If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the
books on film, that was more than a little naive. I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book. The movies can never replace the books, and nobody should feel threatened by the films. Three types of people saw the movie:
1. Those that have read and loved the books.
2. Those that had not yet read the books, but will now.
3. Those that have not nor will ever read them.
Category 1 already knows the books, and nothing about the movies could ever diminish the books. Those in category 2 will discover an even richer and deeper experience, much more so than 10 hours of film could ever provide. The people in category 3...well, I just plain pity them.
The net result will be, more people will experience
Tolkien. More poeple will have read his work. More will read The
Hobbit and
the Silmarillion. How can anything bad come from that?