There is nothing wrong with this, but it's time to stop blaming time constraints, fiscal concerns and New Line Cinema for what Mr. Jackson has created. This is what he wanted and this is what he got!
In my opinion that's a faulty assesment of the situation. Let me refer you to some words from PJ that I quoted a while back, but will do so again here. It's from an interview regarding the EE:
-------------------------
How did you go about putting the extended DVD version together?
We were actually talking about it all the way through the editing of The Fellowship. Whenever we would look at a version of the film, and we would sort of agonize over whether we were going to cut a scene out, we would often say to ourselves, "Well, if we cut it out of here, it will be great for the DVD." Which actually helps soften the blow! As a filmmaker, you do feel a certain amount of emotional attachment to everything you've shot. You know that a two-minute scene in the movie represents a day's worth of work and that you were working very intensely with the actors to try to create the best performance and with the camera crew to get the best shots. You spend a day of your life crafting a scene, and suddenly, nobody is going to see it. It has a certain emotional blow attached to it when you have to cut it out. I love the fact that, as long as it is a worthwhile scene, then the DVD concept actually helps ease the pain.
As we were cutting the theatrical version, we would say, "We'll do a short version of this moment here but let's make sure we keep this footage and put it to one side for the DVD."
Are scenes cut out for pacing purposes as well?
Actually, scenes cut out for pacing purposes are generally quite nice. Often, there are scenes involving intimate moments between the charachters or a little bit of back-story or development, and those are usually the ones that are taken out for pacing purposes. They are often the very scenes that are good to have back in the DVD because they are for the people who have seen The Fellowship of
the Ring and have seen
Legolas or
Pippin or
Frodo and would like to see more of them. That's what the extended edition DVD can provide. We did shoot things that we didn't put into the DVD...there are deffinitely more scenes from 'Fellowship' that hit the cutting room floor and stayed on the cutting room floor. We only put in scenes that we felt actually enhanced the movie for the DVD viewing.
Which of the new DVD scenes was the hardest for you to cut from the theatrical release?
There is a scene that I regret cutting, but we were under a lot of pressure from New Line to bring the film in under three hours. As it was, it was two hours, 58 minutes, so we just scraped by on that. This three-hour mark was a psychological thing...nobody wanted to say that the film was three hours long. We worked very hard to achieve that goal. The last scene that got cut (which would have tipped us over three hours) was a scene involving Viggo's charachter,
Aragorn, and the four
hobbits in the Midgewater
Marshes going from
Bree to
Rivendell. Then there is a scene at night where Viggo is sitting by the campfire by himself, and the hobbits are sleeping. That was about a three-minute sequence that stayed in the theatrical cut right up until the last minute. It was a scene that the film would ultimately do okay without, but it does nice things for Aragorn's charachter. And, quite frankly, it feels, at that point in the film, that it is a nice moment for that particular scene to happen. That was probably
the one that was the hardest for me to cut out.
Regarding the Gift giving scene
...We were now into our final act of the The Fellowship, heading toward our climax, and it became a bit of a problem to actually stop the film for this gift-giving scene. That was actually a conversation I had with New Line at the time, because we all recognized what the problem was. To be honest, the gift-giving scene actually dictated the date that the extended edition DVD was to be released. I said to New Line, "Look, I will cut the gift-giving scene out, but you realize there are gifts that they are given that they use in The Two
Towers. I will be prepared to take it out as long as you can guarantee and promise me that you will release the extended DVD before the release of The Two Towers." They went away and came back and said, "If we promise to do a November release so that the fans and the people who are interested have a month to buy and to look at the Extended DVD before they go into The Two Towers, is that okay?" And I said, "Sure, that would work." That was a negotiation that happened before we agreed to to take the gift-giving scene out. They had to guarantee me that people would be able to see it in place in The Fellowship before they went to see The Two Towers in December.
--------------------------
Make of this what you will, but there is clear, clean proof that PJ wanted one scene that didn't make it in. Also, the fact that the film had to be under 3 hours is, well, a fact. There were constraints, there were limits, and I think the EE is half an hour more of PJ's original script. And, mind you, nobody writes a script with scenes they don't intend to see in the film. In fact, if there is one thing a script doesn't take into account, it's action.
I guess my point is this: The TC is, at the very most, PJ's vision
restricted to 3 hours. But I think that is faulty as well, since it neglects other pressures that were on him regarding what scenes to include and what not. I don't see the logic in accusing PJ of the TC on the basis of what he includes in the EE.