• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Foehammer posted:
Again, I stopped reading here, because you have completely missed the point.
Foehammer, you complain that others insult you yet you continually insult others, especially for not listening to you.

Yet if you yourself will not listen, what reason have you to complain?

If you had read further you would see that I did not miss your point. I was strongly addressing your point.
Movies are made to make money. They make money by being popular. They are popular because they appeal to a broad portion of the population. The more popular the movie the better it is.
Totally true in this circular definition in which monetary profit is the only criteria of excellence.

It seems to me a most Sauronic philosophy that there is only one kind of good and that good can be rated only and solely by monetary profit, that, for example, the National Enquirer must be one of the best newspapers in the world by all standards (since in fact only one standard counts according to you) and that books or films and music that I esteem highly and which speak to me are objectively of little value except insomuch as they correspond with those books or films or music which have made the highest profits.

Aragil posted: Movie-Sam states:
You wanna know why your brother died? He tried to take the ring from Frodo. After swearing an oath to protect him, he tried to kill him. The ring drove your brother mad.
This is not why Boromir died except in a very tortuous, indirect fashion. It would be just as sensible to claim that Boromir died because he let Frodo get away with the Ring.

In fact Sam doesn’t know how Boromir died though movie-Sam now claims he does. Yet Movie-Faramir, though grieving for his brother, surprisingly shows no curiosity on the issue, no interest in what Sam knows or how Sam knows it and no curiosity about what other matters might have been hidden from him.

I suppose that could be justified on the assumption that movie-Faramir wrongly believes movie-Sam and would rather not know, at least at the moment, such sorry details as Sam might provide. Of course, if movie-Faramir had asked, “Yes! I would know the worst. Tell me how my brother died! then movie-Sam, careless in his words, would have been hard put to it to explain them.

I don’t mean that movie-Sam is supposed to be dishonest. I think the scriptors, and seeming yourself, forgot that Sam has no knowledge of how Boromir died.

For all Sam knew Boromir went mad mad and was slain by Aragorn. But for movie-Sam to present idle and unsupported speculation as fact is very odd.

Your suggestion that Boromir was driven to this almost hopeless task only by his guilt about Frodo is suppositious. Yes, it would seem hopeless. But would one expect Legolas or Gimli or Aragorn in a similar position not to undertake the same apparently hopeless task though not driven by guilt?
If he had not first been driven mad by the Ring, he would not later have sacrificed his life in trying to save others.
Boromir is presented throughout Tolkien’s writing and in the film as an honest and brave and guileless man, except in the matter of the Ring, exactly the kind of person who would die in defense of his comrades whether he had reason to feel guilty or not.
I thought this was the generally accepted reading of the book- that Boromir's madness brought around his own demise.
It isn’t. I occasionally encounter similar statements but never with supporting analysis. I expect that statement arises because Boromir’s death is associated closely with his madness chronologically and because a strong causal connection between ill-deeds arising from pride or anger or possessiveness and a subsequent death so often does occur in tales.

No direct connection of that kind appears in Tolkien’s tale. Boromir dies redeeming himself ... but with no indication that he would have acted any differently in other circumstances. Frodo was planning to sneak off in any case. In the book it is by chance more than anything that Aragorn has Boromir especially go after Merry and Pippin. (Well not altogether by chance, since Aragorn suspects something of the truth of what happened between Frodo and Boromir and so gives him a task that is not directly connected to searching for Frodo. But it is purely by chance that the Orcs first meet Merry and Pippin rather than any others of the Fellowship.) In the film it is chance rather than anything else, so far as we can see, that Boromir comes upon Merry and Pippin at that particular moment.

In the films Merry and Pippin also fight hard, Merry even cutting off the hands of several of the Orcs. Cowardly movie-Merry and cowardly movie-Pippin stand inactive as Boromir dies defending himself against incompetent Orcs who largely throw themselves on his blade.

Why was Aragorn not also killed when surrounded by Orcs? I’ve heard it suggested that it was because the movie-Orcs don’t care about Aragorn, being only interested in finding the Halflings. But when the Orcs do find two Halflings they ignore the Halflings and focus all their efforts on the man even when he lies wounded and helpless and is no threat to them at all and the Hobbits might have fled.
 
Last edited:
jallan said:
I think the scriptors, and seeming yourself, forgot that Sam has no knowledge of how Boromir died.
But for movie-Sam to present such idle and unsupported speculation as fact is very odd.
PJ's whole Faramir/Sam/Frodo concoction is so confusing that this point sometimes gets lost among all the other nonsense. There have been a variety of opinions about what was supposed to be happening. If Sam DID know, how did he know; if he didn't know, did he just invent something on the spur of the moment that he thought might stir Faramir? Does anyone know whether the writers actually know what it's all about; have they told us what they expect us to make of the mess? Whatever the answer, the whole thing does remain what I used to call an instance of incompetence, until I was told that such a thing cannot exist.
 
I disagree - with just about everything that you have said. And, in fact, there are some things that you have said that can be objectively proven to be wrong and not just a matter of "taste". Aragorn in the book is not "Mr. Perfect". I assume that you have read the book? If so then you are either using extreme hyperbole to "prove" your point or you need to read it again with an "eye" to the character whom you profess to know so well as he is presented in the book.

And I shall not go over the whole sorry business again. You may believe what you wish - indeed, it appears that it is impossible for you to even allow that another's opinion just might have some validity and so continuing debate is futile and foolish.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
I disagree - with just about everything that you have said.
Errrrrr; with what WHO has said?
I can guess, but it would be better to know for sure.
 
joxy said:
Errrrrr; with what WHO has said?
I can guess, but it would be better to know for sure.
Sorry! I was responding to our old friend F. H. (who called the book Aragorn Mr. Perfect) but you guys posted in between and thus, the sequence was lost. The post was too long to put in as a quote.

You know, I am less bothered by all the changes and deviations Jackson and his writers made than I am by the way that these are defended and
especially by the suggestion that the audience couldn't/wouldn't understand the original but would have no problem with anything Jackson did no matter how inexplicable and ridiculous! Like it; don't like it, but please, please, puh-lease spare us the assertions that Tolkien was too boring for words and Jackson and Company were essential to rescue the work from oblivion and obscurity - film and book! If that were the case, then why on earth did Jackson choose LOTR and why was there so much interest in the project once it was announced? Surely it wasn't because of Peter Jackson's sterling reputation and wide appeal among possible film goers! No! It was because of none other than a gentle English don who once began to spin tales for his children and then wrote a book - and then another book.

I detest any defense of these films which finds it necessary to trash Tolkien. I have admitted that Jackson could do as he wished; he had the legal right. I have admitted that much of what he did appealed to a great many people. I have admitted that those who like the films - FADs and purists alike - have every right to do so (indeed, I have even wished them joy of them). I really cannot imagine what else I can do to convince FADs that I [1] don't "hate" Peter Jackson or [2] think less of them for liking the films or [3] don't think these are the worst films ever produced. I have made that very clear in every thread in which I have posted; but it never seems to be enough, somehow. I am beginning to believe that there are some film defenders who will never be satisifed until I share their own opinion of the films and willingly agree that they are the greatest thing since sliced bread! I can only say one thing to anyone who is waiting for that day: don't hold your breath!
 
Guess what? I guessed right!
Rejection of this nonsensical idea, that cinema audiences couldn't understand what generations of readers have understood, has just appeared in an entry from me, again in agreement with you, in the thread about some award that TLOTR has failed to win.
 
Yes the FAD justifications are worse then the screenplay writers. I think the writers would have more credibility with their reasons if they didn't have rabid FADs coming in and adding every justification under the sun to try and refute purists.


