• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

New scenes -- new stuff to complain about!

Well, we can all look forward to TTT because I doubt very much if there will be much of a debate regarding how close the Director came to the book in THAT film! And the debate will be even more sparse when ROTK comes along.

So perhaps the time will come when we will all look back fondly on our "nit-picking" arguments about the "purity" of FOTR film vs. book! But as the good Nom has said, that's all old news!
 
There is nothing wrong with this, but it's time to stop blaming time constraints, fiscal concerns and New Line Cinema for what Mr. Jackson has created. This is what he wanted and this is what he got!

In my opinion that's a faulty assesment of the situation. Let me refer you to some words from PJ that I quoted a while back, but will do so again here. It's from an interview regarding the EE:

-------------------------

How did you go about putting the extended DVD version together?

We were actually talking about it all the way through the editing of The Fellowship. Whenever we would look at a version of the film, and we would sort of agonize over whether we were going to cut a scene out, we would often say to ourselves, "Well, if we cut it out of here, it will be great for the DVD." Which actually helps soften the blow! As a filmmaker, you do feel a certain amount of emotional attachment to everything you've shot. You know that a two-minute scene in the movie represents a day's worth of work and that you were working very intensely with the actors to try to create the best performance and with the camera crew to get the best shots. You spend a day of your life crafting a scene, and suddenly, nobody is going to see it. It has a certain emotional blow attached to it when you have to cut it out. I love the fact that, as long as it is a worthwhile scene, then the DVD concept actually helps ease the pain.

As we were cutting the theatrical version, we would say, "We'll do a short version of this moment here but let's make sure we keep this footage and put it to one side for the DVD."

Are scenes cut out for pacing purposes as well?

Actually, scenes cut out for pacing purposes are generally quite nice. Often, there are scenes involving intimate moments between the charachters or a little bit of back-story or development, and those are usually the ones that are taken out for pacing purposes. They are often the very scenes that are good to have back in the DVD because they are for the people who have seen The Fellowship of the Ring and have seen Legolas or Pippin or Frodo and would like to see more of them. That's what the extended edition DVD can provide. We did shoot things that we didn't put into the DVD...there are deffinitely more scenes from 'Fellowship' that hit the cutting room floor and stayed on the cutting room floor. We only put in scenes that we felt actually enhanced the movie for the DVD viewing.

Which of the new DVD scenes was the hardest for you to cut from the theatrical release?

There is a scene that I regret cutting, but we were under a lot of pressure from New Line to bring the film in under three hours. As it was, it was two hours, 58 minutes, so we just scraped by on that. This three-hour mark was a psychological thing...nobody wanted to say that the film was three hours long. We worked very hard to achieve that goal. The last scene that got cut (which would have tipped us over three hours) was a scene involving Viggo's charachter, Aragorn, and the four hobbits in the Midgewater Marshes going from Bree to Rivendell. Then there is a scene at night where Viggo is sitting by the campfire by himself, and the hobbits are sleeping. That was about a three-minute sequence that stayed in the theatrical cut right up until the last minute. It was a scene that the film would ultimately do okay without, but it does nice things for Aragorn's charachter. And, quite frankly, it feels, at that point in the film, that it is a nice moment for that particular scene to happen. That was probably the one that was the hardest for me to cut out.

Regarding the Gift giving scene

...We were now into our final act of the The Fellowship, heading toward our climax, and it became a bit of a problem to actually stop the film for this gift-giving scene. That was actually a conversation I had with New Line at the time, because we all recognized what the problem was. To be honest, the gift-giving scene actually dictated the date that the extended edition DVD was to be released. I said to New Line, "Look, I will cut the gift-giving scene out, but you realize there are gifts that they are given that they use in The Two Towers. I will be prepared to take it out as long as you can guarantee and promise me that you will release the extended DVD before the release of The Two Towers." They went away and came back and said, "If we promise to do a November release so that the fans and the people who are interested have a month to buy and to look at the Extended DVD before they go into The Two Towers, is that okay?" And I said, "Sure, that would work." That was a negotiation that happened before we agreed to to take the gift-giving scene out. They had to guarantee me that people would be able to see it in place in The Fellowship before they went to see The Two Towers in December.

