• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Personally I wish I didn't know that Strider was originally a Hobbit, as I find that it distracts somewhat from me as I re-read the books. <quote Aragil>
Actually, I wouldn't let it bother you. Tolkien originally wanted some sort of "wild hobbit", that is, one who had lived much as did Strider and who meets and assists the four hobbits once they get to Bree. However, it just didn't "work". I suppose he just couldn't reconcile his own description (and mental image) of hobbits with "Trotter" and so he had to "think again". This time, he decided upon a man who would help the four - and the matter went on from there. But "Strider" was never "Trotter" and vice versa.

Frankly, I think Tolkien was quite right to believe that even the "wildest" hobbit would not have been much of a help in the flight to Rivendell and his choice of a "mysterious stranger" was a much better plot ploy. After all, the hobbits would have been inclined to trust another hobbit - however wild - and the few moments we have in the story in which Frodo has to make up his mind whether or not to trust Strider adds to the suspense.
 
Not really. The backlash was also from the rumors that were circulating while the shooting was going on. Whether it was fan back lash from the rumors or after the first movie came out doesn't matter. The back lash was there and I believe had something to do with them rethinking their reasons.

And again, your quotes from the DVD show again what a needless change it was and how their opinions eventually AGREED with what the purists on this forum have been railing against: Arwen was out of character and leaving her as we see in Tolkien was the best move. For examples: If this quote alone doesn't tell you how even the actors felt about 'action Arwen' I don't know what does.


I rest my case. A needless change as far as staying true to the source goes. Sigh
 
Personally, I think I would have been far more bothered by Arwen actually fighting at Helm's Deep than her actions in FttF, which, in case no one has mentioned it, involved ZERO actual fighting. Point being, I don't think an equivalent reaction on the part of the audience to both scenarios was a forgone conclusion.

Also, unlike Helm's Deep (presumably), cutting Arwen from FttF after the fact would have involved more than simply editing her out, it would have involved filming entirely new scenes, not only to take her out of the Ford scenes, but also to reintroduce the character later in the story. Not impossible, but logistically, a much bigger task than the HD change.
 
Taken in their entirety, the quotes seem to indicate that even the writers and director were not all that thrilled with the idea of 'action Arwen' and only embarked on the road to create a character they thought would be more palatable to the guys writing the checks. You remember, the half-billion dollars-ish checks.

Purists have repeatedly claimed that all these changes were made in the name of vanity - "PJ just thinks he can tell a better story than Tolkien!" - if these quotes don't make it clear that PJ and Co. made some changes based on what they deemed, rightly of wrongly, to be 'necessity', I don't know what does.
 
First of all you can't say that it was entirely a choice to appeal to a specific set of people. PJ and Co. have tried to justify it other ways even if they decided against it later. They wanted to give Arwen more of a 'meatier' role and chose to totally create another aspect of Arwen outside of what they found in the book. Basically, Tolkien's Arwen needed a revamping.

Second who cares why they changed her? The fact is, is that they did change her because they weren't even happy with trying to take just the Arwen of the appendix. They made alot of people angry, they killed a good part of the story and after all the bru-hahah they realized what we purists have been saying all along: Tolkien new what he was doing the way he created Arwen.
 
Thorin, I think you rather missed my point. The 'when' is very important. You yourself claim that the writers admit that Helm's Deep was a mistake, therefore they also made a mistake with the Fords, which they didn't realize until later. I disagree. At the same time they realized their 'mistake' with the Helm's Deep stuff, they decided that the Ford scene was A-OK. And actually, I agree with that decision. As Parrot says, no fighting was involved in the Ford scene, just a flight from danger. I feel that that was withing the character of Arwen, as penned by JRRT. I am aware that you disagree, but have yet to see you substantiate this by anything other than "Well, it's obvious!!"

"who cares why they changed her?" I'd say Purists care why they changed her- at least judging by their pronouncements of "hubris" and "PJ thinks he can write a better story". IMO at least, if they truly believed that the only way to make the movies was to change Arwen for the sake of the sales pitch, then to me that is an acceptable 'sin' for the greater good, especially as they later changed her back with no harm being done.
 
brewhaha? I thought all you npw's were mad about how arwen was finally presented in the movie. Or this just an exercise in "na na na na na naaaa we were right and pj was wrong"? If arwen isn't jrr's arwen, and the npw's are still angry about it the argument is about at which direction the changes went?

Besides, arwen never used her sword in battle. heck, the hobbits were more of a warrior than she was....does ayone really think they were great warriors? Of course they never answer that question because it totally deflates their "arwen warrior" spiel.
 
The purists seem to care very much "why they changed her?" These changes have been put forth as evidence not just of questionable cinematic decision-making, but also of an overblown ego that must feed itself by "trying to improve upon Tolkien!" I think it is clear that some of these changes they felt they must do to "sell" the movie.

P.S.: I wrote this, and then saw Aragil's post that says the same thing almost word-for-word. LOL. Must be something in the water.
 
As Liv Tyler says, it wasn't until the second movie was being filmed that they realized they didn't like where Arwen was going. What are they going to do, start from scratch and redo all the Arwen scenes? Perhaps they thought what they did was A-OK, I disagree to some extent. They probably didn't have much choice considering the time and money it might have taken to redo some scenes. It worked and Arwen got more exposure so why not leave it in?

As that last guy says after they toned her down and made her like Tolkien's Arwen, "how could we have thought of her any other way?" However the fact that it wasn't just Arwen at Helm's Deep but where Arwen was going PERIOD that made them drop it like a hot potato says something, don't you think? Arwen at Helm's Deep is the same spirit that started with FoTR. Without FoTR's Arwen, there wouldn't have been a thought of Helm's Deep Arwen.

And holding a sword to Aragorn's throat and whipping out a sword in front of the most fearsome beings in ME screams 'warrior' and that Arwen knows how to use one. Compare to later movie Arwen who is totally different and more like Tolkien's Arwen. I'd say she was warrior like, no doubt.
 

Of course you would think that. You think that you can whip out a book
and that means you know better than professional filmakers.
 
I do not necessarily agree that they shot FotR and TT in the same order that they were later presented in the films. The whole process was a single shoot. One crew could have been working on Sam and Frodo in Mordor on one island, while another crew was working on Rivendell shots of Aragorn and Arwen in another. The one scene would end up in FotR, the other in RotK, even though both are shot simultaneously. We (or at least I) don't know when the flight to the ford was filmed relative to Helm's Deep. They could have been filmed quite close to eachother. And, given that Liv would probably not be making more trans-Pacific flights than absolutely necessary, it is likely that most Arwen shots were scheduled to be shot around the same time. That being said, the script I quoted says that Arwen was trained very early on. Certainly the shots we see in the EE look like rehearsal takes rather than full-fledged Helm's Deep shots. I don't think that the change occurred as late as you inferred, but I could be wrong here.

And finally, wielding a blade is not necessarily warrior-like. That she could defend herself in need does not in my mind make her a warrior- being a purist you probably know that Tolkien said all Elves (men and women) could wield a blade and defend their homes when in need. That doesn't mean that female Elves went out to war, but I didn't see that in the movies, either.
 
I have watched (and read) a great many interviews with Mr. Jackson and his writers, cast and crew and they appear to indicate that things were often changed - and I do mean OFTEN. Frequently actors had to relearn lines that they had learned Tuesday for Wednesday's shooting because someone had changed his or her mind about what the dialogue should be. Now, folks, let's be realistic here. This was a HUGE project (as we have been told countless times). The plot was very intricate. Many decisions had to be made about editing out things from the book, the first of which that comes to mind is the famous Bombadil thread. Characters and film elements had to be "combined" - it was a veritable Noah's Ark of planning and execution. And yet, we are told that given all of the above, Jackson (and, I assume, his writers) continued to make changes throughout the filming! No wonder there are "loose ends" and confusion! Given what he was going to have to work with, Jackson and his people should have laid out their screenplay, decided what they were going to do, kept inventions and reinventions and surprises to a minimum and then, once they started filming, they should have held to their original game plan. The fact that they didn't, that they continued to make changes - including such basic ones as making Arwen a "warrior princess" in FOTR and then simply abandoning that concept later on - indicates to me that Mr. Jackson was not nearly as "in control" as he should have been or he pretended to be.

Certainly during the filming of any movie, circumstances arise which require that changes be made (Tyrone Power died in the middle of a film and his place had to be taken by Yul Brenner!). Such things cannot be helped. But in this instance, it was more Chinese firedrill than well thought out and necessary changes occasioned by acts of God or other unforseen circumstances. I don't care what anyone has to say in defense of these films, like Tolkien's unfocused Niggle, Jackson needed someone to take him in hand and keep him on point. Unfortunately, he seems to have been surrounded by people who were as unable to restrain themselves as he was.
 
If the director/screeplay/actors thought Arwen's role in FoTR worked so well, they could have continued in the same vein without making her 'fight'. To me I don't see that as an issue like you FADs do. The issue is that regardless of what worked in FoTR, the persona of Arwen that was created was not sitting right with them and it needed to be abandoned.

