Foe-Hammer
Member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2001
- Messages
- 984
jallan said:For-hammer posted:It is common enough that when people can’t attack what is said then they attack the person who says it. That is what you are doing here Foe-hammer.
No, I am defeating their irrational logic.
jallan said:Let’s reverse your arguments. Would you claim also that no-one can praise Jackson or any film director unless:
A: they know how to write a screenplay,
B: they are qualified to be film makers,
C: they are better directors than the film director they are praising?Why should those who praise be exempt from your criteria when those who find fault are not?
Backwards logic. If a director makes a film that millions upon millions of people like, then he has done his job. The viewer need only to be entertained. But for a novice to stand in judgement of that work and claim it would have been better if certain changes had been made requires at least a basic understanding of film making and how it comes off on screen. The npw has no such skill and therefore their illogical reasonings need to be challenged.
jallan said:A defender is hard put to it if the defender must resort to argument ad populum rather than looking at the individual points. The defender is hard put to it in adopting the strange position that only people involved in the film industry can criticize negatively while anyone is allowed to praise.
The problem is the npw ONLY focuses on individual points and does not look at the scene in relation to the rest of the movie AND the limitations of the film medium. That statement right there is totally lost on the npw. It has been pointed out so many times and ignored by them that I have come to the conclusion that, it is very likely a problem that really begins and ends in their minds as has no basis in reality.
jallan said:The flaws are obvious in the films. I and many others have pointed them out again and again and have not particularly aimed insults at those who enjoy the films other than by quesitioning how they can really enjoy those parts of the film which are so incoherent or so diminished in respect to the original.
I have seen several insults leveled at people who enjoy the films. Mostly along the lines that they are shallow. You may never had said that, but no one was really talking to you. You just decided to interject yourself into this.
jallan said:Let’s take just one of your own statements:If PJ made the film more in accordance with my likes the film would certain not have felt like Labyrinth (though I quite enjoyed that Alice-in-Wonderland type film) or Legend or Willow. Explain why it should have? None of those films felt like Tolkien though in Willow there was some obvious attempt to imitate Tolkien that mostly failed. To me all three of these films feel very different from one another.
They all fell flat from where they were trying to go.
jallan said:I am at a loss at how a more faithful adaptation of The Lord of the Rings could feel like Labyrinth at all. If you are serious about this assertion, then you should take at least one of these films and show why that are especially flawed in ways that are more like Tolkien’s writing then Jackson’s filming. How would not dumbing Gimli down or treating Faramir more like he is in the books have made Jackson’s films more like Labyrinth or Legend or Willow?
People did not identify with the characters in those movies. PJ was completely successful in this area. Every character was believable and their feelings were such that we can identify. This is what makes for good cinema.
jallan said:Make a case or withdraw your assertion.
Here is the truth.....good books require the reader to imagine many things and get involved. Great movies are like being on a ride...there is no time for a lot of imagination and no time to go back and rewind. There is limited time and the characters have to be developed quickly and need to be setup by other scenes and characters. The arrogant npw thinks all these changes are so easy. Well, if that is so, why did it take so long to make a good movie? If it is so easy, why aren't ALL movies as big of a hit as these are? The npw refuses to ask themselves those questions and stubbornly hangs on to the "needless changes" or "it could have been better" montra.
jallan said:But Bakshi is not normally accused of being overly faithful to the source material. Complaints about his films are on other matters entirely. Your argument fails there also.
It has been a while, but gimli and others were much closer, yet this gimli is remembered and the tolkien one is not.
jallan said:On making a better story, arguably Jackson did improve the tale in some ways. Arguably in other ways he made an mess of it in comparision with his source material, too much of a mess for many to stomach. To change that opinion you will need reasoned argument that those who complain are in some way wrongly viewing or interpreting the films or particular parts of the films, showing for example that the Théoden exorcism scene as realized by Jackson is as good or better than the scene Tolkien wrote or that the scene Tolkien wrote could not be effectively filmed.
Wrong. they need to prove it could be shot the way they claim or they should just cease the argument. They THINK they know more about film making than PJ. If they would just admit they are clueless and that PJ knows better than they do, they might just be able to get some perspective. But we all know that is never going to happen.
jallan said:But reasoned arguments of that kind are rare. More often I find special pleading that the viewer should try to forget about the books or the supposed truism that an adapation cannot exactly follow its source which attempts to evade the issue of whether a particular adapatation of a particular part of a source is better or worse than its source or just different.
Jrr himself knew a majority of his story, as is, was unfit for film and it would be changed. BECAUSE, (for the gagillioneth time) these characters do not exists in a vacuumn, and every change is going to effect other characters or situations and to make a change and then inexplicable jump back to the source material whern it does not fit with the changes made, would fail on film. IE.....That is why it makes sense for arwen to have a sword. For crying out loud, there are nazgul about. Why would elrond send his defensless daughter out into the wilderness without a way to defend herself? The scene established she had a sword (heck, so did the hobbits) and subtlry re-inforces that it is very dangerous out here. The lack of a means of defense would diminish the feeling of danger, call into question elronds grasp of the situation ( and therefore his worthiness to head the council) and question his love for his daughter. Without a sword, ellrond, and every scene concerning him, would have had to been different or the glaring mistakes would have caused the viewer to wonder what they had missed.
That example may not be exactly what would have happened, but it is very plausible, and that is enough to illustrate just how complicated movies are to make well. There was not one time in this movie that I, or anyone else I have met, were confused about what was going on. It was quite the enjoyable ride. Anyone who didn't, was focused way too much on the source material, and as I have pointed out, it was unsuitable as written for the screen.
The npw has also latched onto another point that I have not defeated yet because I felt sorry for them.....the completely silly assumption that some of the book that was adaptable and pj used, MUST mean that the entire work should have been able to be done as it were in the book. Silly!
