Gandalf The Grey
Visionary Spirit
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2003
- Messages
- 180
The following quote comes from the February 2004 issue of The Catholic World Report, from an article by Steven D. Greydanus called "Mission Complete -- Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings: What it did and didn't accomplish."
It is important to note that I am only quoting the final two paragraphs of the article. The scope of the article critiques everything from "faithfulness to the text" to "the Catholic vision" to "religious imagery" to "Jackson's vision, too" to "errors that devalue the characters." Given the article's depth and complexity, I would consider it virtually a must to read the article in its entirety in order to see the quote in its full and proper context.
It is important to note that I am only quoting the final two paragraphs of the article. The scope of the article critiques everything from "faithfulness to the text" to "the Catholic vision" to "religious imagery" to "Jackson's vision, too" to "errors that devalue the characters." Given the article's depth and complexity, I would consider it virtually a must to read the article in its entirety in order to see the quote in its full and proper context.
After seeing The Return of the King, I reread an article I had written earlier in which I characterized Tolkien's climax this way: 'two central characters struggling with evil both succumb, yet in the conflict of their evil wills not evil but good is served.' That description still applies to the scene as Jackson filmed it. The essential meaning remains intact.
The Lord of the Rings film trilogy is an extraordinary cinematic tribute to a great work of Catholic imagination. While not equaling the religious vision of the books, the films honor that vision in a way that Christian viewers can appreciate, and that for non-Christian postmoderns may represent a rare encounter with an unironic vision of good and evil, a moral vision of evil as derivative of good and of the everpresent human susceptibility to temptation. In the landscape of modern Hollywood, The Lord of the Rings is a rare beacon of light.
-- Steven D. Greydanus
The Catholic World Report
February 2004