--------------------------

Make of this what you will, but there is clear, clean proof that PJ wanted one scene that didn't make it in. Also, the fact that the film had to be under 3 hours is, well, a fact. There were constraints, there were limits, and I think the EE is half an hour more of PJ's original script. And, mind you, nobody writes a script with scenes they don't intend to see in the film. In fact, if there is one thing a script doesn't take into account, it's action.

I guess my point is this: The TC is, at the very most, PJ's vision restricted to 3 hours. But I think that is faulty as well, since it neglects other pressures that were on him regarding what scenes to include and what not. I don't see the logic in accusing PJ of the TC on the basis of what he includes in the EE.
 
My Dear Talimon:

I did not say it was EASY for Mr. Jackson to cut ANYTHING. As he hiimself pointed out, Director's become enamoured of ALL that they do. However, let us be realistic! When push came to shove, HE CUT OUT WHAT HE CUT OUT! He didn't cut down on the wizard duel or leave out ONE of the five trees, or the silly business with the tons of impotent orcs between the chamber and the staircase, or the stolen firework, or the broken carrot or ANY of the things that have been pointed to as being overdone or underthought. IN THE END, THE CHOICE WAS HIS so I cannot understand how anyone can say that this is not HIS film AS IT STANDS (NOT the EE).

My Dear Nom (I don't know how to do that nice little thingy over the "o"):

I have long since given up making comparisons between the book and the film save only in those instances where someone has said that the Director was "spot on" and I had rather another point of view on the matter or when a comparison with the book was essential regarding the debate at the time. The films are definitely Mr. Jackson's - but that doesn't mean that I cannot point out inconsistencies within the film itself or how it might have been done better. Even more importantly, it doesn't mean that Mr. Jackson cannot be "exposed" when he has treated the story with barely disguised (if somewhat affectionate) contempt - as has recently been discussed between the good Joxy and myself.
 
Ugh. MM, you are aware that your opinions are your opinions, and not necessarily fact, I hope?
PJ was one of the screenwriters. He helped write the story that we saw in the EE. If anything comes close to telling us what PJ's vision is, it's in the EE. The ONLY reason for judging PJ by the theatrical cut seems to be to further display your disgust for PJ (please correct me if I'm wrong here). Talk about the glass being half empty- instead of just admitting that you like the EE, you instead choose to say that the EE proves PJ can't make a film. The theatrical cut was not PJ's ultimate vision, it was PJ's vision filtered through a 3 hour time limit. PJ was not given free reign to do whatever he pleased. How many more times does Talimon have to post that article before you'll admit that the people who provided the money for the film actually had some say in the final product?

PJ's 'barely disguised contempt for the books' is your opinion. As my mother says, everyone is entitled to their opinion, no matter how wrong it is. I can only guess here, but it seems that what you're saying is that PJ searched around for a few years to find the novel which disgusted him the most. Being basically an evil person at heart, PJ then decided to make the most contemptuous piece of film ever seen based on these books, for the sole purpose of ruining the pleasure that more sensible people find in reading the books. Having made this decision, PJ then decided to dedicate 5+ years of his life to the project, in order to make sure that it turned out truly abominable.

If this is what someone who dislikes the story is capable of, then it's curious that no-one who actually likes the books has troubled themselves with getting $300 million to make a proper adaptation. Perhaps it's just easier to play Tolkien Forum quarterback.

ps Yes my comments about the 65" screen were pure jealousy. I had to squint to watch it on a computer screen. If I had a 65" screen I probably wouldn't go out to movies, which is why I said that. My apologies for any misunderstanding.
 

But aragil, isn't that what all directors do?

