• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

jallan said:
For-hammer posted:It is common enough that when people can’t attack what is said then they attack the person who says it. That is what you are doing here Foe-hammer.

No, I am defeating their irrational logic.

jallan said:
Let’s reverse your arguments. Would you claim also that no-one can praise Jackson or any film director unless:

A: they know how to write a screenplay,
B: they are qualified to be film makers,
C: they are better directors than the film director they are praising?Why should those who praise be exempt from your criteria when those who find fault are not?

Backwards logic. If a director makes a film that millions upon millions of people like, then he has done his job. The viewer need only to be entertained. But for a novice to stand in judgement of that work and claim it would have been better if certain changes had been made requires at least a basic understanding of film making and how it comes off on screen. The npw has no such skill and therefore their illogical reasonings need to be challenged.

jallan said:
A defender is hard put to it if the defender must resort to argument ad populum rather than looking at the individual points. The defender is hard put to it in adopting the strange position that only people involved in the film industry can criticize negatively while anyone is allowed to praise.

The problem is the npw ONLY focuses on individual points and does not look at the scene in relation to the rest of the movie AND the limitations of the film medium. That statement right there is totally lost on the npw. It has been pointed out so many times and ignored by them that I have come to the conclusion that, it is very likely a problem that really begins and ends in their minds as has no basis in reality.

jallan said:
The flaws are obvious in the films. I and many others have pointed them out again and again and have not particularly aimed insults at those who enjoy the films other than by quesitioning how they can really enjoy those parts of the film which are so incoherent or so diminished in respect to the original.

I have seen several insults leveled at people who enjoy the films. Mostly along the lines that they are shallow. You may never had said that, but no one was really talking to you. You just decided to interject yourself into this.

jallan said:
Let’s take just one of your own statements:If PJ made the film more in accordance with my likes the film would certain not have felt like Labyrinth (though I quite enjoyed that Alice-in-Wonderland type film) or Legend or Willow. Explain why it should have? None of those films felt like Tolkien though in Willow there was some obvious attempt to imitate Tolkien that mostly failed. To me all three of these films feel very different from one another.

They all fell flat from where they were trying to go.

jallan said:
I am at a loss at how a more faithful adaptation of The Lord of the Rings could feel like Labyrinth at all. If you are serious about this assertion, then you should take at least one of these films and show why that are especially flawed in ways that are more like Tolkien’s writing then Jackson’s filming. How would not dumbing Gimli down or treating Faramir more like he is in the books have made Jackson’s films more like Labyrinth or Legend or Willow?

People did not identify with the characters in those movies. PJ was completely successful in this area. Every character was believable and their feelings were such that we can identify. This is what makes for good cinema.

jallan said:
Make a case or withdraw your assertion.

Here is the truth.....good books require the reader to imagine many things and get involved. Great movies are like being on a ride...there is no time for a lot of imagination and no time to go back and rewind. There is limited time and the characters have to be developed quickly and need to be setup by other scenes and characters. The arrogant npw thinks all these changes are so easy. Well, if that is so, why did it take so long to make a good movie? If it is so easy, why aren't ALL movies as big of a hit as these are? The npw refuses to ask themselves those questions and stubbornly hangs on to the "needless changes" or "it could have been better" montra.

jallan said:
But Bakshi is not normally accused of being overly faithful to the source material. Complaints about his films are on other matters entirely. Your argument fails there also.

It has been a while, but gimli and others were much closer, yet this gimli is remembered and the tolkien one is not.

jallan said:
On making a better story, arguably Jackson did improve the tale in some ways. Arguably in other ways he made an mess of it in comparision with his source material, too much of a mess for many to stomach. To change that opinion you will need reasoned argument that those who complain are in some way wrongly viewing or interpreting the films or particular parts of the films, showing for example that the Théoden exorcism scene as realized by Jackson is as good or better than the scene Tolkien wrote or that the scene Tolkien wrote could not be effectively filmed.

Wrong. they need to prove it could be shot the way they claim or they should just cease the argument. They THINK they know more about film making than PJ. If they would just admit they are clueless and that PJ knows better than they do, they might just be able to get some perspective. But we all know that is never going to happen.

jallan said:
But reasoned arguments of that kind are rare. More often I find special pleading that the viewer should try to forget about the books or the supposed truism that an adapation cannot exactly follow its source which attempts to evade the issue of whether a particular adapatation of a particular part of a source is better or worse than its source or just different.

