• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Best 🧌Orc Pentathlete

Choose the best Orc Pentathlete

  • Gorbag

    Votes: 6 7.2%
  • Grishnakh

    Votes: 27 32.5%
  • Shagrat

    Votes: 15 18.1%
  • Ugluk

    Votes: 35 42.2%

  • Total voters
    83
Ah yes the brave and wise Ugluk. Pah!

Lets just check our facts...

Number of times Ugluk confronts Grishnakh on his own... 0
Number of times Ugluk confronts Grishnakh when backed up with 100 or so scum from Isengard... 1

Number of times Grishnakh wisely retreats when faced by overwhelming odds....1
Number of times Ugluk runs straight into trouble knowing that the Riders of Rohan are around ... 1
Number of times Grishnakh suggests a route that would have got them out of trouble.... I've lost count
Number of orcs that dies cos of Ugluks stupidity... >200

The fact is that Ugluk is completely incompetent and gets them all killed. Grishnakh tries his level best to retrieve the situation, even to the point of far out-running the wimpy Uruk-Hai, goes to get back up cos he can see they are gonna get slaughtered, tries to save the prisoners.

On another point... the Mordor orcs were battle-hardened proper orcs, well used to butt-kicking the tarks along the length of Anduin. The uruk-hai were hiding away in Isengard, and until that month had fought noone. While the Battle of the Fords of Isen raged, Saruman sent Ugluk far away, presumably in the hope that he wouldn't bring his dreaded 'leadership qualities' to the battlefield.

Number of battles won by Saruman with Ugluk present: 0
Number of battles won by Saruman without Ugluk present: 1
 
I forgot my book AGAIN! I had a great quote for supporting Grishnakh!

Here's the thing, whoever it was that listed quotes comparing Shagrat to Grishnakh earlier manipulated the quotes picking Shagrat's meanest epithet and Grishnakh's tamest mention!
Ok, here's why Grishnakh's better IMO. Ugluk was this tool of Saruman, and to me that likens him to Saruman's position. Saruman was definitely evil, but he was a wimpy evil. He really didn't serve his Dark Lord properly! He was power-hungry and selfish.
Granted Sauron was probably both as well, but he was sooo bad-@$$ that it's alright for him to be! He kind of has a right! But Saruman was weak and foolish, and Ugluk embodies those same qualities.
Granted I usually root for the side of good, but I don't really have a problem with you fighting for evil as long as you do it properly! Saruman and Ugluk alike were NOT loyal to the cause of evil they were serving.
It was like they forgot who it was they were supposed to be following!
(Sauron of course.)
But Grishnakh was certainly loyal to his Dark Lord. I don't think he took Merry and Pippin from the other orcs in order to gain the ring for himself, but rather since he took them after Merry (or was it Pippin) claimed that if they were to take them to Saruman that Saruman would only take the ring for himself and then Sauron would never get it I believe he was trying to protect his master's interest in the matter.
I honestly don't think he wanted the ring for himself, I don't think he had it in him to think big enough to see himself as the leader of the world...
But still, he was pretty nasty! And yeah...he's bad-@$$. Certainly the most rational of the orcs and I think that's why I like him the most. Just because he was always the voice of reason, and he didn't lose sight of his duty to his master.
That's admirable, even if his master is some kind of disembodied eye that wants to enslave the free world. ;)
 
Bless your little Orcish heart, Ithrynluin.

WtS- I'm not sure that Harad would want you on the Grishnakh campaign team.
I don't think he had it in him to think big enough to see himself as the leader of the world...
sort of detracts from Grishnakh's strength in low cunning. Loyalty is certainly not Grishnakh's strong suit either- he ran away rather than trying to lead the Moria Runts against the (obviously superior) Uruk-hai.
Ugluk was loyal to Saruman, Saruman was not loyal to Sauron. Why do you seek to penalize Ugluk for his master's choice. And why would we prefer a lackey Saruman to one strong enough to show his own preferences? Saruman and Ugluk were never 'supposed to be following' Sauron- they were their own branch of evil.

