• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The ⚔️War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (Discussion of organization)

Joined
Apr 19, 2002
Messages
4,431
This is a big rambling sloppy post, but it doesn't matter... just putting ideas out.


This is somewhat similar to the idea Turgon had long ago for a Silmarillion RPG, I guess it is just more focused on war. It is probably also at least slightly similar to the old war RPGs that have happened here long ago... but I'm not sure.

What if we were to have a game that was the War of the Jewels, and it opens at the time that the seige on Angband is being established. Payers will take on the roles of the military leaders in Beleriand, and a single person, or a few people who will work closely as a team or under the single person are in control of all the servants of Morgoth activity. From there we play out the war without a concern if it goes the way it did in the books or not.

Anybody want to?

As I see, at a minimum we Might (depending on how this is structured) need at least one person in charge of the following realms:

Hithlum

Dorthonion

Maglor's Gap and all the Feanorian area can be headed by a single player if needed. otherwise it can be further divided.

Nargothrond.

Belegost

Nogrod

The Falas

Doriath

Angband

Could also have Ossiriand, and Gondolin will eventually be needed most likely. later, especialyy has men enter the scene, there could be smaller independant realms within the larger ones.

The rulers should probably keep decent communication OOC.

But you see, we don't need a leader to repesent each of the leaders mentioned in the SIlmarillion, only one for each realm.

For example I could be the leader in Dorthonion, Aegnor and Angrod will not be roles that I worry about fleshing out, they will just be the roles through which the shots are called In Character. Or the commands given in their name. I envison the characters with the most IC time, those who really make the story, will be those we have invented for the game. Some random warrior character for instance.

But there is another way! Instead of having a bunch of players take on the (headache? role?) of playing a the realm's leader, a select few could be designated to do this job, and then most the players could be free to go about RPing and creating their storylines without a care about keeping track of population or relations with other realms, unless they willingly chose to bother with those issues, such as by making their character a messenger or some kind of diplomat or whatever. Whatever the players think is best.


When we start, some things will have to be decided. Population of the realms. Because of the battle this will have to be kept track of. A few basic guidelines will have to be in place regarding this, since the number of warriors effect your effectiveness as an army, and your number of survivors obviously determines if you won or lost, and how badly.

Since population needs to be tracked, so does the passage of time.

I think it would be cool to have someone in charge of these two things. They would be reading the RPG and would keep track of how many are killed in battle, but will not have any say in how many were killed, other players determine this. Anyhow, they will keep track of deaths and using a predetermined formula calculate the population growth, and then subtract... whatever is needed. Realms of men would multiply faster, elves and dwarves slowly, you get the idea. Of course the rulers of each realm could do this themselves, but they would be double-checked by the population person.

But that isn't the only reason the passage of time must be kept track of. With different locations, we need to take care not to get too far ahead or behind the other realms.


For the most part everybody will have the same enemy. Morgoth. So hopefully there would not be any dispute that another elven ruler was being unfair in battle against you.

But there could be exceptions. The Feanorians, being after the silmarils could strike up a kinslaying. Something could happen among men, or with dwarves. Because of this, someone would have to be in charge of deciding what happens in the case of a dispute.

So in addition to rulers of the realms we need:

Someone to handle disputes regarding battles.
Someone to watch the passage of time and population changes.


These people will have to have the authority of final say in disputes that players can't settle, or else choas could happen.

I know it looks like a huge RP, and I doubt there will be enough interested players, but I think it could be very fun so its worth a try posting this.

Maybe this is just a crazy idea. I honestly don't have the experience to judge that.

I'm sure similar things have been attempted. I also know some of you used to play in some kind of Fourth Age WAR RPs here and at MERPG, so perhaps you have some advice. Though I'm not sure what those were like, so most of it might not apply to the way this WotJ RPG will be done.

I was thinking if each realm has its own thread, and the battles are played out in the realm thread where they take place regardless of who is involved. If Turgon goes to Doriath, post a link to the the Gondolin thread where it says "They arrived in Doriath" or whatever. Another option, which I am leading towards, is to have any major battles fought in their own battle thread, again with links coming from the realm threads.