Jrr himself knew a majority of his story, as is, was unfit for film and it would be changed. BECAUSE, (for the gagillioneth time) these characters do not exists in a vacuumn, and every change is going to effect other characters or situations and to make a change and then inexplicable jump back to the source material whern it does not fit with the changes made, would fail on film. IE.....That is why it makes sense for arwen to have a sword. For crying out loud, there are nazgul about. Why would elrond send his defensless daughter out into the wilderness without a way to defend herself? The scene established she had a sword (heck, so did the hobbits) and subtlry re-inforces that it is very dangerous out here. The lack of a means of defense would diminish the feeling of danger, call into question elronds grasp of the situation ( and therefore his worthiness to head the council) and question his love for his daughter. Without a sword, ellrond, and every scene concerning him, would have had to been different or the glaring mistakes would have caused the viewer to wonder what they had missed.

That example may not be exactly what would have happened, but it is very plausible, and that is enough to illustrate just how complicated movies are to make well. There was not one time in this movie that I, or anyone else I have met, were confused about what was going on. It was quite the enjoyable ride. Anyone who didn't, was focused way too much on the source material, and as I have pointed out, it was unsuitable as written for the screen.

The npw has also latched onto another point that I have not defeated yet because I felt sorry for them.....the completely silly assumption that some of the book that was adaptable and pj used, MUST mean that the entire work should have been able to be done as it were in the book. Silly!
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
I find it very interesting that many of those who absolutely adore these films and refuse to hear one word against them - however well buttressed by fact - often are the same people who are less than enthusiastic about the book. They are of the opinion that Jackson's version works much better than the book - and often not just as film.

You have no facts...you have wishful thinking

Mrs. Maggott said:
They love these films because they represent a type of story telling that the defenders have come to expect in this genre of film. Whether or not is it faithful or even diametric to the book is unimportant.

"this genre of film".....try "from the MEDIUM of film". THAT is in fact a more accurate discription.

Mrs. Maggott said:
As long as the conversation is limited to a purely cinematic perspective, the two groups may find some basis on which to communicate. However, as soon as a purist begins to speak about the films referable to the book, he (or she) is no longer speaking the UD's language - and as a result, the debate is both futile and fallacious.

You surprise me M, I din't think you were capable of saying that without one of your little digs at the fad's.
 
Thorin said:
Not really. Its a prime example of a needless change. I think the fact that the writers made her so warrior like (which was not Tolkien's character plain and simple) and then dropped her image like a hot potato for the remaining two movies (even AFTER filming her fighting at Helm's Deep) says volumes about how the Xen-Arwen thing didn't fly with the writers when they really thought it through. To go right back to Tolkien's Arwen after such a drastic change from the books to begin with ranks up there with a 'needless' change. If it wasn't, and it fit all your points as to why it was good and right to be in the movie the way it was (i.e. spirit, Luthien etc) then her character would have remained the way it was and the scenes of her fighting at Helm's Deep would still have been in there.

ALL movies do that...elsewise we wouldn't need editors. Jeeze, Thorin! Get a grip! Now you complain about what WAS NOT in the movie.

thorin said:
In a way I'm glad that the writers and actors who were doing the scenes came to their senses. Had all of you FADs been doing it with all your amazing justifications, we would have had Arwen not only fighting at Helm's Deep but heading to the black gates to challenge the Mouth of Sauron as well. Why not? Arwen challenging the Mouth of Sauron is perfectly in the spirit of Tolkien and something Luthien could have done. Your only argument would be because it deviates too far from the book. Oh! But wait a minute!! I thought only capturing the themes and spirit of Tolkien was a criteria? Since when did faithfulness to the written source become a staple now? :rolleyes:

Only npw's complain about it being too far from the book, fads are enlightened enough to know that those scenes may have been able to be shot and they may have worked, nut don't bother trying to make hay with it.

