Confusticated
Elite
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2002
- Messages
- 4,431
This is a big rambling sloppy post, but it doesn't matter... just putting ideas out.
This is somewhat similar to the idea Turgon had long ago for a Silmarillion RPG, I guess it is just more focused on war. It is probably also at least slightly similar to the old war RPGs that have happened here long ago... but I'm not sure.
What if we were to have a game that was the War of the Jewels, and it opens at the time that the seige on Angband is being established. Payers will take on the roles of the military leaders in Beleriand, and a single person, or a few people who will work closely as a team or under the single person are in control of all the servants of Morgoth activity. From there we play out the war without a concern if it goes the way it did in the books or not.
Anybody want to?
As I see, at a minimum we Might (depending on how this is structured) need at least one person in charge of the following realms:
Hithlum
Dorthonion
Maglor's Gap and all the Feanorian area can be headed by a single player if needed. otherwise it can be further divided.
Nargothrond.
Belegost
Nogrod
The Falas
Doriath
Angband
Could also have Ossiriand, and Gondolin will eventually be needed most likely. later, especialyy has men enter the scene, there could be smaller independant realms within the larger ones.
The rulers should probably keep decent communication OOC.
But you see, we don't need a leader to repesent each of the leaders mentioned in the SIlmarillion, only one for each realm.
For example I could be the leader in Dorthonion, Aegnor and Angrod will not be roles that I worry about fleshing out, they will just be the roles through which the shots are called In Character. Or the commands given in their name. I envison the characters with the most IC time, those who really make the story, will be those we have invented for the game. Some random warrior character for instance.
But there is another way! Instead of having a bunch of players take on the (headache? role?) of playing a the realm's leader, a select few could be designated to do this job, and then most the players could be free to go about RPing and creating their storylines without a care about keeping track of population or relations with other realms, unless they willingly chose to bother with those issues, such as by making their character a messenger or some kind of diplomat or whatever. Whatever the players think is best.
When we start, some things will have to be decided. Population of the realms. Because of the battle this will have to be kept track of. A few basic guidelines will have to be in place regarding this, since the number of warriors effect your effectiveness as an army, and your number of survivors obviously determines if you won or lost, and how badly.
Since population needs to be tracked, so does the passage of time.
I think it would be cool to have someone in charge of these two things. They would be reading the RPG and would keep track of how many are killed in battle, but will not have any say in how many were killed, other players determine this. Anyhow, they will keep track of deaths and using a predetermined formula calculate the population growth, and then subtract... whatever is needed. Realms of men would multiply faster, elves and dwarves slowly, you get the idea. Of course the rulers of each realm could do this themselves, but they would be double-checked by the population person.
But that isn't the only reason the passage of time must be kept track of. With different locations, we need to take care not to get too far ahead or behind the other realms.
For the most part everybody will have the same enemy. Morgoth. So hopefully there would not be any dispute that another elven ruler was being unfair in battle against you.
But there could be exceptions. The Feanorians, being after the silmarils could strike up a kinslaying. Something could happen among men, or with dwarves. Because of this, someone would have to be in charge of deciding what happens in the case of a dispute.
So in addition to rulers of the realms we need:
Someone to handle disputes regarding battles.
Someone to watch the passage of time and population changes.
These people will have to have the authority of final say in disputes that players can't settle, or else choas could happen.
I know it looks like a huge RP, and I doubt there will be enough interested players, but I think it could be very fun so its worth a try posting this.
Maybe this is just a crazy idea. I honestly don't have the experience to judge that.
I'm sure similar things have been attempted. I also know some of you used to play in some kind of Fourth Age WAR RPs here and at MERPG, so perhaps you have some advice. Though I'm not sure what those were like, so most of it might not apply to the way this WotJ RPG will be done.
I was thinking if each realm has its own thread, and the battles are played out in the realm thread where they take place regardless of who is involved. If Turgon goes to Doriath, post a link to the the Gondolin thread where it says "They arrived in Doriath" or whatever. Another option, which I am leading towards, is to have any major battles fought in their own battle thread, again with links coming from the realm threads.
A generic example:
Thread Hithlum:
"And the army moved off over the hills and out onto the plain where battle waited. (Link)"
Move to Battle thread in progress, an army of Hithlum arives in the post linked to at the Hithlum thread mentioned above:
"Fingon's army was seen approaching in the dawn..."
I hope that gets the idea across.
But very importantly, the realm threads would be used for other storylines to take place. Maybe you have some soldiers who are brothers and their story is followed and later is tied in with a battle... or not.
So in a sense, what you would have are independant RPGs going on which happen to tie in together whenever they like, or whenever Morgoth strikes.
Links to other threads would be used not only to link to battle threads, but also if a character from Nargothrond were to travel to Hithlum.
"At last Edrahil entered Hithlum and looked out over the misty plain. (Links to Hithlum thread)."
In this way anyone reading the RPG can very easily follow the story lines.
I'm not even suggesting this is something that could be started in the near future. I doubt there are enough players interested in it.
This idea has been nagging me so I just had to post.
This thread is really just for interested players to discuss how such a project should be organized if it is ever going to happen.
Something of this size would have to be well organized and thought through thoroughly so that it can best be structured from the beginning to avoid potential later problems. The groundwork.
Oh, and just because I bring this up doesn't mean I expect to be some kind of overlord if this is it ever happens. I wouldn't mind playing Morgoth and forces with a few other evil individuals though
.
