• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Helm's Deep - PJ's Shame Spiral

Gandalf White said:
Theoden tells Aragorn, "I will not risk open war," not wanting to instigate anything with Saruman. To my knowledge, Aragorn never counsels Theoden to charge head-on into Saruman's army, he simply tries to get it into Theoden that he will have to fight and that holing himself up is a bad idea.

When Theoden says he won't risk open war, Aragorn says "open war is upon you whether you would risk it or no" then something like "why not ride out and meet it?" Which IMO sounds like riding out and charging them on a battlefield. Where they would have been slaughtered. Why is Theoden holing himself up at Helm's Deep such a bad idea? I know I'm harping on this, but I still can't see any REALISTIC (considering the times and type of warfare) alternative... :confused:

Hate to admit it, but this royally confused me. Translation! ;) :eek:
No kidding, I was even confused when I read over what I wrote. Grima doesn't specifically say Helm's Deep is the smart choice. He does say
1. Edoras is vulnerable (Which means in PJ land that Theoden shouldn't stay there)
2. Grima also calls Helm's Deep a vast fortress, or impenetrable, or never before vanquished or words to that effect. Which makes it seem like this is the "best" choice. He mentions nothing about any other alternatives.
3. Then when Theoden is packing up at Edoras, he says to Hama or Glanhag or whomever that leaving Edoras is not a defeat. But he doesn't sound at all convinced, and Hama looks at him like he's full of ...beans and then there is a big close up of Theoden whispering to the camera "this is not a defeat!"...one of his many cowardly moments. And my reaction was, DUH. To stay at Edoras waiting for 10,000 orcs would be suicide. Why does anyone need convincing?

IMHO, the plotline here was all over the place and confusing...
 
.

The battle of Helm's Deep in the movie was absolutely nothing like it was in the book first of all. There was no charge of 2000 riders of the Rohirrim to finally defeat the urukai, it was actually 1000 men on foot that arrived with Gandalf, who were scraped up from the remaining patrols in various parts of Rohan. Eomer was never banished from Edoras. When Gandalf finally did release Theodin from Sarumans spell he was not restored 100% he was still somewhat withered and aged. In this withered condition Gandalf and Aragorn counseled him to go to Helm's Deep with his people and prepare for battle there, but Theodin refused. He rode with Gandalf Aragorn Eomer and 1000 riders of the Rohirrim which had not gathered at Edoras and they did ride out to meet Saruman head on. This was all found out to be in vain as they approached Orthanc Rohan's scouts reported that an army of 10,000 urukai was already marching to Helm's Deep. So they had to rush back and defend it with around 1500 men and there were never any elves. Aragorn was never seperated from the party.

In truth, I read the book after seeing all 3 movies and IMO TTT wouldn't work in a movie as it's written. It would not keep the veiwers interested. Movies need a different pace and emotional element to them otherwise they would get tedious and boring on top of not making sense to those who haven't read the book. The elves were a good edition, PJ did a good thing putting them in there showing at least some effort on the part of the elves.
 
IF PJ stuck to the freaking book he wouldn't have any problems making this movie work. He just had to get a smug and change all sorts of things. Honestly, Eomer should have been at Helms Deep and The Fords of Isen should have been shown, wtf?!? It's all writen out for PJ in Unfinished Tales, put it in the movie and HD dosn't have to be near as long! Moron...
 
Aglarband said:
IF PJ stuck to the freaking book he wouldn't have any problems making this movie work. He just had to get a smug and change all sorts of things. Honestly, Eomer should have been at Helms Deep and The Fords of Isen should have been shown, wtf?!? It's all writen out for PJ in Unfinished Tales, put it in the movie and HD dosn't have to be near as long! Moron...
Jackson could not use anything from Unfinished Tales without bringing down a lawsuit from the Tolkien Estate. New Line only had the rights to LOTR. Jackson could make up new things, but using anything from Unfinished Tales, The Silmarillion or HoMe would have been illegal. That said, I can't imagine why he didn't have Eomer at Helm's Deep.
 
Greenwood said:
Jackson could not use anything from Unfinished Tales without bringing down a lawsuit from the Tolkien Estate. New Line only had the rights to LOTR. Jackson could make up new things, but using anything from Unfinished Tales, The Silmarillion or HoMe would have been illegal. That said, I can't imagine why he didn't have Eomer at Helm's Deep.

The Fords of Isen was breifly described in TTT by groups of Rohirrim met by the company etc. And I'm sure if he begged New Line I'm sure they would have gotten the rights to just that chapter if at all possible.
 