Thorin, do you really think PJ regrets arwen in FoTR? I think he was glad it was there and would not have changed it. It worked so well they tried to expand on it and didn't like what they got so they abandoned it. But I have never heard him regret arwen from FoTR. You assume too much if you think because he didn't expand her role as the warrior that he regrets the little that he did. (Besides all that...in FoTR she was more a protector of Frodo that a warrior. Her challenge of the nazgul was to goad them into the river. She used skill and cunning to win the battle not strenght of arms or agression. You would have noticed that had you not been so buzy checking your book.)
 
aragil said:
PJ's family and friends used almost the exact dialog that Tolkien used in the books- the same dialog that you continually praise. As an example: Which change bothers you so much? "Foolish opinion" to "ridiculous belief"? "Grow out of Stone" to "spring out of holes in the ground"?
Yes, I knew what was in the book!
One brief reference, a matter of the minutest importance, at the end of a long appendix, and it is used as the basis of a whole scene!
Thousands of other lines, from the main books, hundreds of other scenes, have to be left out, because there wasn't time for them.
"This has given rise to the foolish opinion among Men that there are no dwarf-women, and that the Dwarves 'grow out of stone'".
Yes, those two changes they made are ridiculous. Why on earth couldn't they leave ONE sentence intact?
Then we have Aragorn as straight man: "(stage whisper) it's the beards" - big grin, joined by Eowyn. Totally pathetic.
Then Gimli falls off his horse, again! Childish and absurd.
That's the point where TTT, which began so promisingly, begins to fall apart; it's downhill all the way from there - as many others have found and told us.
I suppose, actually, that I should give a perverse sort of plus mark to the family: Gimli DOES get a couple of sensible words,
though in a stupid scene: "I couldn't" to Eowyn's offer of the preposterous stew! :D

Oh, and I'll return to M&P later. :cool:

Foe-Hammer said:
I have never heard him regret arwen from FoT

I have heard Liv Tyler regret Arwen from FOTR!
Whether that influenced Jackson in his decision to throw away the HD scenes that he had filmed her in is open to question.
 
joxy said:
Yes, I knew what was in the book!
One brief reference, a matter of the minutest importance, at the end of a long appendix, is used as the basis of a whole scene!
Thousands of other lines, from the main books, hundreds of other scenes, have to be left out, because there wasn't time for them.

Somebody call the waaaaaambulance.

joxy said:
"This has given rise to the foolish opinion among Men that there are no dwarf-women, and that the Dwarves 'grow out of stone'".
Yes, those two changes they made are ridiculous. Why on earth couldn't they leave ONE sentence intact?

That is the most NPW thing I have EVER read.

joxy said:
Then we have Aragorn as straight man: "(stage whisper) it's the beards" - big grin, joined by Eowyn. Totally pathetic.

Someone please keep sharp objects away from joxy....if she ever finds out that arragorn had a sense of humor I fear for what she might do.

joxy said:
Then Gimli falls off his horse, again! Childish and absurd.

Dwarves don't usually ride horses and it is completely believable that he would fall off...many times.

joxy said:
That's the point where TTT, which began so promisingly, begins to fall apart; it's downhill all the way from there - as many others have found and told us.

Hmmmmm.....millions continued to go watch it and still bought the TE and the EE.

You have out-done yourself and me thinks maybe a definition for a super npw might be needed. :eek:
 
Last edited:
Foe-Hammer said:
millions....bought the TE and the EE.
I was one of the millions who bought them, and I'm very satisfied with a large part of my purchases.
The pathetic attempts at comedy from poor Rhys-Jones, courtesy of PJ, were nowhere near important enough to put me off them!
I'd still like to know though, why PJ thought it was a good idea to mix Tolkien with some ancient film style in the manner of a tenth rate version of Laurel and Hardy.
And I'm a he; I thought that was established long ago. :D
 
joxy said:
I'd still like to know though, why PJ thought it was a good idea to mix Tolkien with some ancient film style in the manner of a tenth rate version of Laurel and Hardy.

Because it worked and it was funny.....you just don't get it.
 
My Goodness!

You go away for a day or so and come back and look what you find! I don't even know what some of these acronyms stand for. The movies certainly were not perfect. The "book" isn't perfect either. Its just the best story ever written, but it isn't perfect. As a whole, to be truthful, Tolkien's characters are very shallow and one dimensional. Thus when multiple sides of Arwen are depicted in the movies, people are aghast. Mainly because Tolkein wrote her as being very one dimensional, as he did Faramir and others.

