Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
Parrot said:
If you are actually going to have a Frodo as physically compromised as he was in the film (glassy eyed and virtually comatose) and you are going to have a day or day and a half ride to the fords, then it is Aragorn who should have carried the Bearer to safety. He knows that the Riders will follow the Bearer (all the more reason to prevent Arwen from going!) so he leaves his beloved and the other hobbits in relative safety. He also knows that she can lead the hobbits to Rivendell as she obviously knows the way. So if you weren't going to have it play out as it did in the book (Frodo riding on his own on the elf horse and defying the Riders) then the next best thing would be for Aragorn to do it. It makes the most sense, is the easiest to understand and gives the character another little "boost" rather than having him meekly turn over the most important person in Middle-earth to a maiden however pretty and "fast"!Foe-Hammer said:
implies that you still don't 'get it'.If FoTR Arwen worked so well, they would have kept using her in that fashion.
To those who tell us we must give our account of how things should have been done before we can criticise what was done, this is as good an idea as any could ask for. We have been asked who should do the job if Glorfindel can't do it: the answer's simple: Aragorn is there already and he can take on both the roles. Better than Bakshi's idea of Legolas, which wasn't all bad, and very much better than Arwen.Mrs. Maggott said:
Now it is you who is making "no sense". Aragorn was the obvious person to carry Frodo on Arwen's horse. That whole bit with her doing the "rescue" is too contrived for words. To begin with, Aragorn has already driven the Riders away at Weathertop. He is a fine rider - none finer despite the lady's boast! - and a better swordsman (or at least he has a longer sword!). He is also stronger and heavier. Indeed, his weight would serve him well for the elf-horse would not be overly bothered by it but the Riders could not simply grab him and pull him out of the saddle which they might well be able to do with a mere slip of a girl and a small hobbit!Foe-Hammer said:Well the horse has to get there somehow and for aragorn to take the horse away from arwen says....
A: Why is she out there in the first place?
B: She is just a weak female...and why is she out there?
C: How did someone so uncapable get past the Nazgul....and why is she out there?
D: She is uncapable of saving a hobbit by herself...and why is she out there?
That makes no sense MM and it's obvious why it wasn't even attempted.
Mrs. Maggott said:Now it is you who is making "no sense". Aragorn was the obvious person to carry Frodo on Arwen's horse. That whole bit with her doing the "rescue" is too contrived for words. To begin with, Aragorn has already driven the Riders away at Weathertop. He is a fine rider - none finer despite the lady's boast! - and a better swordsman (or at least he has a longer sword!). He is also stronger and heavier. Indeed, his weight would serve him well for the elf-horse would not be overly bothered by it but the Riders could not simply grab him and pull him out of the saddle which they might well be able to do with a mere slip of a girl and a small hobbit!
No one is saying that she's a "weak female", but she is a female. She isn't even built like Xena, so we might well assume that she isn't as strong - at least physically - as Aragorn. Frodo must be protected at all costs; everything depends upon the Ring reaching Rivendell safely. The fords are at least a half day's hard riding away (if Jackson's shot of Arwen riding full tilt in daylight after leaving during the previous night can be believed). The obvious person to carry the Ringbearer to safety is Aragorn. After all, if the lady hadn't found them or if she hadn't come at all, who else would you suggest was available to take Frodo?? If Aragorn was so hopeless that you would prefer simpering, pretty and totally lacking muscle tone Arwen, why have him meet the hobbits in Bree and then drive off the Nazgul? But then, perhaps either you or Jackson were waiting for Glorfindel?
MM, in this short paragraph you are disregarding not only what the movie tells us, but also what we know about physics. Arwen says she is the faster rider. Aragorn does not disagree with her. That's just two folks' opinion on the relative horse-riding prowess of Aragorn and Arwen, but why should I believe your opinion over theirs?Mrs. Maggott said:He is a fine rider - none finer despite the lady's boast! - and a better swordsman (or at least he has a longer sword!). He is also stronger and heavier. Indeed, his weight would serve him well for the elf-horse would not be overly bothered by it but the Riders could not simply grab him and pull him out of the saddle which they might well be able to do with a mere slip of a girl and a small hobbit!
What a silly, rambling, exercise in pretentiousness!
Just so the forum gets what you were trying to say, I'll try to parse it into what it appears that you are saying.
Foe-hammer has got you so aanoyed that you went off on him and now you're aren't sure it was the right thing to do.
I would like a forum admin to move your post to the thread it really belongs in.
Alas, my beautifully plumaged bird, restraint should have begun before there was any necessity for "change".
but the Riders could not simply grab him and pull him out of the saddle which they might well be able to do with a mere slip of a girl and a small hobbit!
Aldanil said:Apparently, some people just have nothing better to do!
In my sorry case, to further engage in fistfighting a tar-baby...
Fleer and fume on then, feckless Foe-Hammer:
The boy's done puzzled out that an Ent tends toward long-winded! Hm, hrum, hoom; must be some sort of analytical wizard!
You've already admitted you're not a professional teacher. Although I'm not sure the Forum really needs much help in comprehending my meanings, I will say, on the basis of your accuracy in paraphrasing just what you think I intended, that you probably shouldn't claim to be a professional reader, either.
This is one point, at least, on which your numerous postings have resolved my doubts.
Whereas numerous pages on either side of my Moria-comment, debating at considerable length the matter of Arwen at Helm's Deep, for example, or the Flight to the Ford, have not (thus far at least) inspired your righteous fervor for recategorization. Eru forfend that I should attempt to dissuade you from putting all of the Forum into proper order, however; why not go and ask ReadWryt? It's his birthday, you know!
Aldanil said:And I'll grant you the hand-rails,...
Aldanil said:(Minor) Point #1: The grimly determined and Gimli-delivered "Nobody tosses a Dwarf!" is what professional teachers (and I am one) call an allusion, a reference to someone or something known from literature, history, sports, science, politics, popular culture, religion, etc. "Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, did you enjoy the play?" It depends for its effect, whether comic, emphatic, or whatever else, on knowing something from outside of the primary context.
Aldanil said:In the particular case of this tossed-off one-liner that you (and very many others, apparently) find so hilarious, the reference is to a politically incorrect and rather vulgar bar-game, reportedly popular in California and elsewhere some years ago.
Aldanil said:To say that recognizing, and laughing at, such a contemporary and crude allusion would also entail shattering the "enchantment" of Middle-earth is only to acknowledge the unavoidable. It quite abruptly busted the mood for me, and I didn't even laugh!
Aldanil said:And any FAD who thinks that this wretchedly tone-deaf line would not have made John Ronald wince, at least, and more likely stand up and start yelling back at the screen, is only deluding himself; but hey, that old gaffer's been gone for at least thirty years now, and who cares about him anyway?
Aldanil said:(Major) Point #2: With the specter of the Balrog just behind, and the death of Gandalf just ahead, the tale (by which I mean "screenplay") simply DOES NOT NEED, IN BETWEEN, TO NEARLY GET THE ENTIRE FELLOWSHIP KILLED WHILE HURRYING DOWN A LONG FLIGHT OF STAIRS, COMPLETE WITH A JOKE! This is not just some abstract and "technical" matter of film-making, either, but a fundamental understanding of the dynamics of story-telling.
Aldanil said:Philippa Boyen
Now that we've managed to come back to the book, what we've discovered is [...] that you could in fact tell the story as written.
Aldanil said:I've got the tall tree-limbs, if y'all bring the rope.
Mrs. Maggott said:The Arwen bit in FOTR has been discussed to death including the points being made here. It is foolish to continue the debate because neither side believes or accepts the points made by the other, so why waste time making them?
Mrs. Maggott said:Arwen could have been there instead of Glorfindel; I have no problem with that. Jackson should have started with her entry into the camp in bright light. It would have been effective and neither the lady nor the Ranger would have suffered from the stupid "sword-to-the-throat" business that was both unnecessary and, well, stupid.
Mrs. Maggott said:However, she should not have carried off Frodo. That was equally stupid because it didn't make sense. Here we have Aragorn built up as a strong hero who takes on all the Nazgul by himself at Weathertop (the hobbits were no help) but no sooner does Jackson build him up than he tears him down.
Mrs. Maggott said:From the time that Arwen appears, Aragorn becomes subservient to her.
Mrs. Maggott said:She puts him down in the sword scene, flatly dismisses his instructions to her as he is about to take Frodo with the claim that she is the "faster" rider (which is just plain silly since it is the horse who's doing the running) and then he hangs his head and humbly acquiesces to sending her and the Bearer off against all the Nazgul while he meekly trails along behind with the others; it was pathetic.
Mrs. Maggott said:In a few minutes of film, Jackson emasculated his primary hero for the sake of building up his love interest! Now, you may like it. Again, that's your right. But I thought it was terrible.
As so often before, you have absolutely no way of proving that claim about the minority and the majority, any more than I have any way of disproving it.Foe-Hammer said:....since you are in the minority, and that sequence is a favorite of the majority....
On top of that, JRR used building suspense to increse tension in the book....but for some reason you don't like it in the movie.
The reason, or excuse, for Arwen's prominent role in FOTR and TTT that has always been given has been that she is so prominent in ROTK that she could not suddenly appear there out of nowhere. The accounts I've read indicate that her role in ROTK is NOT all that significant after all, but you clearly do not find it that way.aragil said:
I think if you were to go that route Joxy, you would be well served to take the other rider out altogether and go back to just Frodo and the special elven horse that won't let the rider fall. For Aragorn to get on the horse with Frodo and leave not only the marginally defenseless hobbits, but also the love of his life, behind eating his dust and at the mercy of the Nazgul, would not have done much to bolster his quality of character either.joxy said:The suggestion of Aragorn taking over from Arwen to look after Frodo really needs the further change of restoring the actual "flight" to its "original" form: of the "long straight mile". The scientific discussions about the stamina of horses would then be unnecessary. As it is, the length of the chase is actually another bit of bad cinema: no-one seems able to agree how long it is! Having Aragorn on the long straight mile would have looked wonderful, so much better than all that weaving in and out of trees - that results only in a small, delicately positioned scratch on the face for Arwen; and then Arwen would lead the others back home!
Absolutely, and when I said this scenario needs "restoring the actual "flight" to its original form", I did have in mind the idea of a complete restoration. A Frodo who was a living being rather than a sack of potatoes, who made desperate lone efforts to retain consciousness and take part in the action, would have further surpassed the spectacle of the chase as I had begun to imagine it. PJ could have done it, so well.Parrot said:
Which is why Arwen should never have been out there to begin with. The whole beef to begin with was that Arwen was non-existent in LoTR so they needed to introduce her to the audience earlier and give her more time so her marriage in RoTK wouldn't be a surprise. That they did with the Rivendell scenes and the numerous fabricated scenes between Arwen and Elrond. I can deal with that because in these scenes Arwen is in character.Parrot said:I think if you were to go that route Joxy, you would be well served to take the other rider out altogether and go back to just Frodo and the special elven horse that won't let the rider fall. For Aragorn to get on the horse with Frodo and leave not only the marginally defenseless hobbits, but also the love of his life, behind eating his dust and at the mercy of the Nazgul, would not have done much to bolster his quality of character either
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?