• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Mrs. Maggott said:
So apparently, Mr. Jackson's first inclinations for the character weren't all that cinematically adroit, were they?!
Much like the Wright Brothers' first inclinations at flight weren't all that aerodynamically adroit, were they?

You try things, they don't work, you move on. You're an artist aren't you Mrs. M? Never balled up a drawing or tossed a canvas? Many of the world's finest artists would be quite envious I'm sure.

Once upon a time, some fool actually opined that you learn more from your mistakes than your successes. Go figger.

Do we really need to revisit "Trotter" again?
 
The difference between the two men's sense of humor is that Tolkien's humor in the book arises from life; it isn't an "add on" or an "in joke" or an attempt to actually be "humorous". It is, in fact, the sort of humor in which people engage in their daily life as, for instance, Merry - or Pippin's - statement that Sam would charge down a dragon for Frodo - if he didn't fall over his own big feet first! That's the sort of "funny" thing one would say in a real conversation.

On the other hand, Jackson's "humor" is intrusive. It is external to the narrative flow. It is, in fact, put in to "get a laugh" from the audience. I didn't mind Gandalf bumping his head so much (as that is something that certainly could happen!) or even M&P's fireworks hijinks as that, too, "fit" in the narrative flow. But comments about "dwarf tossing" in FOTR, the bit with the at once too big and too small chain mail in TTT and a lot of other "funny bits" were distinctly out of character and/or context. They didn't appear to be anything but what they were: an effort to make the audience laugh. And each time Jackson included one of these "in jokes", he seriously compromised the world he ostensibly wished so devoutly to create. You can't have it both ways! You can't be Peter Jackson of The Frighteners and at the same time, a serious film director who has sufficient respect for his films that he refrains from poking fun at them however tempting it may be to do so.
 

Tell you what Thorin.....you provide facts that prove the movie would have been better with your scenes, and I'll provide you with facts surrounding it's record breaking success as it is and we'll just see who is wishful thinking.
 

You are going to answer that directly.

joxy said:
Who else here found it funny?

Ask yourself that question and have the courage to answer it. Most people did. It is mostly the npw that complains about it and their opinions are such a small percentage of the whole, they are dismissed out of hand on a regular basis.

joxy said:
Regarding horses: It was mildly amusing when Don Quixote fell off his donkey 400 years ago; the idea has become slightly less hilarious since then.

I found the scene amusing and the audiences I have been in reacted the same way. Why do you keep changing adjectives? You are always exaggerating the effect of the scenes you hate. Why?

joxy said:
Level one = Anglo-Saxon
Level three = Latin
Level two = ??

Greek and some latin.

joxy said:
And what happened to rule A, with you in rule C?
[/quote]

Those words best described my thoughts. I try to use as many level one words as I can so that communication is easier. We aren't here to try to impress anyone with our vocabulary. Right?
 

That would be true IF they portrayed her as a warrior.

Please list each scene from FoTR that casts arwen as a warrior in the extreme sense that you are claiming.
 

Absolutely brilliant! Kudos Parrot! You nailed it!

(Of course, the npw will claim that pj should have just followed the entire book and he would have had a bigger success than he does now. Had he done that we'd have a verbatium re-telling of the FoTR and the other two movies would never had made it to the theaters and PJ's FoTR would be as poor as R & B and Bakshi)
 

You continue to beat that drum like a red-headed step child.

The humor was in Gimli's pridefulness. A trait that is completely in character throughout the movie. It is humorous because even when facing death, his pridefulness is intact. You, like always, choose to focus on what is different than the book and not that which is consistant with the book. The consistancy is there, you just choose not to see it.

So, my dear MM, you can't have it both ways either.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
1. You are going to answer that directly.

2. That would be true IF they portrayed her as a warrior.
Please list each scene from FoTR that casts arwen as a warrior in the extreme sense that you are claiming.

1. ????
You said that Gimli's line about dwarves appearing out of a hole in the ground "worked". I didn't understand that, but made some wild guesses what it meant, and then asked you what it meant. I'd still like to know.