This is somewhat similar to the idea Turgon had long ago for a Silmarillion RPG, I guess it is just more focused on war. It is probably also at least slightly similar to the old war RPGs that have happened here long ago... but I'm not sure.
What if we were to have a game that was the War of the Jewels, and it opens at the time that the seige on Angband is being established. Payers will take on the roles of the military leaders in Beleriand, and a single person, or a few people who will work closely as a team or under the single person are in control of all the servants of Morgoth activity. From there we play out the war without a concern if it goes the way it did in the books or not.
Anybody want to?
As I see, at a minimum we Might (depending on how this is structured) need at least one person in charge of the following realms:
Hithlum
Dorthonion
Maglor's Gap and all the Feanorian area can be headed by a single player if needed. otherwise it can be further divided.
Nargothrond.
Belegost
Nogrod
The Falas
Doriath
Angband
Could also have Ossiriand, and Gondolin will eventually be needed most likely. later, especialyy has men enter the scene, there could be smaller independant realms within the larger ones.
The rulers should probably keep decent communication OOC.
But you see, we don't need a leader to repesent each of the leaders mentioned in the SIlmarillion, only one for each realm.
For example I could be the leader in Dorthonion, Aegnor and Angrod will not be roles that I worry about fleshing out, they will just be the roles through which the shots are called In Character. Or the commands given in their name. I envison the characters with the most IC time, those who really make the story, will be those we have invented for the game. Some random warrior character for instance.
But there is another way! Instead of having a bunch of players take on the (headache? role?) of playing a the realm's leader, a select few could be designated to do this job, and then most the players could be free to go about RPing and creating their storylines without a care about keeping track of population or relations with other realms, unless they willingly chose to bother with those issues, such as by making their character a messenger or some kind of diplomat or whatever. Whatever the players think is best.
When we start, some things will have to be decided. Population of the realms. Because of the battle this will have to be kept track of. A few basic guidelines will have to be in place regarding this, since the number of warriors effect your effectiveness as an army, and your number of survivors obviously determines if you won or lost, and how badly.
Since population needs to be tracked, so does the passage of time.
I think it would be cool to have someone in charge of these two things. They would be reading the RPG and would keep track of how many are killed in battle, but will not have any say in how many were killed, other players determine this. Anyhow, they will keep track of deaths and using a predetermined formula calculate the population growth, and then subtract... whatever is needed. Realms of men would multiply faster, elves and dwarves slowly, you get the idea. Of course the rulers of each realm could do this themselves, but they would be double-checked by the population person.
But that isn't the only reason the passage of time must be kept track of. With different locations, we need to take care not to get too far ahead or behind the other realms.
For the most part everybody will have the same enemy. Morgoth. So hopefully there would not be any dispute that another elven ruler was being unfair in battle against you.
But there could be exceptions. The Feanorians, being after the silmarils could strike up a kinslaying. Something could happen among men, or with dwarves. Because of this, someone would have to be in charge of deciding what happens in the case of a dispute.
So in addition to rulers of the realms we need:
Someone to handle disputes regarding battles.
Someone to watch the passage of time and population changes.
These people will have to have the authority of final say in disputes that players can't settle, or else choas could happen.
I know it looks like a huge RP, and I doubt there will be enough interested players, but I think it could be very fun so its worth a try posting this.
Maybe this is just a crazy idea. I honestly don't have the experience to judge that.
I'm sure similar things have been attempted. I also know some of you used to play in some kind of Fourth Age WAR RPs here and at MERPG, so perhaps you have some advice. Though I'm not sure what those were like, so most of it might not apply to the way this WotJ RPG will be done.
I was thinking if each realm has its own thread, and the battles are played out in the realm thread where they take place regardless of who is involved. If Turgon goes to Doriath, post a link to the the Gondolin thread where it says "They arrived in Doriath" or whatever. Another option, which I am leading towards, is to have any major battles fought in their own battle thread, again with links coming from the realm threads.
A generic example:
Thread Hithlum:
"And the army moved off over the hills and out onto the plain where battle waited. (Link)"
Move to Battle thread in progress, an army of Hithlum arives in the post linked to at the Hithlum thread mentioned above:
"Fingon's army was seen approaching in the dawn..."
I hope that gets the idea across.
But very importantly, the realm threads would be used for other storylines to take place. Maybe you have some soldiers who are brothers and their story is followed and later is tied in with a battle... or not.
So in a sense, what you would have are independant RPGs going on which happen to tie in together whenever they like, or whenever Morgoth strikes.
Links to other threads would be used not only to link to battle threads, but also if a character from Nargothrond were to travel to Hithlum.
"At last Edrahil entered Hithlum and looked out over the misty plain. (Links to Hithlum thread)."
In this way anyone reading the RPG can very easily follow the story lines.
I'm not even suggesting this is something that could be started in the near future. I doubt there are enough players interested in it.
This idea has been nagging me so I just had to post.
This thread is really just for interested players to discuss how such a project should be organized if it is ever going to happen.
Something of this size would have to be well organized and thought through thoroughly so that it can best be structured from the beginning to avoid potential later problems. The groundwork.
Oh, and just because I bring this up doesn't mean I expect to be some kind of overlord if this is it ever happens. I wouldn't mind playing Morgoth and forces with a few other evil individuals though
Last edited:

