Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
Mrs. Maggott said:My dear F. H. Infatuation is a perfectly legitimate word in this context - unless you are suggesting that the "love" that your much vaunted audience has for the films is somehow more deep and lasting - as in romantic love - which I'm sure is not the case. Every "fad" of fashion - film or otherwise - is a matter of public infatuation with the craze for at least some period of time.
Mrs. Maggott said:As for suggesting that the films could be better: I think that there has been more than enough proof raised that many things Mr. Jackson and his writers did were deleterious to the films themselves and caused confusion, a lack of coherence and a general feeling that it should have been done differently - and that has nothing to do with the book. At the end of every one of these films, the cry is raised, "Wait for the EE! That will explain everything!!!" I'm sorry, but had people said that the EE would bring extra goodies, that would be fine. But most of the time when we are told about the salvific EE, it had to do with something left undone or unexplained in the film. To my mind, that constitutes something that could have been done better.
Mrs. Maggott said:The suggestions that have been made by many purists have at times been followed by Jackson himself. The greatest example of this is the return of Arwen from a warrior princess to "herself" as has been quoted and shown many times on these threads. If Jackson is not above reconsidering some of his deviations, why should you find fault with them being pointed out by purists?
Mrs. Maggott said:Do I think that being faithful to the book would have made these films better? I sure do! And I have no problem saying that.
Mrs. Maggott said:At least Jackson would have had some form of discipline for his obviously over-excited imagination!
Mrs. Maggott said:However, since it wasn't done that way, I cannot prove my point. At the same time, however, since it wasn't done that way, you cannot disprove it either. It therefore becomes simply a matter of opinion.
Mrs. Maggott said:And as for talking about the Jerry Springer audience: I do not say that everyone who loved the films falls into that category, but I think if you have read enough comments on this and other sites, you will find a great many (mostly younger) viewers who were totally disinterested in all the things we have been debating.
Mrs. Maggott said:All they knew was that the battle scenes "rocked"! Some even said that anything other than fighting or spectacular special effects was "boring". So I think it is a fair assumption that there was certainly a percentage of the audience whose interest was not cinematic excellence, don't you?
Mrs. Maggott said:So you're saying that your wonderful Mr. Jackson could not make a film about King Arthur (another "hidden king")? Or are you saying that he isn't good enough to take a fine character such as Tolkien created and make him "real" to his audience? In other words, as soon as Mr. Jackson comes across a challenging character he has to "deconstruct" him (or her) into a modern "lost soul" sans nobility and strength? Gee! I can hardly wait to see if he turns King Kong into Bonzo!
No I didn't; you told me about it and I believed what you said - why shouldn't I believe you?Foe-Hammer said:Obviously you took up the challenge and did the search.
....these movies are universally hailed by everyone (except for the minescul amonuts of npw's) who has seen it and the moria scene is a favorite in the FoTR. Go to Rotten tomatoes .com and read the reviews.
And, again, what earthly difference does it make? Do you like the films better because others did? Would you not like them as well if other's didn't? Who did and didn't like the films, their numbers and everything else to do with the silly argument of popularity makes not one whit of difference as to how individual people felt about them.joxy said:No I didn't; you told me about it and I believed what you said - why shouldn't I believe you?
I was hoping I wouldn't have to spell this out:
The only way to establish what people think of these films, and to establish which is their favourite scene is to issue a questionnaire, giving a list of scenes in each film, asking for opinions of the films and of the scenes, to every person in the world who has ever seen the films in the cinema or on television or on tape or on DVD, and to collate the replies to them.
Anything else is pure guesswork.
Your web sites and your reviews tell what the people who contribute to them think; no more, no less.
They may reflect accurately the views of the many millions of people who have not had the opportunity to express their opinions; or they may not reflect them.
There's no way of knowing.
I'm sorry. I truly fail to see how Tolkien's Aragorn is more complicated that he'd need 'the majority of film' to work it out? The difference between book Aragorn (bA) and movie Aragorn (mA) is:Foe-Hammer said:Well, if the story of King Arthur was as complicated I'd agree. If all we had to do is deal with aragorn then it would be possible but it would be about him only. But aragorn is not the main character (the Hobbits are) but the depth that jrr wrote him would require a majority of a film. That is why I said that in order to do him justice and make him fit the realism that PJ achieved, we would be talking about a lot more scenes.