A generic example:

Thread Hithlum:

"And the army moved off over the hills and out onto the plain where battle waited. (Link)"

Move to Battle thread in progress, an army of Hithlum arives in the post linked to at the Hithlum thread mentioned above:

"Fingon's army was seen approaching in the dawn..."

I hope that gets the idea across.

But very importantly, the realm threads would be used for other storylines to take place. Maybe you have some soldiers who are brothers and their story is followed and later is tied in with a battle... or not.

So in a sense, what you would have are independant RPGs going on which happen to tie in together whenever they like, or whenever Morgoth strikes.

Links to other threads would be used not only to link to battle threads, but also if a character from Nargothrond were to travel to Hithlum.

"At last Edrahil entered Hithlum and looked out over the misty plain. (Links to Hithlum thread)."

In this way anyone reading the RPG can very easily follow the story lines.


I'm not even suggesting this is something that could be started in the near future. I doubt there are enough players interested in it.

This idea has been nagging me so I just had to post.

This thread is really just for interested players to discuss how such a project should be organized if it is ever going to happen.

Something of this size would have to be well organized and thought through thoroughly so that it can best be structured from the beginning to avoid potential later problems. The groundwork.

Oh, and just because I bring this up doesn't mean I expect to be some kind of overlord if this is it ever happens. I wouldn't mind playing Morgoth and forces with a few other evil individuals though ;).
 
Last edited:
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

*jumps up and down*

Ohh! Ohh! Me! Me!

I like this idea very much...although I don't have any books with me, so making references is going to be rather difficult, hrm...would that be a problem?
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

Wow... somebody already willing! :D

As for books, well there are tons of internet resources and other players you could get information off of.

But if you're just speaking of casual references made In Character that serve no purpose other than making it feel more like Middle-earth, it shouldn't be a problem if some of the players do not do a lot this.

I know you have a lot of experience Ciryaher. What type of roles would you be interested in? Maybe ruler of Belegost or something? (I know you like Dwarves almost a smuch as you love Elves. ;))

But any thoughts have on how a project like this could be run would be helpfull. I'm curious what you think about the structural ideas I suggest.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

Hmm...Dwarves, yes. That'd be nifty. That can wait for now, though :)

One thing that is definitely needed is an impartial system of determining the outcome of a battle. Now things can spiral out of simplicity easily, but with the right person, you can be safe knowing that the battles will be done well. Who that person could be...I have no clue.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

Yes, I agree that is important.

Those who play Morgoth and his forces would have to be aware of how important this is.

Perhaps asking a realm OOC ahead of time what the absolute worst damage is that they are willing to take.

This is a big war, and it would only be more realistic and make for a better and longer game if there are times when the good guys take big losses. Even maybe once or twice to the ruin of an entire realm eventually, resulting in the survivors joining under another realm. Kind of in the way Curufin and Celegorm joined Nargothrond.

In The Silmarillion Ossiriand was the only elven realm that ended up untouched in the WotJ. I would hope something similar happens in the RPG... Morgoth comes near victory.

My opinion is that the RPG ultimately belongs to the good guys since it is set in Middle-earth where they do eventually always survive, and ideally I would say that those who determine how badly the good guys are damaged keep this in mind and put the story first.

One reason I want to be on the side of evil is to help control this. I would not want Morgoth to ultimately win, but I would want him to gradually gain more ground over the good guys before his ultimate defeat occurrs. Kind of an alternate version of 'The Silmarillion'.

But it's not just the damage Morgoth does. We wouldn't want any elven-king going in and wipping out Morgoth's army then going into Angband and taking off his head.

My opinion is the main idea of The Silmarillion remain. Morgoth will not be defeated entirely without aid from Aman, and a silmaril that is won must guide a mariner to Valinor. But this should really go however the players want.

But lets say two good guy realms go to war with eachother for some reason. This is even more tricky in my opinion. If there is disagreement about the outcome, this would be where the person with the authority steps in.

