continuing to bicker with madbrained rudesby AND The Smoking Gun, At Last
Apparently,
some people just have nothing
better to do!
In my sorry case, to further engage in fistfighting a tar-baby...
Fleer and fume on then, feckless
Foe-Hammer:
What a silly, rambling, exercise in pretentiousness!
The boy's done puzzled out that an Ent tends toward long-winded!
Hm, hrum, hoom; must be some sort of analytical wizard!
Just so the forum gets what you were trying to say, I'll try to parse it into what it appears that you are saying.
You've already admitted you're not a professional
teacher. Although I'm not sure the Forum really needs much help in comprehending my meanings, I will say, on the basis of your accuracy in paraphrasing just what
you think I intended, that you probably shouldn't claim to be a professional
reader, either.
Foe-hammer has got you so aanoyed that you went off on him and now you're aren't sure it was the right thing to do.
This is one point, at least, on which your numerous postings have resolved my doubts.
I would like a forum admin to move your post to the thread it really belongs in.
Whereas numerous pages on either side of my Moria-comment, debating at considerable length the matter of
Arwen at
Helm's Deep, for example, or the Flight to the Ford, have not (thus far at least) inspired your righteous fervor for recategorization.
Eru forfend that I should attempt to dissuade you from putting all of the Forum into proper order, however; why not go and ask ReadWryt? It's his birthday, you know!
Speaking of
orcs, they live underground too and would certainly been able to scale sheer
walls like ants since they are in fact corrupted
elves and elves were pretty fleet of foot too.
This, I'll admit, took me quite by surprise; perhaps other
loremasters as wise as yourself (if indeed any such can be found in the land) can help to support this rather startling notion!
Well, that was tedious fun, but as our dear Maggott was wont to sign, all that is needed for the triumph of
evil is for good
men to sit idly by and do nothing. In that ennobling spirit, then, let me try once again to make a couple of central points about The Mess in
Moria more crystalline to your uncertain understanding. And I'll grant you the hand-rails, as a show of good faith.
(Minor) Point #1: The grimly determined and Gimli-delivered "Nobody tosses a
Dwarf!" is what professional teachers (and I am one) call an
allusion, a reference to someone or something known from literature, history, sports, science, politics, popular culture, religion, etc. "Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, did you enjoy the play?" It depends for its effect, whether comic, emphatic, or whatever else, on knowing something from outside of the primary context. In the particular case of this tossed-off one-liner that you (and very many others, apparently) find so hilarious, the reference is to a politically incorrect and rather vulgar bar-game, reportedly popular in California and elsewhere some years ago. To say that recognizing, and laughing at, such a contemporary and crude allusion would also entail shattering the "enchantment" of
Middle-earth is only to acknowledge the unavoidable. It quite abruptly busted the mood for me, and I didn't even laugh! And any FAD who thinks that this wretchedly tone-deaf line would not have made John Ronald wince, at least, and more likely stand up and start yelling back at the screen, is only deluding himself; but hey, that old
gaffer's been gone for at least thirty years now, and who cares about
him anyway?
(Major) Point #2: With the specter of the
Balrog just behind, and the death of
Gandalf just ahead, the tale (by which I mean "screenplay") simply DOES NOT NEED, IN BETWEEN, TO NEARLY GET THE ENTIRE FELLOWSHIP KILLED WHILE HURRYING DOWN A LONG FLIGHT OF STAIRS, COMPLETE WITH A JOKE! This is
not just some abstract and "technical" matter of film-making, either, but a fundamental understanding of the dynamics of story-telling.
The Smoking Gun Aforementioned, OR Did You Hear That? I KNEW It!
Having temporarily shot my Capitalizing Wad (or my Capitalizing Bolt, with a nod to joxy), I employ the even more emphatic device of Increasing Font Size to declare the most salient point advanced on this thread (and on many another) in many a post; a sentence which has gone hitherto quite unremarked, but which yet may reveal, as Ishmael sez, that
"this is the key to it all." The citation is taken from accurate aragil's TT EE transcription, in whose scrupulous fidelity I have the utmost faith; the bracketed elision is mine (although minor), for greater effect; the speaker is discussing the Revision of Evenstar. With that stipulation, this is all I needs for that necktie-party I been hankerin' after.
Philippa Boyen
Now that we've managed to come back to the book, what we've discovered is [...] that you could in fact tell the story as written.
I've got the tall tree-limbs, if y'all bring the rope.