All I am saying, MM, is that you can't "blame" everything on PJ. I quote "blame" because I personally find many of the scenes you mention to be very entertaining and don't agree that they detract from the film. They aren't universally bad, something you seem to be taking for granted. In fact, as I've argued, I feel that many of them are paticularly nice for non-readers, and at least for one reader . But that aside, it's important to accept the fact that PJ had a 3 hour time-limit. I'm not using this as any sort of excuse, because I enjoyed the TC very much. But if you want to know why the TC ended up the way it did, New Line are patially to "blame", for good or ill.
 
As to why Jackson chose LOTR, he has said he "liked it". The problem is he apparently didn't "like it" enough to follow at least the spirit of the story. To quote one critic: "I found in it an unadulterated tribute to virtue - virtue in its many forms and guises. The virtue of the great and of the less: faithfulness, courage, justice, courtesy, kindness, SELF CONTROL (my emphasis), long suffering, costly repentance, true humility - in short, righeousness, agape."

The same critic later says of the film, "Jackson undervalues and misrepresents Tolkien's various expressions of goodness and virtue and strength. One case in point is the character of Elrond. While Tolkien's Elf-lord is powerful, he is nothing if not courteous. He is a paragon of wisdom and almost impossible to ruffle. He may at times be stern, but he is always kind. However, the only way the movie seems to be able to portray strength is with a scowl. Jackson's Elrond has a chip on his shoulder, a 3,000-year-old unresolved grievance with the Man Isildur, who did not destroy the Ring when he had the chance. He speaks disparagingly about his future son-in-law Aragorn, to whom (in the book) he is a surrogate father figure. He never smiles but is always acerbic and irascible."

The critic makes a particularly telling point about the orcs: "Equally misunderstood and misrepresented are those who have succumbed to the forces of evil. An excellent example is in the depiction of the Orcs, a race that was bred to be the minions of evil...They (Tolkien's Orcs) are surprisingly faceless in battle...In numbers...they are overwhelming masses of bureaucratic evil: the nameless faceless denizens of the dark, tied to their Lord by mutual hatred and fear, rather than by loyalty and love...Yet Jackson, though he expends valuable screen time on the exposition of their (Urak-hai) lineage, misses this crucial point when he dedicates huge amounts of time to brief shots of snarling INDIVIDUAL orcs. In so doing, he nullifies the true horror of the Orcs; this faceless horde is what broken and twisted people can become...they (Jackson's Urak-hai) are not twisted versions of recognizeable people. They are totally other. Jackson's cartoonish Orcs are evil because they are foreign, not foreign because they are evil."

This article sums up completely my problem with Mr. Jackson's presentation of TOLKIEN's story. I have other problems with Jackson's presentation of his OWN story, but they are simply matters of, as has been noted, personal taste. But the article from which I have quoted above (and which I have mentioned in other posts) is a very clear, cogent and concise critique of how Jackson failed the story and why.
 
I guess one of the nice things about Literature is that there can be multiple impressions from the same piece of writing. What I love about Lord of the Rings is very different from what your critic loves, so perhaps it's not surprising that I have a very different impression of the movie. I also happen to be in agreement with a great many critics on the movie, but whether or not I'm alone in my readings of Tolkien doesn't really bother me. I have my view, others have theirs. I hope your critic does not think that they are the only ones that truly understand Tolkien, or that their opinions on the messages from either book or movie are somehow more 'right' than someone else's. Of course that's just my hope, and their opinion on the matter won't bother me too much, one way or the other.
 
What Mr. Dickensen meant was this: Tolkien's orcs are faceless, (and in all but a few cases) nameless agents of terror. They are what PEOPLE can become when they are twisted by evil cultures (Nazism, communism). In other words, they are "foreign" to us BECAUSE they are evil. (By foreign, the author does not mean coming from another country except where it might be said that they have been changed so greatly as to be "alien" to us.)

With Jackson, there is a concentration on various orcs to the point wherein they gain "individuality". We no longer have a nameless, faceless horde of evil, but individual "creatures" whose very ugliness and "foreigness" has set them aside as evil. No longer can we say that this is what tormented, twisted PEOPLE can become - and thus take care within our own cultures that it is not permitted to happen. Rather, with Jackson's orcs, we can take comfort in knowing that they are so utterly alien and "foreign" to our humanity, that their evil becomes a thing which is "distanced" from us. No one need be concerned that human beings can become such creatures.