Jackson and Company: - "We thought we'd give Arwen an expanded role to introduce her early to the audience"

FADs: - "Arwen has every right to be where she is. She is an elf and she could use a sword an sneak up on ranger. It wouldn't make sense for Glorfindel to be there. Considering that her father is Elrond bringing in the flood makes sense. Being the descendant of Luthien it seems proper that the She Elf defies the Nazgul and doesn't 'give up the hafling'. Why, Tolkien should have written her that way, his Arwen being boring with nothing to do.

(After the fact......)

Jackson and Company: - "We decided to keep Arwen the way she was written. She doesn't need a sword to be strong and when we look back at it, we can't imagine Arwen as anything else."

FADs: - Umm...err....Well, it seemed like a good explanation at the time.
 
We will not rest! As God is my witness Woman, you WILL learn to love everything about these films! Like Pavlov's dog, you will begin to salivate at the mere sight of Viggo Mortensen and that is only the beginning!!!!!

Oops, sorry, time for my next six month hiatus. As you were.
 
Then, of course, there is the flip-side to this coin...

NPWs:They simply have no regard for the written word or Tolkien's characters! Blasphemers! Philistines!

Jackson and Company:We changed Arwen back because we felt she was getting too far away from what Tolkien intended.

NPWs:- Umm...err....Well, it seemed like a good explanation at the time.
 
For writers to forget what particular characters know or don’t know about other characters is a common error. The idea that Boromir’s attempt on the Ring directly caused his death also occasionally appears in commentary but never with analysis. As I mentioned above I think this a careless subsitution of a common motif but one one that Tolkien happens not to use in respect to Boromir’s death.

That Faramir shows no response to Sam’s revelation that he knows Boromir’s death I think also careless writing. The Osgiliath scene is one that reviewers and commentators who praise the films seldom mention. I was taught long ago you can often spot the weak parts of a work by what those who praise it don’t talk about and about what they go out of their way to very carefully and very pedantically explain (the protesting too much syndrome).

It is interesting to note that had all the company been together, considering the large number of Orcs, quite likely Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli and Boromir would have been slain and all four Hobbits captured. (In the books many of the Orcs have bows and arrows while among the Fellowship, rather oddly, only Legolas is armed with a bow. The Orcs could have kept their distance and kept firing arrows which is how the book-Orcs intelligently took care of Boromir.) The only strategy I see that the Fellowship could have followed would have been to attempt a defensive retreat to the boats, then to cross the river and disappear into the mazes of the Emyn Muil.

Those surviving to that point would have continued the quest. Any idea of anyone going to Minas Tirith would have been dropped by the Fellowship as a whole even had Boromir been one of the survivors. Had Boromir been one of the survivors, he would have likely attempted the Ring at that point. Let anyone else who wishes continue that further.

Ironically Boromir’s attempt on the Ring in the story may have aided the quest more than it harmed it.
 
It certainly has to be another sign of carelessness, one more inexplicable element in that whole confusing scenario. Up to and including the excellent Forbidden Pool, Faramir is something like his "real" self; then he falls apart into confusion, and takes everyone around him with him.
Tolkien took care that everything in his books linked with everything else, and not always in the most obvious way. That inverse effect on Boromir could be a reflection of that characteristic.
 
My Beautiful Bird: I really do like Mr. Mortensen very much as both an actor and as great bone structure (I'm an artist and I luv the wee laddy's bones - and other parts!). Indeed, part of the reason I so looked forward to Mr. Jackson's film is that he got rid of the "pretty boy" and hired Mr. Mortensen who is definitely not "pretty" (thank God!). And until the sword at the throat bit, I was overjoyed with Jackson's rendering of Aragorn; I just wish it could have continued at the level at which it started! However, by the end of FOTR, I was prepared to enjoy the films as Jackson's version of the tale and, in fact, on one thread, I even advised a fellow purist to go and enjoy TTT! Unfortunately, I took my own advice and went! For the first 40 minutes, it was great..... ROTK had its moments as well and I will not say that I hate the films, only that I find them singularly disappointing considering what might have been! But rest assured, I acknowledge that as far as films go these days, they are head and shoulders above most of what's out there!

