Not getting burned to death, that I will agree with... they should have.***I dunno. That's why I'm going to review the full scope of things.
but I must say though it may well be my conclusion matches yours when I've reviewed it all more closely, given the description of the internal events of the Mountain, my biggest surprise is still the lack of a fricasseed Frodo and scalded Sam. It was far more than just 'hot' in there.
I believe that's why Gwaihir would have been willing to take Gandalf there and blast them into the pit, hoping for a singed Sam snack into the bargain.
I think I'm going to start another thread.It was far more than just 'hot' in there.
thank you for working on this while I was working on mine.I bet it takes you longer than 30 minutes.
It would seem that for once, Lestrade is on the right track.
Oh no! A Scotland Yard joke! But I best not say more lest you trade me a worse one. *Coughs*ooooo ... that's a low blow, that is.
Indeed, this is 'Providence'...what many others lacking understanding of call 'intervention,' not realizing when it actually occurs rather than when it SEEMS to occur.It means that where supernatural help was necessary, where human nature would fail, help was provided.
Something occurred to me on my 2nd reading of LOTR (which was 2001).Indeed, this is 'Providence'...what many others lacking understanding of call 'intervention,' not realizing when it actually occurs rather than when it SEEMS to occur.
The actuality is Providence. The 'seeming' of it results in the errant 'intervention.'
It is, of course, the only explanation.
It is also one of Tolkien's three (3) keynotes of his work underlying the whole...
These 3 keynotes are the subject of the Appendix I've written for the book coming out in January, and are the keynotes of the book I will be writing soon myself.
I'm thankful it was recognized, and has now been stated.
Indeed. Feel free to feed me any examples of 'providence' you find.So Providence intervened there also.
Not sure... redemption?Indeed. Feel free to feed me any examples of 'providence' you find.
course, some do. Others don't.
And we're back to the 2nd of Tolkien's 3 keynotes throughout all his works. Choice.
So now you see Providence, and Choice.
I await you for the 3rd.
I was thinking along those lines. Grace, as well. Maybe that falls into Providence, though.Not sure... redemption?
I was using Fonstad for my volcano info.Whatever he was, JRRT was not a volcanologist. Nor am I professionally, though I may have picked up the odd bit of information by a lot of watching of documentaries, and by reading on the subject, that even a professional volcanologist in the first half of the 20th century would not have known.
Deimos mentioned Mount St Helens and stratovolcanoes. Mount St Helens blew up, yes, as did Mount Pinatubo in 1991, Vesuvius in 79, and the ultimate blast in recorded history, the 1815 eruption of Mount Tambora on Sumbawa Island in Indonesia. Not a snowball’s chance in Angband surviving that, for miles around due to pyroclastic flows, never mind up close. But stratovolcanoes have alternating ash explosions and lava flow incidents, even if the latter are not as “gentle” as common lava flows in the Hawaiian Islands – or rather now only on the big island giving the archipelago its name, these being shield volcanoes.
But stratovolcanoes (composite volcanoes) appear to be quite steep, at 30-35 degrees, compared to 5-10 degrees for shield volcanoes. So if Mount Doom had the slope steepness Deimos assumes … erm .. was it a composite-composite volcano? A shield-composite volcano? Most likely, I would guess, a “needs-to-fit-the-story” volcano. That bit about the cloud extending all the way to Rohan, but apparently without any noticeable ash rain … erm. The bit about how close the three Hobbits were to the lave below is another issue. Whenever volcanologists get somewhat close to the danger zone, they usually wear silver-colored heat-protective special gear – and also, like fire-fighters, an oxygen supply due to the poisonous gases. JRRT does not state how close the three came to the lava … PJ’s having Frodo hang by one hand above it is another case of total duh!
Perhaps the case of Stromboli, located on the Italian island of the same name, fits the picture as far as Frodo and Sam’s survival best. It is constantly active with minor eruptions, and the 500 inhabitants of the island don’t seem to get excited by most of the eruptions. Perhaps not spectacular enough for the dramatic needs of JRRT the writer. I’m not even going to start about PJ’s blockbuster “visions”. He would possibly have complained that even Mount Tambora could use some “jazzing up”.
OK, OK... I'll spill the beans. The 3 pillars are Faith, Choice and Providence.Not sure... redemption?
Ok... I see that.OK, OK... I'll spill the beans. The 3 pillars are Faith, Choice and Providence.
....
Oh, he flavors it so it appears differently than the 'overt Christian Reference' he was so adament against... but it is clearly there, thoughout.
This is why Gandalf says to the Balrog "you cannot pass" rather than PJ's totally misunderstood "you shall not pass." But I will leave the rest of that explanation unstated.
Anyway, Tolkien's work is NOT about the standard 'good vs. evil' themes of most cookie-cutter Fantasy / Myth fare... as Tolkien understands 'good' and 'evil' are NOT a 'thing' of their own, having power of their own... they are simply the RESULTS of receiving the gift of Good, then our choices made with regard to maintaining that gift of Good or not, and the Providence inevitably resulting from our Choices.,, though of course, and here's the kicker, Eru knew every choice going to be made well before it was made... just as does Tolkien's God.
That's why he speaks to Providence and does not dapple with 'intervention.'
Intervention implies something happening because of an incident...often one of surprise.
Providence however, entirely has to do with providing IN ADVANCE for those things which are needful in the course of events.
Tolkien's work deals with Providence.
Ah yes.... Grace. It is distinctly there as well, but not as big a focus for Tolkien.Grace,
Were the Ringwraiths only called Nazgûl when they rode Fell-Beasts though? I always considered Nazgûl to be a joint-name, as Gollum puts it: "Wraithssss on wingsss!"In my view, a Nazgul still can't fly at all.
I THINK they were called Nazgul as much as Ringwraiths. In fact, if I'm not mistaken, Nazgul translates to 'ringwraith'.Correct me if I'm wrong.
Very interesting. Now I see what you mean because there is a distinction between a Nazgûl and a winged-Nazgûl. So Nazgûl on their own could not fly, therefore.I THINK they were called Nazgul as much as Ringwraiths. In fact, if I'm not mistaken, Nazgul translates to 'ringwraith'.
BUT... I'm going to neet to check... (again, later.)
The Fell Beasts had no name of their own.
From Foster: Complete Guide:
NAZGÛL (B.S.: nazg ‘ring’ + gûl ‘wraith’) Nine beings, slaves of the Nine Rings and the chief servants of Sauron. Originally Men, three of them Black Númenóreans, the Nazgûl were each given one of the Nine Rings by Sauron in the Second Age, and, being desirous of power, were easily corrupted. About SA 2250 they first appeared as the Nazgûl, beings utterly dependent on Sauron, or, more accurately, on his power acting through the One Ring. When Sauron fell at the end of the Second Age, the Nazgûl were overthrown or went into hiding. They reappeared about TA 1300, at which time their chief, the Lord of the Nazgûl (q.v.), became the Witch-king of Angmar. The other eight stayed in the East until about 1640, when they secretly entered Mordor and began to prepare that realm for Sauron, who was in Dol Guldur. In 2000, joined by their Lord, the Nazgûl besieged Minas Ithil, capturing the city and its palantír in 2002. From this time, the Nazgûl were closely associated with Minas Morgul, as Minas Ithil was then called. In 2951, ten years after its desertion by Sauron, three Nazgûl went to Dol Guldur and stayed there until the WR.
Foster, Robert. The Complete Guide to Middle-earth: Tolkien's World in The Lord of the Rings and Beyond (pp. 358-359). Random House Worlds. Kindle Edition.
exactly. A Nazgûl was never able to fly on his own at any time.therefore.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?