But you did not say "flat out" you haven't seen it. Perhaps you had and your statement was merely unclear and I misread it. You still haven't said "flat out" you haven't seen it, though the implication is certainly much clearer now. As for the "factual reports", you don't know how "factual" any report is or whether it has been tinted by bias. We are not talking about a criminal case here where a jury must rely on the accounts of witnesses who actually saw the crime. (Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable anyway.) We are talking about a film where you can easily determine the "facts" by viewing it yourself. How can you possibly say you like somethings and dislike somethings (as you do endlessly say) when you haven't seen the film? How can you possibly know whether the film falls short of, meets, or exceeds any norm (be the norm yours, rss691919's or anyone's) if you haven't seen it. I said: "I consider that opinion to have no foundation other than bias and therefore valueless." I am free to assign any value or merit to your opinion that I choose. Based on the evident fact that you haven't seen ROTK, I consider any opinions you have on it valuelesss. The fact that you choose to comment on it at all and primarily in a negative way leads me to place very little value on your opinion of the two films you have seen.joxy said:Isn't that near enough to saying flat out that I haven't seen ROTK, for anyone to get the implication without just "suspecting" it?!
Are you saying that the "factual reports that others have given here" are all biased, that I cannot rely on those others to have been truthful, and, therefore, that any opinions I reach on the basis of those reports are "valueless"?
I said nothing about you or anyone with similar opinions to you wasting their money. You stated:joxy said:That's telling you that I do NOT dislike the films, and therefore your point about me, and anyone with similar opinions to mine, wasting their money, is irrelevant.
In my experience, people rarely voluntarily, repeatedly, spend money on things they dislike. I asked if in your experience they do. If you are upset about my quip about the English, I am sorry, it was not meant to be insulting, merely humorous -- I am a quarter English myself. As for your dislike of the films, it seems quite apparent to someone who reads more than a handful of your posts. You constantly say you like somethings about the films and dislike others, but you are rarely specific about any "likes". On the other hand you go on seemingly endlessly, on many different threads, about a few barrels that have no relevance whatsoever to the story. You repeatedly cite what your refer to as "instances" of incompetence by Jackson, et al. I have also cited instances when you referred to Jackson as a "porn artist" and a "con artist". Your continual claims not to dislike the films in the face of your evident attitude to the contrary seem specious at best.joxy said:nor is it relevant if they choose to see them several times.
Last edited:
