I am not a super-active member of TTF, even though I have been a member for a number of years. One thing I always remarked was how in depth some of the conversations got, which is why I preferred at times to sit back and listen (or read, so to speak). That has been plenty enriching. But now that I am rereading
the Lord of the Rings and paying more attention to the forum, I have come across these
Mourning Threads and have come to wonder about something (please don't crucify me for saying this!):
Perhaps some of the members you speak about who offered so much to this thread (thousands of replies of depth and logic) don't have much more to say and that is why they disappeared. Believe me, I love the Lord of the Rings, and I could talk about it until I am blue in the face. And so could all of you, or else TTF wouldn't exist. BUT, is it possible that, after a while, there is only so much you can say about
Tolkien and his
books?
One of the most prominent reasons (in my mind) of my return to TTF is that I simply don't get the same intellectual stimulation from various other works of literature (unless you count some of the Classics such as
Nineteen Eighty-four,
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (which is the
only book that I found more enjoyable as a singular book than
The Lord of the Rings - my favourite book so to speak),
The Odyssey,
Brave New World,
A Clockwork Orange and a few others that couldn't be considered as Classics). I find Tolkien's Legendarium to be somewhat the literary equivalent of the Mandelbrot Set (
i → i² + c) and a lot of the precepts of Chaos Theory. The deeper you observe the literature the more you discover that there is no end to the depth of your observation. Tolkien's works present (almost) an infinite number of possibilities. So, I'd have to disagree with you
completely Lady_of_Gondor on that particular aspect. The unfortunately correct facet is that a lot of people who post here are obviously new to the Legendarium and post threads that have been discussed numerous times which tends to portray the fallacy that the works of Tolkien
are quite
limited.
I, as someone who loves all literature, believe there is always something new to say about a work, but sometime I need to take time off from it in order to come back with a fresh perspective. Perhaps if people started some new and interesting threads that haven't been talked about before,
the old members would return.
I think that the answer is actually far more simpler than that Lady.

Life often gets in the way. I receive great criticism from friends and family for coming on the boards as (and I hate to say this) it is a last resort for me. I almost
never do anything in moderation and chances are, based on my usual behaviour, I will spend a great quantity of time here for a short period and will likely disappear again for some years. Life will just inexorably prevent me from unnecessary cogitation; and I'm sure this has happened to many other members of the forum.
I was reading the other thread on this topic and it seemed many people were complaining, but not actually posting something to discuss. I will try to come up with a new topic as I continue my reread of the Lord of the Rings. In fact, I have an idea about illustration in my mind right now that I may go and post.
This thread was not designed to complain or really even mourn. I noticed that there was a significant amount of this in
The Decline of TTF thread and bright ol'
Aulë asked that wonderful question - and out of admiration for the idea I posted it as a new thread to explore the hope of a
Durin VII, a phoenix that will arise from the ashes and it need not be one person. This purpose of this thread is reminiscence indeed; but it is for positive purposes to remember fondly those who once leant on the forum
walls with their memorable attitudes and brilliant observations and perhaps even utter a silent prayer that they'll return someday...
I look forward to seeing your illustration post, btw...
Basically, I would just like to say, "if you post it, they will come!" So be proactive, and hopefully the old members, and hopefully some clever new ones will show up.
Problematically it just isn't as easy as that either. I've posted some threads that took me days to construct just from reading the necessary material to attain a decent understanding and thus are hopefully of good quality. One thread in particular was:
I Liar Núra Sanwëo: Ingolë - Moringottova i Saurova Milli: Arda Sahta ar i Milli Túrë which received virtually no attention.
I think it also has a lot to do with the depth of knowledge required to banter with such
loremasters as a Nóm or an
Úlairi. I have found that you have to be really immersed in Tolkien's works to be able to fully understand the structure of the lore (and to be able to form a solid debate without being shot down like a World War 2 fighter plane).
Yeah, sorry about that.
I think that whilst Peter Jackson's movies were being released quite a few people were interested in Tolkien, Tolkien, and more Tolkien - leading to some incredible conversations on here. But be that as it may, eventually a change of scenery is required.
Yes, but not when that scenery becomes
Mordor - The Scenic Route.
Orc Tour Guide: "Here on our left we have the very first torture chamber built in
Barad-dûr. It was commissioned by the
Dark Lord one month after the
towers construction and was eventually abandoned as the infectious fumes of the rotting corpses gave the Great Eye terrible conjunctivitis."
I plan on revisiting the world of Tolkien (and those scary looking History of
Middle Earth monstrosities on my book shelf) in the build up to The
Hobbit movies in a couple of years time, and I'd expect that a fair few of TTF's alumni will plan on doing the same.
And I think you'd be pretty much spot on there. It is likely I will do the same if the internet still exists in the next four years.
I haven't dared post in any Tolkien related thread in recent times because I do not think I'm at my best in regards to Tolkienology right now. It's different when you are new to Tolkien, fresh faced and raring to dig your claws into a bit of discussion. But for myself, posting now wouldn't compare with my knowledge a few years back: sure I recall the basics, but a thorough re-reading of Lost
Tales would be required before I ventured into a bit of deep Tolkien philosophy.
Wanna know something absolutely horrifying? I haven't read them for
six years. I swear! I seem to remember where most things are however... weird.
So what I'm really getting at here is that I expect that these TTF legends are trudging through other literary works right now, and do not feel prepared to take on TTF's current crop of loremasters...at least until they pick up the ol' dusty Tolkien bibles once more. If they are anything like me, it'll be in the lead up to the Hobbit movies.
Nah, they're pushovers!

I personally don't think people like Grond and
Ancalagon would have much of a problem. Knowledge derives from understanding and understanding from literary talent in textual interpretation. Many "
Loremasters knowledge" of Tolkien is extraordinarily shallow. They purport a deep level of understanding but all they've truly achieved is the acquisition of little knowledge from a wider variety of topics (
learning a little from a lot) where as I believe a true Loremaster is someone who derives a deep understanding from a more narrow perspective (
learning a lot from a little). Anyway it's damn late and I should've been asleep hours ago!
Cheers,
Úlairi.