• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Rowan Evensong said:
...the movies...were simply one man's best attempt to translate HIS interpretation of the book of the 20th century to an entirely different medium.

First off, welcome to the Forum!
Yes, this was a difficult undertaking. I agree that its easier to critisize someone else's hard work after the fact, and I think its a shame when people see these movies with a closed mind, determined to find fault.

However, does that mean EVERYONE should turn a blind eye when there is substantial evidence that PJ did NOT always make his best attempt? PJ is an ARTISTIC filmmaker who chose to make these movies, loudly proclaiming he wanted to remain true to the spirit of Tolkien, changing only what he needed to to make the movie work. He created this duty - he is being held up to the standard he has created for himself. If you had asked me after FOTR, I would have said he filled it.

But over the course of the trilogy (especially TTT), he decided to take the low road...many cheap laughs that disrespected the characters, the gaping holes in plot lines he either hoped we wouldn't notice or didn't care if we did, and poorly written characters with inconsistancies that leave movie-goers scratching their heads. The brilliant parts of the movies leave me in no doubt he was capable of doing better. Instead of taking the time and energy to think through the changed plot lines and develop characters, he got lazy and took the easy way out.
 
channeling Snidely Whiplash, apparently

Danger, Will Robinson! Cheap Sarcasm Ahead!


Few-Harmer said:
You keep using the phrase "needless changes" as if you really know what you're talking about and are qualified to determine what does and does not work in the medium of film.

In stark contrast to your own eminently credentialed self, of course, whose expertise is unquestioned in Hollywood, Wellington, and across the world. All the presumptuous rest of us mere amateur movie-commentators are ever so envious of someone who actually gets to cast his vote for the Academy Awards.



Foo-Harper said:
Had PJ done what you npw's wanted, this movie would have had the feel of [...] goodness knows.....bakshi's version! Thanks heavens he had the skill to [...] make a better story that will be enjoyed for years.

On the contrary; as rs691919 has very recently pointed out, a number of PJ's scenes are taken directly from Bakshi. After all, why bother going all the way back to Tolkien when a cartoonish shortcut is already available?




Please forbear indignation at the odd misspelling; it's only "obvious laziness". . .
 

What PJ did on film actually worked while your day dreaming has produced..??? What was it again that your wishful thinking has produced?

Aldanil said:
On the contrary; as rs691919 has very recently pointed out, a number of PJ's scenes are taken directly from Bakshi. After all, why bother going all the way back to Tolkien when a cartoonish shortcut is already available?

See, this is just another example of the npw being completely clueless to their limitations.....sarcasim requires at least a portion of the statement to be true. You should, as a personal favor to all, avoid trying to be sarcastic along with critiquing film, because you are poor at both.

Aldanil said:
Please forbear indignation at the odd misspelling; it's only "obvious laziness". . .

That was a little better, but I fear the admins will feel it "over the top" as far as acceptable according to the faq's. Myself, I have always lost respect for people who make fun of others names because it is so obvious and requires no imagination what-so-ever. But hey, if you're proud, I say revel in it.
 
simbelmyne said:
However, does that mean EVERYONE should turn a blind eye when there is substantial evidence that PJ did NOT always make his best attempt?

According to who? The miniscul amount of npw's or the millions that have seen it multiple times?


"movie-goers scratching their heads"?????? Again, are you speaking of the millions who continue to see it or the complaining npw's who I dare say PJ knew he could never satisfy and didn't even bother?

Anyone who says that he didn't capture the spirit of jrr's work is just plain blind and obviously has an ax to grind.
 
it must in honesty be acknowledged

simbelmyne said:
Instead of taking the time and energy to think through the changed plot lines and develop characters, he got lazy and took the easy way out.

