• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

‘The Rings of Power’ Rewrites 72 Years of ‘LotR’ Lore

Radaghast

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 31, 2021
Messages
2,918

The show also introduces a form between these characters' time as ordinary Men and their time as the Nazgûl: the Nazgnagôl. This invention suggests that Sauron's Ringwraiths didn't immediately become otherworldly, hollowed-out beings. The Nazgnagôl have extraordinary strength and resilience, still wear dark cloaks, and cover their faces. However, they're fully human underneath their masks, as their corruption is only just starting.

"Nazgnagôl"


Animated GIF
 
It actually makes sense IMO that there would be a transitional phase; Bilbo is starting to feel the weariness, "thin and stretched" effect (the 'butter over too much bread') as he reaches the outer limits of his Hobbit potential life span; Gollum is much more warped, but still visible.

Granted, I think Gollum was able to stay visible so long because he didn't actually use the Ring all that often, plus inherent Hobbit resistance (?). The wraithification probably progressed faster with the presumably power hungry Nazgul-to-be who likely used their Rings more (not just for invisibility, but also the general personal enhancement effect of all Rings of Power, and apparently they used the "see Unseen things" effect to help learn sorcery?). But I still doubt it was anything like instantaneous. They would have felt the "thin and stretched" effect first, probably as they approached the limits of their potential lifespan (so faster for the non-Numenoreans), then begun to "fade".

I have no idea where they got that word though. And I don't think they would get "extraordinary strength and resilience" early on - I think the Nazgul being hard to kill has to
do at least partly with their bodies fading into the Unseen World, though the Witch-king apparently has additional protective magic (the "all blades perish" thing). I actually don't think the book universe Nazgul have exceptional strength at all - they have "no great physical power against the fearless", and I don't think they ever do any feat of physical strength that an ordinary human warrior couldn't - but the size of mace/flail wielded by the movie universe Witch-king does suggest superhuman strength.

(otoh, there are various references to the Nazgul's power being linked to Sauron's. Perhaps while Sauron was wearing the One in the Second Age, he could directly empower his Ring-wearing slaves through some kind of sorcery/Ainur power exploiting the link between the One and the other Rings?)
 
Last edited:
I have no idea where they got that word though. And I don't think they would get "extraordinary strength and resilience" early on - I think the Nazgul being hard to kill has to
do at least partly with their bodies fading into the Unseen World, though the Witch-king apparently has additional protective magic (the "all blades perish" thing). I actually don't think the book universe Nazgul have exceptional strength at all - they have "no great physical power against the fearless", and I don't think they ever do any feat of physical strength that an ordinary human warrior couldn't - but the size of mace/flail wielded by the movie universe Witch-king does suggest superhuman strength.
The questionable word is "nagol". Tried to find a source for it online and came up empty.

I actually don't think the book universe Nazgul have exceptional strength at all - they have "no great physical power against the fearless", and I don't think they ever do any feat of physical strength that an ordinary human warrior couldn't - but the size of mace/flail wielded by the movie universe Witch-king does suggest superhuman strength.
The WK does the same thing to Éowyn's shield in the book.
Out of the wreck rose the Black Rider, tall and threatening, towering above her. With a cry of hatred that stung the very ears like venom he let fall his mace. Her shield was shivered in many pieces, and her arm was broken; she stumbled to her knees. He bent over her like a cloud, and his eyes glittered; he raised his mace to kill. ("The Battle of the Pelennor Fields")
As for the quote about the Ring-wraiths "having no great physical power against the fearless", Tolkien seems to contradict himself in another letter where he describes them as "savage warriors with great strength." And the scene from the book seems to contradict it too, since Éowyn can certainly be considered fearless.
 
There's a lot of mystery surrounding the Nazgul, so there's a ton of room for argument. And I may be wrong. And it may be irrelevant anyway because Gandalf says that the Nazgul during LOTR are "only shadows" of what they would be if Sauron got the Ring back, so their having super-powers in the Second Age may be perfectly reasonable. But...

The WK does the same thing to Éowyn's shield in the book.
Yes, absolutely, but IMO in the book he was using a more or less conventional mace, not the impractical thing in the movie.


As for the quote about the Ring-wraiths "having no great physical power against the fearless", Tolkien seems to contradict himself in another letter where he describes them as "savage warriors with great strength." And the scene from the book seems to contradict it too, since Éowyn can certainly be considered fearless.

It could be a contradiction, but I don't think it needs to be. "Great" is a relative term. I think that the "no great physical power against the fearless" quote refers to their physical strength not being beyond what would be expected from comparable humans; while the "savage warriors with great strength" quote is talking about Frodo with the Ring vs the eight surviving Nazgul (in a hypothetical situation where Gollum did not take the Ring at the end). Their strength could be 'normal' for Men (though undiminished by age, and some were originally Numenorean and thus above average human) while still being 'great strength' relative to a hobbit (much less a dehydrated, starved, and exhausted one).

I agree Eowyn is fearless in that scene, but I am not sure the Witch-king demonstrates any physical strength that he wouldn't have had as a living man, especially if the Witch-king was one of the Numenorean ones (as seems likely IMO) and thus possibly in the 7' range. Shields did break in real world medieval combat; I don't think shattering her shield and breaking her arm is beyond what would be physically possible for a large, powerful, trained warrior.
 
