Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
Aragil stated precisely what I was going to say. There is absolutely no way you can be sure that HP fans would dislike the movies if they were changed. Of course, you could interview the majority, but that would take a while.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Again, I ask the members to consider what would have happened if Chris Columbus had "rewritten" J. K. Rowling's characters and various plot elements in his two Harry Potter films to the extent that Jackson rewrote Tolkien's in his films. Of course, Tolkien's characters and story are far more complex and subtle than Rowling's and therefore Columbus' digressions would have been more noticable than were Jackson's. But the fact remains: Harry Potter fans would not have happily accepted such fundamental changes to the characters even if the special effects "rocked", the actors were excellent and the overall plot line remained fundamentally true.
Well, if it wouldn't have been acceptable to make such fundamental changes to the characters created by J. K. Rowling, one has to wonder why it okay to do it to those created by J. R. R. Tolkien.
You've done us movie defenders a great dishonor here, aragil.Originally posted by aragil
1) Purists say movies would have been better if PJ stuck closer to the books.
2) Film defenders say movies would have been wildly unsuccessful if the movies had been more true to the books
I freely admit to being an enthusiast for the HP films, and one who has never understood the thesis that they are poorer films because they are accurate.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Well, I for one can say that doing the same thing to Tolkien's characters has caused similar discontent among those for whom the book is the "golden mean" and not simply all the visuals and special effects that appear in the film. Remember, they had such things in Harry Potter as well, but Mr. Columbus did not utilize them like some sort of sleight of hand magic trick to cover up his machinations with the stories and the characters.
This was the point I was making:Originally posted by joxy
I freely admit to being an enthusiast for the HP films, and one who has never understood the thesis that they are poorer films because they are accurate.
There ARE changes, of course, and plenty of special effects, but the difference betwen the HP films and the LOTRs is that in HP both of these elements blend in with their surroundings, not stand out against - or, indeed, cover up - theirs, as they do in LOTR.
PostScript to the "Tale"Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
And so you have, as it were, "A Tale of Two Directors" and their efforts to bring popular (and in one instance at least, great) works of fiction to the screen.
You also would have said this before LotR came out, but look how it was received. Even people such as joxy, who love the books, like the movies.I don't think it takes a wild flight of fancy to be fairly certain that Harry Potter fans would not have liked Harry being presented as anything but Harry - and the same goes for Ron, Hermione, Dumbledore, Hagrid, Malfoy, Snape et al. These, after all, are the characters that made the books so incredibly popular. To present the film characters in ways which in some cases would be diametric to the book characters would have caused considerable discontent.
Has that thesis been stated here on TTF, because I haven't heard it. I'm not exactly sure what you mean by the last paragraph. Perhaps an example directly from the movie would help.I freely admit to being an enthusiast for the HP films, and one who has never understood the thesis that they are poorer films because they are accurate.
There ARE changes, of course, and plenty of special effects, but the difference betwen the HP films and the LOTRs is that in HP both of these elements blend in with their surroundings, not stand out against - or, indeed, cover up - theirs, as they do in LOTR.
Yes, there have been clear statements that the accuracy of the HPs makes them duller, poorer, films than they need have been. I totally disagree, of course!Originally posted by Gandalf White
Has that thesis been stated here on TTF, because I haven't heard it. I'm not exactly sure what you mean by the last paragraph. Perhaps an example directly from the movie would help.
Well, the FOTR changes weren't all that bad - most of us have admitted that! What those nods suggest to me though, is that the nodders are not at all likely to have been ardent and knowledgeable readers of the substantial works which they claim to have been adapted well.Originally posted by aragil
FotR, with all it's changes from the books, managed to get nods for best adapted screenplay.
....to date, no HP film has been up for any of these.
I think my latest comment, that FOTR's changes are "not all that bad" is the nearest I have come to being positive! I'd be quite happy for that to be taken as an example of "damning with faint praise".Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....Joxy is very positive about FOTR although I find that TTT has done much to change my opinion for the worse of that film as well.
Originally posted by joxy
Those "not so bad" changes inevitably led to worse ones, as PJ's lost control of his machinations
Tolkien's books are elaborately crafted structures, in which every detail links to every other. Change one simple point, and you produce a string of changes all down the line.Originally posted by simbelmyne
I cannot see why bad changes "inevitably" lead to terrible ones.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?