P.S. Are you going to see Hidalgo? I am!
 
The conversation has gone too far for me to make a point-by-point reply to jallan's (now much) earlier post. But suffice it to say, by the time TT picks up, Frodo and Sam have been wandering for some days in the wilderness. Not that they had to be huge chatterboxes, but mightn't Sam at some point ask "Gee Mr. Frodo, what made you make up your mind to so suddenly leave the Fellowship." Is it unreasonable to suppose that at some point in the several days that they are wandering in circles around the Emyn Muil, that Frodo might have filled Sam in on that leetle detail?

Sam strikes me as the type of fellow who is a great believer in justice and the underlying "good in this world". jallan says "a strong causal connection between ill-deeds arising from pride or anger or possessiveness and a subsequent death so often does occur in tales". I agree. Sam was a lover of tales, and I think he would subscribe to this as not only something that happens in tales, but as a principle which guides actual events in his world. In Sam's mind (as I understand the character), there would be more than just a strong connection between Boromir's actions towards Frodo and his later death. In Sam's mind the one would cause the other. For me this is not restricted for the movie character- it would be quite the same for book Sam. As I recall, Sam was awfully suspicious of Mr. Maggot for having beaten Frodo as a youth, even though Frodo was trespassing and thieving mushrooms. How much worse would he think of Boromir's deed- physically attacking Frodo alone in the wilderness, without provocation, and after 'swearing an oath to protect' Frodo? I'm sure that he would have thought that Boromir's subsequent death was just and deserved- a karmic consequence of his actions.

Having said something like the underlined bit numerous times, I'll take it that this rather unflattering impression is of me and my ilk. However, I should point out that I do not say that Arwen is simply the descendant of Luthien. Tolkien (to my knowledge) explicitly describes Arwen's character once in all of his writings- one time to tell us so much about how she acts in given situations. In this one instance he says she is much like Luthien in character. This is an explicit definition by the author of one of his characters, and it is rather amusing that you would claim to be a purist while at the same time brushing off the author's own words so easily by implying our comparison between Arwen and Luthien is (as jallan would say) tortuous.

Mrs. Maggott said:
I detest any defense of these films which finds it necessary to trash Tolkien.
I don't know if this is directed at me or not, but I would like to say that I have never in my life trashed Tolkien. I have on occasion pointed out what I perceive to be errors (typographical, chronological, or even moral) in the text, but I don't see that along the same line as trashing. I have also pointed out how I believe that Tolkien's continual re-writing (and even drastic overhauling) is similar in some ways to what PJ has done with different portions of the movie, but this is not trashing- it does not bother me with either PJ or Tolkien.
 
I don't think that the book had the same number of orcs at Parth Galen, although Tolkien doesn't really go into great detail about it. Also, they were not all Urak-hai, that much we do know. Some came from Mordor as well (Grishnakh, for one).

In the book, nothing happens to Aragorn because by the time he reaches Boromir, the orcs have left with their two captives. Legolas and Gimli have spent their time hunting orcs in the wood, but have taken no hurt. The orcs came for hobbits and did not stay to do battle with anyone remaining after they slew Boromir. In fact, had Boromir not reached M&P, he too would probably have lived since the orcs were not interested in any but the halflings.

In the film, a lot more action takes place (which is understandable). What I could never understand is why Aragorn is given the luxury of his single combat with Lurtz. No one comes to the leader's assistance or even waits around to be sure that he wins in the end! God knows there were enough orcs to take the hobbits and still stick around to watch the fun!
 
Not that I want to derail the thread too much, but Orcs at Parth Galen is a pet subject of mine, and I have debated the exact subject through about 60 posts on another forum. I believe Grishnakh was the only Mordor Orc present, and Ugluk's lot consists of about 80+ Uruk-hai and 100+ Moria Orcs (plus the 20 Boromir slew and however many Legolas and Gimli took care of).

