• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

joxy said:
I have to say that I have NEVER seen a spelling mistake in one of YOUR postings.

I might be more inclined to believe this if I did not remember that once you quoted something I said, and kindly fixed my spelling error in the quote :) :p

Mrs. M, what happened to your legal document? :eek: One time I mailed a package without an address on it at all. :( :rolleyes: The embarrassing part was explaining to the post office what happened. It was never seen again, sad since it was a present for my mom *sigh*
 
joxy said:
As I was specificially referring to SOME people, I was stating a fact, not offering a theory.
As I have reached no conclusion that correct spelling is REQUIRED before clear thinking can be achieved, I cannot specify a route by which such a conclusion might be achieved.

I only ask because clear thinking is a prerequiset to words. spelling those words would be achieved as you created them. Ideas are formed and words are created after. a person is completely capable of presenting ideas and not spell a single word correctly. The idea of water is completely understood regardless of it's spelling. Agua, vassa, water, wuter.

I believe that what goes on here can be characterized more as people being lazy spellers and that has no bearing on their ability to organize thought. I have found the opposite to be true. I have found people to be so entirely engrossed in spelling that they have a difficult time presenting rational arguments.

The only mis-spelling I have a problem with is not really a spelling error. A lot of people use "your" in place of "you're" and because they have different meanings, I have to do a double take just to make sure what there (they're ;) ) saying.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
....clear thinking is a prerequiset to words.
....what goes on here can be characterized more as people being lazy spellers
I have to do a double take just to make sure what there (they're ;) ) saying.
It would be a much easier world to understand, and a pleasanter one, if that were a universal rule!
We would have NO "psychobabble" and politicians would rarely make speeches at all!
My general point was that being a "lazy speller" MAY be an indication of being a "lazy thinker".
Of course, you are right to say that the inverse of that may also occur.
And that is an example of why accurate spelling, especially in English, is often a compliment to the reader:
bad spelling forces the reader to do just that sort of double-take, and not ONLY about the misplaced apostrophe!
 
joxy said:
It would be a much easier world to understand, and a pleasanter one, if that were a universal rule!
We would have NO "psychobabble" and politicians would rarely make speeches at all!
My general point was that being a "lazy speller" MAY be an indication of being a "lazy thinker".
Of course, you are right to say that the inverse of that may also occur.
And that is an example of why accurate spelling, especially in English, is often a compliment to the reader:
bad spelling forces the reader to do just that sort of double-take, and not ONLY about the misplaced apostrophe!

Yeah, but the difference between "their" and "thier" or "sited" and "cited" is so obvious, to dwell on it to the point where it is distracting when it is obvious laziness is just too obsessive for a place like this.
 
It was a wonderful movie trilogy.

If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the books on film, that was more than a little naive. I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book. The movies can never replace the books, and nobody should feel threatened by the films. Three types of people saw the movie:

1. Those that have read and loved the books.

2. Those that had not yet read the books, but will now.

3. Those that have not nor will ever read them.

Category 1 already knows the books, and nothing about the movies could ever diminish the books. Those in category 2 will discover an even richer and deeper experience, much more so than 10 hours of film could ever provide. The people in category 3...well, I just plain pity them.

The net result will be, more people will experience Tolkien. More poeple will have read his work. More will read The Hobbit and the Silmarillion. How can anything bad come from that?
 
Rowan Evensong said:
I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book.

LOL! And they continue to see it muliple times just to find more stuff that they can be pissed about!
 
Rowan Evensong said:
I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book.
Nobody went to these movies ready to hate them because "they weren't the book". This is nothing more than anti-purist sentiment conjured up out of nowhere. Myself, joxy and I suspect (even though Foe-Hammer would be loathe to entertain the thought) Mrs. Maggot, went to these movies with apprehension yet still went hoping to see Tolkien's magic captured on screen (even knowing some of the drastic changes). For the most part many of us felt let down. Why? Not because of changes in general, but because of Jackson's intent to change the meanings, characters and plot lines NEEDLESSLY while instituting his own brand of storytelling (i.e. trying to retell LoTR in his own clumsy fashion) all the while telling people that changes had to be made and edits had to happen due to time restraints.

I liked RoTK but hated the theatre version of FoTR. Maggot like FoTR. Had Arwen and Saruman been portrayed like the book instead of Jackson's caricatures, I would have given FoTR EE a huge thumbs up for adaptation (as it was it was still good). None of us went in to these movies looking to hate it. We went in and said, "Alright Jackson. We know you can't bring all of LoTR to the screen, but show us what you did!" And sadly, Jackson (for the most part as a whole trilogy) fell short.
Rowan Evensong said:
The net result will be, more people will experience Tolkien. More poeple will have read his work. More will read The Hobbit and the Silmarillion. How can anything bad come from that?
And that is a positive thing. However it saddens me to think that many of the 'attention span like the life of a fruit fly' generation will toss the books because they are "too boring" and walk away thinking Arwen kicking butt at the Fords was "just awesome!!"
 