I "adore" the movies Mrs. Maggot. I love the books more. Could the movies have been better? Of course. I have yet to see a perfect movie, or read a perfect book. But they just as certainly could have been much, much worse. Try as I might, having read all of the arguments, I fail to see how anyone could find them as tragically bad as some of you portray them to be.

Ah well, to each his or her own.
 
Rowan Evensong said:
I "adore" the movies Mrs. Maggot. I love the books more. Could the movies have been better? Of course. I have yet to see a perfect movie, or read a perfect book. But they just as certainly could have been much, much worse. Try as I might, having read all of the arguments, I fail to see how anyone could find them as tragically bad as some of you portray them to be.

*does a little happy dance* :eek:

Ok, with that out of the way, I must say I am so glad to finally find someone who (apparently) shares my very views. Someone who thinks that the books are better than the movie, yet thinks the movies are awesome, all the while acknowledging there is room for improvement. Hurrah!

(Let me know if I went off track somewhere...) :eek: :)
 
aragil said:
Absolutely I wrote them. By all means point to me a spot in FotR where you think Pippin is acting out of place, and I'll show you three passages from the books where he shows the same behavior.
Okay. How about the Council of Elrond? In the book Pippin and Merry know exactly where they are going and what seriousness it entails. Yet they decide to push on showing their true loyalty and bravery (though naive as it may have been). Movie Pippin, after all is said and done, says "Where are we going again?" Strictly for comic relief and book Pippin is mocked in this display of idiocy. Couple this with the fools who stumble on to Sam and Frodo and get caught up with them shows that they have no clue what they are doing. Far from book Pippin despite his hobbit impulsiveness. The only thing PJ got fairly accurate as to show book Pippin's character (until RoTK of course, there Pippin is mostly redeemed) is at the well in Moria. Merry and Pippin were buffoons throughout the first two movies. And the stupid extra scenes of the ent-draught didn't help either.
Foe-Hammer said:
Thorin, do you really think PJ regrets arwen in FoTR? I think he was glad it was there and would not have changed it. It worked so well they tried to expand on it and didn't like what they got so they abandoned it. But I have never heard him regret arwen from FoTR. You assume too much if you think because he didn't expand her role as the warrior that he regrets the little that he did.
Did he regret FoTR? Probably not. However to film her in that same character and then completely abandon that route to put her back into Tolkien-ish character says something. If FoTR worked so well and they didn't have a problem with the way she was being portrayed, they could have put her in doing something else in the same character without fighting at Helm's Deep. They did not and it was not just because Arwen didn't work at Helm's Deep, it was with the character they began to mold in FoTR. It wasn't working PERIOD, not just at Helm's Deep. The interview with Liv Tyler showed that the Arwen they were developing didn't feel right. This Helm's Deep Arwen didn't just appear out of knowhere. She was fighting at Helm's Deep based on what she did at the Fords. That was the character they developed. That was the character they abandoned. Needless.

The belief that you felt it worked in FoTR (which IMO, it did not) doesn't negate the fact that eventually they felt that it was not the character Arwen needed to be in. The fact that Arwen went right back into the 'little princess' mode of Tolkien's appendix Arwen throughout the rest of the two movies adds support to that.
 
Chronology

Thorin- I replied to your M&P problems in the characterization thread, as that is really a more fitting place for it (IMO).

As for Arwen, I think you are rather missing something with the chronology. Helm's Deep was filmed before FotR was released. They had already decided to cut Arwen from the fighting there before the first movie even came out. Apparently what they were thinking is that Arwen as portrayed at the fords was fine, but Arwen at Helm's Deep would be out of character. Since all these decisions were made relatively early on, I don't see how you can say that they were unhappy with her at the Fords but decided to leave her in those scenes anyway.
 
another exasperated swipe at the tar-baby

Foe-Hammer said:
1) Their illogical reasonings need to be challenged.

2) You may never had said that, but no one was really talking to you. You just decided to interject yourself into this.

3) Here is the truth.....good books require the reader to imagine many things and get involved. Great movies are like being on a ride.....there is no time for a lot of imagination and no time to go back and rewind.

4) It has been a while, yet this gimli is remembered and the tolkien one is not.

5) If they would just admit they are clueless, they might just be able to get some perspective. But we all know that is never going to happen.