2. I didn't say anything about Arwen being portrayed as a warrior, I've claimed no extreme sense, and I don't know any scenes that cast her as a warrior, in an extreme sense. I commented on the discovery she made, that her part in FOTR had not appealed to many "fans" who had seen it; in relation to the claim that had been made, that the lack of appeal was well known even before the film was released.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
You continue to beat that drum....
....The humor was in Gimli's pridefulness.
While you take on the whole percussion section with that ancient stuff about an imaginary "verbatim" film.
And, you've beaten your own drum before, about this pride you see.
I see nothing of the kind - just a bit of silly boastfulness, in a mock Scots accent.
If PJ was supposed to be showing pride in him, he failed; I'd never even thought he was trying for that.
Of course, the REAL Gimli was proud; and he showed it with great dignity - and still found the ability to be humorous at appropriate times in the appropriate way.
 

HAHAHAHAHAHA! Am I surprised that you never thought he was trying for that? You missed tons of stuff because you went looking for something else. Something that someone else told you about and you believed it.

Gimli's pridefullness WAS almost the whole character. The audience laughed and you assumed it was because the WORDS were funny. Gimlis humor was in his stubborn pride. But you have to be open to it. When you aren't, you just end up going with whatever is easiest to believe. And the loathing distaste for PJ has colored many a post because he is the easy target.
 

My comment was a general one about Gimli and not a specific one about that line, but the difference was so minute, if you feel one doesn't work, the other must not either.


Oh, misunderstood your point. Sorry.
 
Ah, yes! These films are breaking all kinds of box office records. But remember, they are doing so in the same culture that adores "reality TV" along with the Sopranos, Ozzie Osbourne and Jerry Springer, as well as films chock full of violence, sex, mutilations, explosions, car chases, and endless mindless video games!

It would seem to me that while "popularity" may indicate many things, excellence is not necessarily one of them!
 

Is a horse chase is different than a car chase. Tell the group maggot, is violence worse with sword, spear, and trebochets, or a gun and a bomb?

Jrrs uses the same exact base emotional tricks in his story. It seems to me that you have developed a real hate for our culture. Perhapes it is time for you to find a deep hole so you can enjoy your precious reality without the rest of the evil world assailing you from all sides? (remember, that self same culture is the most charitable. See 9-11, afghanistan aid, Iraq aid, etc. Those same people sat next to you in the theater and they enjoy the movie)

Mrs. Maggott said:
It would seem to me that while "popularity" may indicate many things, excellence is not necessarily one of them!

But in this case it does. People are being entertained by a story of good and evil, love and hate, right and wrong. It is by no stretch, gratuitous.
 
Foe-hammer posted: An old argument which attempts to prevent almost anyone from criticizing anything negatively.

But if commercial success is all you look for there’s no point in discussing the good or bad points. Just look at the cash that it brings in and shut one’s mouth altogether. Yeah, Britney Speers and Danielle Steele!

The have lots of fans and make lots of money and are therefore beyond anyone’s criticism.

Logical reasoning?
The problem is the npw ONLY focuses on individual points and does not look at the scene in relation to the rest of the movie AND the limitations of the film medium.
More wild accusation. Why would anyone accept that?
I have seen several insults leveled at people who enjoy the films. Mostly along the lines that they are shallow. You may never had said that, but no one was really talking to you. You just decided to interject yourself into this.
I’ve seen insults that other way also, some of them unwarrented, some from you.
People did identify with the characters in those movies. PJ was completely successful in this area. Every character was believable and their feelings were such that we can identify. This is what makes for good cinema.
You claimed that if Jackson had been more faithful to the sources the result would be like those films. I asked you to support that statement. You have not done so, of course.

More unsupported claims.

What people are criticising in Jackson’s films have nothing particularly to do with the other films you mentioned, nothing at all.

