Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
There is nothing wrong with this, but it's time to stop blaming time constraints, fiscal concerns and New Line Cinema for what Mr. Jackson has created. This is what he wanted and this is what he got!
I can only guess here, but it seems that what you're saying is that PJ searched around for a few years to find the novel which disgusted him the most. Being basically an evil person at heart, PJ then decided to make the most contemptuous piece of film ever seen based on these books, for the sole purpose of ruining the pleasure that more sensible people find in reading the books. Having made this decision, PJ then decided to dedicate 5+ years of his life to the project, in order to make sure that it turned out truly abominable.
Originally posted by PRH
2) Frodo the interrupter: What a jerk! Why would Frodo butt in while Aragorn is singing nicely to himself demanding to immedietly know who he's singing about? That would've played a lot better if Aragorn had ceased singing and Frodo had paused and asked his question more calmly. It was a very nice little scene until Frodo crapped on it.
Originally posted by PRH
4) Sam tries to sleep: I think that scene right after F&S see the Elves leaving ME where Sam is trying to get comfortable adds nothing. Further, it kind of ruins the beautiful tone set while watching the Elves
Originally posted by PRH
5) Isildur the coward: At first I was excited that we'd see a little more clearly how the Ring betrayed Isildur. Unfortunately, I think it came off like Isildur just abandons his people as soon as things got hairy. He comes off like a coward. I think it's hard to convey what really happened there in such shorthand.
Originally posted by PRH
8) Boromir...I wonder if he's up to something?: In the theaterical version, I had the complaint that when Galadriel tells Frodo that "he will try to take the Ring, you know of who I speak," it was too much. It blew the nice foreshadowing that had been set up already at the CoE....Now they add (a) Boromir reaching out for the Ring at the CoE (b) Gandalf warning Frodo of a threat from within the Fellowship (c) Aragorn stating he wouldn't take the Ring within 100 leagues of Minas Tirith. Now it's way over the top. There's way too much pointing to Boromir trying to take the Ring now.
Originally posted by PRH
9) Sam the ungrateful: when he gets his rope gift, Sam asks for a dagger like M&P's instead. Doesn't seem in keeping with his character...though I guess if those two wusses got sweet knives and I got some (seemingly) plain old rope I'd feel a little gyped too! Hey Sam - could've been worse - you could've got some dirt for a gift!
Originally posted by PRH
11) "We will not meet again Elessar:" Galadriel says this to (naturally) Aragorn. I guess she's not attending her granddaughter's wedding. Oh well, too bad.
Originally posted by PRH
13) Dimishment of Aragorn's character: I dislike movie Aragorn a little more now because of the new scenes. He just seems more humorless and unfriendly now. Not laughing when tripped...openly chastising Gimli for cursing (not that he didn't deserve it)...smacking Gimli for snoring...removing Boromir's hand from his arm...just a bunch of little stuff.
I suppose 'tis better to have shown it and (slightly) spoiled it, than never to have shown it at all.Originally posted by Thorin
Actually, regardless of whether he did or not, I was glad they stuck it in. The closer to Tolkien, the better! It really implied the parallel between Luthien's plight and that of Arwen. It used the foreshadow real well there and it didn't dumb it down for the audience which PJ has done elsewhere.
Hmm..I didn't see the two scenes as relating at all. I'll try to look at it in that light again.
Have you read "The Disaster of the Gladden Fields" in UT? He indeed took off during the fighting, but only under pressure from his men. He was the King, and what more, he felt the great need to surrender the Ring to Elrond, realizing it was too great a matter for him. In the full account, Isildur's men were vastly outnumbered. This was not established at all. We have no idea what or how many they're up against. It just looks like Isildur got scared and booted. Again, I suppose it's better to show it and ruin it than not to show it at all. It's a pretty complex series of events to tell so shorthand. I liked how it played a lot, but it left a bad impression of Isildur (which I think was the intend -- show him as a corrupt guy).Once again, I'm just glad they showed the scenes. It explained and showed the story of the ring much better. I don't necessarily think Isildur was a coward. However, Tolkien pretty much showed the same thing. The Tolkien facts are that Isildur did escape in the water. I highly doubt that even in Tolkien's world, he was the last man standing.
I'm glad you agree but...Well...I loved the invented Caradhras scene...and he never actually touched the Ring there anyway.I agree with you here. I never liked the "You know of whom I speak" comment and the fingering of the ring on Caradhras. PJ did blow the foreshadowing something fierce and he just went too far in showing Boromir's disdain and future betrayal. I didn't care for the Rivendell scene with Boromir and Narsil. It was all just really blown to big and it was too much of a giveaway....It made up for itself with Boromir at Amon Hen, however.
The self-doubting/shirking Aragorn was a fully intentional change. It's not Tolkien, but I like it. My problem was the dimishment of TC Movie Aragorn into EE Movie Aragorn (neither of which resemble Book Aragorn).My biggest problem with Aragorn is the way PJ has shown him to be a doubting, selfish person when it comes to his heritage. Tolkien gave him doubts, but Aragorn always knew he'd retake the throne. He never shirked from it or acted like he never wanted it. PJ really blew that as well and that is unfortunate.
Originally posted by aragil
I am tempted not to get into this right now, but I guess I'll just resist temptation. For anyone to say that all of Tolkien's Orcs are nameless and faceless is absolute BS. MM, if you disagree then feel free to look here at what is quite possibly the poll with the most participation in the history of this forum. The subject: which Orc personality do we like the most.
One of the telling things I've always found about Tolkien's Orcs is the following:
The squint-eyed southerner- is he part orcish or not? No one can really tell (though everyone has an opinion), perhaps because there is not such a great difference between Orc and non-Orc.
Treebeard thinks he might mistake Merry and Pippin for Orcs. Aragorn is worried that the Rohirrim might mistake Merry and Pippin for Orcs. Eomer at first thinks Aragorn Gimli and Legolas are three Orcs. Frodo and Sam are actually able to pass themselves off as Orcs to other Orcs. I don't think that Tolkien intends for Orcs to be so different from the other races. As such I don't see why PJ should treat them so differently- Tolkien certainly had no problems with showing us a little Orc personality in certain circumstances.
No, they don't relate at all! As T says himself, they're a great contrast, far too much of a contrast in fact. As separate scenes they'd have done the job T wants for them; when one so very abruptly follows the other they spoil each other's effects.Originally posted by PRH
[Thorin]"Actually, it shows a great contrast. Seeing the elves in their glory and the beauty of the creatures of ME, and then they are brought down to reality of cold, hard ground and the miserable task put before them. Plus, the more screen time to the hobbits for character development, the better."
Hmm..I didn't see the two scenes as relating at all. I'll try to look at it in that light again.
LINK?
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
But that's just it. Aragorn did NOT know that he would reclaim the throne in the book. As long as Sauron still reigned in Mordor, he could NOT do so. That is why the line of Elendil was kept hidden in the North for all of those years. Had the Dark Lord even suspected that an heir to Elendil still lived, he would have spared nothing to find and destroy or capture him.....Aragorn could not claim the throne and that is why his love for Arwen and Elrond's caveat to their marriage (that he be king of BOTH kingdoms) was such a burden. Until Sauron either fell or there was no further reason to hide his identity (before he took the Paths of the Dead), Aragorn was fated to spend his life without a wife, without a family, with no heir and virtually homeless.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?