• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Second-guessing and Misunderstanding Tolkien

Glad that not all of Reddit is just people with no clue about Tolkien.
I am glad also, yet there are those who think that Manwe made the wrong choice in freeing Melkor from Mandos - I disagree: nauva i nauva.

(Can't believe there are Reddit threads where they actually say r/ManweDidEverythingWrong, because he didn't. Surely, the Grace of the Valar is not with them... better to stay away from them... :oops: )
 
My favorite dude!
download (7).jpeg


In my own head-canon, it's his residual influence that makes the Nazgul afraid of the waters in Middle-earth.
 
I think there might also be a line somewhere which says something about elves' ears being leaf-shaped.

Indeed, this description includes that the Quendian ears were more pointed than humans ears.

But . . . as with the goblin/orc* matter . . . chronology. I've no doubt that at one point (pun always intended) in his life, Tolkien imagined that the Quendian ears were more pointed and leaf-shaped than human ears.

And that at one point in his life, Tolkien also imagined that grown Elves were roughly the size of human children (as general as that is)! Or that at one point in his life (and for decades and decades), Tolkien imagined that Elves reincarnated by being born again as Elf babies.

And at one point in his life, many years after the letter about Hobbit ears and "elvish" ears, and many years after his description of Quendian ears in the linguistic document called Etymologies which looks at Eldarin bases and Eldarin words (the more pointed and leaf-shaped description you referred to), and decades after his drawing of Beleg and Gwindor (if anyone thinks that that particular picture solves the matter, that is) . . .

. . . Tolkien wrote yet another, post-Lord of the Rings description which included information about bases and Elvish words. A description that included an updated look at the bases and Elvish words that had long ago appeared in Etymologies, and that had resulted in the oft-quoted example you refer to.

Back in the abandoned Etymologies, the bases had been LAS1 and LAS2. In the updated version,
the bases are LAS and SLAS . . . and what did this commentary (from Tolkien's Word, Phrases and Passages, or WPP) have to say, if anything (or if anything definitive), about Elvish ears?

Or was this just a post to ramble more about . . .

*Goblins/Orcs!

____________________


Incidentally, I think Helge Fauskanger (Ardalambion) "needs" to add the word orc to his Westron wordlist!

Anyway, the confusions between orc and goblin isn't helped by Jackson's films, nor even by noted Tolkien scholar Tom Shippey (with whom I disagree with regarding his particular conclusion, and who also relies on an incorrect secondary source to draw his conclusions in the first place) . . .

. . . and arguably, it's not helped very much by JRRT himself until we get to the later 1960s!

For example, for the second edition of The Hobbit, Tolkien actually added a description that at least seems to distinguish an orc from a goblin in some way or measure!

Then there's the note that orc appears to be an actual word used by the Rohirrim (Appendix F part I) -- when we also know that JRRT used Ancient English to "translate" (resemble) a lot of the actual language of the Rohirrim (Appendix F Part II) -- noting that (externally speaking now) Tolkien lifted the word orc from Old English forms!

In shorter, according to Appendix F part II at least, and if you know your Old English, the word orc looks like a translation (using Old English instead of English "goblin")!

And yet again it looks like a translation in Quendi And Eldar, at text dated to 1959-1960 -- written well after The Lord of the Rings was published -- which reads: "Note: The word used in translation of Q urko, S orch is Orc. But that is because of the similarity of the ancient English word orc, "evil spirit or bogey", to the Elvish words."

That said, one can still use the Westron/Rohirric word orc to translate the Elvish words! And if so, it would be very, very similar to the ancient English word orc!

;)

In short, I say focus not on these things for JRRT's ultimate answer: rather focus on publication by the author-- plus chronology (late ideas) -- then you simply translate any examples from The Hobbit that appear to be saying something else!

Or, better yet, simply don't read this post!
 
Last edited:
@Elthir - I must confess.
Few can leap and bound, scale the cliffs and descend the crevasses, tie change to change across time, and draw a thread between all as do you.

Your input is as the tides, swelling, crashing, smoothing, soothing, moving the beaches sands with every ebb and flow.

And yet - as the water's work is done, still the sands remain. Moved a little, perhaps. What was here is now there, yet what was elsewhere is now here.

Always instructive, ever entertaining... and a joy to receive.

I for one always glean something from your offerings.
And from this last I have learned the most.

"Start at the end."

(don't take this wrong - i truly enjoy and glean from your sharing. I just couldn't restrain myself here...😁)
 
LOL S-eS!

And speaking of dealing with it. Tolkien was forced to deal with any names or Elvish words that he had already published.

Including lassi "leaves" (LAS) and Amon Lhaw "Hill of Hearing, Hill of . . . ears!" (SLAS)

But does this necessarily mean . . .
 
Oh. Thank you Well-aged Enting. I didn't see that at first!

🐾
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top