In a way, the Star Wars "clone army" which eventually becomes the Storm Troopers of the Empire is more in keeping with Tolkien's orcs than Jackson's monsters although the former still bear the outward stamp of humanity. And in order to maintain the understanding that these are in fact hordes of evil, the Director always has them wearing their battle suits and masks. If we were to see their faces, we would be tempted to make human beings of them when, in fact, they, like the orcs, have been "ruined" and perverted into agents of mindless terror and death. They are incapable of individual thought, bred to "follow orders" and lacking in all those things - free will, conscience etc. - that make us rational human beings. They are, if you will, "pretty" orcs.

As for Elrond, again I must agree with Mr. Dickenson. Yes, he occasionally gives a pale, wintry smile (which seldom reaches his eyes), but there is no laughter, no "merriment" and even though the days are dark and one might say that such things are not appropriate, somehow one doesn't feel that Jackson's Elrond would be much given to them even at the best of times. Furthermore, one cannot escape the fact that he does in fact have a real "problem" with Isildur and, through him, with Aragorn. This is somewhat ameliorated in the EE scene where the two are together at Gilraen's grave, but Aragorn's behavior there only reinforces Elrond's barely concealed (and sometimes NOT so concealed) contempt with his prospective son-in-law. But that brings us back to Jackson's treatment of Aragorn and I really don't want to go there in this post.
 
all i gotta say is i really liked what they added i thought it made lothlorien look way more courteous to the book and it was a much better depiction of ghaladriel which was the only qualm i had with the orginal............but the 2 things were bombadil and sam at galadriel's mirror........bu niether of those were filmed so i knew they wouldn't be there anyway.......but i wish they would have put them in........but its not that big of a deal i liked it.....
 
I am tempted not to get into this right now, but I guess I'll just resist temptation. For anyone to say that all of Tolkien's Orcs are nameless and faceless is absolute BS. MM, if you disagree then feel free to look here at what is quite possibly the poll with the most participation in the history of this forum. The subject: which Orc personality do we like the most.
One of the telling things I've always found about Tolkien's Orcs is the following:
The squint-eyed southerner- is he part orcish or not? No one can really tell (though everyone has an opinion), perhaps because there is not such a great difference between Orc and non-Orc.
Treebeard thinks he might mistake Merry and Pippin for Orcs. Aragorn is worried that the Rohirrim might mistake Merry and Pippin for Orcs. Eomer at first thinks Aragorn Gimli and Legolas are three Orcs. Frodo and Sam are actually able to pass themselves off as Orcs to other Orcs. I don't think that Tolkien intends for Orcs to be so different from the other races. As such I don't see why PJ should treat them so differently- Tolkien certainly had no problems with showing us a little Orc personality in certain circumstances.
 
I never really got to comment on PRH's comments with the EE and seeing as this is going off track quite a bit (like most threads always do), I thought I'd bring it back by making my comments now.


Actually, regardless of whether he did or not, I was glad they stuck it in. The closer to Tolkien, the better! It really implied the parallel between Luthien's plight and that of Arwen. It used the foreshadow real well there and it didn't dumb it down for the audience which PJ has done elsewhere.



Actually, it shows a great contrast. Seeing the elves in their glory and the beauty of the creatures of ME, and then they are brought down to reality of cold, hard ground and the miserable task put before them. Plus, the more screen time to the hobbits for character development, the better.


Once again, I'm just glad they showed the scenes. It explained and showed the story of the ring much better. I don't necessarily think Isildur was a coward. However, Tolkien pretty much showed the same thing. The Tolkien facts are that Isildur did escape in the water. I highly doubt that even in Tolkien's world, he was the last man standing.


