simbelmyne
Member
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2003
- Messages
- 322
Gandalf White said:
When Theoden says he won't risk open war, Aragorn says "open war is upon you whether you would risk it or no" then something like "why not ride out and meet it?" Which IMO sounds like riding out and charging them on a battlefield. Where they would have been slaughtered. Why is Theoden holing himself up at Helm's Deep such a bad idea? I know I'm harping on this, but I still can't see any REALISTIC (considering the times and type of warfare) alternative...
No kidding, I was even confused when I read over what I wrote. Grima doesn't specifically say Helm's Deep is the smart choice. He does sayHate to admit it, but this royally confused me. Translation!![]()
![]()
1. Edoras is vulnerable (Which means in PJ land that Theoden shouldn't stay there)
2. Grima also calls Helm's Deep a vast fortress, or impenetrable, or never before vanquished or words to that effect. Which makes it seem like this is the "best" choice. He mentions nothing about any other alternatives.
3. Then when Theoden is packing up at Edoras, he says to Hama or Glanhag or whomever that leaving Edoras is not a defeat. But he doesn't sound at all convinced, and Hama looks at him like he's full of ...beans and then there is a big close up of Theoden whispering to the camera "this is not a defeat!"...one of his many cowardly moments. And my reaction was, DUH. To stay at Edoras waiting for 10,000 orcs would be suicide. Why does anyone need convincing?
IMHO, the plotline here was all over the place and confusing...


