• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace

Originally posted by aragil
....that is nineteen serious (at least what I thought were serious) lines....
I am afraid those with "lad/die" and "canniest" will have to go.
The only people who use those words are third-rate comedians making jokes about Scots men.
 
This is another language faux pas on Jackson's part. Even when he isn't being "cutsie", his characters frequently wander into the modern idiom. For instance, "Let's hunt some orc!" is not necessarily a "funny" line so much as it is a "modern" one. In other words, it grates upon our ears because a man of Aragorn's "time" would not have said it! He might indeed have said, "Let us hunt orc!" or "Let us now hunt orc!" but the contraction together with the modifier "some", makes the language usage far too contemporary - and thus, it grates upon our ears under the circumstances in which it is uttered.

It is true that Tolkien himself carefully crafted the use of language, sometimes making the speaker almost "modern" while at other times he used much more ancient cadences and phrases, but he never had even his prosaic and parochial hobbits speak in such a way as to cause a break in the narrative flow of the story. Yes, they were much more "rural" and far less "high", but they were always within the time scope of the story.
 
Originally posted by joxy
I am afraid those with "lad/die" and "canniest" will have to go.
The only people who use those words are third-rate comedians making jokes about Scots men.
Hmm. I hate to argue with a resident of the Isles on this one (because I'll probably be wrong), but I always chalked those up to John R-D being Welsh and strongly identifying with the role of Gimli.
 
Originally posted by aragil
I always chalked those up to John R-D being Welsh and strongly identifying with the role of Gimli.

Yes, maybe whomever scribbled his pitiful dialogue thought he was Scotch (just kidding, I meant Scots). Several of those lines (Everything from Helm's Deep), belong on the ridiculously BAD pile, which is almost worse than trying to be funny...
 
Originally posted by Thorin
Unfortunately, TTT has strayed even further from the source and already has to compensate for the changes/additions made in FoTR. Nothing added to TTT EE can help the horrible damage already done to Faramir's bullish attitude and taking the ring to Osgiliath, Treebeard's being 'tricked' into attacking Isengard by Merry and Pippin, and cowardly Theoden.

Thorin, I'm afraid you're right. My hope is that the EE has given PJ more time to LOGICALLY think through each scene and fix many of the gaping mistakes...but how can terrible characterization be fixed? If PJ can possibly make their personalities BELIEVABLE through the EE, I will be more accepting of the movie as a whole.

And, as I've had some time to read back a few pages of this thread, I have to add that "numbers" and the masses who love TTT don't lend it quality. Numbers lie all the time (high percentage of people are sick of political sex scandals, but paper carrying the article has it's circulation go through the roof). Time will tell.
 
I would like to address what always seems to come up in these discussions: the popularity - critical and general - of these films and just exactly what that does and doesn't mean in the overall scheme of things.

To begin with, FOTR was an excellent film. It was very well done as film. It had its weak points - such as some of the silliness in the dialogue (dwarf tossing) and inexplicable occurrences (the Fellowship surrounded by countless orcs in Moria who then mindlessly flee at the approach of one of their own allies), but on the whole, it hung together very nicely as a film. Certainly, the acting was uniformly excellent and the visuals were nothing short of spectacular. Even for those of us who were forced to conclude that Jackson was not going to be faithful to his source, there can be no doubt that the film was eminently enjoyable and even we purists looked forward to TTT - willing to accept the films as a "new" story but excitingly and well told. It is no wonder that FOTR was critically hailed and a top box office draw.

However, TTT suffered severely from a far "bumpier" plot exposition, atrocious editing and far more frequent and grievous "weak points" in the unfolding of the narrative. (And, of course, this says nothing regarding Jackson's much further deviation from his source.) However, again the acting was superb, the visuals spectacular and the pace such that the film was able to keep the interest of those for whom the book was not an issue. Again, it is quite understandable that the film should be critically acclaimed since it virtually stood alone in its genre. Furthermore, its "box office" was influenced by the first film; that is, those who saw and enjoyed FOTR would make it their business to see TTT - and for those for whom the book was a non-issue, what weaknesses the second film had were quickly overcome by its strengths and the loyalty viewers had already formed for its characters from the first film. Again, it is no wonder that TTT was critically hailed and a top box office draw as FOTR was before it.

Furthermore, I have absolutely no doubt that ROTK will be the biggest "hit" yet no matter what depradations Jackson commits simply because so many people have so much invested in the two previous films and also because the story line at this point is exciting and spectacular enough to insure that even if Jackson is mediocre in his presentation, Tolkien's story outline will not let him down. So, I have asbolutely no doubt that ROTK will be critically hailed and a top box office draw as were FOTR and TTT before it.

Now the question is, what difference does it make? To me, at least, none whatsoever. I do not make my judgments based upon how many people "love" (or "hate") something, but on how I feel about it. Right now, I am gathering all the momentos I foolishly bought before and just after the first film came out to give them to my daughter and son-in-law who "love" the films. I no longer wish to own them because they represent something for which I have no real regard and which, in fact, only make me melancholy. I would happily give them the EE of FOTR, but my husband (who read the book only once in his youth) wants to purchase the EE of TTT because he likes the films as pure action-adventure-fantasy works having no real memory of the book and thus, no "axe to grind", so to speak.