Also, personally, I’m no more ready to identify with movie-Gimli than with Jar Jar Binks or Cheetah in the later Weismuller Tarzan movies, for much the same reasons. Again and again the Faramir issue comes up. So factually, at very best, Jackson was obviously not completely successful. You exagerate again. I also did not find movie-Théoden or movie-Gimli or movie-Denethor believable. Why should I? They weren’t believable. That doesn’t effect my problems with those films one way or the other.
The arrogant npw thinks all these changes are so easy.
Not easy. Unnecessary and unacceptable. Since again and again the same complaints arrise, even among supporters of the films, there is probably something in them. Saying the changes were not easy neither justifies or condemns the results.
Well, if that is so, why did it take so long to make a good movie? If it is so easy, why aren't ALL movies as big of a hit as these are?
Who claimed making a feature film is easy? But basic cinematography and acting are not what most complaints are about ... as you well know. Of course I do find flaws in that area also, a clumsily filmed chase scene for one. But those are not the types of complaints mostly made.
The npw refuses to ask themselves those questions and stubbornly hangs on to the "needless changes" or "it could have been better" montra.
Of course. If you don’t like something and you can see how it could have been better why not say so? The complaints are mostly on the line that a particular tune is being played by an orchestra with good to superb technical excellence and the tune itself is very good, but that the arrangement is bad in the ears of those who have heard a much better arrangement by the tune’s composer. One doesn’t have to a top jazz musician oneself to tell the difference between first-rate jazz and watered-down pop music (which may be more popular).
It has been a while, but gimli and others were much closer, yet this gimli is remembered and the tolkien one is not.
I certainly remember the Tolkien Gimli and his feud with Éomer which contained humor that arose from character rather than those inane short jokes. Jackson went too far for me and many others in replacing Tolkien’s character humor with schlock gags. That’s a good example of gratuitous and silly Foe-hammer insulting: anyone who disagrees with him is clueless. In fact I don’t think I know more about the technical side of film making than Jackson. But I can spot things I like and things I don’t like in films and in music and in books and so forth and can often explain my feelings. That’s hardly being clueless or pretending to be at the same level technically as many creators of films or music or books. I may not be able to build a house but I can tell when a roof leaks.

For example, I’m not prepared to accept Sam lying about Boromir’s death and Faramir being too stupid to catch him at it. That is bad scripting. Why pretend it isn’t just because Jackson is a big-name film director. It’s no worse than many other plot holes in many other films of course. But that’s part of the problem ... Jackson took a coherent plot and even fixed up a few problems in it but then ended by creating more problems than he fixed. And you can’t stop me and others from seeing such problems because they are in the films.
There was not one time in this movie that I, or anyone else I have met, were confused about what was going on.
More exageration. There have been many newbies on this and other forums asking questions about the film and why things happened as they did and so forth. Some confusion happens with almost any film. PJ’s films are not unique exceptions.

No-one seems able to explain why Gandalf was afraid to go into Moria when Gimli (and seemingly Gandalf) thought there was a thriving Dwarvish community there. No-one seems able to explain why Aragorn must either become king or spend the rest of his life being hunted (unlike his ancestors?). And who is hunting him? The origin of the Elves who appear at Helm’s Deep are inexplicable in Jackson’s telling. There is Legolas’ strange line: “The red sun rises, blood has been spilled this night.” There is much more not easily understood. The birth of Lurtz was shown in a confused way. Why feign not to know these things? Well, then point out the parts that couldn’t be done as in the book. I suspect you can’t find a single one, though of course time available and change of media would necessitate some omission and shortening and some conflation.

Foe-hammer posted: A friend of mine was almost fatally wounded from accidently leaning back onto an ornamental sword that had been left on a couch.

Real swords are far sharper and and far more dangerous.

Try startling a friend by suddenly and unexpectedly pressing a sharp knife against a friend’s neck as a joke. See what happens!

If someone behaves that way as a supposed joke, what does it tell you about their character?

Novels don’t usually have footnotes at all and don’t usually have red arrows pointing to them on those few occasions when they do have them. What universe are you living in?

But Jackson likes pseudo-dramatic silliness: a sword against a neck, a shield that looks like it has cut off Aragorn’s head for a moment, shield surfing or the Olympic Orc, the kind of thing that reminds one that it’s only another silly Hollywood movie.

If that’s all you want, then the films are indeed good enough. Fantasy films especially seem to get away with lower standards, probably because they have lots of eye candy. A silly kung fu movie Couching Tiger, Hidden Dragon won four academy awards in 2001 (Best Foreign Film, Best Score, Best Cinematography, Best Art Direction) matching the The Fellowship of the Ring in number of Oscars. If you watch The Lord of the Rings on that level then you will never understand why many are disatisfied.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
and endless mindless video games!


just a side note, not all videogames are mindless. Many are thought provoking and can be very emotional as well.
 
Turning "Trotter" into Telcontar (Extended Edition), and a post-script

Hey there, Parrot! "I hear you, man!" It never has ceased to amaze me (on those random occasions it crosses my mind) that the original name of Bilbo's nephew the Ringbearer, retained for a considerable stretch of time in the early manuscript-history of The Lord of the Rings, was actually Bingo Baggins!! What can ol' tone-deaf John Ronald have been possibly thinking? Or hearing, anyway; I thought he was supposed to have some rare sort of gift for inventing strange names and imagining languages!

