Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
My dear F. H. Infatuation is a perfectly legitimate word in this context - unless you are suggesting that the "love" that your much vaunted audience has for the films is somehow more deep and lasting - as in romantic love - which I'm sure is not the case. Every "fad" of fashion - film or otherwise - is a matter of public infatuation with the craze for at least some period of time.
As for suggesting that the films could be better: I think that there has been more than enough proof raised that many things Mr. Jackson and his writers did were deleterious to the films themselves and caused confusion, a lack of coherence and a general feeling that it should have been done differently - and that has nothing to do with the book. At the end of every one of these films, the cry is raised, "Wait for the EE! That will explain everything!!!" I'm sorry, but had people said that the EE would bring extra goodies, that would be fine. But most of the time when we are told about the salvific EE, it had to do with something left undone or unexplained in the film. To my mind, that constitutes something that could have been done better.
The suggestions that have been made by many purists have at times been followed by Jackson himself. The greatest example of this is the return of Arwen from a warrior princess to "herself" as has been quoted and shown many times on these threads. If Jackson is not above reconsidering some of his deviations, why should you find fault with them being pointed out by purists?
As for speaking "broadly" about things, well I voice my own opinion. I have never said "everybody" (as some FADs have done) but from time to time I have invoked the opinion of other purists as they have appeared on the forum. I think that would be considered acceptable. I you prefer to read my comments as generalizations, I cannot help that.
Do I think that being faithful to the book would have made these films better? I sure do! And I have no problem saying that. At least Jackson would have had some form of discipline for his obviously over-excited imagination! However, since it wasn't done that way, I cannot prove my point. At the same time, however, since it wasn't done that way, you cannot disprove it either. It therefore becomes simply a matter of opinion.
And as for talking about the Jerry Springer audience: I do not say that everyone who loved the films falls into that category, but I think if you have read enough comments on this and other sites, you will find a great many (mostly younger) viewers who were totally disinterested in all the things we have been debating. All they knew was that the battle scenes "rocked"! Some even said that anything other than fighting or spectacular special effects was "boring". So I think it is a fair assumption that there was certainly a percentage of the audience whose interest was not cinematic excellence, don't you?
As for suggesting that the films could be better: I think that there has been more than enough proof raised that many things Mr. Jackson and his writers did were deleterious to the films themselves and caused confusion, a lack of coherence and a general feeling that it should have been done differently - and that has nothing to do with the book. At the end of every one of these films, the cry is raised, "Wait for the EE! That will explain everything!!!" I'm sorry, but had people said that the EE would bring extra goodies, that would be fine. But most of the time when we are told about the salvific EE, it had to do with something left undone or unexplained in the film. To my mind, that constitutes something that could have been done better.
The suggestions that have been made by many purists have at times been followed by Jackson himself. The greatest example of this is the return of Arwen from a warrior princess to "herself" as has been quoted and shown many times on these threads. If Jackson is not above reconsidering some of his deviations, why should you find fault with them being pointed out by purists?
As for speaking "broadly" about things, well I voice my own opinion. I have never said "everybody" (as some FADs have done) but from time to time I have invoked the opinion of other purists as they have appeared on the forum. I think that would be considered acceptable. I you prefer to read my comments as generalizations, I cannot help that.
Do I think that being faithful to the book would have made these films better? I sure do! And I have no problem saying that. At least Jackson would have had some form of discipline for his obviously over-excited imagination! However, since it wasn't done that way, I cannot prove my point. At the same time, however, since it wasn't done that way, you cannot disprove it either. It therefore becomes simply a matter of opinion.
And as for talking about the Jerry Springer audience: I do not say that everyone who loved the films falls into that category, but I think if you have read enough comments on this and other sites, you will find a great many (mostly younger) viewers who were totally disinterested in all the things we have been debating. All they knew was that the battle scenes "rocked"! Some even said that anything other than fighting or spectacular special effects was "boring". So I think it is a fair assumption that there was certainly a percentage of the audience whose interest was not cinematic excellence, don't you?
