simbelmyne
Member
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2003
- Messages
- 322
joxy said:I have to say that I have NEVER seen a spelling mistake in one of YOUR postings.
joxy said:As I was specificially referring to SOME people, I was stating a fact, not offering a theory.
As I have reached no conclusion that correct spelling is REQUIRED before clear thinking can be achieved, I cannot specify a route by which such a conclusion might be achieved.
It would be a much easier world to understand, and a pleasanter one, if that were a universal rule!Foe-Hammer said:....clear thinking is a prerequiset to words.
....what goes on here can be characterized more as people being lazy spellers
I have to do a double take just to make sure what there (they're) saying.
joxy said:It would be a much easier world to understand, and a pleasanter one, if that were a universal rule!
We would have NO "psychobabble" and politicians would rarely make speeches at all!
My general point was that being a "lazy speller" MAY be an indication of being a "lazy thinker".
Of course, you are right to say that the inverse of that may also occur.
And that is an example of why accurate spelling, especially in English, is often a compliment to the reader:
bad spelling forces the reader to do just that sort of double-take, and not ONLY about the misplaced apostrophe!
Rowan Evensong said:I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book.
Nobody went to these movies ready to hate them because "they weren't the book". This is nothing more than anti-purist sentiment conjured up out of nowhere. Myself, joxy and I suspect (even though Foe-Hammer would be loathe to entertain the thought) Mrs. Maggot, went to these movies with apprehension yet still went hoping to see Tolkien's magic captured on screen (even knowing some of the drastic changes). For the most part many of us felt let down. Why? Not because of changes in general, but because of Jackson's intent to change the meanings, characters and plot lines NEEDLESSLY while instituting his own brand of storytelling (i.e. trying to retell LoTR in his own clumsy fashion) all the while telling people that changes had to be made and edits had to happen due to time restraints.Rowan Evensong said:I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book.
And that is a positive thing. However it saddens me to think that many of the 'attention span like the life of a fruit fly' generation will toss the books because they are "too boring" and walk away thinking Arwen kicking butt at the Fords was "just awesome!!"Rowan Evensong said:The net result will be, more people will experience Tolkien. More poeple will have read his work. More will read The Hobbit and the Silmarillion. How can anything bad come from that?
Again - and yet again ad nauseum - NO ONE - still less any "purist" I know (including myself) - expected a verbatim translation of the book to film. That excuse is so old, it is eligible for Medicare!Rowan Evensong said:If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the books on film, that was more than a little naive. I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book. The movies can never replace the books, and nobody should feel threatened by the films. Three types of people saw the movie:
1. Those that have read and loved the books.
2. Those that had not yet read the books, but will now.
3. Those that have not nor will ever read them.
Category 1 already knows the books, and nothing about the movies could ever diminish the books. Those in category 2 will discover an even richer and deeper experience, much more so than 10 hours of film could ever provide. The people in category 3...well, I just plain pity them.
The net result will be, more people will experience Tolkien. More poeple will have read his work. More will read The Hobbit and the Silmarillion. How can anything bad come from that?
Mrs. Maggott said:Again - and yet again ad nauseum - NO ONE - still less any "purist" I know (including myself) - expected a verbatim translation of the book to film. That excuse is so old, it is eligible for Medicare!
Mrs. Maggott said:The problems with the films have been posted so often and in such detail that I won't waste anyone's time (including my own) listing them again - especially as it appears that they are continually ignored and/or dismissed by film defenders.
I also can't find anywhere in Rowan's post where s/he stated that the length of the movies made them good films...The fact that the films were long doesn't make them good. I recently watched a DVD of Whale Rider and found it excellent. In fact, my husband (who read LOTR when he was in high school and as he's now 65, he has no problem with the films vis a vie the book) considered Whale Rider to be artistically superior to ROTK which he found the least good of the three films! In his opinion, FOTR was best by far. TTT was confusing and the battle sequences too many and too long. As for ROTK, he found the "holes" in the plot to be much more obvious than either of the other two films and the c.g. battle sequences inferior to both FOTR and TTT. And that's the opinion of someone who is certainly NO "purist".
Are you saying you have viewed each movie of the trilogy 2 or 3 times only???As for F. H.'s statement regarding purists seeing the film many times to find more to complain about_: he may be right with some, but certainly not in my case! I saw it once (bad seating - too close) and I will probably see it once more (better seating, hopefully) when we take my son who hasn't seen it, but after that I shall not see it again. Doubtless, my husband will get the EE to go with the other two, but once a year or even once every other year will be more than enough for me - if I see it that often.
Just a guess, but I'd go with her and she.Gandalf White said:You said this in response to Rowan's post. Try as I might, I can not find his attempt to use this argument as an excuse...
I also can't find anywhere in Rowan's post where s/he stated that the length of the movies made them good films...
I've been here quite a while and I've never seen anything to suggest these ideas of yours about people feeling "threatened byRowan Evensong said:I think many purists did indeed go expecting to hate the movies. In fact, I know some that have said so, and others that expressed great sorrow the movies were even made,
It looks like a bunch of people that some how feel threatened by the movies, that somehow the movie adaptations diminish the books in some way.
Gandalf White said:You said this in response to Rowan's post. Try as I might, I can not find his attempt to use this argument as an excuse...
I also can't find anywhere in Rowan's post where s/he stated that the length of the movies made them good films...
"as if"Rowan Evensong said:"Mrs M" did reply as if I believed that purists expected a verbatim reproduction....
Mrs M seemed to suggest I had implied the that the movies were somehow "good" because they were "long."
This is what I mean by purists wishing it had never been done.
This is where I disagree and where many FADs lose sight of the purist argument. We don't hate the movies, nor do we hate Jackson. We don't expect word for word verbatim or that it meshes nicely with our own imagination.Rowan Evensong said:Of course the movies do not live up to the books. You would need about 300 billion dollars, technology that does not yet exist, and a minimum of 30 hours worth of film to begin to capture the story.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?