I have pointed all this out simply to inform those who continually defend the films by reciting how "popular" they are and how much "critical acclaim" they have received - that neither of these facts mean a blessed thing simply because it cannot influence or affect an individual's own personal view of them. I certainly know that it does not, has not and cannot influence mine.
 
Originally posted by aragil
....John R-D being Welsh....
Rhys-Davies is a Welsh name, but in the films neither his accent nor the words that PJ and his family force him to utter have anything to do with Wales: they are entirely, and crudely, mock-Scottish.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I have pointed all this out simply to inform those who continually defend the films by reciting how "popular" they are and how much "critical acclaim" they have received - that neither of these facts mean a blessed thing simply because it cannot influence or affect an individual's own personal view of them. I certainly know that it does not, has not and cannot influence mine.
Since nobody else has been defending the movies with those arguments, I must assume you are referring to me. As such, I'll point out that I said
And again, I don't expect these statistics to influence anybody's opinion on the movies (they SHOULDN'T!). However, when people start asking 'how could Mr. Jackson make such an inferior product with so much money and such a brilliant set of books for a basis?', I might respond with 'A lot of people/critics/pocketbooks thought the movies were pretty good, in fact some of the best films ever made.'
I'm not trying to change opinions on the movies. I'm just trying to put criticism of these movies (as films) into context.

joxy- JR-D is plainly so excited about the movies, that I assume he injected a lot of his own personality into the character. Offhand the only Welshperson I've heard much from is Catherine Zeta-Jones, and she seems to usually use an American accent. Incidentally, is there a huge difference between Welsh-English and Scot-English?
 
I can assure you that the "critical and box office acclaim" argument has been raised by far more people than you. And, again, I do not believe that such things necessarily comment upon the true value of something. I can recite of many things (and people) that were very popular at one time or another and later were found to be far less than originally thought. I am not saying that Jackson's films are not acceptable given their medium, but alas they pale into comparison given their source material and, worse, they could have been so very much more but were not. Furthermore, the failure of these films to be what they could have been cannot be put down to technology or acting or sets or anything other than the director and his writers.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I can assure you that the "critical and box office acclaim" argument has been raised by far more people than you.
Sorry, I meant to write "Since nobody else has been defending the movies with those arguments in this thread ...

Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Furthermore, the failure of these films to be what they could have been cannot be put down to technology or acting or sets or anything other than the director and his writers.
This is my point entirely- 'failure of these films' is entirely subjective, and the majority of movie-goers don't seem to have found any failure. Yes, you think that the movie failed as an adaption of Tolkien's books- but your criteria is your own. Do you expect that the director and his writers were going to make a film just to please you?
 
A lot of the Orson Wells films didnt get much acclaim during their days, due to politics, jealousies and so forth, ...the test of his greatness is his during legacy long after his death...

noone in their right mind is gonna say that about a b-garde director like PJackson.

And yes if PJ doesnt try to please the audience who will he please....just coz for the most part the audience tend to be from the 2-year old age groups, or from the former communist blocs who have never seen technology on the screen in their lives.

the fact that christopher Tolkien and the tolkien estate tried to distance themselves fom the works speaks volumes, as well as the writers from certain aspects of the script

IF only jackson would stop trying to find ways to put his fat face on the screen :D , he would make a decent movie...dont you agree harad?? ;)
 
Originally posted by aragil
the majority of movie-goers don't seem to have found any failure....Do you expect that the director and his writers were going to make a film just to please you?

The majority of movie-goers haven't found any failure? That certainly doesn't seem true of the people here at TTF. And most of the people I know personally thought TTT had plenty of failures.

TTT made millions, but how many people saw it again and again, content to enjoy a thrilling action movie? How many who saw it numerous times (like me) thought it was a low-quality movie? My point is you can assume things from your own experience, but not from the popular opinion of the moment. You're right that many have enjoyed it and the movie was wildly successful...but that's it.

Yeah, I did think PJ was going to make a film that pleased me. He went on and on about how these movies were made by Tolkien fans for Tolkien fans (and those who hadn't read LOTR). FOTR was well-made and respectful of the source. It seemed a no-brainer that TTT would be good. It's amazing what lavish praise, fame and fortune can do! It becomes a lot easier to lower your standards... PJ makes Boromir look like a tower of strength! ;)
 
Yeah, I did think PJ was going to make a film that pleased me. He went on and on about how these movies were made by Tolkien fans for Tolkien fans (and those who hadn't read LOTR).

Bingo! I've been having those same words running through my memory everytime someone tells me that Pj had to come up with a produtcion easy enough for the regular movie goer.

That the story would have to suffer changes in order to make some of it's details less complex for those that never read the book I can understand and even support. That does not, however, make every modification he introduced justifiable! I expected a movie with different levels of complexity, so that those that were in for the simplier line would get it and those of us interested in the deeper aspects would still have a good Tolkien-like movie to watch. To present an example, I've found something like that in The Matrix Reloaded: complex, yes, even very complex if one's not into computers, but still, it could scope with people with different interests, be it those only into the fight scenes, religion and philosophy themes, etc.