But just who should have the authority is a good question.

In my opinion they should be people who:

1) Players trust to hear everybody out and be fair.
2) Really have a passion to make this a good story.
3) Knows Middle-earth history, and has good judgement about what is absurd or not when it comes to battles.

We could have nominations then vote. I don't think it will be a problem honestly. I think people will make good choices.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

I'm totally in. This sounds like so much fun, and it'll be a challenge. Heck yeah.

As far as someone to be the important guy-behind-the-scenes, I would suggest someone we all know, someone who's been around for a while and knows how these things go. Like you said, Nom, someone we can trust.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

Nóm said:
One reason I want to be on the side of evil is to help control this. I would not want Morgoth to ultimately win, but I would want him to gradually gain more ground over the good guys before his ultimate defeat occurrs. Kind of an alternate version of 'The Silmarillion'.

But it's not just the damage Morgoth does. We wouldn't want any elven-king going in and wipping out Morgoth's army then going into Angband and taking off his head.

My opinion is the main idea of The Silmarillion remain. Morgoth will not be defeated entirely without aid from Aman, and a silmaril that is won must guide a mariner to Valinor. But this should really go however the players want.

But lets say two good guy realms go to war with eachother for some reason. This is even more tricky in my opinion. If there is disagreement about the outcome, this would be where the person with the authority steps in.

But just who should have the authority is a good question.

In my opinion they should be people who:

1) Players trust to hear everybody out and be fair.
2) Really have a passion to make this a good story.
3) Knows Middle-earth history, and has good judgement about what is absurd or not when it comes to battles.

We could have nominations then vote. I don't think it will be a problem honestly. I think people will make good choices.

Nom, you have taken a huge project on your shoulders here and I admire your courage. Furthermore, I would like to lend you a helping hand in this. Since you are the thread starter, the final say should be effectively yours on matters of dispute, as this is YOUR puppy, but I can help you maintain order within it, if you'll have me.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

Wow... good to see more interest.

AT the moment I think there are other important things to be worked out besides deciding which people will have some special authority. We wouldn't know how many are needed to act as realm-rulers and in which positions, until the structure of how the game will be run has been decided on. (Yet the structure will depend on how many are willing, while how many are needed will in turn be dictated by the structure... they evolve together.:D)

There is far more in my posts that can be commented on.

But as for who I would prefer to have final says, honestly? People without big history of seeking high-level authority or power. You know power corrupts right?! :p Just the same I think it should all be decided on vote.

Here is another idea for the structure.

Player who rules the sons of Finarfin.
Player to rule the sons of Fingolfin.
Player to rule Feanorians.
Player to rule Doriath.
Ruler of Belegost.
Ruler of Nogrod (perhaps same player as Belegost?)
Ruler of the Falathrim
Ruler of Ossiriand (could be done by the Falas ruler)
Morgoth


If we had nine rulers, I think such a layout Could work! It could be further divided if more than 9 players want this kind of role.

The important thing here is that when it is a single person overseeing more than one area they are all the siblings or at least allies. In this way they could better structure the story-line and stir up competition, especially if they work closely with the players who run their ally-realms. This is also why I wouldn't suggest that Maedhros's and Fingolfin's realms be ruled by the same player. These two people and their realms have different goals, and not great friendship. I think it would be more fun if the rulers really were in some cases playing along with other realms where you just don't know what the other guy might do!! The Feanorians were such people, and there was plenty of distrust among even the Noldor without factoring in Thingol's hate of Feanorians and resentment of Noldor, or of problems regarding men and dwarves.

Another, even more condensed option:

1) Ruler of the realm realms of the childen of Fingolfin and Finarfin. (The non-Feanorian Noldor in other words.)

2) Ruler of Feanorians.

3) Ruler of Doriath, Falas, and Ossiriand. (Keeping in mind the big differences between these three cultures and their alliances would be vital though.)

4) Ruler of Ered Luin Dwarves.