Weighing in as someone who has not watched RoP since season one, so bear with my cluelessness on plot and story and allow me to address my chief and indeed, only concern for being here: etymology. I have been reading this thread briefly as it popped up and have seen some chatter over the origins of "nagol", and so I thought I might offer some thoughts on it, from a Sindarin/Quenyan and Neo-Sindarin/Quenyan perspective.

I begin by telling you that nagol has never truly come up, so written in that way and dialect, in Tolkien's works.

However, words like it have, and that has led us neo-translators to make some conclusions from it. In most typical fashion of Sindarin neo-translation, "nagol" as seen as coming from the root of the word, "neleg", meaning teeth. "Nagol" has been used in several neo-texts to give focus to the singular of "one tooth" or when combined with other such words as in "nagloth" or "nagse", can carry the meaning of "teeth" in the former, or even "bite" in the latter. This all stems from the root words of "naith", meaning "angled" and "agol", meaning "mark". This then transferred into the meaning of teeth, and such has given it far better implications and applications.

Now, in Tolkien's legendarium, there are a few occurring words which give rise to the same etymological sound as "nagol", though do not posit its existence. "agol", which is confirmed to fit the Tolkienian Sindarin dialect, though it originated in the dialect of Gnomish, means "flash, sudden flame, lightning". A very strange thing to draw on indeed, so it gives us no clarity as to why the Nazgul would be named this in some supposed transitional period.

The most compelling, however, I would claim, comes from the Sindarin word "tagol" which means, "boundary, post, or milestone". It originated from the Quenyan word "talca", meaning, roughly the same. Now, this gives the most fitting definition that I have found, suggesting that perhaps this form of reality and of appearance is a milestone, a mark along their journey to complete corruption as the Nazgul.

Another odd point regarding this last one is that "tagol", is a word that contains in it a soft mutation. (Now, soft mutations, or vocalic mutations, are voiceless and voiced stops which change the sound of a word and direct its meaning.) This, I find particularly interesting, though I am not sure that the folks at Amazon had any intent with putting that in. Still, I find it interesting that the root word, and the present suffix "-gol" point to a soft-mutation, while speaking of a word that suggests some mark or milestone on the road to another mutation.

That being said, I highly doubt that those folks at Amazon did any deep etymological research, and it is most likely, I would think that they merely contrived this as a name, without appreciating the years of lore and learning behind the Elvish and other Tolkienian languages, as so many do. Indeed, it is a tragedy that we live in a world where people can seem more preoccupied in making quick cash than really delving into the genius of a man whom none shall ever be like again.

I can only hope that in some small way, this franchise will lead people back to the true Tolkien and his outstanding works, and we will gain more people with a deep appreciation for the genius of his arts and literature, not less.

I will add to this discussion very briefly: the word "Nazgûl" roots from Black Speech, so it is rather uncommon and odd that it would even have Sindarin or Neo-Sindarin roots at all. We are given no indication for a word of "nagol" in Black Speech, the closest in this dialect being "agh" meaning "and" as well as "gûldur" meaning "black arts/sorcery", however I confess that I have not so deeply studied Black Speech and only know on the surface a small handful of words.

Cheers, I'll be on Taniquetil if anyone needs me,

- EVV
 
Last edited:
It could be a contradiction, but I don't think it needs to be. "Great" is a relative term. I think that the "no great physical power against the fearless" quote refers to their physical strength not being beyond what would be expected from comparable humans; while the "savage warriors with great strength" quote is talking about Frodo with the Ring vs the eight surviving Nazgul (in a hypothetical situation where Gollum did not take the Ring at the end). Their strength could be 'normal' for Men (though undiminished by age, and some were originally Numenorean and thus above average human) while still being 'great strength' relative to a hobbit (much less a dehydrated, starved, and exhausted one).

I agree Eowyn is fearless in that scene, but I am not sure the Witch-king demonstrates any physical strength that he wouldn't have had as a living man, especially if the Witch-king was one of the Numenorean ones (as seems likely IMO) and thus possibly in the 7' range. Shields did break in real world medieval combat; I don't think shattering her shield and breaking her arm is beyond what would be physically possible for a large, powerful, trained warrior.
This seems a bit like quibbling to me. The size of the mace in the book is indeterminate, except that it's a "great back mace", which certainly doesn't necessarily point to a conventional weapon (also, to be technical, the weapon wielded by the movie Witch-king is a flail). And shields and shield arms may break but I doubt a well-made shield ever shivered into many pieces from one blow from a human warrior.

It's okay to say that Tolkien contradicted himself. The example in question would not be the only time. There is one instance within The Lord of the Rings itself, namely the matter of who has the Nine Rings (Gandalf says the Nazgûl have them; Galadriel says Sauron does). The man was brilliant but not infallible.
 
Last edited:
nazgnagol

nazg = blackspeech for "ring" (Seen at The Council as Gandalf speaks the ring verse)

nagol shares a syllable with Snaga which comes from "slave" or "servant"

So, I guess nazgnagol is "ringservant" more or less.
Seems to make sense that they'd be ringservants first then degrade into ringwraiths over time.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top