6) For crying out loud, there are nazgul about. Why would elrond send his defensless daughter out into the wilderness without a way to defend herself? The lack of a means of defense would diminish the feeling of danger, call into question elronds grasp of the situation (and therefore his worthiness to head the council) and question his love for his daughter. Without a sword, ellrond, and every scene concerning him, would have had to been different or the glaring mistakes would have caused the viewer to wonder what they had missed.

7) That example may not be exactly what would have happened, but it is very plausible, and that is enough[...]

8) There was not one time in this movie that I, or anyone else I have met, were confused about what was going on. It was quite the enjoyable ride. Anyone who didn't [didn't think so?], was focused way too much on the source material.

9) The npw has also latched onto another point that I have not defeated yet because I felt sorry for them.

The numbers sequential are mine, of course, appended for greater ease of reference, although this entire exercise is proleptically pointless, as Uncle Remus allusively affirms above. Even so... In the defiantly willful spirit of #1 then, and quite ignoring the warning implicit in #2, let me attempt yet again to pound sand down a rat-hole.


#3 rather succinctly says it all, doesn't it? "Here's the truth"; why don't the rest of us poor benighted souls simply acquiesce, and bow down before the Revealed Divine? The critical standard of aesthetic discernment, which in virtually all of these condescending and tedious posts seeks to contrast a merely "good" book with a "great movie" whose enormous commercial success precludes any possible "rational" criticism, is inherently persuasive, indeed axiomatic, as anyone who isn't a fool must acknowledge. Ipse dixit, ya know what I mean?

#4 expresses a hope we all can share in; the sooner that the character of Peter Jackson's Gimli (New & Improved! Now with X-tra Comic Relief!) supersedes its pallid and inferior bookish original in the popular mind the better, surely!

#5 is no more than a plain statement of fact. Nit-Picking Weenies are clearly incapable of understanding, anything really, and the brain-taxing complexities of film-making especially. If only they had the honesty and intellectual courage to stand up and confess their pathetic limitations! I, for one and speaking just for myself, am beginning to buckle under the terrible strain of maintaining this feckless facade. Thank God I can spell, else I couldn't go on!

#6 strangely complements #3, upon further consideration. "Great" movies are like amusement-park rides, with "no time" to "get involved" or "go back and rewind"; and yet, unless Arwen carries a sword (and diddles its point in Aragorn's ear), Elrond won't even be thought competent to head the Council (of Elrond), and the viewer's heretofore confident comprehension, undermined and subverted by glaring errors, will instead be replaced by a gnawing sense of anxiety. "What may I have missed? Does this even make sense?"

#7 and #8, taken together, establish an unassailable standard for rhetorical evidence. You Can't Prove It Wouldn't Have, along with I Think So And All Of My Friends Do Too, are the twin pillars of logical argumentation. If those hopeless and hapless NPWs had any sense, they'd just give up their futile, fallacious, and feeble efforts. "We hold these truths to be self-evident..."

#9 implies some unavoidable questions, asked and answered already above. Can evil ever finally be defeated? Don't you have to feel sorry for someone who wastes so much time and squanders such overwritten erudite verbiage in long-winded debate with so unworthy a foe? Hasn't the boy something better to do?


The odds against this happening are long, I know, longer even than those for the Quest of the Ringbearer; but perhaps we might somehow persuade Mithrandir, now that the West has been saved and peace reigns in the land, the rightful rule of the Elfstone established and his own passage booked from the Havens for Valinor, to take his mighty and fabled sword (the King of Gondolin surely needs it no longer) and put it back where he found it, hung up on the wall of that lair in the Trollshaws, there to be once again lost and in silence forgotten.

"A blunderbuss, was it? I thought it was horseflies!"
 
I don't see them completely abandoning her that way, because they never filmed her as a warrior to begin with. She was wise and resourceful and they continued that vein throughout the movie. Her character was used in place of the worthless glorfindle for obvious reasons. She needed to be armed while searching for aragorn.....you may not like the sword to the neck bit but it works better and advances the characters more than a big red arrow and a footnote pointing out her sword, which is basically how those things are done in the written medium of a novel. A film maker has a responsibility to actors, writers, producers, et al, to keep his options open and try to make different things work. You act like they were totally commited to the arwen warrior role and the truth is they were trying some different things (like is done in ALL movies) and ultimately decided they couldn't get it to work. I am sure had arwen had to venture out into a dangerous place on her own again, she would have been armed. It just so happens that her role didn't develope that way.