snaga1- what evidence is there that the outcome would have been different if Ugluk had 100 Orcs at his back or none? As we've pointed out before on this thread, Grishnakh did not outrun Ugluk on the plains. He used the Nazgul to fly him closer to the endpoint, and then ran a shorter race (without the handicap of the Moria Maggots to slow him up). And what exactly does Grishnakh accomplish when he catches Ugluk? Well, first off, in spite of the fact that there are now 40 Mordor Uruks and 100+ Moria Maggots, Grishnakh does not even dream of challenging Ugluk and his 80 Uruk-hai. Why, my guess is because 80 Uruk-hai vs. any 140 other Orcs is a mismatch- in favor of the Uruk-hai. Following this Grishnakh only manages one thing- he becomes directly responsible for the Hobbits escape. As Greenwood earlier pointed out, this little show of competence is directly responsible for Sauron's defeat at Minas Tirith, which in turn was responsible for Sauron letting his guard down in Mordor which allowed Frodo and Sam to destroy the Ring. Before we start digging for Elves in Ugluk's closet, we should remember what's hiding in Grishnakh's!
 
Originally posted by aragil
Bless your little Orcish heart, Ithrynluin.

WtS- I'm not sure that Harad would want you on the Grishnakh campaign team. sort of detracts from Grishnakh's strength in low cunning. Loyalty is certainly not Grishnakh's strong suit either- he ran away rather than trying to lead the Moria Runts against the (obviously superior) Uruk-hai.
Ugluk was loyal to Saruman, Saruman was not loyal to Sauron. Why do you seek to penalize Ugluk for his master's choice. And why would we prefer a lackey Saruman to one strong enough to show his own preferences? Saruman and Ugluk were never 'supposed to be following' Sauron- they were their own branch of evil.

First of all that does not detract from his strength in cunning. Grishnakh was a leader of orcs, but not of an entire world. It's not a dis on him, it's just a statement.
I don't think Saruman would've made a good Dark Lord either but he certainly tried.
And he didn't run away rather than lead the other orcs against the Uruk-Hai (who suck) He ran away with Merry and Pippin in order to gain control of The Ring for his master.
That is not a sign of his disloyalty but rather an even greater testament to his loyalty.
Ugluk was loyal to Saruman but not very. If you remember he was always arguing with Grishnakh because he wanted to search the hobbits for the ring himself.
He could barely control himself in his loyalty to his master..let alone to Sauron.
And I completely disagree that Saruman was not supposed to be loyal to Sauron.
He was Sauron's tool, and he used the Palantir to do his bidding.
He did it for ulterior motives, namely with the intent to conquer, but he was, ostensibly at least, supposed to be fighting on the side of his Dark Lord.

Grishnakh is better. The End.

Check out his intelligence and reasoning skills against Ugluk!!
 
WtS- I have never denied Grishnakh his low cunning. However, as Harad freely pointed out often on this thread, the glorious Pentorclon is a five-stage event, with Ugluk being superior in the other four stages. Thus speaketh the democratic community.

originally posted in a malicious effort to undermine the Ugluk campaign
Ugluk was loyal to Saruman but not very. If you remember he was always arguing with Grishnakh because he wanted to search the hobbits for the ring himself.
This quote is sadly devoid of any basis from the books. Here's the facts as I reads 'em:
Number of times Ugluk expressed any desire to search the Hobbits: 0
Number of times Ugluk actually searched the Hobbits: 0
Number of times Grishnakh actually searched the Hobbits: 1
Number of times Ugluk said that the Hobbits were to be kept in pristine condition because of orders: 3 (from memory, there might have been more)

originally posted as a slander of my beloved Uruk-hai
the Uruk-Hai (who suck)
Well, we're all entitled to our opinions in these matters. Just so the readers of this thread know the facts, here they are:

Uruk-hai can fight in the sun, Mordor Orcs can not. source- Gamling, Treebeard, and (best of all) the Uruk-hai

Uruk-hai are larger and more cunning than Mordor Orcs. source- Tolkien, in Morgoth's Ring

Grishnakh, along with 100+ Moria runts and 40 Mordor Uruks does not even contemplate challenging Ugluk with his 80 Uruk-hai (not in combat, anyway). source- chapter 'The Uruk Hai'

I'm sure that Mordor Orcs have their own little endearing points. I just don't know of any.
 
Well you'd be a better fighter too if you'd been "modified" by dark magic!
I have no respect for the Uruk-Hai because their strength and cunning is not of their own devices but was merely gifted to them by an evil-master!
The other orcs had lived for thousands of years doing just fine being evil with what they had!
Gotta stick up for the little guys.
It's like this: Say you have two girls and they're both applying for a modelling job...and they're both equally pretty, but one has been "augmented surgically" and the other has not...
If the one with the fake ta-tas gets the job over the equally pretty yet au natural one then I have NO respect for the first because she's not doing anything by her own merits!
Tis the same with real orcs vs. the Uruk-Hai

And yes, Grishnakh actually went and searched the hobbits, but that was AFTER the big row broke out amongst the other orcs and he new that Ugluk wasn't going to wait to take the ring for himself.

He and Ugluk were constantly arguing about it! Grishnakh was up for taking the hobbits to his real master...rather than to Saruman who would just take the ring for himself!

'You have spoken more than enough, Ugluk,' sneered the evil voice. 'I wonder how they would like it in Lugburz. They might think that Ugluk's shoulders needed relieving of a swollen head. They might ask where his strange ideas came from. Did they come from Saruman, perhaps? Who does he think he is, setting up on his own with his filthy white badges? They might agree wtih me, with Grishnakh their trusted messenger; and I Grishnakh say this: Saruman is a fool, and a dirty treacherous fool. But the Great Eye is on him.'
 
Originally posted by aragil
snaga1- what evidence is there that the outcome would have been different if Ugluk had 100 Orcs at his back or none? As we've pointed out before on this thread, Grishnakh did not outrun Ugluk on the plains. He used the Nazgul to fly him closer to the endpoint, and then ran a shorter race (without the handicap of the Moria Maggots to slow him up). And what exactly does Grishnakh accomplish when he catches Ugluk? Well, first off, in spite of the fact that there are now 40 Mordor Uruks and 100+ Moria Maggots, Grishnakh does not even dream of challenging Ugluk and his 80 Uruk-hai. Why, my guess is because 80 Uruk-hai vs. any 140 other Orcs is a mismatch- in favor of the Uruk-hai. Following this Grishnakh only manages one thing- he becomes directly responsible for the Hobbits escape. As Greenwood earlier pointed out, this little show of competence is directly responsible for Sauron's defeat at Minas Tirith, which in turn was responsible for Sauron letting his guard down in Mordor which allowed Frodo and Sam to destroy the Ring. Before we start digging for Elves in Ugluk's closet, we should remember what's hiding in Grishnakh's!

Grishnakh is well known as more evil than Ugluk. Without his back up, Ugluk would have been maggot-food in moments. What evidence is there that Nazgul ever flew Grishnakh anywhere? That is nonsense, a typical ape-brained comment from the miserable feeble-minded Ugluk camp. How could the Nazgul fly him from the point he leaves Ugluk? They werent there, and if they had been the outcome of the debate would have been very different. All the orcs would have fallen into line straightaway. So Grishnakh clearly makes it back to Anduin on foot. So then how could the Nazgul fly all 40 Mordor orcs back to Ugluk's gang later? Was there some kind of Hercules transport winged Nazgul that I have carelessly overlooked? Or has the preposterous Isenglob snivelling mob just lost the use of their braincell?

So your next feebleminded attempt to cover Ugluks incompetence is scarcely less pitiful. Grishnakh has muster 40 orcs. He does not confront the 80 uruk-hai. The 100+ moria orcs are taking orders from Ugluk at this point, so can hardly be counted on Grishnakhs side. However they are cooking in the sun, so I wont count them for much in any stand-off. But Grishnakh is wise, and Grishnakh is disciplined. Grishnakh sees the horse-filth coming. So yes, although 40 mordor orcs would, through their undoubtedly superior skill, cunning and experience whooped the ill-bred, ill-led @$$es of the 80 uruk-hai, Grishnakh decides not to make their common plight any worse. Of course such thinking never entered the impenetrable skull of Ugluk, or they would never have been anywhere near the horse-muck in the first place.

It is sadly true that Grishnakh fails to escape with the prisoners. But at least he (a) remembered them, since Ugluk forgot them completely, as his braincell was occupied in getting killed, and (b) tried to get them to safety.

It is also true that the hobbits escape and this precipitates the march of the ents. But, given the elven-cloaks, this might have happened anyway. And where does the main responsibility lie? With Grishnakh who tried to get them to Mordor, or with Ugluk who brought them right to Treebeards' doorstep? (And then got every last orc killed in the process). So yes, Ugluk followed Sarumans orders, and brought about his own destruction. Grishnakh did all he could to prevent it...
 
As much as I like seeing 'ta-tas' discussed in a thread, I still must point out the sad truth. Grishnakh himself (along with Shagrat and Gorbag, I might add) was the recipient of a little dark-lord modification. You can see this in appendix A, of the stewards, under the entry for Denethor I (~TA2500). Grishnakh is one of the Uruks- recipients of said modifications, as can be seen by anyone who wants to wade through Uruks vs Uruk-hai. Of course, in HoME 12 we see that it was probably the Nazgul and not the Necromancer directly who was responsible for coming up with the Uruks design template, but that is no excuse for Grishnakh and friends. So you see that Grishnakh's ta-tas were augmented, they just weren't as well augmented as Ugluk's.
My second point here would be that the Pentorclon is not like a job hiring. It's more along the lines of a wet orc-jerkin contest, in which case (well) modified ta-tas are a legitimate asset.

I never disputed the fact that Grishnakh wanted to take the Hobbits to Lugburz and Ugluk didn't. What I was saying was that Ugluk never attempted to search the Hobbits or in any other way violate the orders given him by Saruman. I think the text pretty well bears me out on this.

On an un-related note, I finally thought of something to address this:
Originally posted by Harad the White
Another possible problem, I hesitate to mention, was the Orc Draught that both Ugluk and Grishnakh may have been imbibing, giving them an unfair advantage over Shagrat, and perhaps resulting in them failing the doping test.
I was thinking about this this morning (well, what else am I going to think about in the morning?). If I recall correctly, Frodo recalls some burning liquid being poured down his throat while he's reviving in the tower. This is when Shagrat and Gorbag were still chummy, so I think we can assume that all four of our contestants were imbibing- indicating to me that Orc Draught is simply the Gatorade of its era. In fact, perhaps we should start calling it Orcade?
 
Oh yeah... orc draught ... I wouldnt be without it. Nothing wrong with that.

On the 'ta-ta's' question... I assume you mean their genetic material? Its clear there are lots of varieties of orcs, even from Gandalf description of the Grey Mountains to Bilbo. Gradations within orcs is one thing, but the Uruk-Hai appear to be a different breed entirely. Are they still orcs? I dont know.

As they are defective, I prefer not to include them.

I agree that Ugluk was loyal to Saruman. Its just that Saruman sucks, right? His mindless loyalty to his boss, got him and all the other orcs killed. The key part is 'mindless' ... he doesnt think for himself, and runs straight into trouble.
 
Ugluk doesn't run mindlessly, he runs very deliberately. He has a very clever plan to have Mauhar and his lot attack the Horseboys, which will allow Ugluk to escape with the Hobbits. Of course the plan is foiled, not by the Rohirrim but by the lowly cunning of Grishnakh, who decides that if he can't escape with the Hobbitses, nobody will.
The Orcs yelled and jeered. 'Come down! Come down!' they cried. If you wish to speak to us, come down! Bring out your king! We are the fighting Uruk-hai!'
Looks like they were both Orcs and Uruk-hai. Incidentally, where were you when I was struggling to convince folks that there was anything special about the Uruk-hai in U vs U-h?
 
Originally posted by snaga1
Grishnakh is well known as more evil than Ugluk. Without his back up, Ugluk would have been maggot-food in moments. What evidence is there that Nazgul ever flew Grishnakh anywhere? That is nonsense, a typical ape-brained comment from the miserable feeble-minded Ugluk camp. How could the Nazgul fly him from the point he leaves Ugluk? They werent there, and if they had been the outcome of the debate would have been very different. All the orcs would have fallen into line straightaway. So Grishnakh clearly makes it back to Anduin on foot. So then how could the Nazgul fly all 40 Mordor orcs back to Ugluk's gang later? Was there some kind of Hercules transport winged Nazgul that I have carelessly overlooked? Or has the preposterous Isenglob snivelling mob just lost the use of their braincell?