Comment removed by ithrynluin I mean, what didn't you get about aragorn not being the main character like king arthur, paul, and whatshisname were in their storys? Geeze! Read the post will ya?!Mrs. Maggott said:Any kid who has seen a film with a "hidden hero" - and there are simply tons of them out there from King Arthur to whathisname from Matrix and Paul in Dune - can relate to someone who has spent his whole life in hiding or in disguise waiting to claim his rightful place in the world. This is infinitely easier to understand than Jackson's Freudian psychobabble!
Yes, the Ring is powerful, but does he have to make everybody from Frodo to Aragorn to Faramir such weak sisters just to make the Ring believeable? I think not! But that's what he did, seemingly.
joxy said:No I didn't; you told me about it and I believed what you said - why shouldn't I believe you?
I was hoping I wouldn't have to spell this out:
The only way to establish what people think of these films, and to establish which is their favourite scene is to issue a questionnaire, giving a list of scenes in each film, asking for opinions of the films and of the scenes, to every person in the world who has ever seen the films in the cinema or on television or on tape or on DVD, and to collate the replies to them.
Anything else is pure guesswork.
Your web sites and your reviews tell what the people who contribute to them think; no more, no less.
They may reflect accurately the views of the many millions of people who have not had the opportunity to express their opinions; or they may not reflect them.
There's no way of knowing.
Thorin said:1) bA realizes with the finding of the ring that the time is ripe for him to claim the throne.
Thorin said:2) bA also realizes that to earn his soul mate, Arwen, he must become king.
Thorin said:
Thorin said:mA is a wimp who has no confidence or desire. bA despite his doubts knows his destiny and willingly works toward fulfilling it.
Why is it F. H. that when you cannot find a sensible response you become abusive? Do you think that that makes your point? It doesn't, you know.Foe-Hammer said:Comment removed by ithrynluin I mean, what didn't you get about aragorn not being the main character like king arthur, paul, and whatshisname were in their storys? Geeze! Read the post will ya?!
Pscyhobabble? Ya got that right but you should be looking in the mirror.
As so many times previously, "hated" is a ridiculous word to use about something so trivial as a film, or a scene within a film.Foe-Hammer said:find some complaints about the moria scene from people who liked the movie yet hated that scene.
Mrs. Maggott said:Why is it F. H. that when you cannot find a sensible response you become abusive? Do you think that that makes your point? It doesn't, you know.
Mrs. Maggott said:You stated unequivocally that the audience couldn't/wouldn't understand Tolkien's Aragorn as a "hidden king" and that Jackson had to change him for that reason. I said that for years audiences have been able to comprehend the concept of a "hidden king" or a "savior" who first appears in the story in different guise!
joxy said:As so many times previously, "hated" is a ridiculous word to use about something so trivial as a film, or a scene within a film.
joxy said:I think it's great, but I also think it's in the wrong film - that's my point, not "complaint", about it.
joxy said:Obviously it has nothing to do with the book, but I also think it has nothing to do with the film either, and that including it was bad cinema as it breaks the flow of the story.
Look around the forums and you'll find plenty of people who agree with THAT point, that the scene is in the wrong film.
I'm only going to say this one more time:Foe-Hammer said:I know that you prefer to obfuscate your real meaning behind flowery rhetoric, but I prefer to make my feelings clear. You call it abusive...I call it "calling em how I see em".
I did qualify it and that is why I asked if you were smoking crack. I said that the amount of film time required to do him justice and make him work would require too much time. Since the hobbits are the focus of the story, aragorn cannot have a lions share of the on-film time and setup scenes. Almost every scene in the three movies you mention are developing the lead character or have a direct affect on said lead. This is the reason that jrrs work is not universally hailed as a text book novel. Too many leads, and too many endings. But he made it work and thats great, but it wouldn't work very well on film. PJ did a masterful job of bringing the spirit of jrr to the screen. Much better than any other attempt has or likely will be.
Mrs. Maggott said:I'm only going to say this one more time:
Mrs. Maggott said:1. Rude and abusive is rude and abusive. What you call "flowery rhetoric" is called being polite. If you can't tell the difference, I'm sorry for you.
Mrs. Maggott said:2. I pointed out (which you obviously have failed to notice or refuse to accept) that it would have taken no more time to present Tolkien's Aragorn than Jackson's since most film audiences were more than familiar with that type of character. Indeed, to be especially clear, I named a few for you: King Arthur (several films about him), Neo from the Matrix and Paul Atreides of Dune. All of these characters first appear to the audience as something other than what they are - and yet the audience seems to have no problem accepting their transformation.
Mrs. Maggott said:Are you saying that Jackson's audience was too dense to figure out in these films something that similar audiences had no problem understanding in other films - but at the same time they had no problem with Jackson's character who undergoes a 180 degree turn during the films?
