• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Second-guessing and Misunderstanding Tolkien

The third part especially can be used as a sleep aid.
Noted.

giphy.gif
 
Ando here (I know Gando misses me):

Just to let you know, Elthir is napping.
 
More silly nonsense courtesy of Quora:
Why does Eru did not add to Gandalf White's powers when he resurrected him but merely removing the restrictions of the Valar? Why did he not give him additional powers that can withstand the power of Sauron himself in protecting people?
🙄
From the same batch of questions (in my notifications):
Why didn't the elves (especially Legolas or Glorfindal) take the ring to Mount Doom to destroy it?
😑
 
This is not another "Why didn't they use the Eagles" thread though that topic is briefly discussed here. This is more a thread examining the seemingly constant stream of "Why didn't..." questions on sites like Reddit and Quora. The Eagle-related ones. Ones that ask why the Valar don't intercede. Etc.

Questions about the Eagles and the Valar might be excusable (if not valid) if the askers don't look into the logistics of the story or the background of the writing of the book or, of course, the need to create an engaging story (and, truthfully, how many works of fiction are flawless and without contrivance?). Almost needless to say, Tolkien did not set out to write a sequel to The Hobbit of his own volition, but acquiescing to publisher and public request, he came up with The Lord of the Rings. In doing so, in choosing Bilbo's ring as the genesis of the idea that he would develop, he was perhaps operating under certain constraints. So, whatever flaws one might perceive in the work, I think one must consider the circumstances under which it was composed. If Tolkien had conceived of the idea of the Rings of Power from the start on his own (meaning without the demand for a follow-up to TH) we probably would have had something very different, and one possibly even better than what we were given. And what we got is fairly magnificent, especially considering the circumstances.

But there are some questions that go beyond the pale and look at other reasons why they think the course Tolkien took was the wrong one. One such question asks (to paraphrase), "Would it not have been more reasonable to give the Ring to someone who could control it, but not too strong so that the Ring could be taken from them?" :confused: To my answer in which I basically said, no, it would not be more reasonable, the person replied that the plan in the book is "stupid"; that Sauron should logically have figured out that, since the Ring was not being used against him, that he would have figured out that the plan was to destroy it. :oops:

Honestly, I couldn't be bothered to explain that the answer to this is in the book and that it takes more than a cursory reading to find it. If you don't accept the explanation, I guess take it or leave it and find something else to read, but I didn't even feel like saying that.

How would/do others here respond to such questions, if at all?
First, sorry for my english, it is not my maternal language. This is how i see it :
Sauron made the one ring pouring his malice, his strong will and evil soul into the ring. So , the ring is basically a entity, with a will of its own. Ring is not a source of power, or a weapon. It changes everyone, leaving them with no humanity or any moral values. As Aragorn said at the Council of Elrond : "The ring answers to Sauron alone. It has no other master." Because of its evil nature ,it only corrupts people, giving them a false sense of having power. The Ring is almost powerless in hands of someone WHO DOESN'T WANT POWER . Like the Hobbits. So, the question " Why someone didnt try to use the ring against Sauron - is not valid . If any Maiar or Valar would took the ring they would not destroy it . And Sauron will find the ring in hands of someone powerfull much quicker.
 
First, sorry for my english, it is not my maternal language.

Welcome aboard Gospodar prstenova.
Your English is fine. No apologies needed. Even those of us for whom English IS our first language need a good deal of help..!! 😁
Hope you find a good home here among us, and thank you for sharing your thoughts.
We look forward to more.
 
Stupid Tolkien question of the week:
Why did Gandalf like the hobbits when most of the rest of Middle Earth thought they were lame?
This is apparently because Boromir calls hobbits "little ones" in the FotR movie and that they didn't get any Rings of Power :rolleyes:
*groan*
Most of the rest of M-e didn't even know of their existence, even in Gondor only "northern legends", Faramir in chapter IV "The Siege of Gondor" in Book 5 in RoTK. Aragorn and his northern rangers knew them, and the odd Elf and Dwarf in Eriador perhaps passed through the Shire, and that would be it.
 
He did, actually.
Prior to the third age?

Edit: you're right, as usual

Prologue: Concerning Hobbits:

It is plain indeed that in spite of later estrangement Hobbits are relatives of ours: far nearer to us than Elves, or even than Dwarves. Of old they spoke the languages of Men, after their own fashion, and liked and disliked much the same things as Men did. But what exactly our relationship is can no longer be discovered. The beginning of Hobbits lies far back in the Elder Days that are now lost and forgotten.
 
That reminds me -- seen in comments in various different media concerned with RoP:

"Why do they have hobbits? Hobbits didn't even exist until the Third Age!"
I suppose in any form of history we don't see them until the Third Age. If they're going to show up in this story it DOES kind of undermine that since they would need to explain how this Nori doesn't get mentioned ANYWHERE to the point no other, known, culture mentions them for another 1000+ years.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top