Upon further examination, however, I'd opine that the point which you offer (and I largely agree with) in fact serves to buttress the case you oppose. It's not, after all, for their "first inclinations" at flight that Orville and Wilbur are deservedly famous; they labored for years to make real their idea, and only when they finally got it Wright (for an impressive twelve seconds, not too far south of my house) did the world see fit to acclaim them. And it's not just pioneering aeronauts, either, as you take pains to observe: poets and painters and composers and cooks each follow their unfolding way through the thickets of artistic creation, trying something out, seeing if it holds together, deciding it doesn't, coming at it from another direction, perhaps chucking it in and starting over from scratch. The critical difference is that your famous painter (at least while he's alive) doesn't have his first pencil-sketches on display in a gallery; your better-known poets don't read their rough and unpolished drafts to attentive large audiences.

Tolkien did not publish the first third of his story and only afterwards recognize that "Trotter" and "Bingo" just really weren't working, sounded quite stupid in fact, and then go back to revise them. He labored alone for an obsessive twelve years, and only when he finally had written it right (to his own satisfaction) did he send it to Allen & Unwin. The wide world's resounding acclaim, and the existence of our own beloved Forum, and the tremendous anticipation before the New Line release, and the enormous commercial success of these movies; all these are owed to that long, lonely effort.

Writing a book is, of course (calm down, Foe-Hammer) a very different kind of creative process from making a movie, even one far less complex and logistically demanding than The Amazing PJ's all-three-at-once epic. Hundreds of people contribute in dozens of ways to an extremely cost-intensive and schedule-conscious collaborative process; nineteen different kinds of details need to be kept straight simultaneously; there's simply no time in a mega-budget production to take more than a decade for someone to get it "just right". Nevertheless (to cut to the chase, as we say in the film biz) there aren't too many movies better than the scripts that they're shot from. Screenwriting is always the most important element; the number of great movies that are badly written can be counted completely on the toes of a salmon.

If aragil's right (and isn't he near about always?) concerning just who did just what, I should probably have been heaping my hot coals of opprobrium on the heads of Philippa and feckless Fran all along, and given poor over-worked Peter a break. Whoever may be most responsible for the screenplay, however, the amply documented fact remains that the process of writing and rewriting and re-rewriting these movies was in a state of permanent flux throughout the fifteen months of the main production schedule, and even, apparently, for a year or two afterward. New lines of dialogue were being created, and others deleted, on a continual basis; new conceptions of characters came into being, and others discarded; scenes were altered substantially, often from one day to the next; new scenes were being added as late as last autumn. The master-script for this massive project was put together piecemeal and in most disjointed fashion. Shooting a movie out of narrative sequence is extremely common; trying to write one all out of its natural order, cobbling it together more or less on the fly, seems to nit-picking me like just asking for trouble.

Especially if the source-material being adapted is itself complex and tightly interwoven, although Jackson made clear in a recent PBS interview with Charlie Rose that the screenwriters really "weren't interested in being faithful to the detail" of the original. "We, we made up a lot of scenes. If, if something wasn't in the book that we needed, that we felt we needed - like there's a key sequence in The Return of the King where, um, where we wanted to just have a real moment of conflict between Frodo and Sam, that Gollum creates, and so there's a moment that, that Frodo tells Sam to go home. He's, he's, Sam has been helping Frodo all of this way, and Frodo says, 'I don't need you anymore, Sam. I don't want you. Just go!' And, and that's not in the book, that scene. We, we felt we wanted to have that moment in the story, so we, y'know, if it wasn't there, we created it. We, we also, we also felt that we were making the films for people that read the books ten years ago, not ten weeks ago."

So I suppose that other scene on the Stairs of Cirith Ungol, in which Gollum finds Frodo and Sam nestled together in sleep, and for a brief heart-breaking moment seems "an old weary hobbit, shrunken by the years that had carried him far beyond his time, beyond friends and kin, and the fields and streams of youth, an old starved pitiable thing" was simply beyond the cinematic powers of PJ. (Too much for him, or not enough?) Boffo blockbuster movies just can't show such subtle emotion! Understatement obviously "does not work" on film! Sure, his dear uncle Bilbo can be suddenly transformed before the Ringbearer's eyes into a slavering wretch with pointed teeth, but render poor Gollum sympathetic without schizophrenia? Don't think so! Better he should be just a worm-squeezing creep from the start. Sure, Tolkien himself thought this "fleeting moment" the saddest in the entire story, but what does he know about "being true to the spirit of Tolkien"?


Anyone who believes that the stupendous box-office success of these movies is primarily due to the genius of Jackson and the unimprovable professionalism of his film-making craftsmanship, rather than to the inherent and ultimately indestructible merits of his source-material, needs only to take a good look at The Frighteners.





Foe-Hammer said:
Ahhhh, you're starting to sound like MM the more you write.

This snide remark was no doubt intended as a withering insult, one of that "veiled" variety you're so sensitive to; and certainly the Queen of Farmers' Wives has every reason to feel demeaned, being thus belied and belabored with false compare. I'd rather take your attempt at derision as truly a compliment; it's high praise indeed! "Aww shucks, Foe-Hammer darlin', that's the nicest thing that you've ever said to me!"
 
Last edited:
People, people, people, why must you argue? Why not simply say that the books were excellent books and the movies were excellent movies, even if the films could have been (a lot) better? I personally loved all three movies, regardless of all the modifications, though I must admit many things would have been best if left alone. (The Dead Army floating into Minas Tirith comes to mind as a BIG NO-NO!)

But does it really matter? The movies could have been better for us true Tolkien fans, but they were still good in there own right. Sure, the whole dead army coming to Minas Tirith and the Molotov-Cocktail Man stunt were both things that could have been a LOT better, but why must you insist upon fighting?

I honestly don't understand why the bickering continues.

1. Peter Jackson's movies, while better adapted for non-Tolkien fans, were largely ruined for Tolkien fans do to the alterations
2. Many of the changes are a disgrace to Tolkien, even if they made for a better movie for non-Tolkien fans
3. The movies could have been a lot better for Tolkien fans had most of the alterations been left unchanged
4. Some Tolkien fans, like myself, can still appreciate the movies as having been great, even if they do not compare to Tolkien's masterpiece
5. Some (and ONLY some) of the changes made the films worse for everyone
6. Molotov-Cocktail Denethor was absolutely hillarious

Can't people simply agree upon the above things and be done with this arguing? Can't we all just get along?

"Let's not bicker and argue about who killed who! This is supposed to be a happy occasion!"
— Monty Python
 
Khôr’nagan said:
The movies could have been better for us true Tolkien fans

Those kind of statements are things that start arguments.

Who is to say that people who enjoy both the movies and the books as equal works of art is not a 'true' Tolkien fan? Not you or I can say that.

So please, refrain from statements like that in the future.
 
As usual, F.H., you don't read (at least with comprehension) what has been posted and if you bother to do so, you don't respond to the post but to some vague understanding you seem to have of it. When I spoke of a culture that adores violence, you interpreted that to mean that ancient war was just as bloody as modern war. Well, to a certain extent that is true. Killing is killing, albeit on a smaller scale and with more primitive weapons. But that isn't the point I was making! I was speaking of the fact that we have made violence - real and contrived, physical and emotional - into a spectator sport. Not since the Romans sat around watching gladiators kill each other and Christians being fed to the lions has a culture gloried in gore as we do today. And therefore I maintain my contention that "popularity" does not necessarily equate with excellence - morally, artistically or any other way.

As for "video games": yes, certainly they can help a person aquire a certain amount of manual dexterity and eye-hand coordination. But even the most unbiased critic of the culture must admit that they are a fixation to the point where they have become the main source of "exercise" for far too many children. I have seen youngsters on picnics, at the beach and even at the movies totally absorbed in these games to the point at which they are totally unaware of their surroundings! One sometimes wonders if the concept of the film "The Matrix" might not be much closer than we realize if so many of especially our younger people seem to live "through" their computers!
 
Foe-Hammer said:
Gimli's pridefullness WAS almost the whole character. The audience laughed and you assumed it was because the WORDS were funny.
....the loathing distaste for PJ has colored many a post because he is the easy target.

No, it wasn't; and no I didn't.
That's my point: it's not pride; it's silly boastfulness. There's a world of difference.
I have absolutely no personal feelings whatever about Mr Jackson.
He is responsible for these films - so of course he's easily accessible - he's meant to be - and he made some mistakes in them; that's all I have to say about him. We all make mistakes - don't we?! It's no big deal.
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…