Rowan Evensong said:
....when she quotes me, then replies, she is rebutting me. If her replies were general in nature, then she should note have quoted my post verbatim. She should have made her replies independant of my prior observations.
But the fact is, Mrs M rebutted two points that I did not attempt to make, thus framing my post out of context.
I clearly said that I did not believe purists went expecting a verbatim adaptation.
For "rebutting", read "disagreeing". Is that a problem?
You said "if a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the
books on film, that was more than a little naive."
Mrs M pointed out that, in her opinion, which I share, there are no "people who went expecting a verbatim retelling".
You speculated, by using the word "if", on the possibility that such people existed; Mrs M said they do not exist. I accept, and I am sure Mrs M accepts, that your statement was only a speculation, but I have to add that I did not see the further statement, to which you refer above, that in fact you did NOT now believe that the speculation was valid, that "I did not believe purists went expecting a verbatim adaptation". Perhaps you would specify where you made that statement, and may I mention my posting #335 on the same topic.
On the second "rebutting", it really wasn't one! It was inspired by your mention of the length of the films, but then had no further personal relevance to you.
Regarding the point that Mrs M should not have quoted ALL of your posting, I have to mention that this is something that often happens here, that people do not necessarily remove all parts of a quotation that are not strictly relevant. They mean no harm!
Also, I believe you commented, quite rightly, on the title of this thread. It goes back to the release of FOTR, and has had Parts I and II previously; it was a bit of mischievous fun by the person who started it, and we have all learned to live with it since then.
I hope you will come to view it in that same light.