Very well then, firstly, I voted for
Sauron, because he had this way of making you believe he was behind all the other villians even if he wasn't, like in the case of
Shelob. You could never help wondering what passed through that foul mind, what treachery was contemplated there; feeling somehow that he must know your every thought and there could be no escape from him.
Secondly, however, Peter Jackson (who, I note, never appeared in the
books, which is what this section is devoted to) is the
real villian because he RUINED the otherwise most perfectly
evil, malicious being ever devised. He took all that wonderful subtlety of a devious mind at work and turned it into a 100,000,000 candle-power "Spotlight of Doom"!