5) Mogoth

These would be the positions, along with whoever has final say in battle outcome, that shape the bigger details and rough outline of the overall game, whereas the other players would be the stars with directional power over the finer details such as their own personal storylines and adventures, and their contribution to their realm. The meat of the game. To be honest I see the ruler's role as more work than play.

In a sense the players who rule have the job of making sure the other players have fun. So I think ruling is a job that some would see as work that is not fun, while some players would see it as fun work, the best kind of role to have!! And of course someone could always rule the Falathrim while playing a average joe dwarf, for instance.

Let me share my own philosphy on how I would like to run things if I were to play Morgoth for instance.

I would like at least one other player whose opinion I would often seek on major events. Perhaps whoever plays Sauron.

I might have the following players on my team:

Sauron
Glaurung
Gothmog
Orc captain 1
Orc Captain 2


I would make calls like "Orc captain 2, go North around hithlum and strike them from the west. Gothmog and orc captain 2 you go with Glaurung to hit Hithlum from the east. Sauron you go out and take Tol Sirion if you can, and if you get it rule as you see fit.

It would then be in the team's hands to go about these tasks however they like and with whatever additional bad-guys they like RPing along side of them.

It would be my job as Morgoth to to give the very basics is all, and after they are given I would only step in if one of my players were to do something that I felt would screw up the game or be unfair to others. If this were to happen the player and I would talk about it in private.

It would also be my job to provide the enemy if any players came to me or my team wanting to have a battle, or a surprise attack set on their realm at some point. Whatever the case is. Be it is a small company of orcs or a full scale attack on the Noth of Beleriand.

But I think Morgoth could also have some badguys who are out scounting or hunting... just up to general evil throughout Beleriand, and these could basically do whatever they want, only going to Morgoth for the big decisions. These (I will call them average joe orcs, though they may be high ranking) would be mostly independant of Mogroth, free to go about RPing up whatever storyline they like, within reason like everyone else though. So if a goodguy just needs an orc two, you could go to these orc players without having to come to Morgoth OOC and ask for it. As lon as it is nothing major.

Or if I were ruler of the Sons of Finarfin for instance:

I mostly sit back while players RP whatever they want within my realm.

All I have to do is:

Have whatever necessary communications with other rulers (IC and OOC), for alliance talks, or reuinions, whatever case is.

Step in if a player were to initiate something that is a little too much, just as pull an enormous orc invasion out of nowhere, which would hinder other players of just be absurd. I mean a small company of orcs wouldn't for instance slip into Nargothrond at the height of its power and slay the king. But a small company of orcs might strike near the edge of the realm of Nargothrond and cause trouble.

Keep track of populations, passage of time, or allow someone under you to do this. But ultimately you would be answerable.

Discuss with other rulers which inter-realm events, be it war or some kind of exudus, whatever the case, is to happen next, and where the story might go.

In IC and/or OOC talk to the players of yoru realm about any of their concerns and consider where they want the story to go.

How big my IC role is is up to me. If I am someone like Maedhros I will have big involvement in the war and planning battles if I want to, but as Cirdan (depending how the war goes) Turgon for example, I might only get involved in battle a couple of times.


I hope those examples give you a good idea of how I envision the structure and the way in which the rulers work together.

To be honest there are few single people who I would be comfortable with the authority of final say over everybody.

The best option may be to set up a group of three for this. I would only suggest that no two of the three have similar interests as far as in character battles go.

Something like this is what I'd suggest:

1) Morgoth

2) Someone to represent the other rulers to specifically hear their concerns.

3) Someone to repesent by the average joe players, and this is very important, to represent them in the matters that might come up. Perhaps this person could play Ulmo too?

I would not suggest the ruler of Feanorians or any group of people who may potentially try to take over another good-realm! Hehehe!

The text that you have entered is too long (12102 characters). Please shorten it to 10000 characters long.
 
Last edited:
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

Anyhow, these three would take council with eachother, and all three would be available for ANY player regardless of their role, to bring concerns to.

Three is best I think. With three the chances that any given player will have faith in at least one of them is very good!

