Foe-Hammer said:
If you would like to give specific instances in the movie where the characters were inconsistant for no reason, then by all means go for it.
Hey, do I really get to go for it?

Allrighty, here's a start...
1.
Theoden - these are so obvious that I'm reluctant to go into detail (once again). He's strong and brave in one scene, then weak and scared in the next...and not because of things happening in the plot. Just senselessly random...."Who am I?" indeed!
2.
Aragorn - He pleads his troth to Liv (gross) in FOTR, but changes his mind in TTT flashback...why would he go to sleep in
Rivendell sworn faithful (for many many years) and wake up the next morning rejecting her when he's FINALLY made the decision take control (as shown by then bossing Theoden around) and she's told him she'd rather die than live without him? and then he changes his mind again in the infamous fake death sequence for no apparant reason...
3.
Gandalf - the strongest, wisest character in FOTR, teaching
Frodo, etc. about showing your enemies pity and not dealing out death and judgment. Yet in ROTK he beats up
Denethor and then PUSHES him onto the funeral pyre. And Gandalf, book or movie, does not need to ask Aragorn how Frodo and
Sam are or need to have it explained WHY marching to the Black Gates is a good diversion tactic. Ridiculous!!
4. Frodo - yes, there is some tension between F and S concerning
Gollum, that builds as the movies progress. To go from Frodo getting mad at Sam for picking on Gollum to Frodo
believing and trusting Gollum and calling Sam a liar over
food is completely inconsistant with what was established for all three characters in FOTR. Ring or no ring, Frodo knows Gollum is a liar, theif and murderer. The steadfast Sam has sacrificed his life to follow his master, and gives Frodo most of the food for the entire journey...too big of a leap for logic.