WAS it deliberately set up for that purpose? The thought didn't even cross my mind that it was a wraith. Of course a reader knows it wasn't, but I don't see any strong reason why a non-reader should think otherwise, and I certainly don't undertstand why PJ should want them to- very childish if he did. Inserting the new scene does make it even less likely.
Originally posted by PRH
and this?:
16) Yes another weird edit: The Fellowship is aprehended just as they enter Lothlorien. It is probably late in the day but it was still decidedly before dusk. Then we cut to the tree tops and it is clearly nighttime. THEN introductions and greetings are made! Why the huge time lapse here?
Is it just always dark in the tree tops, or is the movie actually trying to imply that the Fellowship spent the night in the tree tops before heading to Caras Galadhron (as in the book)(and if yes, why would they wait so long to make introductions?)? [/B]
It's absolutely nighttime at the grave site! Compare the lighting to that of the Aragorn/Arwen bridge kissing scene. The bridge scene is clearly at night and they have the same sort of lighting. If that's not enough - listen to the crickets chirping away (compared to birds in the Legolas/staircase shot)!Originally posted by Talimon
Why do you assume it's nighttime? I looked over it again, and you can clearly see behind Elrond that it's day. It's just in a grove and shaded, but you can see it's daytime.
Am I the only one who thought Aragorn's singing was, well, crap? It sounded much more like "mumble, mumble, mumble" than singing the Lay Of Luthien. And this was supposed to be one of the main additions to the EE as well.Originally posted by PRH
2) Frodo the interrupter: What a jerk! Why would Frodo butt in while Aragorn is singing nicely to himself demanding to immedietly know who he's singing about? That would've played a lot better if Aragorn had ceased singing and Frodo had paused and asked his question more calmly. It was a very nice little scene until Frodo crapped on it.
There are crickets and it is the same lighting scheme as at the bridge.
The vocal line on EE often seems to get buried, and if Frodo heard Aragorn the way we do there's no way he could have made out what he was singing about- even if he HAD known the language. Nice idea, poor execution.Originally posted by CraigSmith
....Aragorn's singing....sounded much more like "mumble....
Hey, I missed G's snores: I thought at first A had taken a swipe at SAM, then guessed he had just punched a cushion or something! Sam's song is great though; Astin really deserved to have the extra minutes he gets in EE.
I like Nóm's points about why Aragorn's singing sounded like crap. Here's a little extra bit from the book further excuse Viggo's apparent lack of talent:Originally posted by CraigSmith
Am I the only one who thought Aragorn's singing was, well, crap?
So not only do we have the move reasons that Aragorn was singing to himself and trying not to wake the Hobbits, but even in the book the lay was not sung but chanted, and not chanted loudly but softly.The Lord of the Rings, A Knife in the Dark
'I will tell you the tale of Tinúviel,' .... He was silent for some time, and then he began not to speak but to chant softly:
I don't think there are many who do NOT like MOST of the newly added "stuff"!Originally posted by Ariana Undomiel
there are some of us who enjoyed the newly added stuff.
But I'll still take up a posting to say thanks! We Brits should stick together!Originally posted by CraigSmith
To clear that up, joxy posted in another thread about the singing. Saves you doing it, joxy
Is this the royal We MM? I'd just like to point out that this We learned quite the opposite: that PJ et al really appreciated the books, and were regretful of every omission. However, the theatrical release still got the story right (In the Royal We's opinion), did so in 3 hours, and was wildly succesful with both fans of the books and Tolkien virgins. Not bad for a proported horror-movie hack with nothing on his mind but action and gore.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
We learned that the Director cared more about making an action adventure than telling a great story.
If you hadn't mentioned it in the first place, Aragil wouldn't have had the opportunity to make his very brief remark, which I am sure was free of the implications you assign to it.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Finally, such considerations as to how or where I watch the film has no bearing WHATSOEVER in the validity of my comments.
Yes, EE confirms what we have been saying all along: that leaving out irrelevant scenes, such as the staircase, wizard-swinging, tree-uprooting, and orc-birthing, would have left enough time to include all the excellent new material, the full scenes and the very significant brief additions alike, and still left the whole film very close to Newline's desired 3 hours.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Some film scenes could have been eliminated entirely - the "staircase chase sequence" in Moria added to the "action" but not the plot line. There was already quite enough action between the Chamber battle and the flight to - and fight on - the bridge. The time that staircase scene took would have been better used to include much of the dialogue and small scenes that defined the whole film.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?