If the three disagree after discussion, a vote.... 2 out of three wins. But anything messy or that is a headache should be kept out of public view in my opinion. Above all the game leaders are creating the best environment and game that they can for the other players. Thats my philosphy on this.

In fact, why not go ahead and lets decide on who these game leaders could be if the game were to start soon!? In this way the three could already, as they read everybody's input there, begin to make final decisions on the game's structure.

Umm... nominate who you want. Does three seem better than one? We'll take nominations for at least a week, perhaps much longer. I want anyone interested in having ANY involvement in the game to come forward, in this way we will know if it is any use to nominate that person or not.

And if later down the line any of three can't continue with their role, then we'll all just vote on a replacement.

How's that?

But really now. What about the structural/organizational things I suggest? Anybody who wants to be in power should obviously be concerned with this!!

I'd also like to get a feel before long for how many players might like to be realm-rulers, and what those interested players think of my different suggestions regarding these rulers. How many needed minimum on the outset in your opinions?

Which places should have their own thread when this begins? No sense starting Ossiriand, Falas, or any realm where there are not yet players wanting to RPing in those locations, I would guess. On the other hand, opening a thread for a location might inspire RPers to jump in with a character.

Oh, and as for joining, I would put it up to reach realm to decide if their ruler wants to aprove players whose homeland will be in that realm.

I want it to basically be an open RPG, but I don't know who would agree.

But however it goes, I don't want there to be any sense that someone must be measured up and scrutinized before they enter into the game. Perhaps a small note at the head of each thread saying something like this would be sufficient. "This RP is part of a larger game involving other threads. All are welcome, but please PM realm-ruler and let him/her know you are on your way. See this thread [... something linking to a short description and guide to the overall game] for more details about this game.

the guide thread, FAQ, or whatever you want to call it could have the following layout.

Post 1: What is the WOTJ game?

How do I join?

What are the rules?

Post two, three, four and so on would be one post for each realm.

The post would contain a few default things: their leaders, roles needed, and any special or specific instructions each realm leader may have set up for potential players. [For example it might say "Doriath only accepting Sindarin elves, Elves of the house of Finarfin, or dwarves by invitation." Or maybe In Hithlum's FAQ post: "This realm is open to all who are friendly, please PM realm-leader beore entering though." Or maybe "Maglor's gap. Enter at your own risk." :D Or maybe some realms say "all may attempt to enter but will have to answer to scouts" :p.

As well any note from the realm-ruler to potential players that was not covered above. Maybe maps, anything from ruler.


As for the rules, I imagine something like this:

1) Same rules apply as the rest of the RPG forum.

2) What else?

As for how do I join?

Maybe something like this.

Contact the leader of the realm that your character will primarily be dwelling in. If your characer is a wandering without home ;) contact the leader of whichever realm you character will enter the game in. [If any realms don't require permissions they can be listed here.]


I very much value input of those who have been involved in this kind of game. Especially those who can guide this in a direction that will give the most freedom and enjoyment to evey player regardless of rank, or who think in the terms of underlying structure, organization, and can look ahead and forsee how things might unfold under any given structure.


Once these things are worked out, and enough players want in (this may be a while), we can set up and get to playing.

I also think its important that the "work" only be done by those who want this type of role, so that players will not be put off by tons of regulations or worries. Not everyone who wants to play needs to even bother with the suggestions in this headachy thread, though they might like to have a say in things while this is young! Or make their interest known.

In fact maybe a mod can add (organization ideas) to this thread title, and we can open a new thead for "Stating your interest in joining." I don't know. I don't want players put off by all this oganizing talk is all I know!
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

As for realm rulers, Nom, I'd be happy to either play an elven realm or help you on the dark side of things. :)
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not?

I love the idea as well, especially since we never quite got round to carrying out Turgon's Silmarillion RPG idea. I was interested in playing Sauron back then, though I'm not averse to mucking about Doriath either. :p But seriously, I'd be content playing almost any smaller role, that much at least I can promise, due to time constraints.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (organization ideas)

Hey if I'm going to be Morgoth I'd like to have you as Sauron if you have the time. Or if not him, then smaller evil roles.

This might have to be done on a much smaller scale than I suggested originally. We just don't have the number of players we did two years ago. Smaller would be easier to manage too. But its hard, how do you have an RP concerning a large scale war without involving all the realms?

One alternative, and it was actually from this idea that the WoTJ idea sprang, is to set the RP to the East of the ered Luin, and have it concerning the Avari, Dwarves, and Men. The problem with this is that it would still be pretty large scale, and set in strange lands with strange people would mean that players would have conflicting imaginings about important things. In Beleriand we know what the cultures and landscape was like.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (organization ideas)

Nom, we did this scale of RP on MERPG before in the Chronicles of Ea. It takes some organising, but with a handful of good people, you can run an RPG in this size in a fairly good way, without too much difficulties.

As for making decisions, one person is too little and it cannot be an even number. Three would thus be a good option.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (organization ideas)

I would like to get invloved my exams are over and i have no real schoolwork till september.
I would like to take the sons of Fingolfin. I also agree on having three ultimte rulers. I nominate Nom if he will take it.
On my list I would have,
Finrod
Gorfindel
as captins these have the power to do what they want but must ask the ruler first and of course about 30 elf soilders would be nice but i think i'll only get 3. :(
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (organization ideas)

Dwarves would definitely be my cup of tea, as they have the advantage of being the most neutral faction in the region (zug zug). In addition to having a neutral "gamemaster" or "moderator" or whatever, perhaps we could have a representative of high reputation from each side to help serve on the little board thingy? Not for judging battles, perhaps, but at least for making game decisions.

Also, from what I gather, this will be a bit like the Chronicles...am I correct in that assumption?
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (organization ideas)

Nóm said:
Since population needs to be tracked, so does the passage of time.

I think it would be cool to have someone in charge of these two things. They would be reading the RPG and would keep track of how many are killed in battle, but will not have any say in how many were killed, other players determine this. Anyhow, they will keep track of deaths and using a predetermined formula calculate the population growth, and then subtract... whatever is needed. Realms of men would multiply faster, elves and dwarves slowly, you get the idea. Of course the rulers of each realm could do this themselves, but they would be double-checked by the population person.

Hmm...statistics. Is it just me, or does that have "Aule" written all over it? :p
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (organization ideas)

Glad to have you Alatar.

I can only guess this will be something like Chornicles were, but I say this without knowing much about the chronicles.

Like Ciryaher, I think those estimations are too high.

Fortunately JRRT gives us the numbers of the houses of Edain in HoME.

But regarding the elves, as JeffF points out in the thread Ithrynluin links to, the biggest evidence we have for their numbers is the fact that Turgon's army at the Nirnaeth Arnodiad was 10,000 strong.

Aside from this, JeffF says very little on First Age numbers, and what he does say is so rough that I don't think it would be of much help to us.
I don't see why we can't come up with our numbers, and if there is strong disagreement take a vote.

I think that more important than the numbers themselves are the population sizes relative to the other populations. We wouldn't want 1,000,000 Elves and 10,000 dwarves ;)

This is what JeffF. says on Gondolin:

This is much more difficult because the only number given is the 10,000 for the Army of Gondolin. I estimate that the total number for Gondolin was closer to 12,000 since they would not have denuded the fortress of defenders and their army consisted of 12 battalions (Book Lost Tales). This number might be as much as 1/3 that of the total number of warriors available to Fingolfin (and his sons) and the Sons of Feanor. This is based on the fact that the Sons of Feanor led a smaller host of the Noldor than Fingolfin and his sons (the host of Finfarin's sons came over with Fingolfin's division of the Noldor).

Inderjit and I discuss Gondolin's population elsewhere:

Well Turgon took 10,000 to the Nirnaeth. From there we can mostly just estimate and guess.

First it depends how many soldiers you think Turgon left behind in Gondolin. I think he left few, for people like Glorfindel and Ecthelion and of course Turgon himself went out for the Nirnaeth. I think from this we can assume that the best of them went to that battle, meaning Turgon probably didn't leave too great a strength of warriors behind... at least not the best of his stregth. We can also try to figure what Turgon might have thought would be accomplished in the Nirnaeth. At this point he thought the time was right, he knew the plans of his brother and cousin... this was to be THE attack on Morgoth... this was to whip him good. If this failed, then how much hope would be left? And if he thinks this is THE attack... he'll take all he can bear to I think. Yet, Turgon would not leave his people with no defence. I tend to think he probably left only 2,000-5,000 men behind.... then we'll say there was 12,000 to 15,000 women, and they were a happy and growing people... I'll give them oh say... 10,000 - 15,000 children.

Inder said:
Turgon took 2/3 of Fingolfin's folk as well as a greater host of the Sindar. This would amount to a lot of people. I would imagine 10,000 people was somewhere close to half of Turgon's forces. He tells Huor that Gondolin would not last long when it is apparent that they will lose the battle so he put quite a lot of faith in the Union of Maedhros, so he would have brought a significant amount of soldiers to battle.

We know of three lords of Gondolin attending the Nirnaeth, Maeglin, Glorfindel and Ecthelion. Glorfindel and Ecthelion were mentioned because they held the flanks to the right and left and Maeglin acted as the kings seems to have been the King's guard. So each lord of Gondolin mentioned seems to have played a memorable part. There may have been other Lords/Houses of Gondolin there too.
Eventually for estimation purposes we agree on 7,000 warrior's left behind.[/quote]

Any of us could be way off.

I'll put together a rough estimation of all the populations a little later and post it here. Anyone else who wants do the same and we'll find Middle-earth ground.

And speaking on population, we learn in one version of the Sil that nearly half the Noldor were in Feanorian-land. I don't know how many would agree with though, based on what 'The Silmarillion' says. Started a thread on this once but it got no reply.

We're also told Dorthonion has a relatively small population.
 
Last edited:
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (organization ideas)

I also made up some example posts for the FAQ/Information thread. Earlier I suggested each realm would keep a post in this information thread. Here is an example of how those individual Realm Information Posts could look:


--------------------------------------------

Dorthonion​


Ruler:

Nom (as Aegnor and Angrod)

Population at time of establishment:

20,000

Populated by who:

Noldor originally of the following of Fingolfin, and some Sindarin elves. See full stats here.

Description:

Of Beleriand and Its Realms

South of Ard-galen the great highland named Dorthonion stretched for sixty leagues from west to east; great pine forests it bore, especially on its northern and western sides. By gentle slopes from the 'plain it rose to a bleak and lofty land, where lay many tarns at the feet of bare tors whose heads were higher than the peaks of Ered Wethrin; but southward where it looked towards Doriath it fell suddenly in dreadful precipices. From the northern slopes of Dorthonion Angrod and Aegnor, sons of Finarfin, looked out over the fields of Ard-galen, and were the vassals of their brother Finrod, lord of Nargothrond; their people were few, for the land was barren, and the great highlands behind were deemed to be a bulwark that Morgoth would not lightly seek to cross.
History of realm:

When the seige was set Aegnor and Angrod came to Dorthonion with a small following, for it was not thought that Morgoth would likely try to cross this landscape. Some Sindar came in their following from Hithlum, and a few had already been living in the pine forest. Language spoken is Sindarin.

There have been no major events other than the establishment of this place. No battles.

Border:

Presently open, but pretty watchful.

Present situation:

It is about 200 years since the coming of the Sun.

All is well and peaceful. All "good" charcters are welcome.

Roles desired:

Angrod needs a captain.

Other roles fitting of this realm are welcome.

To join:

New Players, PM Nom with a character profile. If you're not sure who you want to play, you can ask her for suggestions.

Visitors from other realms, just enter.

Ruler's comments:

There are a lot of small settlements throughout this area.
A nice area for players who want to to set stories in the pine forest.
See here for a list and links to the profiles of all characters playing in Dorthonion.