What I found with PJ's story was something reduced to a couple of basic ideas and minimal plot complexity, a poor production in many ways, ways for which visual effects are not a good replacement, at least not for me.

And I'm wondering how many people will keep the vivid support for PJ in a couple of years from now, when things are quiter and the sensacionlist effect begins to run out. Hegel would say that Minerva's bird flies at twilight...;)
 
The solution in my opinion

I believe that Mr Jackson has done an excellent piece of filmhistory. There are always something you can complain on, no matter how perfect it is. So maybe it´s not because of the movie that can be perfect for some and an disapointment for others.
Maybe it´s because of us, because we are different from each other, and have different values, experiences and demands.
Instead of complaining about things that you dislike, see the positive side of the movie.

Thank you
 
So maybe it´s not because of the movie that can be perfect for some and an disapointment for others. Maybe it´s because of us, because we are different from each other, and have different values, experiences and demands.

Which again reminds me of those words, that the movie was made by Tolkien fans, for Tolkien fans. If they had no intention of doing so they might as well been honest about it.

Instead of complaining about things that you dislike, see the positive side of the movie.

You're forgetting that to some of us the positive side of the movie does not cover for the negative, i.e., what it has of good - at least as far as I'm concerned - is overwhelmed by what it has of bad. It takes more than great visual effects and soundtrack to make a good movie to me: it needs to have an equally great and coherent story, plus a character construction up to it, which is something PJ missed, while at the same time he flooded our eyes with great scenes of "fireworks". To have elves at Helm's Deep not only contradicts what was presented in the introduction of the first movie (let alone Tolkien's mythology), it's actually impossible for that army to reach Rohan in such a short notice (4 to 5 days); to show that Ents are slow, careful in their decisions and words and that it takes more than a hasty feeling to move them in full strengh contradicts the way they grouped and moved to attack Isengard; and that ridiculous charge at the end of the battle, right before Gandalf shows up with Éomer...it's a fantasy movie, yes, but that doesn't make it an "everything goes".

I could go on and on about other parts and details of the story and dialogues, but great setts, soundtrack and visual effects don't cover for it, at least not for me: the faults I mentioned are things of a sensacionalist production, aimed at the more "inflamed" feelings it causes in that very moment, to the lost of more rational thinking: Great! Cool! Awesome! Wow! I wish more people were like Tolkien's Ents instead of PJ's but, alas, too many of us fall for it...but I'm still waiting for the twilight to come :D :p
 
Originally posted by Madonna Baggins
Instead of complaining about things that you dislike, see the positive side of the movie.

A positive attitude is great, but simply pretending things you dislike aren't there isn't a solution to anything, IMHO. Communicating opinions while keeping an open mind to others makes the world go round...

Spelling Master, you crack me up!
 
Originally posted by aragil
....JR-D is plainly so excited about the movies, that I assume he injected a lot of his own personality into the character. Offhand the only Welsh person I've heard much from is Catherine Zeta-Jones.
....is there a huge difference between Welsh-English and Scot-English?
If you mean he is excited IN the films, then presumably that's because PJ DIRECTED him to be excited. He certainly is a strong personality though, he looks the part, the technical problems of his size are handled well, and everything adds up to suggest that he could have been a great Gimli, if only PJ, and his family of writers, had let him stay true to Tolkien! Offhand the one and only time I can recall when he approaches that level is the gift-giving in the FOTR EE, including his comment to Legolas about it.
C Z-J may be from Wales, but if she is, it doesn't show in her voice, and there's no relevance in the fact. She first came to notice on UK TV, playing a rustic but beautiful girl from Kent, in Darling Buds of May, and had the perfect voice for the role.
There are very small differences in vocabulary between Standard, Welsh, and Scottish English, but the three are slightly more distinguishable by the rhythm of the speech. In both respects Welsh E is more different from Scots E than either is from Standard E. This reflects the difference between the two Celtic languages, Cymraeg and Gaelidh, spoken by small minorities in each country.
 
I didn't mind Gimli's interpretation as being "excited" since he was a foil to Legolas' much more introspective "laid-back" character. However, there is a difference between emotional and infantile.
 
Jackson has completely written these characters for himself. I believe he at least should have portrayed the characters personalities as Tolkien had written them. The TTT movie is a disgrace to the book, I get upset because people that will never read the book will think of the movie as a basis to the story. When in fact after about fifteen minutes into the movie Mr. Jackson craps on the book and becomes Peter Tolkien, writing his own version. I feel very strongly about Tolkiens work,having been able to escape into his world at a very early age. When someone is going to use a mans life work, you should have the respect to portray it accurately to the end. I challenge anyone to imagine spending a good majority of your life on a project. Maybe something that not everyone has read, then to have another guy release it to the world where millions more will see it, only drastically changed to HIS LIKING. I don't buy the whole ' well, it's difficult to really bring it all from book to movie' bit. Peter Jackson changed the story to his liking. ALL FOR MONEY. If he were a true fan he would have found a way to make everyone happy.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top