I agree with you here. I never liked the "You know of whom I speak" comment and the fingering of the ring on Caradhras. PJ did blow the foreshadowing something fierce and he just went too far in showing Boromir's disdain and future betrayal. I didn't care for the Rivendell scene with Boromir and Narsil. It was all just really blown to big and it was too much of a giveaway....It made up for itself with Boromir at Amon Hen, however.


I agree here as well. PJ blew that whole thing. Sam's behavior really didn't esteem him in the eyes of the viewer, and PJ did a good job of showing Sam's fidelity, politeness to the fair folk, and good nature throughout (something that Tolkien did all through the book), and it all came down at that one moment. That's really too bad.

Originally posted by PRH
11) "We will not meet again Elessar:" Galadriel says this to (naturally) Aragorn. I guess she's not attending her granddaughter's wedding. Oh well, too bad.

I was a little confused by this quote as well. My guess is that PJ will not be having the Lorien Elf band come down to the wedding in RotK.


My biggest problem with Aragorn is the way PJ has shown him to be a doubting, selfish person when it comes to his heritage. Tolkien gave him doubts, but Aragorn always knew he'd retake the throne. He never shirked from it or acted like he never wanted it. PJ really blew that as well and that is unfortunate.
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: New scenes -- new stuff to complain about!

I suppose 'tis better to have shown it and (slightly) spoiled it, than never to have shown it at all.

Hmm..I didn't see the two scenes as relating at all. I'll try to look at it in that light again.

Have you read "The Disaster of the Gladden Fields" in UT? He indeed took off during the fighting, but only under pressure from his men. He was the King, and what more, he felt the great need to surrender the Ring to Elrond, realizing it was too great a matter for him. In the full account, Isildur's men were vastly outnumbered. This was not established at all. We have no idea what or how many they're up against. It just looks like Isildur got scared and booted. Again, I suppose it's better to show it and ruin it than not to show it at all. It's a pretty complex series of events to tell so shorthand. I liked how it played a lot, but it left a bad impression of Isildur (which I think was the intend -- show him as a corrupt guy).

I'm glad you agree but...Well...I loved the invented Caradhras scene...and he never actually touched the Ring there anyway.

The self-doubting/shirking Aragorn was a fully intentional change. It's not Tolkien, but I like it. My problem was the dimishment of TC Movie Aragorn into EE Movie Aragorn (neither of which resemble Book Aragorn).
 

No one said that Tolkien did not write about INDIVIDUAL orcs when the circumstances demanded it. Nevertheless, the horror of the orcs is not in any one individual, but in their overwhelming numbers and their nameless, faceless evil. They are like the army ants of South America which, once on the "march", devour EVERYTHING in their path. Tolkien even refers to them in such a way (as creatures of the hive) when he describes what happens after the fall of Sauron. The orcs represented in Tolkien's work what happens when men are co-opted by an evil system.

Think of the pictures that you have seen on television of the endless ranks of Nazi soldiers, storm troopers and SS, all looking alike, all dressed alike and all horribly, terribly obedient to an insane, evil will. THAT is what the orcs were in Tolkien's mind and to him they represented not merely monsters of the body that were hideous to LOOK at, but monsters of the soul, empty of all but the will to do evil. The fact that he gave several names in the course of his narration or that he described a few (like the tracker orc in Mordor and his larger companion - whom he slew with an arrow), does not mean that he wanted us to look at and judge them as INDIVIDUALS. By seeing only the WORDS, you are missing the MEANING.
 
No, they don't relate at all! As T says himself, they're a great contrast, far too much of a contrast in fact. As separate scenes they'd have done the job T wants for them; when one so very abruptly follows the other they spoil each other's effects.
 
quote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
My biggest problem with Aragorn is the way PJ has shown him to be a doubting, selfish person when it comes to his heritage. Tolkien gave him doubts, but Aragorn always knew he'd retake the throne. He never shirked from it or acted like he never wanted it. PJ really blew that as well and that is unfortunate.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
The self-doubting/shirking Aragorn was a fully intentional change. It's not Tolkien, but I like it. My problem was the dimishment of TC Movie Aragorn into EE Movie Aragorn (neither of which resemble Book Aragorn). <quote PRH>
***********************************

But that's just it. Aragorn did NOT know that he would reclaim the throne in the book. As long as Sauron still reigned in Mordor, he could NOT do so. That is why the line of Elendil was kept hidden in the North for all of those years. Had the Dark Lord even suspected that an heir to Elendil still lived, he would have spared nothing to find and destroy or capture him. He would have waged all out war in Middle Earth instead of the slow, steady encroachments and deeply laid plans that he was using at the time of the story which took time but would have ended in success had the Ring not been destroyed.

