Ah, the big 'if'
The problem here is that
Grishnakh had every opportunity to get the
Hobbits to
Mordor. If he had been able to face up to
Ugluk in the first place, then the whole troop would have been off Eastwards to Mordor. But when push came to shove, Grishnakh ran away from confrontation and had to ask the
Nazgul for help. Ugluk was his own
Orcs.
1) Grishnakh cheated in the Death March, Ugluk took the longer route and still was traveling faster when Grishnakh ran across them.
2) Ugluk made Threats and followed them up with lopping off heads. Grishnakh made Threats and then ran for it.
3) Ugluk was not a brilliant Insulter, but he was proficient with statements about the 'mountain maggots', 'filthy horse-boys', and the 'apes of
Lugburz'. Grishnakh was so often bested physically that he had much more practice at spinning off insults. Yet it seems to me that for all his practice, Grishnakh did not come up with anything brilliant either.
4) Ugluk is a run-away victor in the Brute Strength category, lopping off heads of
mounted horse-boys and Orcs alike. Grishnakh apparently tried to use his 'terrifying strength' to wrench a spear out of a horse-boy's hand after having been skewered with it.
5) Low Cunning was never Ugluk's greatest asset, yet he does very well in leadership and tactical decision-making. He is able to hold a heterogenous mixture of Orcs together with a minimum of bloodshed, a feat which is beyond all the scheming of Grishnakh. He is also able to make the best of a bad situation- holding a small band together during the morning route and nearly fighting his way out of the
Rohirrim. After all, he was only being stopped by the personal heroism of the
King of Rohan. In comparison Grishnakh's plan is undone by his own action- foolishly drawing his
sword in the presence of a horseman. Finally, I notice that the Hobbits were not quite able to play with Ugluk's head, like they were with Grishnakh. When dealing with the
halflings Ugluk seemed cool and collected, Grishnakh seemed to be trembling.
Clearly Ugluk is the leader in categories 1, 2, and 4. In categories 3 and 5 Ugluk is competitive. The Pentathlon considers all 5 categories equally, so I must say that Ugluk appears to be the best pentorclete.