• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Hobbit as movie?

Burb said:
i was thinking that too. the elves in "the hobbit" seem more like dreams than actual beings.
The Mirkwood Elves begin to become less distant and more 'real' when Bilbo surrenders the Arkenstone. I would have liked it if Bilbo and Gandalf (and Beorn?) spent some time with Thranduil at the end, but it would have just been fellowship and merrymaking, not real 'story', and wouldn't do for a film. The Elves at Rivendell were very merry indeed; they had sobered up considerably by the time Frodo got there (though him being dangerously wounded and bringing the mightiest evil in Middle-earth with him might have had something to do with that). I would also like to see a flashback to Gondolin as Elrond examines the swords - paving the way for the next film
 
Though it is true that they could not use The Quest of Erebor, remember that there is a reduced form in Appendix A to The Lord of the Rings, which they do have the rights to.
 
Greenwood said:
Given Christopher Tolkien's behavior in cutting off his own son for having anything to do with the current films, I can't see him letting Jackson (or probably anyone else) use anything from Unifinished Tales.

Again, these are just rumors. The story of Simon and Christopher Tolkien is only one-sided, and Simon Tolkien's story has never been complete. He has certainly encouraged the press to believe that the feud with his father has to do with the movies, because that puts CJRT in a bad light. But there are certainly issues involving the Tolkien Estate which have been underreported.

The most substantial rumor deals with the ordering of the Tolkien Estate once CJRT dies. Apparently CJRT set up an "executive board" to deal with licensing issues. His second wife (Simon's stepmother) was apparently placed on the board, but Simon was not. Whether this means that Simon has been "cut off" financially is unclear, but I've never heard him make that claim--rather he complains about being cut off from his grandfather's "literary inheritance". That would imply that he doesn't get to make decisions regarding licensing of rights that the Estate still holds; it says nothing of whether he still gets royalties. Interestingly enough, Simon Tolkien recently published a book called, guess what? The Stepmother.

CJRT did make one statement regarding the movie, and buried within it was an oblique reference to his son:


CJRT said:
The suggestions that have been made that I 'disapprove' of the films, vent to the extent of thinking ill of those with whom I may differ, are wholly without foundation.



Finally, it should be noted that if you are seeking to publish something on Tolkien for critical or educational purposes and wish to quote Tolkien in those works, the Estate grants permission with relative ease. It's Harper-Collins (who owns the publishing rights) that presents the difficulties.

Oh, and here's a link to an article which details some of the family feud.
 

They seem to be rather substantial rumors. The story you provide a link to appears to provide quite a bit of background to them rather than refuting them. Family feuds tend to have long histories with rarely a single cause so I do not find it surprising the Tolkien family feud might not be an exception. The timing given in the article: 1998 - Simon and Christopher disagree ove the estates involvement in the prospective films and limits contact with his son; 1999 - Christopher sets up a board to oversee the estate and does not include his only son; lends credence to the idea of a connection between the father's and son's disagreement over the films and the estrangement.
 
Last edited:

Again, this is only one side of the story, and it comes solely from a disgruntled Simon Tolkien (who has hawked this story to just about anyone who'll listen). However, he's not even allowed to talk about the Tolkien family trust (as distinct from the Estate), and he's not allowed to discuss how much money he has received. There is a lot missing from this story (such as how the relationship with the stepmother plays into this), and therefore it is impossible to conclude that the movies are the source of contention.

Having said this, it will be interesting to see which road the Tolkien Estate takes once CJRT dies. One cannot imagine that it will be so protective of JRRT's work as the years pass.
 
Last edited:
As I said, family feuds usually have long histories and rarely a single cause. If as you say Simon Tolkien "has hawked this story to just about anyone who'll listen", I am sure news organizations have tried to get a comment from Simon's father when they ran the stories. I would certainly like to hear Christopher's side. Evidently CT has chosen to remain silent. That leaves the field to Simon.
 
It leaves the field to him, yes. It does not make his story any more likely. Personally, I'd rather that personal family feuds stay private; it appears Christopher feels the same way.
 
rs691919 said:
It leaves the field to him, yes. It does not make his story any more likely. Personally, I'd rather that personal family feuds stay private; it appears Christopher feels the same way.
As long as Christopher stays silent, it is the only story we have, and we have no way to say whether Simon's is any more likely or unlikely than your suppositions. Evidently Christopher does have lawyers; he could always issue a statement with his side of the story. You cited one earlier, so he knows he has that option. Personally, I doubt Simon is telling the whole story, but it is the only story we have.
 
rs691919 said:
Yes, it's the only story we have. So what? Does that make it true?
Because it is the only story we have, does that make it untrue?
 
Greenwood said:
Because it is the only story we have, does that make it untrue?