I just noticed this post, which slipped in while I was responding to WtS. Since this has been brought up a couple of times, I think I'll try to use quotes to lay the matter to rest.
First off, the Nazgul were not on the West Side of the Anduin, but they were nearby, as pronounced by Grishnakh:
'I came across,' said the evil voice. 'A winged Nazgul awaits us northward on the east-bank.'
It's important to notice several things about this. First off, it is implied that the Nazgul can ferry Orcs. Second off, the Nazgul is waiting to the Northwards, which will become important momentarily. Next, is there another way across the Anduin besides the Nazgul-ferry? Well, on February the 23rd the Fellowship is attacked from the East Bank by Orcs of Mordor (who make very poor archers, I might add) while trying to go through the rapids of Sarn Gebor. These Orcs of Mordor have an exact fix on the Fellowship's location, yet are either unwilling or unable to attack the Fellowship's camp on the West Bank. Tellingly, the accompanying Nazgul's mount is shot down by Legolas. In the Chapter The Uruk-hai we get further confirmation that it is difficult for Orcs to cross the Anduin without Nazgul-ferrying:
'If we could cross the Great River, we might,' said another voice. 'But there are not enough of us to venture down to the bridges.'
If there had been another way to get across the Anduin than going to the bridges (presumably of Osgiliath), then now would be the time for Grishnakh to mention them. Since he only mentions the Nazgul, I'll assume that there was no other option. This means that Grishnakh at least had to have contact with the Nazgul again in order to get his 40 lads- a perfect opportunity to shift his position. For anyone with access to a map you can see the route the Uruk-hai and Moria Runts took from the Emyn Muil- Northwest to the Entwash, then North following the river up to the eaves of Fangorn. How did Grishnakh and company approach this group? Eomer informs us that
Others joined them, coming out of the East across the Great River, their trail is plain to see a little north of this spot
and later we hear of this trail again
Before long they came to the borders of the Entwash, and there they met the other trail of which Eomer had spoken, coming down from the East out of the Wold.
So while Ugluk and company were heading along the shortest possible path -northwest- Grishnakh and company were heading straight west (coming out of the east). Either Grishnakh and boys headed first north from the Emyn Muil and then turned a 90 degree corner to head West, or else Grishnakh was flown North, and then given his troops, allowing him to cut out a large part of the Death March. If Grishnakh and boys headed first north and south it means that they covered much more ground in less time than the Uruk-hai. Is there any hint that they were capable of this?
Either because they were quicker and hardier, or because of some plan of Grishnakh's, the Isengarders gradually passed through the Orcs of Mordor
I think we can assume that Grishnakh (being the clever git he is) is not purposely trying to get his boys closer to the archers of the Rohirrim. This means that the Uruk-hai are quicker and hardier, making it unlikely that the Mordor Orcs travelled farther in less time. Therefore, Grishnakh was flown North and travelled a shorter distance, which also explains how he was able to get to Ugluk's band without being seen by the three hunters.

As for who is more competent in individual combat we need only look at the manner in which are contestants expire- Grishnakh is easily spitted by a single rider, Ugluk is only stopped by the personal heroism of Eomer, who dismounts to fight Mr. Magnificent sword to sword. Would Eomer ever dismount to fight Grishnakh? It is to laugh, Magnificently.
 
Grishnak (sp?) is the best! come on! No actually I just voted for him because he is the one I remeber best. I remember him and Ugluck or whatever.
 
I don't even know any of them! i just read which one sounded cooler and that was my vote.... lol!
 
Which one sounded cooler to you?

Who did you vote for?

*Crosses fingers* GrishnakhGrishnakhGrishnakhGrishnakh!
 
Dum-da-da-da-dum-duuuum. Daaa-da-da-da-dum-duuum. daa-da-da-da-daaaaaa-da. Da-da-da-da-da-daaaaaaaa.

Today, as I stand hear listening to the triumphant Anthem of Isengard, I consider myself the luckiest Orc on the face of Middle-earth.
It hasn't always been easy. There has been ugly campaigning, and name-calling. Some have questioned my intelligence, others my leadership ability. But through it all, I tried to carry myself with a quiet dignity. When they questioned my vision, I let my sword speak for me. When they tried to steal victory from under my fangs, I again let my sword speak for me.
What has been most gratifying has been the knowledge that through it all, you, the voters of this great forum, have still shown trust in me, and that you believe me to be the best candidate in the PentOrclon. This victory belongs as much to you as it does to me.

I would like to take the opportunity during this joyous occasion to extend my claw to those who have made this event so competitive:
Gorbag, sorry to see what happened to your face. I'm sure the plastic surgeons can fix it.
Shagrat, congradulations on a race well-run. I will do my best to see that our common values of brutish strength and savage insults are upheld while I'm in office.
Grishnakh, about you I have no comment.
And finally a special mention for those who were deemed 'unfit for comptetition'- Azog, Bolg, and Snaga. While you were physically not allowed in the race, your orcish spirit was with us always- pushing us to higher levels of death marching and insult dispensing. Without you three, the Pentorclon would not have been such a tremendous success.

And a final "thank you" to everyone here. Orc draught and manflesh will now be served in the Orthanc lobby.

-Victory speech of Ugluk the Magnificent
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top