Aglarband said:
The Fords of Isen was breifly described in TTT by groups of Rohirrim met by the company etc. And I'm sure if he begged New Line I'm sure they would have gotten the rights to just that chapter if at all possible.
Christopher Tolkien has refused to sell any of the rights to any of the books he published after his father's death. There was no possibility at all getting the rights to anything in Unfinished Tales.
 
Where does T describe the death of Theodred? In TTT, or in an appendix?
 
ahem, the fords of isen thing is in the EE and T mentions the death of Theodred at the Fords in the Appendices.
 
joxy said:
Where does T describe the death of Theodred? In TTT, or in an appendix?
I don't think Tolkien ever describes the death of Theodred in LOTR. In TTT in the chapter "The King of the Golden Hall" during the confrontation between Gandalf and Grima, Grima says: "It is not yet five days since the bitter tidings came that Theodred your son was slain upon the West Marches: your right-hand, Second Marshall of the Mark." Then in the beginning of the next chapter, "Helm's Deep" after Gandalf, Theoden and company ride out from Edoras they encounter a lone rider who tells them: "Things have gone evilly since Theodred fell. We were driven back yesterday over the Isen with great loss; many perished at the crossing." Other than these passages I don't think we are told anything specific in LOTR about Theodred's death. In "The Tale of Years" in Appendix B, under Feb. 25, 3019 there is: "First Battle of the Fords of Isen; Theodred son of Theoden slain." These passages are non-specific enough that they don't even prove Theodred was slain at the Fords of Isen. Perhaps someone remembers another passage.
 
Thanks for both of those confirmations.
Unfinished Tales gives an account of the battle at the Fords, in which Theodred died, and a footnote adds that Theodred's body was laid under a low mound with his banner raised above it as its identification.
Jackson, for some reason known only to himself, though guessed at by some here, chooses to replace this brief account with a long-drawn out funeral scene, which would, of course, have been incomplete without a screeching dirge in accurate Old English.
The DVD EE includes the battle; did Jackson have to get special permission to use that extraneous material?!
 
joxy said:
The DVD EE includes the battle; did Jackson have to get special permission to use that extraneous material?!
No, LOTR says there was a battle at the fords and that Theodred died there so he could make up any version of the battle he wanted. But, if he had used the account from Unfinished Tales he would be open to a lawsuit.
 
The UT account is quite brief and, apart from Theodred being found dying rather than dead, the scene in the EE version of the film is as near to it as anyone could ask for.
Surely it would be impossible to establish, within legal definition, whether the film is based on the UT account, or is an invention?
Who would be bothered to start such an action?
And, has anyone seen an explanation from PJ of why he had to give a full scene of the film to an incident that is covered in just one line in an appendix to TLOTR?
I like the scene, but I've never understood why it's there.
On the other hand I dislike the funeral scene, which has no basis at all in any book, and am baffled as to why IT is there.
The time taken up by both could obviously have been put to much different use.
 
joxy said:
The UT account is quite brief and, apart from Theodred being found dying rather than dead, the scene in the EE version of the film is as near to it as anyone could ask for.
Surely it would be impossible to establish, within legal definition, whether the film is based on the UT account, or is an invention?
Who would be bothered to start such an action?
And, has anyone seen an explanation from PJ of why he had to give a full scene of the film to an incident that is covered in just one line in an appendix to TLOTR?
I like the scene, but I've never understood why it's there.
On the other hand I dislike the funeral scene, which has no basis at all in any book, and am baffled as to why IT is there.
The time taken up by both could obviously have been put to much different use.

The funeral scene for me has the significance of underlining Theoden's 'obsession' (though that is probably too strong a word) with his previous weakness, whether he is deserving of going to join his fathers upon his own death, hence the references to the other tombs, and the fact that his son has earned the right to that ultimate reward.
Hence his dying words,(pardon me but I haven't viewed the scene lately), to the effect that he has died with valour and will not be ashamed before his forebears
 
I'd agree with Arwen48. The whole business about Theodred is an excellent way to introduce several characters (Theoden, Eowyn, Eomer, and Grima), and their different reactions tell us loads about the personal interests and motivations of each. It also tells us much about the political situation between Isengard and Rohan, in a very compact manner. That it was based on a very brief account in the book is hardly the point- it is very significant, one of the most significant events in the lives of these four (very significant) characters from the books. In fact, joxy's complaint that the dirge is in Olde English and not something more modern is about the only complaint I've ever seen about the scene. That aside (as I don't really understand the nature of the complaint), I believe the scene does an excellent job in establishing the sense of melancholy and impending doom of the Rohirrim, which is exactly what PJ was trying to do leading up to Helm's Deep. The young and strong are being killed off, leaving their parents (and children) to face the full weight Saruman's forces. What more explanation is needed?
 
Arwen's point could have been covered by a couple of lines of dialogue within an "original" scene. I don't see the need to invent a whole scene to convey the message.
Aragil, are you saying that the battle - in the EE only -and the funeral introduce those four people? I thought I'd seen them all already, and had got a perfectly good idea of their characters from more-or-less "original" material. Could you expand your point about the "political" relationship between Rohan and Isengard, in relation to these two scenes?
Obviously the basis of my questioning these scenes - not actually complaining about them! - is that they have only the flimsiest of connection with the books, but I don't think they do much strictly within PJ's own concept either.
I'd certainly be interested to hear any explanation he has offered, of the need for them.
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
Aragil, are you saying that the battle - in the EE only -and the funeral introduce those four people?
Yes. The first time you see Eomer in the EE is when he finds Theodred's body. The first time you see him in the TC is when he brings the body to Edoras. The first time you see Eowyn, Theoden, and Grima is when Eomer then bears the body to Meduseld. The funeral, however, does not happen until after the exorcism- this lends weight within the story to how "out of sorts" Theoden was, he didn't even have the werewithall to bury his own son. Shocking stuff.
joxy said:
I thought I'd seen them all already, and had got a perfectly good idea of their characters from more-or-less "original" material.
What can I say? You were mistaken.
joxy said:
Could you expand your point about the "political" relationship between Rohan and Isengard, in relation to these two scenes?
Certainly- Isengard is attacking Rohan. Rohan is allowing this to happen. Not even the death of the King's son causes the King to rise against Isengard. In fact, for merely suggesting such the King has his nephew and apparent heir bannished. That says a lot about the politics between these two countries- the one pursuing an aggressive policy of unprovoked expansion, the other a policy of quietly rolling over.
joxy said:
Obviously the basis of my questioning these scenes - not actually complaining about them! - is that they have only the flimsiest of connection with the books, but I don't think they do much strictly within PJ's own concept either.
Well, for not being a complaint, the tone is amazingly negative! The Fords is a rather important moment in the book, and is mentioned in at least 4 separate chapters, as well as the aforementioned appendix. If you think that is 'flimsy', so be it. I suppose having Arwen in the movie is also flimsy, as she is only mentioned in 4-5 chapters.
I thought I already explained how they fit in with PJ's concept: "I believe the scene does an excellent job in establishing the sense of melancholy and impending doom of the Rohirrim, which is exactly what PJ was trying to do leading up to Helm's Deep." Not that this can't be argued with, but I don't didn't see any rebuttal!
joxy said:
I'd certainly be interested to hear any explanation he has offered, of the need for them.
Sorry if you're trying to channel PJ through me. I'm only speaking for how I react to the movie. I thought these scenes were done well, captured small parts from the book, and integrated them well into the overall theme of book and movie. It's a little thing I like to call "adapting well".
 
Thanks Aragil - your reply sent me back to the book, and it's always good to have an excuse for doing that!
My question was "are you saying that the battle - in the EE only -and the funeral introduce those four people?"
Your answer tells me that, literally, they do NOT do so, except, minimally, in the case of Eomer in the EE battle. Theodred's invented return is separate from the battle scene, and the funeral happens, as you say, after they have appeared, and been introduced. The scenes give information about the characters, they throw light on them, but they don't introduce them.
I have to admit that I had forgotten the complete transformation that PJ renders to the actual introduction, and the substantial move forward in time at which he presents it. The shifting forward of the time-line seems reasonable enough for the benefit of the film, but I've made it clear before what I think of the transformation. The book's account is more substantial and more interesting.
You say that the Battle is mentioned in four chapters; I've seen a sentence in only one, in my current reading, and would be interested to hear how much else is said on the matter, and where. I really don't see justification for converting four mentions into two complete invented scenes, given that Tolkien's story gives perfectly adequate ways of making the introductions, explaining the relations between the characters, and expounding the political situation.
As I've said, I am impressed by the EE's battle scene, though I would have preferred Theodred to remain as he does in the book appendix version, but it was one of those scenes of PJ's, some vaguely connected with the books, others total inventions such as the falling staircase, which are good in themselves but inessential or irrelevant to the story, and a distraction within the films.

I wasn't channeling PJ; I was asking the populace in general to volunteer any reports they may have seen, of any statements that PJ may have made on these matters.
 
Last edited:
I saw no Fords of Isen in the EE what are you people talking about? What battle?
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top