Ah, answering my question with another question...brilliant rhetorical device! I'll answer yours, and then maybe you can answer mine.

No, it doesn't make it (Simon Tolkien's story) untrue.
 
rs691919 said:
Ah, answering my question with another question...brilliant rhetorical device!
As opposed to the brilliant rhetorical device embodied in: "So what?" Sort of on a par with: "Oh, yeah?"


rs691919 said:
I'll answer yours, and then maybe you can answer mine.
I answered the question already, but since you evidently missed it:
 
Greenwood said:
As opposed to the brilliant rhetorical device embodied in: "So what?" Sort of on a par with: "Oh, yeah?"


I answered the question already, but since you evidently missed it:

Actually, no sarcasm was intended; it is indeed a brilliant rhetorical advice, for it allows you to avoid a "yes" or "no" answer. The post which you quote seemingly gives an answer (although I hadn't asked the question as of then), but then is followed with more words to confuse the issue (at least in my mind). Whether CJRT has lawyers, whether he could give a statement, whether Simon's is the only story is all irrelevant. So, I ask again: does the fact that we only have Simon's version make his story true?
 
I see. So because I answered your question before you asked it, the answer doesn't count. (Please note the lack of a question mark at the end of the last sentence. I am showing my rhetorical nimbleness by not replying to your question with a question. )

I have now answered your question twice, both before and after your asked it, but you seem to be having difficulty comprehending the answer. Perhaps three times is the charm. To repeat: Now to expand on my thrice given answer, for us to make a judgement on whether Simon's story is true or not we have to look at the evidence and use our own common sense. As for evidence we have almost nothing other than what Simon gives us. Christopher has apparently been silent on the subject. You give a link to a news story which quotes Christopher. In it Christopher is quoted as saying in regard to the movies: "My own position is that The Lord Of The Rings is peculiarly unsuitable to transformation into visual dramatic form." Certainly sounds like he is not in favor of any attempt to make LOTR into a film ("visual dramatic form"). That seems to lend some evidence to Simon's story. I have not engaged in the research to verify Simon's story that CHristopher set up a board for the Tolkien literary estate that excludes him, but since that should be fairly easily refutable if not true (and Christopher and his lawyers have not refuted it) I see no reason for Simon to make it up. You say that Christopher's statement has "buried within it was an oblique reference to his son". The "reference" to Simon is indeed "buried" and "oblique". So much so, that unless Christopher tells us directly what "sugestions" he is referring to we cannot be sure what he is talking about.

So to return to your question, my answer remains that while I do not think Simon is telling the whole story, his story is all we have. What little evidence we have does not refute his version of events. We are not dealing here with an American criminal trial where Christopher gets the benefit of a presumption on his side.
 
rs691919 said:
As I thought, you cannot give a yes or no answer.
Ah, more rhetorical brilliance.

Yes, I accept it as true pending evidence it is not, but I do not accept it as the whole story. You have presented no "evidence" beyond your suppositions that it is not true.
 
Greenwood said:
Yes, I accept it as true pending evidence it is not, but I do not accept it as the whole story. You have presented no "evidence" beyond your suppositions that it is not true.

See, now honesty is more becoming. Actually, I have no supposition other than that it is most likely not the only side of the story. Whether its true or not, I have no idea (and what's more, I don't care). What I do have disdain for is the airing of family dispute in the media. That's distasteful, even if the story is true.
 
Let's see if we can get this thread back on track...the debates have been endless regarding the changes from the books to the movies. For arguement's sake, the legalities have been settled and PJ is making the film. Now the world of ME varies from Hobbit to LOTR, so in this theoretical 'movie' version of The Hobbit what do you think the necessary changes would have to be bridge the gap from the Hobbit (movie) to the LOTR (movies). No matter what stance you have on the existing movie a version of ME has been created, now lets say its your job to fit the Hobbit into that world...how would you do it?
 
I guess four times is the charm since I had to say the same thing four times before you seemed to understand the answer.

Fundin Snowarm said:
No matter what stance you have on the existing movie a version of ME has been created, now lets say its your job to fit the Hobbit into that world...how would you do it?
I suspect you don't really mean "fitting The Hobbit" into the cinematic version of ME that has already been created, as much as you mean changing the "feel" of it from a "children's" story to an "adult" story.
 
That is an obvious point, and right along the lines of what i was thinking. When i say fitting it in i mean, for example in the Hobbit the spiders can talk in the common language while in the LOTR Shelob does not...in a movie version would you have the spiders talk or would you keep it within the realm of the LOTR movies and just have them make spider noises. That's just one example the are many other small differences between the LOTR (books) and The Hobbit (book) that could effect continuity in movie versions...so the question is point out some of the differences and how would you address them.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…