I highly doubt all the concens about Arwen and where they were taking her were only influenced by the thought of Arwen fighting at Helm's Deep. "What! We can't have her doing that! Why that...that would be out of character for her! Surely she can wave a sword, creep up on a ranger and defy all the Nazgul with cheesy one liners. But..to actually have her FIGHT with that sword???" Really. The fact that PJ even filmed shots of her fighting there tells you that they didn't seem to see it as much of a stretch for Action Arwen of FoTR to actually USE her blade instead of just waving it in everyone's faces.

Your own argument condemns you. If you use the whole "Elven women could defend themselves with swords if they wanted to", means that they could use them. If they could use them, they could fight with them. Obviously PJ thought so by filming Arwen at Helm's Deep. Therefore, the obvious problems did not come from just Helm's Deep, but the fact that the Arwen they were creating was not Tolkien's Arwen.

More credibility is given to this when we see Arwen go back, not to FoTR action Arwen, but to the little princess in Rivendell Arwen of Tolkien. If FoTR Arwen worked so well, they would have kept using her in that fashion. They abandoned that train of thought TOTALLY, and as was mentioned previously by the EE quotes from the folks on it, it was hard to imagine Arwen any other way then what they eventually settled with.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
Unfortunately, he seems to have been surrounded by people who were as unable to restrain themselves as he was.


They decided their character of Arwen, a character they had apparently used to help sell the movie to investors, had moved too far away from the Tolkien character, so they reconsidered and changed her back. That would seem the very definition of being able to "restrain themselves" to me.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
including such basic ones as making Arwen a "warrior princess" in FOTR and then simply abandoning that concept later on

I would like you to explain which scenes convince you that they were trying to cast her as a "warrior princess". At the end of FoTR is can see why a person might feel that way. Just as they might feel Srtider was a real bad guy if they stopped reading about him just before it becomes obvious he is an ally. Once we see the whole movie we can see the direction they were going and again, the movie arwen is not the book arwen.

So, I don't really see an indictment against the crew that shouldn't be made against JRR and any other person involved in any creative process.
 
Another point that must be looked at when discussing the "feel" of arwen is when she is first seen by Frodo. She is seen as an elven princess surrounded by ethereal light. The next scene, she is kneeling beside him in different garb.

I have never seen anyone mention that but it surely is significant insight to what PJ really felt she was.
 

It's no wonder that PJ lost his focus, as Mrs. M points out, amid the chaos that dominated filming. I think part (but only part) of it was fleshing out a 3rd movie when they originally thought to make two (hence adding the extra writer for TTT), which sparked a general disorganization that snowballed.

This goes back to the point I tried to made earlier (which now seems pages and pages ago), about PJ making "lazy" choices. I in no way meant to imply that PJ did not work hard or devote himself completely to the movies. But he didn't go about making changes in a disciplined manner...instead he dug himself deeper and deeper by continuing to make hectic changes without thoughtfully evaluating whether the ones he had already made were good changes. Making more and more choices that dumbed-down the adaptation because they were the easier choices to make.

And no matter HOW crazy the filming was, PJ made these choices a SECOND time by choosing what footage to include in the movies and what was best left on the cutting room floor. IMHO, there is no excuse for leaving out the crucial Faramir/Boromir scenes in TTT theatre version and meanwhile expanding Helm's Deep ad naseum. Not to mention until I saw TTT EE, I still held out hope that PJ would exert some BADLY needed damage control over Gimli's antics (even cutting ONE line would have been a blessing)...
 

Come, come, come, F.H.! That whole bit with Arwen is "warrior princess" and I ought to know, I used to watch Xena! Her contemptuous bit with the knife at her lover's throat. Her "blowing him off" when he tells her to stay with the other hobbits while he takes Frodo to safety and she tells him she is the "faster" (not, by the way, the "better") rider - to which he quickly and submissively agrees! Her aggressive demand for an explanation when she couldn't find him in the wild! My God! If all of that isn't "warrior princess", what the heck is?

Even in Rivendell, she is strong while he vacillates, mumbles and shrugs. She is the suitor; he the pursued. She is strong while he is weak. In the next film, however, she is having the vapors, falling back on her couch with tears in her eyes and going off with other "ladies" in long dresses to the Havens. What happened??! My guess is that word got back to Ullman and Jackson that Arwen was "killing" Aragorn by making him ineffectual, weak and certainly lacking in anything that could permit the scriptwriters to turn him into a king even after twenty films!
 
Unless you were there, you can't really make the point that he made lazy choices. You have the luxury of thinking your choices would have been better. But that is all it is. You presuppose that your changes would have melded perfectly with what had been and what was to be filmed.

That is an impossible claim to make with any credibility. You do not know of every scene that was cut and it may very well be that your version was tried and it failed.

What he did finally get to the public is being hailed as a great movie. I don't see how you (as a non-professional) can assume that your specific changes would have improved on it's success.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…