Aragorn could not claim the throne and that is why his love for Arwen and Elrond's caveat to their marriage (that he be king of BOTH kingdoms) was such a burden. Until Sauron either fell or there was no further reason to hide his identity (before he took the Paths of the Dead), Aragorn was fated to spend his life without a wife, without a family, with no heir and virtually homeless. Of course he had doubts! It's just that they weren't about his heritage, but, rather, whether or not he would EVER have the opportunity to claim the throne and marry the girl! It's no wonder he was a bit "dour" in nature!
 

Yeah, you're right. I guess "knew he'd reclaim the throne" were too strong of words. Let's say that he had doubts that he could physically claim the throne (i.e. with Sauron in the way). But he never had problems that he WOULDN'T claim the throne under any circumstances....That's something that PJ didn't (or couldn't show), the fact that if Aragorn DID not try to fufill his heritage, that he would be wifeless, for Elrond wouldn't give him Arwen...In light of that, PJ's interpretation of Aragorn falls woefully short of what he should be.
 
In light of that, PJ's interpretation of Aragorn falls woefully short of what he should be. <quote Thorin>

Amen, brother! That's what I've been saying all along!

My Dear Parrott:

That is in the article that I am going to TRY to type into my thread "I have an article" somewhere in the forum (!) - I think in the Film v. Book area.

Have you looked into adopting an abandoned and/or abused parrot yet? I am sure there is a parrot society and I know that some of them make birds available to good homes! You may not get a huge and beautiful McCaw, but there are many other beautiful birds waiting and hoping for good homes! Let me know if you should be successful and if you are, what you have adopted!
 
Mrs. M.,
I now have a black-lab who is a bird-killing machine so any idea I had of owning a bird has gone pretty much gone (ahem) out the window. My neighbors have a beautiful Maccaw which they usually leave on their screen porch (during warm weather), so I am able to get my bird fix on our nightly walks.
 
When one looks at the orcs individually, one is tempted to assume that, just as human beings (or elves, or US, for that matter) they have the innate ability to react "individually". However, the orcs do not. Yes, they have leaders and, yes, they are "individuals" insofar as Gorbag is not Shagrat is not Grishnakh. They also have the capability of reacting individually with a given situation. But they do NOT have the ability to be anything other than what they are: evil. That is why Tolkien describes them as being creatures with a "hive" mentality. They are bred to their condition and CANNOT, despite individual "personalities", be other than what they are.

Tolkien lived in a world that not too many younger people know of or remember, a world where a great country with a wondrous background of culture and religion became in scarcely less than a decade, a totally alien place where evil on a scale such as the world to that time had not known (we didn't know about the 10 million dead under Stalin at the time), where young children were "orcasized" into mindless automatons who killed without hesitation, mercy or conscience. This is what Tolkien's orcs represented: what happened to actual human beings when they were subjected to the brain-washing of the Nazis or the Communists. It wasn't allegory so much as it was recognition that it was possible to "create" creatures (no longer men and women) who were outside the boundaries of humanity.

But Jackson's orcs are, in fact, "monsters". They are ugly to the point of being foreign to us in all respects. Hence, their evil is limited; nothing could be "drawn" from them in the way of a warning about what can happen "if"... I am not saying that Jackson's orcs are "wrong" or even "bad" in the sense that they do not "match" the descriptions in the book. Rather, they are like the creature in Alien: something so "foreign to us" that we could never say to ourselves, "there but for the grace of God, go I".
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…