Your complaints are just more of the same nonsense that makes it appear that you think you would have surely made a better film and all you had to do was follow the book. Well, Thorin, that has been proven erroneous multiple times since the first day after FoTR was released.
 
Aldanil said:
The numbers sequential are mine, of course, appended for greater ease of reference, although this entire exercise is proleptically pointless, as Uncle Remus allusively affirms above. Even so... In the defiantly willful spirit of #1 then, and quite ignoring the warning implicit in #2, let me attempt yet again to pound sand down a rat-hole.


#3 rather succinctly says it all, doesn't it? "Here's the truth"; why don't the rest of us poor benighted souls simply acquiesce, and bow down before the Revealed Divine? The critical standard of aesthetic discernment, which in virtually all of these condescending and tedious posts seeks to contrast a merely "good" book with a "great movie" whose enormous commercial success precludes any possible "rational" criticism, is inherently persuasive, indeed axiomatic, as anyone who isn't a fool must acknowledge. Ipse dixit, ya know what I mean?

#4 expresses a hope we all can share in; the sooner that the character of Peter Jackson's Gimli (New & Improved! Now with X-tra Comic Relief!) supersedes its pallid and inferior bookish original in the popular mind the better, surely!

#5 is no more than a plain statement of fact. Nit-Picking Weenies are clearly incapable of understanding, anything really, and the brain-taxing complexities of film-making especially. If only they had the honesty and intellectual courage to stand up and confess their pathetic limitations! I, for one and speaking just for myself, am beginning to buckle under the terrible strain of maintaining this feckless facade. Thank God I can spell, else I couldn't go on!

#6 strangely complements #3, upon further consideration. "Great" movies are like amusement-park rides, with "no time" to "get involved" or "go back and rewind"; and yet, unless Arwen carries a sword (and diddles its point in Aragorn's ear), Elrond won't even be thought competent to head the Council (of Elrond), and the viewer's heretofore confident comprehension, undermined and subverted by glaring errors, will instead be replaced by a gnawing sense of anxiety. "What may I have missed? Does this even make sense?"

#7 and #8, taken together, establish an unassailable standard for rhetorical evidence. You Can't Prove It Wouldn't Have, along with I Think So And All Of My Friends Do Too, are the twin pillars of logical argumentation. If those hopeless and hapless NPWs had any sense, they'd just give up their futile, fallacious, and feeble efforts. "We hold these truths to be self-evident..."

#9 implies some unavoidable questions, asked and answered already above. Can evil ever finally be defeated? Don't you have to feel sorry for someone who wastes so much time and squanders such overwritten erudite verbiage in long-winded debate with so unworthy a foe? Hasn't the boy something better to do?


The odds against this happening are long, I know, longer even than those for the Quest of the Ringbearer; but perhaps we might somehow persuade Mithrandir, now that the West has been saved and peace reigns in the land, the rightful rule of the Elfstone established and his own passage booked from the Havens for Valinor, to take his mighty and fabled sword (the King of Gondolin surely needs it no longer) and put it back where he found it, hung up on the wall of that lair in the Trollshaws, there to be once again lost and in silence forgotten.

"A blunderbuss, was it? I thought it was horseflies!"

Ahhhh, you're starting to sound like MM the more you write.

Since the art of effective communication seems to be lost on you, let me give you a few pointers before I systematically deflate your arguments once again.

A: Avoid using level 3 words that are derived mostly from latin.
B: Use level one words whenever possible. These are mostly Anglo-saxon.
C: To avoid the impression of being pretentious, use level two words in lieu of a level one word only when it is a more precise word for the idea you are trying to convey.

On to the rest of your silly post.....

#3....you totally missed the point. The point was not the contrast between the two, the point was HOW each medium becomes "good" or "great".

#4...I assume that was another feeble attempt at sarcasim? I warned you about that. Find something else try to be funny with, cause it ain't working.

#5...Since I do not name names, I must assume that you believe that discription applies to you? I would argue that because you have the ability to actually turn your computer on, but hey, if you say so, who am I to argue when you accept that as an accurate discription of yourself?

