I would like to address what always seems to come up in these discussions: the popularity - critical and general - of these films and just exactly what that does and
doesn't mean in the overall scheme of things.
To begin with, FOTR was an
excellent film. It was very well done as
film. It had its weak points - such as some of the silliness in the dialogue (
dwarf tossing) and inexplicable occurrences (the Fellowship surrounded by countless
orcs in
Moria who then mindlessly flee at the approach of one of their own allies), but on the whole, it hung together very nicely as a film. Certainly, the acting was uniformly excellent and the visuals were nothing short of spectacular. Even for those of us who were forced to conclude that Jackson was not going to be faithful to his source, there can be no doubt that the film was eminently enjoyable and even we purists looked forward to TTT - willing to accept the films as a "new" story but excitingly and well told. It is no wonder that FOTR was critically hailed and a top box office draw.
However, TTT suffered severely from a far "bumpier" plot exposition, atrocious editing and far more frequent and grievous "weak points" in the unfolding of the narrative. (And, of course, this says nothing regarding Jackson's much further deviation from his source.) However, again the acting was superb, the visuals spectacular and the pace such that the film was able to keep the interest of those for whom the book was not an issue. Again, it is quite understandable that the film should be critically acclaimed since it virtually stood alone in its genre. Furthermore, its "box office" was influenced by the first film; that is, those who saw and enjoyed FOTR would make it their business to see TTT - and for those for whom the book was a non-issue, what weaknesses the second film had were quickly overcome by its strengths and the loyalty viewers had already formed for its characters from the first film. Again, it is no wonder that TTT was critically hailed and a top box office draw as FOTR was before it.
Furthermore, I have absolutely no doubt that ROTK will be the biggest "hit" yet no matter what depradations Jackson commits simply because so many people have so much invested in the two previous films and also because the story line at this point is exciting and spectacular enough to insure that even if Jackson is mediocre in his presentation,
Tolkien's story outline will not let him down. So, I have asbolutely no doubt that ROTK
will be critically hailed and a top box office draw as were FOTR and TTT before it.
Now the question is,
what difference does it make? To me, at least, none whatsoever. I do not make my judgments based upon how many people "love" (or "hate") something, but on how
I feel about it. Right now, I am gathering all the momentos I foolishly bought before and just after the first film came out to give them to my daughter and son-in-law who "love" the films. I no longer wish to own them because they represent something for which I have no real regard and which, in fact, only make me melancholy. I would happily give them the EE of FOTR, but my husband (who read the book only once in his youth) wants to purchase the EE of TTT because he likes the films as pure action-adventure-fantasy works having no real memory of the book and thus, no "
axe to grind", so to speak.
I have pointed all this out simply to inform those who continually defend the films by reciting how "popular" they are and how much "critical acclaim" they have received - that neither of these facts mean a blessed thing simply because it cannot influence or affect an individual's own personal view of them. I certainly know that it does not, has not and cannot influence mine.