peter Jackson (who, I note, never appeared in the books, which is what this section is devoted to) is the real villian because he RUINED the otherwise most perfectly evil, malicious being ever devised. He took all that wonderful subtlety of a devious mind at work and turned it into a 100,000,000 candle-power "Spotlight of Doom"!
 
Ok, since 'Peter Jackson' now has as much as 25% of the overall votes I think it's time to let him go. :rolleyes: I'll put Gríma in his place, everybody who voted for PJ here might be able to re-vote, I'm not sure how that works actually.. :eek: If it turns out that you cannot re-vote, those people are welcome to PM me and say which choice they want their vote in.
Lomin... said:
RE: I didn't include Melkor-Morgoth, Eol, Glaurung, etc. Because the poll is about The Lord of the Rings, NOT all of Middle-Earth's histories, and mythologies and tales.
Yes I know; I was just justifying or explaining my choice in the full context of the works. :)
 
I also now realize I forgot "The Mouth of Sauron". I thought he was quite dispisable.

Note: I did vote for Jackson and I can't revote, but that's OK with me(the whole thing was a half joke anyway). I'm just informing you.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top