simbelmyne
Member
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2003
- Messages
- 322
Rowan Evensong said:...the movies...were simply one man's best attempt to translate HIS interpretation of the book of the 20th century to an entirely different medium.
First off, welcome to the Forum!
Yes, this was a difficult undertaking. I agree that its easier to critisize someone else's hard work after the fact, and I think its a shame when people see these movies with a closed mind, determined to find fault.
However, does that mean EVERYONE should turn a blind eye when there is substantial evidence that PJ did NOT always make his best attempt? PJ is an ARTISTIC filmmaker who chose to make these movies, loudly proclaiming he wanted to remain true to the spirit of Tolkien, changing only what he needed to to make the movie work. He created this duty - he is being held up to the standard he has created for himself. If you had asked me after FOTR, I would have said he filled it.
But over the course of the trilogy (especially TTT), he decided to take the low road...many cheap laughs that disrespected the characters, the gaping holes in plot lines he either hoped we wouldn't notice or didn't care if we did, and poorly written characters with inconsistancies that leave movie-goers scratching their heads. The brilliant parts of the movies leave me in no doubt he was capable of doing better. Instead of taking the time and energy to think through the changed plot lines and develop characters, he got lazy and took the easy way out.