Forgot to address this. First off, I imagine you meant that in the books Merry and Pippin fight hard. Otherwise it seems odd that you would say that the film-incarnations fight hard one moment, then that they are actually cowardly in the next moment. But of course, Merry and Pippin do fight hard in the movie- they not only chop off the hands of some Uruk-hai, they also kill several others. They enjoy a few moments of success against the Uruk-hai, but then stand stunned when Boromir is shot. How this could be accounted as cowardly behavior is beyond me, especially as it is preceded by them sacrificing themselves to help Frodo, and is followed by them hopelessly charging at the Uruk-hai with drawn blades. Exactly what does one have to do in order to avoid the label of a coward, in your book?
This where you seem to be mis-remembering the movie. When Boromir is no longer a threat, the orcs absolutely ignore him- they grab Merry and Pippin and leave Boromir to Lurtz. Prior to that moment, Boromir was very much a threat to them, and continued to kill any Uruk-hai that approached the Hobbits. Did you mis-type here?
 
jallan said:
Ironically Boromir’s attempt on the Ring in the story may have aided the quest more than it harmed it.

May have? It was written that way to add depth to the story. Do you really think it was a mistake by jrr? It was the pivitol event that sends sam and frodo on their own.
 
Really, who gives a crap if that was a mistake? It is a minor point that the npw has been reduced to attack in order to try and salvage their credibility since most every one of their other points have been dismissed several times over.

PJ's Aragorn was a much better for film than jrrs would have been without tons of extra scenes. They act like all their changes could have been added, replaced, or modified, and the story would have been better for the majority. That claim, of course, is absolute nonsence and untenable.

Since PJ is the professional, his opinion and skill must be given the bulk of the consideration when critiquing the film. Thus, the ONLY changes that have any CREDIBLE weight that the npw's want to make, would be in fact, whatever changes PJ is saying that he would like to make.

So, if you npw's want to continue on the line of reasoning that sets your opinined changes up as preferrable to PJ's finished product (the professional that made a successful movie that a majority of the people like very much) when discussing the success of this film, you will continue to be kicking against the pricks.

Kicking against the pricks.....

The prick was usually a wooden shaft with a pointed spike (prick) at one end. The man working the ox would position the goad in such a way as to exert influence and control over the ox. You see, if the ox refused the command indicated by the farmer, the goad would be used to jab or prick the ox. Sometimes the ox would refuse this incentive by kicking out at the prick. As result, the prick would be driven deeper into the flesh of the rebellious animal. The more the animal rebelled, the more the animal suffered. Hence, the statement to Saul: "It is hard for thee to kick against the pricks."
 
joxy said:
As so often before, you have absolutely no way of proving that claim about the minority and the majority, any more than I have any way of disproving it.

Sure I do. Go do a search on "favorite scenes fellowship of the ring" and tell me how many claims you get that the moria scene was bad and how many you get that say it was good. There are over-whelmingly positive. So, as I have stated, anyone who thinks that scene was just awful, then their opinion is in fact in the minority and rightly casts doubt on any proposed changes they offer and pulls the rug out from under any complaint that they have because they obviously are using the wrong criteria to judge it. Remember, their opinion is opposed to the majority and more importantly, PJ the professional film maker who is getting rave reviews from those with no ax to grind.
 
Frankly, F. H., for someone who posts that purists give their opinion as "Gospel", it seems that you are the one who does that! You state categorically and apparently with full knowledge that Tolkien's Aragorn "wouldn't work" in the film and that only Jackson's pale imitation could. Would you please give us the benefit of what palantir you used to make that determination? As Tolkien's Aragorn was never presented, how can you be sure that he would not have worked? As Yoda might say, "Prescient are we? Able to see what others cannot, can we??"

