• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

The following quote comes from the February 2004 issue of The Catholic World Report, from an article by Steven D. Greydanus called "Mission Complete -- Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings: What it did and didn't accomplish."

It is important to note that I am only quoting the final two paragraphs of the article. The scope of the article critiques everything from "faithfulness to the text" to "the Catholic vision" to "religious imagery" to "Jackson's vision, too" to "errors that devalue the characters." Given the article's depth and complexity, I would consider it virtually a must to read the article in its entirety in order to see the quote in its full and proper context.

After seeing The Return of the King, I reread an article I had written earlier in which I characterized Tolkien's climax this way: 'two central characters struggling with evil both succumb, yet in the conflict of their evil wills not evil but good is served.' That description still applies to the scene as Jackson filmed it. The essential meaning remains intact.

The Lord of the Rings film trilogy is an extraordinary cinematic tribute to a great work of Catholic imagination. While not equaling the religious vision of the books, the films honor that vision in a way that Christian viewers can appreciate, and that for non-Christian postmoderns may represent a rare encounter with an unironic vision of good and evil, a moral vision of evil as derivative of good and of the everpresent human susceptibility to temptation. In the landscape of modern Hollywood, The Lord of the Rings is a rare beacon of light.

-- Steven D. Greydanus
The Catholic World Report
February 2004
 
Greenwood said:
....stop wasting my time.
Aragil has given you examples before as have I,
....here again are some simple ones: From the first page of MY God It Was Horrible:
You might also try looking at the first page of this thread.
posting the examples over and over
A person being accused of being mindless for their enjoyment of the films is an attack, whether you will recognize it as such or not.
As is her condescension.
Wasting YOUR time?!?!
Do you think this thread, or this area of the forum, is entirely for YOUR benefit, and use? There are numerous other contributors here, you know, and many of them share many of my opinions, and are happy to share their time with me; they are maybe just a little less vocal than you are.
I have traced two examples from Aragil and have responded to them.
You say you offer SOME simple examples, but offer ONE, the first page of this thread.
I know, and everyone knows, that this thread is the third part of a set of wildly over-the-top entries by Beorn. No-one takes his ideas seriously, and as far as I can recall, from the 41 pages of postings which followed his absurd initial one, no-one has expressed themselves in anything close to his level of heightened language.
I have NOT seen you, or anyone else, posting examples "over and over". It's possible I might have missed them; do you read
EVERY posting on ALL the threads? It would have been a simple matter of courtesy to point me to them when the questions arose.
Aragil HAS pointed me to the "mindless" reference, and I DO recognise it for what it is, an inappropriate comment.
I have actually had several disagreements with Mrs M, but I have never found her attitude "condescending"; she seems to me always to take great care to write with precision, and with respect for others, whether they share her opinions or not.
 
Last edited:
Gandalf The Grey said:
I would consider it virtually a must to read the article in its entirety in order to see the quote in its full and proper context.
I take your point about needing to set the paragraphs in the context of the complete article, but I must comment, as a Catholic, that I consider the phrase "extraordinary cinematic tribute to a great work of Catholic imagination" and "the religious vision of the books" as a gross exaggeration in both respects. I have never taken the books anywhere near as seriously as that, and therefore the idea of the films as a "tribute" is one that seems quite inappropriate.
The books tell a good story; the films are entertaining; that's enough for me. I'll keep looking elsewhere for education in my faith.
 
And how would you reword the phrase, joxy? :)

EDIT:

I see you've edited your post ... and you seem to have answered my question. * nod of acknowledgement *
 
Gandalf The Grey said:
And how would you reword the phrase, joxy? :)
The "tribute" phrase?
"The films are a reasonably good and entertaining cinematic rendering of the enjoyable books"
 
joxy said:
And this is where you go wrong again: in your "implying". You should be more careful what you "imply" from what you read. Mrs M writes in very clear and precise language, saying exactly what she means, and no more, and leaves no room for implications. I see NONE of the implications you take from those comments. There's nothing sanctimonious about Mrs M, or condescending; she is amazingly patient in the face of some extraordinarily unpleasant and totally unjustifiable comments made against her.
I could say the same for myself!
Hold up, joxy. Mrs. Maggott said:
Mrs. Maggott said:
You have chosen to embrace the appearance, the form, over the meaning or the substance of what is being told - and that' s fine if you are satisfied with it. For me, I find horses and castles and c.g. monsters do not in and of themselves tell the story. They are its setting, not its heart and soul.
To me this certainly appears to be saying the following: "Greenwood enjoys the setting of LotR. The setting is separate from the hear and soul of LotR. Mrs. Maggott likes the books but dislikes the movies because she likes the heart and sould of the books, which the movies missed."