#6...Wow! An intelligible argument! Too bad you you still mistaken, but at least you are clearly mistaken. A female, wandering about all alone, with no visable means of defense with 9 nazgul (half of which she doesn't know their where abouts) many days away from safe haven, and you don't think that effects the viewers belief in a scene? And that in turn doesn't affect the consistancy of other characters? Ya know what, you're right.....your #5 point, I bow to you. You really do know yourself.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
I don't see them completely abandoning her that way, because they never filmed her as a warrior to begin with. She was wise and resourceful and they continued that vein throughout the movie. Her character was used in place of the worthless glorfindle for obvious reasons. She needed to be armed while searching for aragorn.....you may not like the sword to the neck bit but it works better and advances the characters more than a big red arrow and a footnote pointing out her sword, which is basically how those things are done in the written medium of a novel.
Oh yes, I've no doubt that Jackson made Arwen consistent to his own invention. The question still begs why he had to have her doing all those things to begin with, regardless of the false belief that it was necessary to replace Glorfindel. It also goes to show that a change begets a change, begets a change until you have something totally different from the written source. Something Jackson has done continually throughout the films. At least it keeps the FADs busy. They have to continue to go to greater lengths to try and explain numerous and grievious deviations.
Foe-Hammer said:
You act like they were totally commited to the arwen warrior role and the truth is they were trying some different things (like is done in ALL movies) and ultimately decided they couldn't get it to work.
Yes. A needless change. That's what I said.
Foe-Hammer said:
Your complaints are just more of the same nonsense that makes it appear that you think you would have surely made a better film and all you had to do was follow the book. Well, Thorin, that has been proven erroneous multiple times since the first day after FoTR was released.
And again, like always for most FADs of your kind, you miss the point entirely. The fact is, is that Jackson's movie would have been much better in some points if he had followed the book just as it would have failed in some points HAD he followed the book. You however, seem to think that Jackson's movie was perfection and nothing could have been done to improve it from the written source. This is so illogical considering that the movie depended on the written source for much of its success.

1)The Arwen thing could have been handled much better for movie success and sufficient placation for purists, even without having Glorfindel in.

2) Saruman could still have been portrayed as a tangible villain without being made Sauron's total lacky. Movie still succeeds, purists satisfied.

3) Merry and Pippin could have been made less idiots and more like the book and still provided the comic relief to keep the movie going.

None of these things would have made the movie worse and it still could have been true to the written source just like over 70% of the rest of the movie was.

Oh, wait. I forgot that it was the 30% of useless invention and Jackson's version that made the movie so successful. Staying true to the written source had nothing to do with it.
:rolleyes:
 
As for the "Arwen" thing: my daughter (who follows such things) told me that the actress went to Jackson and said the "warrior princess" thing wasn't working; that the "feedback" from the audience/fans had not been as positive as Jackson had hoped after FOTR. So, in the next film, he tried to go back to a more passive, romantic, "tragic heroine" Arwen and in the last film, well, she almost disappeared until that bit with the face-sucking - and, of course, her vision "child". So apparently, Mr. Jackson's first inclinations for the character weren't all that cinematically adroit, were they?! The same may be said for the rest of his character inventions. He would have been safer (and better off) pocketing his hubris and following the Master of Middle-earth - who, by the way, is definitely NOT Peter Jackson! :rolleyes:
 
Foe-Hammer said:
Because it worked and it was funny.....you just don't get it.
I certainly don't get it, and I don't want it, thank you!
Define "worked". That is a level-one word isn't it?
How did it work? By making you laugh? That wasn't exactly hard work then.
By giving Aragorn a funny line?
By giving Aragorn and Eowyn an excuse to exchange meaningful glances?
By being a useful introduction to Gimli falling off his horse?
By some other means of your own definition? In level-one words only please.

Who else here found it funny? :confused:

Regarding horses: It was mildly amusing when Don Quixote fell off his donkey 400 years ago; the idea has become slightly less hilarious since then.