Rowan Evensong said:
If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the books on film, that was more than a little naive. I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book. The movies can never replace the books, and nobody should feel threatened by the films. Three types of people saw the movie:

1. Those that have read and loved the books.

2. Those that had not yet read the books, but will now.

3. Those that have not nor will ever read them.

Category 1 already knows the books, and nothing about the movies could ever diminish the books. Those in category 2 will discover an even richer and deeper experience, much more so than 10 hours of film could ever provide. The people in category 3...well, I just plain pity them.

The net result will be, more people will experience Tolkien. More poeple will have read his work. More will read The Hobbit and the Silmarillion. How can anything bad come from that?
Again - and yet again ad nauseum - NO ONE - still less any "purist" I know (including myself) - expected a verbatim translation of the book to film. That excuse is so old, it is eligible for Medicare!

The problems with the films have been posted so often and in such detail that I won't waste anyone's time (including my own) listing them again - especially as it appears that they are continually ignored and/or dismissed by film defenders.

The fact that the films were long doesn't make them good. I recently watched a DVD of Whale Rider and found it excellent. In fact, my husband (who read LOTR when he was in high school and as he's now 65, he has no problem with the films vis a vie the book) considered Whale Rider to be artistically superior to ROTK which he found the least good of the three films! In his opinion, FOTR was best by far. TTT was confusing and the battle sequences too many and too long. As for ROTK, he found the "holes" in the plot to be much more obvious than either of the other two films and the c.g. battle sequences inferior to both FOTR and TTT. And that's the opinion of someone who is certainly NO "purist".

As for F. H.'s statement regarding purists seeing the film many times to find more to complain about: he may be right with some, but certainly not in my case! I saw it once (bad seating - too close) and I will probably see it once more (better seating, hopefully) when we take my son who hasn't seen it, but after that I shall not see it again. Doubtless, my husband will get the EE to go with the other two, but once a year or even once every other year will be more than enough for me - if I see it that often.
 
I gracefully disagree.

I think many purists did indeed go expecting to hate the movies. In fact, I know some that have said so, and others that expressed great sorrow the movies were even made, before their release even. Perhaps better put, many went with a mental tally sheet in their heads, waiting to pounce upon the films and catalogue every instance where the movie divurged from the book. As the movies went on, they gleefully began to compose their critiques. Only you can know your own heart and know if you were one of them.

Where the movies perfect adaptations? Heavens no, nor would any sensible Tolkien fan claim they were. They were simply one man's best attempt to translate HIS interpretation of the book of the 20th century to an entirely different medium. A daunting task to say the least, and one Tolkien fans ought to have the good grace to thank him (and the studio that placed an awful lot of faith and money in him) for doing. Would you have made a different movie? Of course! Do you think that every reader of Tolkien has the same experience upon reading it? Of course they do not. Jackson's movie was based on what HE experienced from reading the books, and what he believed could be translated to a much shallower medium.

The question this all begs then, is DID he "capture the magic" of Tolkien? I say he did. The movies, just like the books, have to be viewed in a larger context than a scene by scene comparison. I thought for the most part, overall characterizations were good and accurate. There were some exceptions, obviously. I guess its up to each person to decide for themselves whether they wanted to focus on the 90% of the movies that worked, versus the 10% that didn't really fit well.

I'm a newcomer to this board, so let me relate to you how this thread appears to someone just newly arrived. It looks like a bunch of people that some how feel threatened by the movies, that somehow the movie adaptations diminish the books in some way. Nothing could be furthur from the truth. Lord of the Rings is my favorite "book" and it is now also my favorite movie trilogy. Neither are perfect. Both are beautiful and special in their own unique way. I consider the book a greater achievement, but literature will always be a superior medium to film. There are so many fewer restrictions.

Peace.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
Again - and yet again ad nauseum - NO ONE - still less any "purist" I know (including myself) - expected a verbatim translation of the book to film. That excuse is so old, it is eligible for Medicare!

You said this in response to Rowan's post. Try as I might, I can not find his attempt to use this argument as an excuse...

Mrs. Maggott said:
The problems with the films have been posted so often and in such detail that I won't waste anyone's time (including my own) listing them again - especially as it appears that they are continually ignored and/or dismissed by film defenders.

