• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Hobbit as movie?

Fundin Snowarm

New Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
15
Working within the Middle-Earth established within the LOTR films, what changes would you think were necessary to have a solid continuity? Why? & any additions?
 
Before I put my two cents worth in about that, I thought I'd draw people's attention to the following article in the Melbourne Age.

Long wait likely for The Hobbit

Peter Jackson won't be returning to the Shire any time soon.

The Oscar-winning director is planning to film The Hobbit, the prequel to The Lord of the Rings trilogy by JRR Tolkien, but two studios must first fight over legal rights to the film.

Jackson said New Line Cinema has the rights to make the movie, but MGM has the rights to distribute it.

"I guess MGM's lawyers and New Line's lawyers are going to have a huge amount of fun over the next few years trying to work it all out," he told reporters recently in Los Angeles. "I'm obviously busy for a couple of years on King Kong so those lawyers can just go at it for a long time."

The Hobbit tells the story of Bilbo Baggins, who found the ring and eventually passes it on to his nephew, Frodo Baggins. Frodo's journey to Mount Doom to destroy the ring is the basis for the Rings books and films.

Jackson said if he were going to direct the movie, he'd want it to feel like the rest of the trilogy. Jackson last week won an Academy Award for best director and shared the adapted-screenplay award with his two co-writers for the final Rings film, The Return of the King.

"I'd want Ian McKellen to be back as Gandalf, I'd want it to feel like it was part of the same mythology that we've done with Lord of the Rings," Jackson said.

The Return of the King swept this year's Academy Awards, winning all 11 categories in which it was nominated.

Jackson is in the middle of remaking King Kong, due out next year, starring Aussie actress Naomi Watts.

- AP
 
Fundin Snowarm said:
Working within the Middle-Earth established within the LOTR films, what changes would you think were necessary to have a solid continuity? Why? & any additions?

Assuming that PJ made the film, there are some passages from "Unfinished Tales" that would make a perfect intro for a film version of "The Hobbit." They take place a week or so before Gandalf makes his visit to Bilbo. In them, he is extremely worried about Sauron's rise in power and strength, and especially his possible use of Smaug the dragon as a WMD.

"As fortune would have it," he runs into Thorin Oakenshield at the Prancing Pony. It seems that Thorin has been stewing and stewing, building up a dangerous head of steam about the fact that Smaug sits atop the dwarf treasure Under the Mountain. He wants vengeance on Smaug for all the death and destruction he caused, and to regain his treasure.

Gandalf sees a possibility: perhaps he can use Thorin's anger to help in a plan to destroy the dragon and keep Sauron's power down. So they hatch a plan involving Bilbo. At first Thorin is contemptuous of the whole idea (he doesn't think much of hobbitry), but Gandalf convinces him that here at last is a viable plan to take vengeance on Smaug and recover the treasure.

I think that would be an excellent intro to The Hobbit, just as going back to The Silmarillion was an excellent opening for FOTR. Otherwise, you can be sure we shall have more PJ filmic whimsies and plot embroideries to deal with again, and that will launch more anti-PJ frenzy, you can be sure!

(By God, I can't wait to see that red dragon zooming in over the Long Lake and attacking the town of Dale and the surrounding woods like a gigantic flame thrower — to say nothing of the Battle of Five Armies, and of course the trolls William, Bert and Tom — to say nothing of the spiders in the woods!)

Lotho
 
My first thought is that he would have to make some "adjustment" to the Elves. They seemed very different in the Hobbit and LOTR.
 
oh dear. as much as i'd like to see this story adapted, by far simpler than the lord of the rings, please please i hope it's not peter jackson does it... :(


there will be no excuse (in my book, that is) for any change in the story .. not that i find pj any for the changes he made in his films, but it's another forum...


i'm not even sure now, if there would be any need for an introduction (lotho, your ideas are great though !!! :))... so many people worldwide know gandalf and bilbo by now... not like when we opened the book for the first time, nobody had pre-chewed the work for us !!!!
 
I like your ideas Lotho.
I'd like to see the two Ians as Bilbo and Gandalf, simply because I can't think of anyone who could do the parts better.
Hmmm.....who would do the voice of Smaug??
It's got to be evil, wrecked and smoky-sounding but still somehow appealing.
 
I could imagine Peter Jackson giving Nancy Cartright the role as the voice of Smaug...
"Eat my shorts!" ;) :p

As I've said before, PJ has the opportunity to re-use quite a few of the actors from LotR. Gandalf (McKellen), Bilbo (Holm), Legolas (Bloom), Galadriel (Blanchett), Arwen (Tyler), Elrond (Weaving), Gollum (Serkis) and Saruman (Lee) could all be used again. Knowing PJ, he'd love to go into more 'depth' with the White Council's actions at Dol Guldur, and Galadriel and Saruman could make their cameos.

One thing that I've been thinking about is what New Line would do if Jackson's latest project (King Kong) is a flop. Perhaps they'll lose confidence in him and go for a fresh face to direct The Hobbit?


Btw, totally off topic:
IMDb
Hollywood superstar Nicole Kidman has been signed to star in a new movie version of CS Lewis' classic children's novel The Lion The Witch And The Wardrobe. Studio bosses at Disney - who are backing the project - were desperate for Kidman to play the White Witch, and her two kids with ex-husband Tom Cruise, Isabella, 11, and Connor, nine, convinced her to say yes. A Tinseltown source says, "Nicole's kids don't pay great attention to her career - she's just mom to them. But when she mentioned she had been asked to star in the movie they went wild. They even asked for jobs as extras." Kidman even made a secret visit to New Zealand last week to see locations and meet the crew. Walt Disney chairman Richard Cook recently said of the movie - which is due to start filming later this year - "It's a very, very ambitious project and one that we believe could be very important to the studio."
 
duilwen said:
...so many people worldwide know gandalf and bilbo by now... not like when we opened the book for the first time, nobody had pre-chewed the work for us !!!!