I agree that Mrs. Maggott is quite clear in what she says, but it appears that what Greenwood and I have understood is difficult to reconcile with what you understood. I do not think that I only appreciate the 'form' of LotR- in fact, to that end I have desperately tried to engage purists and other in discussion of the themes of the work (see here). I had (with the help of others) posited some themes of the work, demonstrated where they occurred in the books, and then listed where they occurred (and in some cases how they were enhanced) in the movies.
I CERTAINLY don't think of myself as someone who only looks for the "form" of LotR- I believe I love (not a typo) it for its heart and soul, and I'm sure Greenwood does as well. Therefore, when Mrs. Maggot tells us that we only go for the setting and miss the heart of the matter, we find it fairly insulting, and indeed condescending.
 
joxy said:
Wasting YOUR time?!?!
Do you think this thread, or this area of the forum, is entirely for YOUR benefit, and use? There are numerous other contributors here, you know, and many of them share many of my opinions, and are happy to share their time with me; they are maybe just a little less vocal than you are.
I have traced 2 examples from Aragil and have responded to them.
You offer SOME simple ones, and offer one, the first page of this thread.
I know, and everyone knows, that this thread is the third part of a set of wildly over-the-top entries by Beorn. No-one takes his ideas seriously, and as far as I can recall, from the 41 pages of postings which followed his absurd initial one, no-one has expressed themselves in anything close to his level of heightened language.
I have NOT seen you, or anyone else, posting examples "over and over". It's possible I might have missed them; do you read
EVERY posting on ALL the threads? It would have been a simple matter of courtesy to point me to them when the questions arose.
Aragil HAS pointed me to the "mindless" reference, and I DO recognise it for what it is, an inappropriate comment.
I have actually had several disagreements with Mrs M, but I have never found her attitude "condescending"; she seems to me always to take great care to write with precision, and with respect for others, whether they share her opinions or not.

Aragil and I have posted examples to which your standard replies are things like: that is an old comment; everyone knows that person is over-the-top; that was inappropriate, but it was only one person's comment. Times goes by, we face the same attitudes and point them out and you jump in with your usual: Nobody ever said that, give me examples line. Then a new person comes on the Forum and makes the same observations (as happened recently) and you are right there with your protests that it never happened.

You don't like that I said SOME examples and only gave one, well here is another (it can be found here :
Blue Wizard said:
As for Peter's utterance of "staying true to the book". The only argument I have heard by the way that leads credence to any of this bickering back and forth, well, all I can say is Peter lied to you all.

Finally, I may disagree with a lot of what Mrs. Maggott says and how she says it, but I respect her intelligence and her ability to defend herself. She does not need you to constantly leap to her defense, especially when she is much better at it.
 
Greenwood said:
Aragil and I have posted examples to which your standard replies are things like: that is an old comment; everyone knows that person is over-the-top; that was inappropriate, but it was only one person's comment. Times goes by, we face the same attitudes and point them out and you jump in with your usual: Nobody ever said that, give me examples line. Then a new person comes on the Forum and makes the same observations (as happened recently) and you are right there with your protests that it never happened.
....especially when she is much better at it.
"Examples" and "One person's comment". If you've given more than one example, from more than one person, from more than Beorn's initial nonsense, then obviously I would NOT say "it was only ONE person's comment".
So, it's "attitudes" we're talking about now, and you've seen them the same as Beorn's nonsense? I haven't. And "observations", and a new person comes on and makes the same ones as Beorn's? I didn't see it. As I said, I don't read everything on the forums; if I miss something and then ask a question to which the answer is in the something I missed then it would only be courteous to supply the appropriate reference. You've just done that with Blue Wizard's incoherent sentence. I can't work out what he was actually referring to, but he did come right out with "PJ lied", and if he can't be specific about it, then he should withdraw it.
Don't tell me that I "protest that it never happened" about something that did happen.
Ouch; you really hurt me with that dig about my inferior standard of defensive qualities! :D
 
joxy said:
I take your point about needing to set the paragraphs in the context of the complete article, but I must comment, as a Catholic, that I consider the phrase "extraordinary cinematic tribute to a great work of Catholic imagination" and "the religious vision of the books" as a gross exaggeration in both respects. I have never taken the books anywhere near as seriously as that, and therefore the idea of the films as a "tribute" is one that seems quite inappropriate.
The books tell a good story; the films are entertaining; that's enough for me. I'll keep looking elsewhere for education in my faith.

Greetings, joxy,

Two questions:

1) Do you then disagree with the good Professor Tolkien's quoted statement below that the Lord of the Rings does indeed contain a religious vision?

