• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Helm's Deep - PJ's Shame Spiral

One of my biggest problems with Helm's Deep was the arrival of a host of elves from Rivendell. As PJ stupidly banished the entire Rohan army which never happened, they had no choice but to bring in an army from Rivendell. Absolute trash that this happened.
[sarcasm]But PJ HAD to! He needed to 'improve' the storyline! He couldn't make his movie just like the way Tolkien wrote it, it would be boring![/sarcasm]

Hence 20 years later you get Rings of Power with a free hand to make whatever changes deemed necessary to create a TV show.
😅
 
Last edited:
Um, no, that's OK, thanks. . . 🙄

View attachment 12705
This means that Bilbo goes to Rivendell with the One Ring. Having it right under their noses, Elrond and Gandalf will much sooner realize what it is, avoid lots of delay, and the Fellowship sets off before Sauron can do a lot of stuff. This also leads to an alternate Fellowship, most likely without Boromir. Thus, Gandalf goes with some hobbits to Mordor, which makes the quest highly more successful.

Because they leave earlier in the year, they manage to cross Carahdras peacefully. So, they destroy the Ring before anything too major happens, and a lot less people die.

In short, it's all Gandalf's fault. He should've left when Bilbo said that.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top