The same way our arguments are ignored/dismissed by the "NPW's"? :rolleyes:

The fact that the films were long doesn't make them good. I recently watched a DVD of Whale Rider and found it excellent. In fact, my husband (who read LOTR when he was in high school and as he's now 65, he has no problem with the films vis a vie the book) considered Whale Rider to be artistically superior to ROTK which he found the least good of the three films! In his opinion, FOTR was best by far. TTT was confusing and the battle sequences too many and too long. As for ROTK, he found the "holes" in the plot to be much more obvious than either of the other two films and the c.g. battle sequences inferior to both FOTR and TTT. And that's the opinion of someone who is certainly NO "purist".
I also can't find anywhere in Rowan's post where s/he stated that the length of the movies made them good films...

The opinion of your husband is certainly bound to be more biased toward the purist side, considering his wife falls rather decidedly into that category. (No offense!)

As for F. H.'s statement regarding purists seeing the film many times to find more to complain about_: he may be right with some, but certainly not in my case! I saw it once (bad seating - too close) and I will probably see it once more (better seating, hopefully) when we take my son who hasn't seen it, but after that I shall not see it again. Doubtless, my husband will get the EE to go with the other two, but once a year or even once every other year will be more than enough for me - if I see it that often.
Are you saying you have viewed each movie of the trilogy 2 or 3 times only???
 
Gandalf White said:
You said this in response to Rowan's post. Try as I might, I can not find his attempt to use this argument as an excuse...
I also can't find anywhere in Rowan's post where s/he stated that the length of the movies made them good films...
Just a guess, but I'd go with her and she.

Mrs. M- given that Rowan only has two posts, it is hardly fair to lump her post in with those of any other 'film-defenders', nor is it exactly polite to accuse her of continually ignoring the plethora of purist posts on these boards.

Welcome to the boards Rowan- you'll find that not all threads are as vehement as this one, and even here the title is rather tongue-in-cheek. And of course, there are others here who share your views, as well as many who disagree to varying extents. Enjoy!
 
Whoa, this thread is playing tricks on me... :eek:

Rowan, my apologies concerning the gender confusion; my post was written in a hurry. I am also rather notorious for confusing gender, even with perfectly clear names... :eek:
 
Rowan Evensong said:
I think many purists did indeed go expecting to hate the movies. In fact, I know some that have said so, and others that expressed great sorrow the movies were even made,
It looks like a bunch of people that some how feel threatened by the movies, that somehow the movie adaptations diminish the books in some way.
I've been here quite a while and I've never seen anything to suggest these ideas of yours about people feeling "threatened by
the films" or that "the adaptations diminish the books". I'd very much like to know what has made it "look" that way to you.
How could these, or any other, films, "threaten", or have any other deleterious effect on the books; how could they "diminish" them? The idea is absurd.
The furthest we go in criticising the films is to say that they partly good, and partly bad; what product could expect better than that?! Of course, we also say that, for $300million it should have been easy to make a larger part of the good, leaving only a tiny part bad, but PJ's fans seem to think he couldn't have done better if he'd tried.
It's hard to believe that "many purists did indeed go expecting to hate the movies" and that "in fact, I know some that have said so", but I must take your word for it.
I was going to add that the word "hate" is totally inappropriate here, that no-one ever expresses it against the films. Unfortunately one instance has crept in today, but I invite you to take my word for it that this was a first, and, I am sure, a one-off occasion.
My personal take on the idea of "hatred", which I've expressed here before, is that it is far to strong an emotion to apply to anything as trivial as a film; and that I will consider it as a "personal attack" if I find it ascribed to me.
 
Gandalf White said:
You said this in response to Rowan's post. Try as I might, I can not find his attempt to use this argument as an excuse...

I also can't find anywhere in Rowan's post where s/he stated that the length of the movies made them good films...

Rowan began by saying "If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the books on film, that was more than a little naive.
I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part...."
I took Mrs M's comments to be a clarification, which "we" have made many times, that no-one, as far as we know, expected the "verbatim re-telling"; and also to be pointing out that it is not a matter of "suspecting" that we knew what we were going to get - of course we knew. Mrs M didn't say anything about Rowan using anything as an excuse.

Rowan mentioned the length of the films; Mrs M simply went on to make her own comments on the length, without making any further connection with Rowan's post. That seems a reasonable way of developing a discussion; otherwise we would get nothing but point by point retorts all the time.
 
Its a man, baby!

I assure you I am quite male. Though I did shed a tear or two at various points during the movies. ;)

Was hatred too strong a word? Perhaps but for goodness sake, look at the title of the thread! It hardly suggests that the "anti's" saw any redeeming virtues in the movie at all. As for a 300 million budget to make a trilogy of that scale? I think they did well to produce what they did for 300 large.

What made it look as if people feel Tolkien's legacy is threatened is the outright indignation with which some people are attacking various scenes and points in the movie. I'm just telling you truthfully as an outsider, how it looks. Imagine if you will several of you were sitting in a coffee shop speaking these words and I happened to sit at the next table and over hear. Its hard to attribute the level of anger being expressed by some, not all but some, to anything other than the belief that somehow the movies will taint the books.

