• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Hobbit as movie?

Greenwood said:
I guess four times is the charm since I had to say the same thing four times before you seemed to understand the answer.

Well, it did take you three times to give a yes or no answer; and your final answer appears to be "yes", it does make Simon's story more likely to be true in your mind (although earlier you said it made it neither more nor less likely). At least you're being honest now, whereas before you were hemming and hawing and making qualifications to your answers.

Incidentally, take a look at post #20 (and take a look at the date of the post) for more brilliant rhetorical devices.
 
Last edited:
Fundin Snowarm said:
That is an obvious point, and right along the lines of what i was thinking. When i say fitting it in i mean, for example in the Hobbit the spiders can talk in the common language while in the LOTR Shelob does not...in a movie version would you have the spiders talk or would you keep it within the realm of the LOTR movies and just have them make spider noises. That's just one example the are many other small differences between the LOTR (books) and The Hobbit (book) that could effect continuity in movie versions...so the question is point out some of the differences and how would you address them.

I apologize for hijacking your thread. Back to the topic. The main divergence between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings is in tone. The former is set in a world where you can have talking spiders; the latter less so. As for the spiders, I think it would be appropriate to reign them in, so to speak--that is, make them more like spiders.

But then what do you do with the three talking Trolls with very English names? That's a little stickier, for it's one of the memoable parts of the book; light-hearted, but still the point at which Bilbo has his first adventure. Overall, I would want The Hobbit to stay as is. Part of its greatness is its lightheartedness. So while the events are of course crucial to The Lord of the Rings, I wouldn't want to delve too deeply into that connection, because it would inevitably make the story darker than it is.
 
rs691919 said:
Well, it did take you three times to give a yes or no answer; and your final answer appears to be "yes", it does make Simon's story more likely to be true in your mind (although earlier you said it made it neither more nor less likely). At least you're being honest now, whereas before you were hemming and hawing and qualifications to your answers.

Incidentally, take a look at post #20 (and take a look at the date of the post) for more brilliant rhetorical devices.

I gave my answer repeatedly. The fact that it was not an answer you liked or agreed with does not give you the right to question my honesty. You are skating awfully close to a personal attack, if you have not already crossed the line.

The post you cite was made on Jan. 20, 2004. So what? ;)

Oh, I get it! You mean I used the expression "So what?" on a date prior to the occasion that you used it. I must say, another brilliant rhetorical device!

I am humbled by the brilliance of the rhetoric in your arguments. :rolleyes:
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top