Mrs. Maggott said:3. If Tolkien was so impossible and/or difficult to make into a film or films, why chose his book? Why not just go straight to King Kong and leave it at that?
Mrs. Maggott said:4. If you honestly think that Jackson captured the vision and soul of this work (and you aren't just saying it to make a point), then obviously you don't understand the book or, conversely, you don't understand Jackson. I don't know which it is, but there's a disconnect here somewhere.
Beorn said:From the guy who brought you My God, It Was Horrible, Part I and My God, It Was Horrible, Part II is the following: My God, It Was Horrible, Part III.
To those who haven't seen the movie, spoilers lay within. The Way is Shut to you.
Let me first list my grievances, those that I could remember at least since the mental list ran out of paper.
- Saruman? Who's that?
- ...At least we know for sure now that Eowyn killed The Witch King
- Frodo broke up with Sam
- The Shire wasn't scoured
- Lothlorien wasn't sacked
- Eowyn cut off a Nazgul's head (retracted)
- There are only 6 levels of M.T.
- The white tree wasn't replaced
- Denethor went flying like his own molotov cocktail...
And now I shall explain them!
- Who the heck is that Saruman guy? Where did he go? Hrm....I guess Pippin just had to grab the Palantir out of the water....
- So, at the Battle of P. F., Eowyn stabbed Los Witch King straight through the face, and all the way out through the other side of his helmet? OK. We are now 100% sure that she killed him, not the minor characters (i. e. Hobbits). Remember, The Downfall of the Lord of the Rings and the Return of the King is a story of how resilient Hobbits are, and how they can prevail in the worst of cases. So much for them....
- Frodo & Sam broke up. In the book, Frodo recognized that Gollum/Smeagol was a necessary evil. He remembered Gandalf's words, regarding giving life & death, and that he may have a part in the end. Frodo and Sam were the best of friends, and although Frodo followed Smeagol/Gollum, he didn't trust him entirely. He trusted the oath sworn on The Precious.
- The Scouring of the Shire was cut. We knew that. It's still a major faux pas. Don't you just love how the Battle of P. F. was made an hour long, the destruction of the ring about 20 minutes, and the ending (from the return to The Shire to blackout) was 25 minutes. They had to stretch their return to make up for the fact that SotS was sacked (unlike Lothlorien).
- Lothlorien was sacked three times. Is it mentioned? No. Who gives a rat's hindquarters (as I believe RD put it once) about the Elves? Apparently Peter Jackson doesn't. If he doesn't, I suppose it doesn't matter.
- Simply put, could you cut of that thing's head? (Sorry about that. I forgot, and Tal so kindly reminded me. It reads, "A swift stroke she dealt, skilled and deadly. The outstretched neck she clove asunder, and the hewn head fell like a stone. ")
- Count 'em
- Gandalf took Elessar to a small plant, sprouting out of the ground. There was a seed planted there, nigh on 1000 years ago. It was to replace the White Tree of Gondor, but according to Mr. Jackson, it didn't exist. So much for the White Tree shown in the crowning of the king as the camera panned away...
- What the heck was that?! He launched himself, as though he were on the enemy's side, like a molotov cocktail into his own city. Oh, wait, wasn't he almost in league with Sauron in the books? Something about a palantir? Oh, wasn't that the thing Saruman threw out the window? No! Pippin picked it up! That Fool of a Took!.
Most of you know my extremely sarcastic style. If you didn't, you do now. This style is evoked by an anger. A Plague. A Pestilence. Peter Jackson deserves to see King Kong bomb in the box office, since he showed how well the term 'hack' fits him when his master plan of making movies of The Lord of the Rings to get his foot in the door for King Kong.
We, the People of The Tolkien Forum, in order to form a more perfect Community, establish truth, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense of Tolkien's Works, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of The Lord of the Rings to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Nit Picking Weenie Guild of The Tolkien Forum"
Ladies and Gentlemen, the time has come. Our discussions will rage. Our words will issue forth like fire. Although I won't start up the Nit Picking Weenie guild again, I will say this: anyone who has a decent respect for The Lord of the Rings would agree that this is nothing less than a mockery of our complaints for the past two years. Peter Jackson, as he has shown in the past, is quite full of himself and believes his ability to "flawlessly" cut out parts and add in his own is unmatched and perfect.
Remember, you didn't see J. R. R. Tolkien's The Return of the King. You saw Peter Jackson's The Return of the King. Are you a Tolkien fan, or are you a Jackson fan?
- Mike B
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?