We know that Jackson's Aragorn didn't work for many devotees of the book, so that, at least, is an objective finding. There is proof of that contention. However, we have no way of knowing if in fact, Tolkien's Aragorn would not have worked simply because he was never presented! Yes, even you cannot credibly claim that you would not have liked the character had he been presented in the film as he was in the book. You may guess that you wouldn't have liked it, but in my humble opinion, had Jackson presented Tolkien's Aragorn, you would have been just as happy as you were with Jackson's character. True, that is a "guess" on my part, but you have nothing more going for you than a "guess" as well since you never saw the other character. Any declaration of dislike on your part of something which you never had an opportunity to see sounds like 20-20 hindsight to me!
 
Aragil posted: A better piece of fan fiction to save appearances than usual, Aragil. You’d probably have probably done a better job than the script writers.

But such saving would not have been necessary had the writers written something like: This would have avoided making Sam a liar and avoided anyone wondering why Faramir does not pick up on the lie and question Sam further.

Of course Faramir also sees that Frodo is being driven to madness. Accordingly the scene is a very difficult one to take seriously. Faramir has no reason to trust Frodo or Sam after that madness scene and after Sam’s seeming claim, out of the blue, to know the truth about Boromir’s death.
First off, I imagine you meant that in the books Merry and Pippin fight hard.
Oops! and yes. Merry and Pippin are first brave and then suddenly appear cowardly, probably because Jackson wanted to focus attention on Boromir’s slow-motion death. The audience is not supposed to be thinking of Merry and Pippin particularly. Then, after Boromir is practically immobile and it is too late, the two Hobbits suddenly regain their bravery. Boromir kills Orcs that approach him though at the same time seems hardly able to move. This is not unrealistic ... a last great adrenalin rush despite massive internal bleeding. But the Orcs had no need to worry about Boromir. They could have grabbed the Hobbits and scrammed. At least some of them could. If they cared about Boromir, one might have expected them to try the normal strategy used for multiple opponennts against a single opponent. Surround the single opponent, defending on the front and attacking on the back. I suppose Jackson wanted a big Hollywood style duel to end the film, logic or no logic. It could certainly have been integrated better (or dropped out altogether.) I suppose one might explain it by the fact that Lurtz seems to be the only archer movie-Orc and is sadistically slow about shooting while his faithful followers stupidly sacrifice themselves falling on Boromir’s sword. (When will Hollywood do a film in which a shield is intelligently used as a shield?) Presumably the only Orcs left by that time were too intelligent to wish to continue under the command of such a captain.

Or maybe they had gone over the crest of a sound-blocking hill and didn’t hear the sounds of battle.

In any case the Uruks who survived that we we see later all seem to be Cockney Orcs rather than Lurtz-style growling Uruks. Maybe all the stupid growlers in the party had been killed off. Stupid, stupid Saruman.

I too can make up fan fiction to attempt to save the film. But I don’t believe it.
I believe Grishnakh was the only Mordor Orc present, ...
No. See in Appendix F: I just noticed a remark posted on page 4 by Freawine in this forum: But possibly excellent if considered as a new work based on the original. See Kurosawa’s Ran, Akira Kurosawa’s Ran and Amazon.com: Ran for starters.

Ran is widely considered a magnificent film but not an incredibly popular one worldwide, probably because purposely too stylized according to Japanese stage tradition. But though based on King Lear and including much dialogue from King Lear, Ran is purposely not King Lear, purposely an alternate King Lear story, in some ways more grim than King Lear.

But that it doesn’t pretend to be the same story makes a great difference. Kurosawa had previously revamped Macbeth as Throne of Blood. And Kurosawa had his own original work adapted in turn. Kurosawa’s film The Seven Samurai was later watered down in an American reworking to become The Magnicent Seven.

Foe-hammer posted:
May have? It was written that way to add depth to the story. Do you really think it was a mistake by jrr? It was the pivitol event that sends sam and frodo on their own.
Of course I don’t think it was a mistake by Tolkien. May have indicates that we don’t know what would have happened had Boromir remained true, that is we don’t know what Tolkien would finally have written if Tolkien had decided not to have Boromir fall for the lure of the Ring.

In fact, of course, it is pretty certain Tolkien would have had the quest come out all right regardless of what he might have done with Boromir.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…