----------------------------------------------------------

Rulers would make and update their realm's post as needed.

The information thread would also have a post which is frequently updated with population stats.

Population stats might look something like this:

------------------------------------------------
Hithlum​

Total population: 150,000
Present birth-rate: Slow
Noldor - 90,000
Sindar - 60,000
Men - 70,000
Women - 72,000
Children - 8,000



Military:

Warriors in total: 25,000

5,000 is cavalry.

Last updated July 5th, 2005.

Doriath​

Total population: 250,000
Present birthrate: Medium-slow
Sindar - 245,000
Greenelves - 5,000
Man - 95,000
Women - 95,000
Children - 60,000

Military

50,000 scouts, hunters and archers, best suited to stealth forest combat.

Last updated June 1st, 2005


Hithlum​

and so on...

_____________________________

Generic but it gives the idea.

Rulers would submit their stat updates to whoever mainatins the stats post. It could be some random member as well as any willing moderators. The random member might be the one in charge of double-checking the populations.

Information thread layout:

Post 1) About the WotJ RPG, and FAQ

Post 2) Index to Information Thread.

Post 3) Hithlum

Post 4) Dorthonion

Post 5) Nargothrond

So on....

Post 11 or whatever) Population and Military stats.

Post 12) Overall chronology of WotJ RPG.

Post 13 &14) Characters

Post 15... and on on... whatever is needed


As for the "Characters" post... it would be like this:

Characters by Realm...

Dorthoion's people: Angrod, Aegnor... (these are links to their profiles.)

Falas characters: Cirdan... so on.... and with each realm.

List of Characters listed in Alphebetical order:

Character listed by type... elves, dwarves, men, evil, good beasts... so on...

This will help people in deciding which realm they would like to join or visit.


That "Index post" I mentioned above would be with links to specific posts within the Information Thread, like this:


Realms

Dorthonion
Hithlum
Nargothrond
Belegost
Maglor's Gap
Doriath
Falas
Gondolin


Population stats

Tales of Years for WotJ

Who is where... characters list

And as for the birthrates, we could set up a system and formula.


Fast
medium
medium slow
slow
very slow

Fast - This would only ever apply to men. This could be a rate of one child per 10 adults per year. (I'm pulling this RANDOM EXAMPLE out of nowhere, the numbers will be given more figuring later.)

Medium - 1 child per 10 adults every 5 years. This would men during the hardest of times, and elven realms of great safety, stability, and little fears. Perhaps Gondolin moves this fast for a while.

Very slow - 1 child per 10 adults every 20 years. This would only ever apply to elves in times of flight or very great danger.

A realm's birthrate would change depending on major events like war, and the increase of danger. It would be up to thr ealm leader to set the rate, overseen by someone who will have the job of overseeing all the population stats. Disagreements go to the council.

By the way... should we see if Webmaster would allow us a subforum for the Realms of Beleriand threads to go into? Not that we need our own for the game, but I wouldn't want people to get annoyed about the Serious RPG forum being flooded with these. What think ye? But either way, no use asking until we know for a fact the game is about to start.
 
Last edited:
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (Discussion of organizati

Nóm said:
By the way... should we see if Webmaster would allow us a subforum for the Realms of Beleriand threads to go into? Not that we need our own for the game, but I wouldn't want people to get annoyed about the Serious RPG forum being flooded with these. What think ye? But either way, no use asking until we know for a fact the game is about to start.

I thought that this would be a good idea as well, for a project of this size, so that the 'Council of the Wise' forum doesn't get flooded, since this RPG will I think require several threads; So I went ahead and made a subforum for it, though if you'd like a different description or name for it, let me know.
 
Re: The War of the Jewels... huge project.... crazy or not? (Discussion of organizati

This is a map i doodled on to show relm boundries. I had a lager one but it wouldn't load. So there it is a rough starter to show relm sizes. Anything not claimed in colour is thingols(in belerliand)
 
Last edited:

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top