Letter# 142: "The Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision. That is why I have not put in, or have cut out, practically all references to anything like "religion', to cults or practices, in the imaginary world. For the religious element is absorbed into the story and the symbolism." --- J.R.R. Tolkien

2) Do you also disagree with the following statement taken from an interview with James Caviezel, who portrayed Jesus in Mel Gibson's film The Passion of the Christ?

Many a great stories that you see including the Lord of the Rings, are inspired from this story.

"This story" of course referring to the story of Christ's passion.
 
Gandalf The Grey said:
Do you then disagree with the good Professor Tolkien's....
Do you also disagree with the following statement.....
I repeat what I said: I don't take the books as seriously as that, and the same applies to the films. As far as I know about Gibson's film, I'm pretty sure I shan't take that seriously either, even though it has been widely praised by an Archbishop, no less!
I enjoy the versions of TLOTR story as entertainment, and I look for my religious inspiration and vision in other areas.
Other people's ideas about them are interesting, especially Tolkien's of course, but they are not relevant to my use of them.
 
joxy said:
And "observations", and a new person comes on and makes the same ones as Beorn's? I didn't see it. As I said, I don't read everything on the forums; if I miss something and then ask a question to which the answer is in the something I missed then it would only be courteous to supply the appropriate reference. You've just done that with Blue Wizard's incoherent sentence. I can't work out what he was actually referring to, but he did come right out with "PJ lied", and if he can't be specific about it, then he should withdraw it.

NOT the same observations as Beorn's! The same observations of the many of us who complain about the criticisms of some of the purists. And since I KNOW you are going to demand an example, just look back in this thread to Post #330 by Rowan Evensong. In fact I will save you the trouble and just plae her comments here:
Rowan Evensong said:
I think many purists did indeed go expecting to hate the movies. In fact, I know some that have said so, and others that expressed great sorrow the movies were even made, before their release even. Perhaps better put, many went with a mental tally sheet in their heads, waiting to pounce upon the films and catalogue every instance where the movie divurged from the book. As the movies went on, they gleefully began to compose their critiques. Only you can know your own heart and know if you were one of them.

Where the movies perfect adaptations? Heavens no, nor would any sensible Tolkien fan claim they were. They were simply one man's best attempt to translate HIS interpretation of the book of the 20th century to an entirely different medium. A daunting task to say the least, and one Tolkien fans ought to have the good grace to thank him (and the studio that placed an awful lot of faith and money in him) for doing. Would you have made a different movie? Of course! Do you think that every reader of Tolkien has the same experience upon reading it? Of course they do not. Jackson's movie was based on what HE experienced from reading the books, and what he believed could be translated to a much shallower medium.

The question this all begs then, is DID he "capture the magic" of Tolkien? I say he did. The movies, just like the books, have to be viewed in a larger context than a scene by scene comparison. I thought for the most part, overall characterizations were good and accurate. There were some exceptions, obviously. I guess its up to each person to decide for themselves whether they wanted to focus on the 90% of the movies that worked, versus the 10% that didn't really fit well.

I'm a newcomer to this board, so let me relate to you how this thread appears to someone just newly arrived. It looks like a bunch of people that some how feel threatened by the movies, that somehow the movie adaptations diminish the books in some way. Nothing could be furthur from the truth. Lord of the Rings is my favorite "book" and it is now also my favorite movie trilogy. Neither are perfect. Both are beautiful and special in their own unique way. I consider the book a greater achievement, but literature will always be a superior medium to film. There are so many fewer restrictions.

(emphasis added)

And what do we find four posts later:
joxy said:
I've been here quite a while and I've never seen anything to suggest these ideas of yours about people feeling "threatened by
the films" or that "the adaptations diminish the books". I'd very much like to know what has made it "look" that way to you.
How could these, or any other, films, "threaten", or have any other deleterious effect on the books; how could they "diminish" them? The idea is absurd.
The furthest we go in criticising the films is to say that they partly good, and partly bad; what product could expect better than that?! Of course, we also say that, for $300million it should have been easy to make a larger part of the good, leaving only a tiny part bad, but PJ's fans seem to think he couldn't have done better if he'd tried.
It's hard to believe that "many purists did indeed go expecting to hate the movies" and that "in fact, I know some that have said so", but I must take your word for it.
I was going to add that the word "hate" is totally inappropriate here, that no-one ever expresses it against the films. Unfortunately one instance has crept in today, but I invite you to take my word for it that this was a first, and, I am sure, a one-off occasion.
My personal take on the idea of "hatred", which I've expressed here before, is that it is far to strong an emotion to apply to anything as trivial as a film; and that I will consider it as a "personal attack" if I find it ascribed to me.

