I am afraid those with "lad/die" and "canniest" will have to go.Originally posted by aragil
....that is nineteen serious (at least what I thought were serious) lines....
Hmm. I hate to argue with a resident of the Isles on this one (because I'll probably be wrong), but I always chalked those up to John R-D being Welsh and strongly identifying with the role of Gimli.Originally posted by joxy
I am afraid those with "lad/die" and "canniest" will have to go.
The only people who use those words are third-rate comedians making jokes about Scots men.
Originally posted by aragil
I always chalked those up to John R-D being Welsh and strongly identifying with the role of Gimli.
Originally posted by Thorin
Unfortunately, TTT has strayed even further from the source and already has to compensate for the changes/additions made in FoTR. Nothing added to TTT EE can help the horrible damage already done to Faramir's bullish attitude and taking the ring to Osgiliath, Treebeard's being 'tricked' into attacking Isengard by Merry and Pippin, and cowardly Theoden.
Rhys-Davies is a Welsh name, but in the films neither his accent nor the words that PJ and his family force him to utter have anything to do with Wales: they are entirely, and crudely, mock-Scottish.Originally posted by aragil
....John R-D being Welsh....
Since nobody else has been defending the movies with those arguments, I must assume you are referring to me. As such, I'll point out that I saidOriginally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I have pointed all this out simply to inform those who continually defend the films by reciting how "popular" they are and how much "critical acclaim" they have received - that neither of these facts mean a blessed thing simply because it cannot influence or affect an individual's own personal view of them. I certainly know that it does not, has not and cannot influence mine.
I'm not trying to change opinions on the movies. I'm just trying to put criticism of these movies (as films) into context.And again, I don't expect these statistics to influence anybody's opinion on the movies (they SHOULDN'T!). However, when people start asking 'how could Mr. Jackson make such an inferior product with so much money and such a brilliant set of books for a basis?', I might respond with 'A lot of people/critics/pocketbooks thought the movies were pretty good, in fact some of the best films ever made.'
Sorry, I meant to write "Since nobody else has been defending the movies with those arguments in this thread ...Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I can assure you that the "critical and box office acclaim" argument has been raised by far more people than you.
This is my point entirely- 'failure of these films' is entirely subjective, and the majority of movie-goers don't seem to have found any failure. Yes, you think that the movie failed as an adaption of Tolkien's books- but your criteria is your own. Do you expect that the director and his writers were going to make a film just to please you?Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Furthermore, the failure of these films to be what they could have been cannot be put down to technology or acting or sets or anything other than the director and his writers.
Originally posted by aragil
the majority of movie-goers don't seem to have found any failure....Do you expect that the director and his writers were going to make a film just to please you?
Yeah, I did think PJ was going to make a film that pleased me. He went on and on about how these movies were made by Tolkien fans for Tolkien fans (and those who hadn't read LOTR).
So maybe it´s not because of the movie that can be perfect for some and an disapointment for others. Maybe it´s because of us, because we are different from each other, and have different values, experiences and demands.
Instead of complaining about things that you dislike, see the positive side of the movie.
Originally posted by Madonna Baggins
Instead of complaining about things that you dislike, see the positive side of the movie.
If you mean he is excited IN the films, then presumably that's because PJ DIRECTED him to be excited. He certainly is a strong personality though, he looks the part, the technical problems of his size are handled well, and everything adds up to suggest that he could have been a great Gimli, if only PJ, and his family of writers, had let him stay true to Tolkien! Offhand the one and only time I can recall when he approaches that level is the gift-giving in the FOTR EE, including his comment to Legolas about it.Originally posted by aragil
....JR-D is plainly so excited about the movies, that I assume he injected a lot of his own personality into the character. Offhand the only Welsh person I've heard much from is Catherine Zeta-Jones.
....is there a huge difference between Welsh-English and Scot-English?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?