Which leads to why 3 friends of mine (I shall call them Patrick, Michael and Jim) hated the idea of the movies being made and hated the movies themselves as the result of a self-fulfilling prophecy. They feared the movies would not live up to the books, and that millions of people all over the world would get the wrong ideas about Tolkien and Middle Earth. Of course the movies do not live up to the books. You would need about 300 billion dollars, technology that does not yet exist, and a minimum of 30 hours worth of film to begin to capture the story. But what annoyed me the most about their attitude was that they seemed to feel they had some kind of exclusive right to the Tolkien experience, and that the movies would as I said taint the books because they would not be a verbatim replication. Thus the experience would leave others with a different experience, a "wrong" one and that would somehow cheapen the "true" experience of the books.

I just don't see it.
 
rs69191 (at least) seems to think that the books have been diminished by the movies. He (I assume) recently said that switching the character's dialog or the context of dialog was a disservice to the original, which I assume means that the original is somewhat diminished. How this occurs, I have no idea- indeed I agree with you that the idea is absurd! However, Rowan's point stands that some purists have said this (if I bothered to dig, I know I could find more).
And while the furthest you might go is to say "some good/some bad", the title of this thread is "My God it was Horrible"- which is considerably less centered.

And, as a 'PJ fan' that is probably more strident than most, I do think that parts could have been better, but that as a whole the trilogy is beyond anything that I could (or indeed did) expect.
 
Well...

"Mrs M" did reply as if I believed that purists expected a verbatim reproduction; which I clearly stated I did not believe the case. And I used the 10 hours worth of film to suggest it was simply not possible to relate the entire story within that short time frame. In her argument, Mrs M seemed to suggest I had implied the that the movies were somehow "good" because they were "long." I offered no such assessment. I in fact suggested that 10 hours was far too little to do Tolkien's story justice.

In addition, here is a quote from her in another thread...

"I have nothing "against" Mr. Jackson personally but I wish he had practiced his revisionist skills on some other literary work or perhaps redone King Kong or Godzilla or any number of "stories" which had (or had not) been films previously. Unfortunately, he decided to exercise his "talents" on Tolkien's LOTR. Even more unfortunately, he had the wherewithall - money, cast, technology, location etc. - to make his films look like the book, while his revisionist characters essentially changed the meaning of the original."

This is what I mean by purists wishing it had never been done.
 
Rowan Evensong said:
"Mrs M" did reply as if I believed that purists expected a verbatim reproduction....
Mrs M seemed to suggest I had implied the that the movies were somehow "good" because they were "long."

This is what I mean by purists wishing it had never been done.
"as if"
"seemed to suggest"
That's where you've got Mrs M wrong.
She replied in a neutral sense, simply stating the case, without any personal reference.
A "suggestion" of an "implication"?! That's getting much too remote. She didn't "suggest" anything; she said what she meant.
The lady always says what she means, and no more, just as I do. :cool:
Of course, Mrs M can speak for herself, but I would ask you not to imply anything from my postings. If I have something
to say, I say it; I don't write "as if" it, or "suggest" it.

When did you say about "purists wishing it had never been done"?
Do you mean when you said "others that expressed great sorrow the movies were even made, before their release even"?
Mrs M certainly didn't feel that way; nor did I.
I believed what PJ told us: that he had made a faithful representation of his source material.
Of course, speaking after the event, I agree with Mrs M, that PJ would have been better occupied exercising his unique vision on other material, leaving someone else to make genuinely faithful representations of TLOTR.
That's not the same as "wishing it had never been done"; there are two equally attractive alternatives for us to wish on:
that PJ had given us less of his vision and more of Tolkien's, or that someone else had been privileged to work on the material.
 
Rowan Evensong said:
Of course the movies do not live up to the books. You would need about 300 billion dollars, technology that does not yet exist, and a minimum of 30 hours worth of film to begin to capture the story.
This is where I disagree and where many FADs lose sight of the purist argument. We don't hate the movies, nor do we hate Jackson. We don't expect word for word verbatim or that it meshes nicely with our own imagination.

PJ's problem wasn't lack of money in bringing a faithful adaptation. Visually (where all the money and man-power truly goes), PJ was as dead on as dead on can be, short of our own imagination and the acting was good as well. The problem was the poor scriptwriting. Had PJ not added in so much of his useless stuff, kept some characters truer to the book and worked on his dialogue more rather than try and tell a different story or put his 'touches' on it, he could have kept the flow of the movie pretty much to what it was and still have come up with a much better adaptation.

He chose not to do these things for some bizarre unknown reason. The purist argument is that it could have been much better had these simple things been respected and more time spent on them. Not that the movies themselves weren't closer to the book or done verbatim.
 

Today's events

Back
Top