Foe-Hammer said:
A. Avoid using level 3 words that are derived mostly from latin.
B. Use level one words whenever possible. These are mostly Anglo-saxon.
C. To avoid the impression of being pretentious, use level two words in lieu of a level one word only when it is a more precise word for the idea you are trying to convey.
Level one = Anglo-Saxon
Level three = Latin
Level two = ??
And what happened to rule A, with you in rule C?
 
joxy said:
Who else here found it funny? :confused:

Regarding horses: It was mildly amusing when Don Quixote fell off his donkey 400 years ago; the idea has become slightly less hilarious since then.
I found it mildly amusing, and in a similar vein to Don Quijote. Gimli has absolute confidence in his own abilities, whether on horseback or otherwise. Here his ego would have been slightly deflated, except for the fact that it was, of course, a 'deliberate' fall. Sometimes people who turn a blind eye to their own 'short'comings are mildly amusing. Similar things happen in the books- look at his words to Boromir before attempting the portage at Sarn Gebir, or his boast to Aragorn that Dwarves don't tire sooner than Orcs. In both cases Giimli thorougly exhausts himself, yet never for a moment considers humbly admiting that he overestimated his own abilities.

MM- no offense, but what are your daughter's sources? For me it is easier to believe that your daughter might be mistaken on the matter than to think that the producers are straight-faced liers. They quite clearly state (on the TT EE, part three of the appendices, 'books to film' section) that Arwen fighting at Helm's Deep was abandoned early on in the filming process (say 1999-2000)- long before FotR came out. This was based on fan reaction to an early leaked script and to a leaked rumor that Liv Tyler was seen with sword at the Helm's Deep set. This had nothing to do with fan reaction to the first film, as far as I can tell.
 
aragil said:
MM- no offense, but what are your daughter's sources? For me it is easier to believe that your daughter might be mistaken on the matter than to think that the producers are straight-faced liers. They quite clearly state (on the TT EE, part three of the appendices, 'books to film' section) that Arwen fighting at Helm's Deep was abandoned early on in the filming process (say 1999-2000)- long before FotR came out. This was based on fan reaction to an early leaked script and to a leaked rumor that Liv Tyler was seen with sword at the Helm's Deep set. This had nothing to do with fan reaction to the first film, as far as I can tell.
My daughter's "sources" are the same as everyone else's. She is "into" this type of stuff and peruses all the sites, magazines, fanzines, TV programs, DVD extras etc. about the subject. You cannot pretend that Jackson and the rest of those involved with these films have been particularly reticent in their comments! Indeed, they have said enough on those same DVD extras, interviews, TV programs, fanzines, film sites etc. that were it to be filmed, you'd have five films as long as the three that they made!

But nothing proves what she has said more than Jackson's "about face" on a character whom we were led to believe before the release of FOTR was going to be a strong "warrior type" throughout the films. In fact, Arwen shows up at Helm's Deep, but Jackson later thought better of it and edited her out (although it is possible to catch a glimpse of her there). What can this possibly mean except that the Director changed his mind about the character's presentation? And what would make more sense than he did so because (contrary to your assumptions) he did get "negative feedback" about Arwen in FOTR?
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
<Gimli>I found it mildly amusing, and in a similar vein to Don Quijote.

What can this possibly mean except that the Director changed his mind about the character's presentation? And what would make more sense than he did so because (contrary to your assumptions) he did get "negative feedback" about Arwen in FOTR?

In his own context the Man of La Mancha is still amusing.
So are the US Austin Powers series of films, and the UK Carry On.... series.
I'll watch them and enjoy them, when I'm looking for that sort of entertainment. When I'm looking for a different kind of entertainment, I do NOT expect to find their equivalent. I don't expect it in Star Wars, or in Titanic, or in Psycho,
or in Gone with the Wind - or in something claimed to based on TLOTR. When I get it, in FOTR and TTT, I don't like it.
Unfortunately, PJ has chosen to take his style of humour from them, and, as I understand it, from his previous oeuvre.
Tolkien had his own sense of humour, which has appealed to his readers for the last fifty years.
The two styles have very little in common, and I know which would have been the more suitable, and the more effective,
in these films. The book incidents you mention bear no comparison with what poor J R-D is made to do and say.
PJ's choice doesn't only clash with Tolkien; it completely loses the mood of his own films. Watching them is sometimes
like switching channels from the Simpsons to Shakespeare and back, all in a couple of minutes! Is that the sort of expert cinematography that we're all told to go and be educated in? :D


There's a possible clue in the fact that Liv was surprised to find unfavourable reaction to her actions in FOTR.
If they knew before FOTR was released that there was unfavourable reaction to Arwen at HD, they should have been able to make a guess that her part in FOTR would also be unpopular with the "fans" - then she wouldn't, or shouldn't, have been so surprised.
 
Last edited:

Today's events

Back
Top