"Pre-chewed the work!" Hah! Do you realize, Duilwen, that you have inadvertently created the kernel of an idea for an entire new industry: Pre-digested Tolkien booklets! Instead of "see D*ck run" we could put out similar books for toddlers: "See Bilbo run;" "See Smaug eat ponies," "See Frodo vanish," etc. (Do you suppose that PJ, Phillipa and Fran could be Guest Editors for some of these?;):p

Lotho

PS — this censorbot — really!!!
 
Hikaru said:
I like your ideas Lotho.
I'd like to see the two Ians as Bilbo and Gandalf, simply because I can't think of anyone who could do the parts better.
Hmmm.....who would do the voice of Smaug??
It's got to be evil, wrecked and smoky-sounding but still somehow appealing.

It would be great to have the two Ians, but unfortunately, Ian Holm is simply too old now to play Bilbo at the age he was in The Hobbit.:(

Lotho
 
Aulë said:
I could imagine Peter Jackson giving Nancy Cartright the role as the voice of Smaug...
"Eat my shorts!" ;) :p

Hehehehehe!

As I've said before, PJ has the opportunity to re-use quite a few of the actors from LotR. Gandalf (McKellen), Bilbo (Holm), Legolas (Bloom), Galadriel (Blanchett), Arwen (Tyler), Elrond (Weaving), Gollum (Serkis) and Saruman (Lee) could all be used again.

I think there would be a serious age problem, no? By the time PJ (I assume, and New Line) would be finally ready to actually film the Hobbit, all those actors would be considerably older than they were during LotR, and The Hobbit begins at least 60 years BEFORE LotR. There would need to be a quantum leap in makeup and prosthetic technology!;)

King Kong a floperoo, eh? Interesting conjecture...PJ a one-hit wonder...hmmmm....

Lotho
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
Ian Holm is simply too old now to play Bilbo at the age he was in The Hobbit.:(

Lotho


do you really think such a tiny detail would stop the make-up/special effects armadas ? or maybe it will intice jackson to create a bilbo like he created a denethor.

moi ? bitching about the movies ? and i'm off topic to top it all....
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
I think there would be a serious age problem, no? By the time PJ (I assume, and New Line) would be finally ready to actually film the Hobbit, all those actors would be considerably older than they were during LotR, and The Hobbit begins at least 60 years BEFORE LotR. There would need to be a quantum leap in makeup and prosthetic technology!;)

King Kong a floperoo, eh? Interesting conjecture...PJ a one-hit wonder...hmmmm....

Lotho


hahaha; I hadnt' read that post before posting mine... what's with you and age btw lotho ? ;) ;) ;)

seriously. it hasn't bothered these film-makers to make frodo look like a 15 yr-old. :mad: :mad: :mad: so they can't be that picky about one more betrayal. why not set the hobbit after the lord of the rings, and modify tolkien's works once more ?


i am out of here. this thread i mean. i get too mean. and i have to abide my newbie's shyness !!!!! ;)
 
Yes, I heard that. It's just not going to be the same without Ian H. But if they did make a movie of the Hobbit...to have 2 different Bilbo's?
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
I think there would be a serious age problem, no? By the time PJ (I assume, and New Line) would be finally ready to actually film the Hobbit, all those actors would be considerably older than they were during LotR, and The Hobbit begins at least 60 years BEFORE LotR. There would need to be a quantum leap in makeup and prosthetic technology!;)
Not really, as Gandalf, Arwen, Galadriel, Saruman, Legolas, and Elrond would look identical and Gollum would look about the same.
 
Flame of Udûn said:
Not really, as Gandalf, Arwen, Galadriel, Saruman, Legolas, and Elrond would look identical and Gollum would look about the same.

Yes, but the actors who played them would have aged about 10 years or so. Gollum wouldn't be a problem for obvious reasons, and I suppose Gandalf and Saruman are buried under all that facial hair anyway. Then again, cosmetic and prosthetic technology would have advanced 10 years as well.

I think the real trick will be getting Christopher Lee and Peter Jackson to kiss and make up.
 
Flame of Udûn said:
Not really, as Gandalf, Arwen, Galadriel, Saruman, Legolas, and Elrond would look identical and Gollum would look about the same.

First we have to get King Kong out of the way, which is going to take at least a couple of years. Let's suppose further that it takes at least 5 years from then to get through the legalities, and PJ is ready to film, and all those film stars who took the original parts were all available (a dodgy proposition). The film would take at least several months to film, and several more for postproduction. So let's say the film would be ready for release 9 or 10 years from today. All the actors would look that much older, and different from the way they looked in the original film. That ain't supposed to happen with Elves, and only a little bit with wizards! The audience would really have to be willing to suspend disbelief...

Lotho
 
The possibility of a Hobbit prequel has been issued by someone as a press release, as my children saw it as a news item on a BBC junior news programme (in England). I didn't see it myself, so I don't know where the information came from.
 
Eledhwen- glad to see you're here, as I remember you posting some rather enticing sequences from the Hobbit. Those were of course more in-line with the tone of the Lord of the Rings than with TH, but that is fine by me. Personally, I'd think the Gandalf/Dol Guldur stuff would work well enough in flashback. That would allow for an ultimate James Bond-style opening: Smaug attacking the Mountain. What fun to go through a transition from Smaug smoking out the Dwarves to Bilbo smoking quietly in the Shire.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top