To try and be fair to poor put-upon PJ (What?! A kind word for the Kiwi Kaiser, from a notorious curmudgeonly Nit-Picking Weenie? Is Arda turned suddenly upside-down?) I do not think in all good conscience, whatever other cinematic sins, moral/character lapses, and crimes against our beloved Tale he may be accused of, that either laziness or taking the easy way can be included among them. Quite the opposite: the most egregious flaws in these movies arise, I believe, from excessive ambition and a corrosive exhaustion brought on by sheer over-work. I've already suggested elsewhere that if only 1% of the enormous New Line budget (a mere three million dollars) had been devoted exclusively to the screenplay, giving that most important of all responsibilities to the full-time attention and effort of wordsmiths as acclaimed and talented at their craft as John Howe and Alan Lee are as visual artists, thus leaving Jackson himself with no more demanding business to manage than conceiving, coordinating, and bringing to fruition a fantastically complicated fifteen-month-long continuous shoot, with as many as nine film-units in the field at once, personally tending to the ten (or twelve or thirty-five) thousand specific details of set construction, locations, costuming, camera angles, uncooperative weather, unforeseen circumstances, etc., etc., etc., which even in an ordinary production can consume entirely the "time and energy" of any committed and caring director, we would all have been happier, NPW and FAD alike, with the better result. The actors report that script-changes were innumerable throughout the process, dialogue being altered substantially from one day to the next, often from morning to evening, and whole new scenes were being shot as late as last October; by his own admission, Jackson went for literally months on end without getting enough sleep, week after week after mind-dulling week of twenty-one-hour days piling up in a unrelenting rush to stay almost on schedule. It's frankly a wonder the wee fellow lived through it! The very idea that he could piecemeal and simultaneously rewrite ("adapt") the most painstakingly constructed and carefully interwoven narrative in modern literature speaks hubristic volumes about his over-reaching.

This is not even to mention any of those "dark corners" that joxy has pointed to: a great love for the grotesque, a sophomoric sense of humor, and an obsession with Uruks (this last trait shared by one or two others on our Forum, perhaps - I'm looking at you, noble pentathletic royalstar!)



It Must Further Be Acknowledged

Foe-Hammer, ol' fiend, I never said I was proud; occasionally one's bilious gorge just overflows, with results self-demeaning, unworthy, or otherwise. Mocking you is rather like shooting fish in a barrel. A stanza of Thomas Campion, by way of rueful expiation:

Ruth forgive me, if I erred from human heart's compassion
When I laughed sometimes too much to see thy foolish fashion;
But, alas, who less could do that found so good occasion?
 
Last edited:

It is rather ironic that you understand the concept behind the latter part of your post yet still wrote the former.

Every part of your comment betrays the fact that....

You think

A: you know how to write a screenplay.
B: you are qualified to be a film maker.
C: you are a better director than PJ.

The facts do not support your position for these reasons (just to name a few)....the film works and millions have enjoyed it. One needs no other proof to illustrate that the npw is totally wrong. The only way I see the npw deal with this is by aiming insults at those who do enjoy the movie.
 
Whadya know?

I checked last night- PJ's words were indeed "the confrontation with Saruman" (apologies to joxy). Most of the footage shown in the excerpt was indeed in the final film, excepting one very interesting-looking shot of Saruman peering over the railing at Gandalf and co.
In case anyone is interested, it is on the second disk of appendices for the TT EE (The Appendices, part IV), in the "editing" segment. I'll try to copy down the transcript when I have a chance.
 
Thank you for the mention! Of course, many purists are also guilty of uruk-obsession, and display this in a rather extreme manner. PJ has an undeniable appreciation for the grotesque, but there are (IMO) enough beautiful moments in LotR that I am not overly bothered. I don't know if I'll see King Kong, though. And finally, having perused JRRT's Letters a time or two, I noticed that he was sheepishly-proud of his own Hobbit-like and rustic humor, though he thought it might irritated some of his readers. I think PJ's sense of humor worked more for him than against him.

As for the script, there was no way that this project was going to be done without Fran writing the script (PJ had very minimal duties in terms of writing, as far as I can tell). PJ and Fran are a team and a family- nothing, not even LotR, is important enough to split that up. Just IMO, of course.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
Thorin,

You keep using the phrase "needless changes" as if you really know what you're talking about and are qualified to determine what does and does not work in the medium of film
Alrighty, I tried to put this to rest and forget about it but here we go again (heh, heh You all know me better!)...let's take another look at she-elf shall we?

You, Harad and markrob lambasted me continually for harping on how Arwen was stupid and barely worked cinematically. You justified it up the wazoo bringing in every crazy argument from 'spirit of Tolkien' to 'descendant of Luthien' and 'Tolkien didn't know what he was doing when he wrote Arwen'. In a nutshell, the conscensus among FADs was that: Tolkien's Arwen wouldn't work for the screen and Jackson HAD to change her.

Lo and behold if we don't see ANY of this type of Arwen in TTT. Why, she's just like the BOOK Arwen?!! Why? Well we look at interviews on the extended edition and we see Liv Tyler and others saying exactly what I thought from the beginning: her character change didn't feel right, it wasn't working and Arwen didn't need a sword to show she was strong! A needless change if there ever was one. Even they felt it ended up being a needless change.

So now we end up with what Tolkien started with. Unfortunately, a part of FoTR was destroyed by a needless change. I might even have put up with Saruman had Arwen not been so 'needlessly' hacked.
 
For-hammer posted:
Every part of your comment betrays the fact that....

You think

A: you know how to write a screenplay.
B: you are qualified to be a film maker.
C: you are a better director than PJ.
It is common enough that when people can’t attack what is said then they attack the person who says it. That is what you are doing here Foe-hammer.

Let’s reverse your arguments. Would you claim also that no-one can praise Jackson or any film director unless:

A: they know how to write a screenplay,
B: they are qualified to be film makers,
C: they are better directors than the film director they are praising?

Why should those who praise be exempt from your criteria when those who find fault are not? A defender is hard put to it if the defender must resort to argument ad populum rather than looking at the individual points. The defender is hard put to it in adopting the strange position that only people involved in the film industry can criticize negatively while anyone is allowed to praise.

The flaws are obvious in the films. I and many others have pointed them out again and again and have not particularly aimed insults at those who enjoy the films other than by quesitioning how they can really enjoy those parts of the film which are so incoherent or so diminished in respect to the original.

Many of those same flaws are admitted by those who like the films.

Those who complain about the films certainly do not do so only by aiming insults at those who enjoy the film.

Let’s take just one of your own statements: If PJ made the film more in accordance with my likes the film would certain not have felt like Labyrinth (though I quite enjoyed that Alice-in-Wonderland type film) or Legend or Willow. Explain why it should have? None of those films felt like Tolkien though in Willow there was some obvious attempt to imitate Tolkien that mostly failed. To me all three of these films feel very different from one another.

I am at a loss at how a more faithful adaptation of The Lord of the Rings could feel like Labyrinth at all. If you are serious about this assertion, then you should take at least one of these films and show why that are especially flawed in ways that are more like Tolkien’s writing then Jackson’s filming.

How would not dumbing Gimli down or treating Faramir more like he is in the books have made Jackson’s films more like Labyrinth or Legend or Willow?

Make a case or withdraw your assertion.

As to Bakshi’s effort, the main complaints against Bakshi are of a different kind: omissions that confused the plot, overacting of the animated characters, bad animation in parts, too much dependance on rotoscoping, great carelessness in details (e.g. Aruman versus Saruman and inconsistancy on coloring of Merry and Pippin’s hair) and so forth. Had Bakshi had something like Jackson’s budget and had not been so pressed for time and had been able to redo scenes that didn’t work a good film might have emerged. Perhaps not.

But Bakshi is not normally accused of being overly faithful to the source material. Complaints about his films are on other matters entirely. Your argument fails there also.

On making a better story, arguably Jackson did improve the tale in some ways. Arguably in other ways he made an mess of it in comparision with his source material, too much of a mess for many to stomach.

To change that opinion you will need reasoned argument that those who complain are in some way wrongly viewing or interpreting the films or particular parts of the films, showing for example that the Théoden exorcism scene as realized by Jackson is as good or better than the scene Tolkien wrote or that the scene Tolkien wrote could not be effectively filmed.

But reasoned arguments of that kind are rare. More often I find special pleading that the viewer should try to forget about the books or the supposed truism that an adapation cannot exactly follow its source which attempts to evade the issue of whether a particular adapatation of a particular part of a source is better or worse than its source or just different.
 
Last edited:
I don't think there was a 'consensus FAD opinion'- I certainly never said that she wouldn't work as written, nor did Greenwood, nor (I think) did Harad. "Spirit of Tolkien" meant that what she did in FotR was not beyond what Tolkien himself would have had her do- and I still stick by that. I don't think that what she did in FotR (excepting the sword to the throat bit) was out of character for her in the books as written, nor did it clash with what happened in the other films. Not to try and derail your point Thorin, but if you really want to prove it you should look elsewhere for examples.
 
I find it very interesting that many of those who absolutely adore these films and refuse to hear one word against them - however well buttressed by fact - often are the same people who are less than enthusiastic about the book. They are of the opinion that Jackson's version works much better than the book - and often not just as film. They love these films because they represent a type of story telling that the defenders have come to expect in this genre of film. Whether or not is it faithful or even diametric to the book is unimportant.

Then there are other film defenders who like and even love the films but who regret that Jackson was not faithful to the book in a great many ways. They "wish" that he had been so that a definitive LOTR had been filmed, but they follow the advice to go read the book if you want the story!

When the issues of "name calling" or the cinamatic criteria which a critic must possess in order to be allowed to make a negative comment about the films arise, generally it is to be found in the former group. On the other hand, the latter group is usually willing enough to admit the faults that purists find in the films even though these don't affect that group's enjoyment of them.

I would suggest therefore, that it makes no sense for "purists" and "ultra-defenders" (they can't be called FADS because the issue of the book is not of importance to them) to "do battle" since they are talking about entirely different matters. Purists are making judgments about the films in light of the book while UDs are totally uninterested in that particular matter and do not view the films in that light at all. About the only issues which might provide a point of true interaction are limited to purely cinematic concerns: how well (or poorly) did a particular actor/actress perform, was the armor believable, did this or that plot thread make sense etc. As long as the conversation is limited to a purely cinematic perspective, the two groups may find some basis on which to communicate. However, as soon as a purist begins to speak about the films referable to the book, he (or she) is no longer speaking the UD's language - and as a result, the debate is both futile and fallacious.
 
aragil said:
PJ said one thing: ~"I will be true to the spirit of Tolkien, and I will be as accurate as possible to the world of Middle-earth."
What is there of the "spirit of Tolkien" about the way that P&M are made to behave in FOTR and the way that Gimli is made to behave in FOTR and TTT and Denethor is made to behave in TTT?
And why was it IMpossible to be accurate to their position in the world of M-E, while it WAS possible to be accurate in the cases of Bilbo, Sam, Legolas, and Saruman?
 
I've asked for examples of Gimli behaving like anything other than a cheap mock-Scotsman comedy act.
I've found two: the gift-giving and the report of Aragorn's "death". In every other appearance he does, and especially says, crudely comical, or absurd, things. I certainly do NOT ignore the "real" Gimli's "overly prideful aspects"; indeed they are a major part of his "true" character - but they don't come over in the film at all - the attempts to convey them come over as yet more silly comedy - his attempt at solo horse-riding for example.
That pride is indeed a distinctive character trait of the "real" Gimli, and he has plenty of other traits which could have been used to give him the clarity and distinction of character which you rightly claim to be necessary. All that he is actually allowed, with which to distinguish himself, are his appearance and his foolishness - and they are extremely boring.
I've hesitated until now to make a specific point, which may not be understood in some parts of the English speaking world. The use of what I have referred to as mock-Scottish humour is regarded as offensive, by many Scots people, and by many others in the other countries of the UK. That sort of thing, which comes close to being "racist", is not much appreciated here.
 
I believe that Merry and Pippin were spot-on in FotR, and I'd love to discuss it in a characterization thread (http://thetolkien.forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=1531). I also thought Gimli was well-done in FotR. TT was a little over the top (very little), but I still enjoyed much of his lines- in addition to informing Eowyn about Aragorn's fall there was his comments about Dwarf women (attributed to Gimli in the appendices) and his 'counting game' with Legolas that, while amusing, also come from the books.
I don't understand the complaints about Denethor- certainly in the TT EE his material seems drawn directly from the book. Maybe other people saw him as a kind and loving father to both his sons, but that was never my impression.

