Rhiannon complained that they were green, but rotting dead people are a bit *****...
But
these dead people weren't supposed to be! And it destroyed the wonderful tension of the dead following, which is one of the my favorite elements of the sequence. And I couldn't stop hearing the Indiana Jones theme in my head.
You know what, the scene between
Éowyn and the
Nazgul worked and was done effectively- it was of minor detail that her
helm was taken off at the wrong moment, they used the same script pretty much and did an excellent job. Girl power!
I didn't think so- It just felt all
wrong. Of course, I know the scene backwards and forwards, but all of us here agree that her taking off her helm at the wrong moment
ruins everything. It's like an afterthought. No pause of sudden doubt, no shrill wailing that fades away, no deadly gleam of fiery eyes...the Nazgul was totally not scary, and
Eowyn's valor was equally diminished. This doesn't mean that I didn't whoop at the top of my lungs, but I know with absolute certainty that with reptition the scene being wrong is going to drive me
crazy.
there was not enough of
Éomer (the most emotional scene in the book for me was him finding Éowyn on the field)
I thought of you as they skipped that scene,
Dain
Éowyn talking to
Théoden before he died (I think if it was just like the book where
Merry talked to him with Éowyn lying nearby it would be much more effective and more heart-rending)
Agreed, although it kind of fit with the film's upping of the relationship between
Theoden and Eowyn- I just wish they'd given some of that to her relationship with
Eomer as well. I think as far as the film goes, Merry speaking to Theoden would have been less effective because we never see him and Theoden interact like they do in the book. No 'as a father you shall be to me'.
the absence of the Houses of Healing (it was a bit wierd to leave the
Fields with Éowyn and Merry 'dead' on the field
NO KIDDING!
Oh I see! You must have read the book while you were watching the movie, so you not only missed the whole greatness because you were in your own little world, but also you were able to squeeze every little thing to complain about on this board!
Pause. Breathe. Don't get your panties in a wad. I'm not making a personal attack on your flesh and blood. I didn't enjoy the film. I'm annoyed because I saw that it could be better, and it should have been better-
in my opinion. But you're free to think differently. So breathe. I'm not going to throw rocks at you for liking the movie.
I had the book read
to me immediately prior to seeing the movie, because it is a deeply held tradition in my family that my dad reads LotR outloud in the fall, and this is a major part of my life. This is something that's important to me. I feel justified in being annoyed that someone got it wrong-
in my opinion. I missed the greatness because there was none-
in my opinion. I like my little world. I prefer my little world to reality. But you don't have to come hang out in my little world if you don't want to, that's fine. I won't be offended. Have a cookie anyway. I didn't 'squeeze in every little thing to complain about', I hit the main reasons I disliked the movie. I was maybe a little scathing, but I was honestly scathing. Relax.
I´m sick of hearing people complain about the differences and saying the film stinks, because that actually makes you believe it stinks. Which has nothing to do with the truth!
I DO believe the film stinks. I think I said so quite eloquently, in fact. But it's okay of you don't think the film stinks. Have a cookie.
I just read OVER 200 REWIEWS ON THEONERING.NET WERE THEY GAVE IT A 5 CLAIMING IT`S THE BEST MOVIE OF THEIR LIVES, TAKING YOUR BREATH AWAY NOT ONLY ONE TIME AND YOU DON`T GET IT BACK UNTIL YOU`RE ON YOUR WAY HOME.
That's great for them. I'm glad they enjoyed it. I'm genuinly sorry that I didn't enjoy it- but I still feel justified in being scathing. Besides, being scathing is fun, as you obviously know. I hope none of those people had to go to the emergency room. No oxogyn to the brain can cause brain damage.
Rhi has her right to complain- since the movie didn't include
Faramir/Eowyn scenes and didn't follow the
Witch-King battle line by line, that's like a slap in her face!
Thank you, Dain- I'm glad
someone understands where I'm coming from!
I think this says it all, let me guess, you favorite movies of all time have to be the "Revenge of the Nerds" movies, right?
Never heard of them. I do enjoy Kevin Smith films, if those count. My favorite movie is probably Casablanca, if I had to pick one.
Rhiannon
Some of the 200 equal rewiews I found at theonering.net
How nice for them. Unfortunately, other people saying they liked the film does not make me like the film. If this were so, I would like Charles Dickens much more than I do.
The Eye of Sauron was soo freakin cheesy!! I burst out laughing when that thing started darting around looking for stuff, and made comments like "I can't find my keys!" And "Where's my Contact?!". The movie had it's high points but overall it was just like lame. The Battle of Pelanor Fields was uh, how can I say this, cheap, it was nothing like the grand fight that it is in the
books. As far as the movies go I prefer FotR over TTT and RotK.
Thank you! I was starting to think Tal and I were the only ones that didn't like it. It's nice not to be a lone negative voice (why do I always end up on the extreme end? Oh well...price of being interesting).
O Gigantic-Titanic-fanatic,
I guess we all get sick of things at these forums from time to time. I can relate to that. For example, one thing that I get sick of is hearing people say that anyone who doesn't like or even love these movies has something wrong with them, or is doing something wrong. It's indicative of denial really. Inablity to accept that the films could be short of perfect in the eyes of others.
Thanks, Nom (glad to see you back around!). There are actually, as difficult as it may be to believe, people who don't like Casablanca. And I can deal with this. Everyone have a cookie.
Look at the bright side, Rhi:
You can always work on your homework instead of going to see ROTK again.
I HAVE no homework! My semester is over! Hurrah! So I'll write an article on Eowyn and a profile thing for Dain instead
Rhiannon,
After that review, I would be convinced that your ability to view anything in your life without dissaproval has been taken away from you. Here is a half-empty glass of milk that you can enjoy while you wear your awesome costume.
Why, thank you. I'll treasure it forever. I still feel justified in hating the movie. I'm happy for people who enjoyed the movie. Go you. I didn't enjoy the movie. I expressed my honest opinion on the subject. Now that we've both done so, we can go our seperate ways, you minus your glass, and me going to lock myself in my room with a copy of LotR. Have a cookie.
Hey, enough with the snide remarks. Just because someone doesn't like the movie doesn't mean you have to be rude about it. It's just a bloody movie after all.
Hear, hear. I'm sorry I ticked you all off. Have a cookie. Take a deep breath. Tal, I love the signature!
Overall, it had a more modern feeling to it. All characters (except perhaps
Gandalf) have flaws. I missed the heroism, the honor, the sacrifice for the common good.
That's it exactly. What I feel in a nutshell. Brytta is profound. I'm going to go sit next to her. Have a cookie.