Originally posted by joxy
I freely admit to being an enthusiast for the HP films, and one who has never understood the thesis that they are poorer films because they are accurate.
There ARE changes, of course, and plenty of special effects, but the difference betwen the HP films and the LOTRs is that in HP both of these elements blend in with their surroundings, not stand out against - or, indeed, cover up - theirs, as they do in LOTR.
This was the point I was making:
1. Chris Columbus wanted to make films based upon the wildly popular Harry Potter
books. He made them for that audience, not people for whom those stories would have no interest.
2. Peter Jackson wanted to make films based upon the wildly popular LOTR. Ostensibly, he wanted to make them for that audience, not people for whom that story would have no interest.
3. Chris Columbus made what changes were necessary in the books to permit the films to come in under a week long. Sometimes, he had to take a few liberties, but he was EXTREMELY careful to keep the characters true and even had the author present to be sure that the settings such as Diagon Alley and Hogwarts were what Ms. Rowling had in mind. In the case of the Potter books, there just wasn't that much history to draw from and he did have the author for a guide.
4. Peter Jackson did NOT have the author to guide him although one wonders even had he been available would the Director have paid all that much attention given that for the first film at least, he
did have a "
Tolkien" aboard for some assistance and it really didn't matter very much at all. Of course, Jackson had many years of "
artists" renderings (including the author's) to help to create his settings which were ordinarily brilliant (except for
Bree which was a matter of the Director's own dark vision).
5. Chris Columbus made very sure that the characters were as true to the book as possible and that as much as possible of the plot(s) was included in the film(s) in order to please his audience which, in general, he did.
6. Peter Jackson seemed determine to recreate the story and characters in his own image and the devil with his audience even though every change, deviation and devolution was excused by saying that it was done specifically
for the audience whom, it seems, Mr. Jackson believed didn't have the intelligence to understand or appreciate either the characters or the story as written.
And so you have, as it were, "A Tale of Two Directors" and their efforts to bring popular (and in one instance at least, great) works of fiction to the screen.