As for Saruman, I think he has thus far been close, but not as close as Merry and Pippin- my scoring in your 'rate the characterizations' thread reflects that. So why was it impossible for M&P to be portrayed as well as Saruman? It wasn't- in fact I think their characterizations were closer to the book than Saruman's!
 
Not really. Its a prime example of a needless change. I think the fact that the writers made her so warrior like (which was not Tolkien's character plain and simple) and then dropped her image like a hot potato for the remaining two movies (even AFTER filming her fighting at Helm's Deep) says volumes about how the Xen-Arwen thing didn't fly with the writers when they really thought it through. To go right back to Tolkien's Arwen after such a drastic change from the books to begin with ranks up there with a 'needless' change. If it wasn't, and it fit all your points as to why it was good and right to be in the movie the way it was (i.e. spirit, Luthien etc) then her character would have remained the way it was and the scenes of her fighting at Helm's Deep would still have been in there.

In a way I'm glad that the writers and actors who were doing the scenes came to their senses. Had all of you FADs been doing it with all your amazing justifications, we would have had Arwen not only fighting at Helm's Deep but heading to the black gates to challenge the Mouth of Sauron as well. Why not? Arwen challenging the Mouth of Sauron is perfectly in the spirit of Tolkien and something Luthien could have done. Your only argument would be because it deviates too far from the book. Oh! But wait a minute!! I thought only capturing the themes and spirit of Tolkien was a criteria? Since when did faithfulness to the written source become a staple now?
 
It isn't often that I'm left speechless, but those comments have come very close to taking all my breath away!
Are you SURE you wrote them?
The only things about M&P that resemble the originals, until almost the end of FOTR, are their names. They do make a startling improvement, for the fleeting moment after they are caught and carried off by the orcs; and they do improve in TTT, though they fluctuate like crazy even there.
It's precisely Gimli's LINES, like those, that I find absurd, even offensive.
I know there is a reference to dwarf women in an appendix, and I know he and Legolas compared tallies, but the words in which both were expressed in the films shows up again what a bad decision it was to leave the dialogue to PJ's family and friends!
 
Last edited:
Mrs. Maggott said:
I find it very interesting that many of those who absolutely adore these films and refuse to hear one word against them - however well buttressed by fact - often are the same people who are less than enthusiastic about the book.
Please, PLEASE, tell me you're not referring to Aragil with this statement.
 

Yes, she had to change.


Why is it so far of a reach for her to be armed when she is well aware of the nazgul roaming the country? And as an elf, wouldn't she be as light-footed as all elves and be able to sneak up on aragorn? It is far from a needless change, common sense and cinematic consistancy demands it. As far as TTT is concerned, they were probably talking about the scenes at helms deep that were eventually dropped because they didn't like the feel. The FoTR scenes were completely fine.


We have the arwen that jrr wrote? ain't heard that one before.

I have given you rational arguments why the changes were needed and make perfect sense, but of course, you will claim they could have been done better/different but you have no credible skills to back that up. So, PJ gets the benifit of the doubt and the npw's can go cry in their gandalf hats.
 
I guess where we disagree is whether Arwen was like a warrior in FotR. I certainly don't think so. She ran away with Frodo and then beguiled the Nazgul into crossing the stream. At no point did she fight, therefore IMO she was not "warrior-like".
If she had fought at Helm's Deep I would have been disappointed- I don't think that that was in Arwen's character, nor was it in Luthien's character.

Absolutely I wrote them. By all means point to me a spot in FotR where you think Pippin is acting out of place, and I'll show you three passages from the books where he shows the same behavior. The FotR characterization thread is already linked.


PJ's family and friends used almost the exact dialog that Tolkien used in the books- the same dialog that you continually praise. As an example: Which change bothers you so much? "Foolish opinion" to "ridiculous belief"? "Grow out of Stone" to "spring out of holes in the ground"?

(For heaven's sake Parrot, stick around this time!)
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…