In dark and loneliness they are strongest; they will not openly attack a house where there are lights and many people - not until they are desperate, not while all the long leagues of Eriador still lie before us. FOTR, Strider
Originally posted by joxy
Yes, the hobbits' sword practice and their presence at Boromir's death are well done, but they have nothing to do with the story as written- unless I've missed something and Tolkien did give M & P a special love for Boromir- if so, where is it in the book? The two scenes are extra to the book, yet so many scenes have to be left out because there isn't time for them- isn't there a contradiction there?
Gimli being saved from a fall that doesn't happen in the book would have worked quite well in Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs; in FOTR it's silly.
M & P veg-pilfering would have been amusing in any children's film but again is silly here- especially THAT carrot! Again, PJ has time for this nonsense, but not for a whole lot of "real" action.
Originally posted by Talimon
PJ's goal wasn't to stick in as many scenes from the book as he possibly could. Go see Harry Potter if that's what you are looking for....Those small bits of comedy hardly ruin anything in my opinion....PJ is having them grow and loose thier inocense....Without those small comedy scenes, the movie would seem much colder and desolate. It would be far more difficult for a modern non-fantasy-reading audience to relate to the tale....He has kept many important scenes.
Don't hold your breath. We have Arwen at Helm's Deep bringing Elves from Lothlorien (is that in the book anywhere?) and then she takes up with some Rohanian refugees and a whole new plot develops. (err... umm... that would be a totally PJ plot that had no dream of existence in the book).Originally posted by joxy
...and from the advance shots it looks as if TTT and ROTK will be even better because "truer".
Originally posted by Grond
We have Arwen at Helm's Deep bringing Elves from Lothlorien and then she takes up with some Rohanian refugees and a whole new plot develops....PJ----warned there wasn't enough material and depth in the last two novels to adequately develop the characters on the big screen....And of course, PJ (director of three or four other mediocre films) knows the best way to improve upon a book
Originally posted by Grond
Don't hold your breath. We have Arwen at Helm's Deep bringing Elves from Lothlorien (is that in the book anywhere?) and then she takes up with some Rohanian refugees and a whole new plot develops. (err... umm... that would be a totally PJ plot that had no dream of existence in the book).
PJ in a recent interview even warned us Tolkien fans to hold our breath due to an increased number of changes in the next two movies because there wasn't enough material and depth in the last two novels to adequately develop the characters on the big screen. And of course, PJ (director of three or four other mediocre films) knows the best way to improve upon a book that is treasured by millions and has been read by some 75 million people. It was written by J. R. R. Tolkien... but what did he know anyway. He lived a while ago and was totally out of touch with this day and time. *Grond's voice drips with sarcasm.*
I must apologize then. I forgot what I had already written once in another thread. That is, that Arwen was to be at Helm's Deep.... the scene's were even shot but then PJ changed his mind because she didn't seem to do well in combat/action scenes. (I posted this somewhere.) The fact remains that PJ intended initially for Arwen Evenstar to appear at Helm's Deep.Originally posted by Talimon
1) 95% of those readers have taken the films with complete open arms. Go ask your average Tolkien fan on the street what he thinks.
2) You need to stop spreading fake rumours. Richard Taylor said Arwen isn't at Helm's Deep. End of story.
Originally posted by Grond
I must apologize then. I forgot what I had already written once in another thread. That is, that Arwen was to be at Helm's Deep.... the scene's were even shot but then PJ changed his mind because she didn't seem to do well in combat/action scenes. (I posted this somewhere.) The fact remains that PJ intended initially for Arwen Evenstar to appear at Helm's Deep.
So, it was not a false rumour. It was a directorial change of direction.You need to look at the poster's comments with more clarity Talimon. I am one who enjoyed the film immensely. I am also one who realizes that it could have been so much better if PJ had maintained the integrity of the author. Arwen's scene at the Ford's of Bruinen did nothing to strengthen the story. It didn't make the story more diverse. It was a shameless ploy to get the big name female lead on camera sooner rather than later. You movie supporters need to start calling the shots with a little more truth yourselves. Most of the Tolkien purists here loved the film... we just didn't much like the story.
Don't hold your breath. We have Arwen at Helm's Deep bringing Elves from Lothlorien (is that in the book anywhere?) and then she takes up with some Rohanian refugees and a whole new plot develops. (err... umm... that would be a totally PJ plot that had no dream of existence in the book).
The Ringwraiths walk in. (Let's keep in mind that they're blind, so supposedly they should have an extraordinary sence of smell and hearing). Complete silence. No breathing. No smell.
Still, despite of the fact that there are no signs of hobbits being present, the Ringwraiths attack the pillows!! As if that's not dumb enough, they need to thrust their swords through "hobbits" three or four times to realize their mistake!!! Pillows are soft and hobbits are not!!!! What kind of warrior are you if you can't notice the difference between hobbits and pillows?!
Don't they also walk into the Prancing Pony with one hand out in front of them, that could be a way of showing their blindness
Does it not seem odd that if Bill and his buddies came into the room that they would trash it considering that they could see. If wraiths had come in they would probably be vicious to the room, considering they could not exactly see what they were looking for.
However, could they see in the movie? I get the feeling that they could.
As far as I can remember, they did walk into the Prancing Pony with one hand out in front of them.
Well, I just realised why the Wraiths had no reason to trash the bedroom in "The Prancing Pony".
The Ring! The One Ring was not in the hobbits' bedroom and therefore the Ringwraiths had no need to enter the room, since they can feel the Ring's presence (or absence).
The Ringwraiths walk in. (Let's keep in mind that they're blind, so supposedly they should have an extraordinary sence of smell and hearing). Complete silence. No breathing. No smell.
Well, I just realised why the Wraiths had no reason to trash the bedroom in "The Prancing Pony".
The Ring! The One Ring was not in the hobbits' bedroom and therefore the Ringwraiths had no need to enter the room, since they can feel the Ring's presence (or absence).
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?