Long time members of the forum, new members, many people except some purists see and react to the ceaseless moanings of a few of the purists, but whenever they point them out they can count on joxy to jump in and say "I have never seen it! Give me examples!" And when you do joxy dismisses them. Then the next person comments about the purists and joxy once again jumps in: "I have never seen it! Give me examples!"
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
I repeat what I said: I don't take the books as seriously as that, and the same applies to the films. .....
I enjoy the versions of TLOTR story as entertainment, and I look for my religious inspiration and vision in other areas.

We have finally found a point of agreement!!!!

But for someone with that point of view you are amazingly quick to leap to the defense of Mrs. Maggott's constant efforts to treat LOTR as a religious text. :confused:
 
joxy said:
Jackson has NOT been "subjected" to any personal, or any other kind of, "vilification". The suggestion is absurd.
People who have enjoyed the films, who include ME among their honourable ranks, have NOT been "subjected" to any "attacks". The suggestion is absurd.
Can't you see the difference between "criticism", in the strict sense of the word, and "vilification" and "attacks"??
And this is where you go wrong again: in your "implying". You should be more careful what you "imply" from what you read. Mrs M writes in very clear and precise language, saying exactly what she means, and no more, and leaves no room for implications. I see NONE of the implications you take from those comments. There's nothing sanctimonious about Mrs M, or condescending; she is amazingly patient in the face of some extraordinarily unpleasant and totally unjustifiable comments made against her.
I could say the same for myself!

Still speaking for others? What is it that you don't "get" about that?
 
Greenwood said:
We have finally found a point of agreement!!!!

But for someone with that point of view you are amazingly quick to leap to the defense of Mrs. Maggott's constant efforts to treat LOTR as a religious text. :confused:
I realize that this is just more wasting of time and effort, but I had to comment on the above: if you cannot tell the difference between someone speaking about the AUTHOR'S intentions and the poster's personal beliefs, then I am quite right in my conclusion and trying to enlighten you is a total waste of my time.

However, just to give you something else to misunderstand, the following is from the March 3rd column by the ultimate Hollywood "insider", Liz Smith. I hope for those of you who labor under the delusion that all those shiny awards actually mean something to the movers and shakers in Tinseltown, this will provide you with a dose of reality. For like most of those in the "in crowd", Ms. Smith does not operate in a vacuum. When she expresses an "opinion", you may be absolutely sure that she is speaking for a considerable group within the Hollywood establishment - or she wouldn't say it! She is a "follower", not a "leader" for all of her pretense otherwise:

THE OSCARS: I don't know which I disliked more - the overemphasis, now seized on by every facet of the media, to show fashion as if it were a new religion, or the crazy-looking New Zealanders who won everything but couldn't bother to trim their hair and looked as if they hadn't washed or even knew how to button their shirts.

The contrast between these wooly Kiwis and Hollywood's bejeweled and overbosomed elite was disconcerting. I don't know which group was more irritating. Possibly, for the sake of time, it would have helped to put Peter Jackson's "Rings" gang down front, since the academy knew they'd be going up to the podium over and over. Maybe they should have separated them from one another, so we didn't have to watch all their group kissing every time they won another Oscar. (Yes, the Kiwis have a lovable al fresco quality. I'm sure they're nice and talented, but I still think the movie they made is for adolescent boys and, as a fantasy, will never be remembered like other classic movie fantasies such as "The Wizard of Oz.") <quote Liz Smith>


I would suggest that FADs read her (and her Hollywood patrons') succinct summation of these films as something "...made for adolescent boys and as a fantasy, will never be remembered like other classic movie fantasies such as "The Wizard of Oz." Tolkien as an author, was far beyond "Wizard" creator L. Frank Baum, nice fellow that he was. Furthermore, "Wizard" was in fact, a children's story and had none of the glorious special effects available to it at the time of its release. So we might suspect that the unfavorable comparison does not lie entirely with the source material but does have something to do with the films themselves. After all, it seems to be a reasonable conclusion, but then when is "reason" a criteria when speaking about these films?

However, you may now rejoice, for this is my last post on the film threads. I know that it's time to go when I get more enjoyment out of transcribing Workers Compensation cases and closing statements than I do participating here.

Good luck and God bless. Oh, I beg your pardon. Such political incorrectness! :rolleyes: :eek: :D
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
I realize that this is just more wasting of time and effort, but I had to comment on the above: if you cannot tell the difference between someone speaking about the AUTHOR'S intentions and the poster's personal beliefs, then I am quite right in my conclusion and trying to enlighten you is a total waste of my time.

However, just to give you something else to misunderstand, the following is from the March 3rd column by the ultimate Hollywood "insider", Liz Smith. I hope for those of you who labor under the delusion that all those shiny awards actually mean something to the movers and shakers in Tinseltown, this will provide you with a dose of reality. For like most of those in the "in crowd", Ms. Smith does not operate in a vacuum. When she expresses an "opinion", you may be absolutely sure that she is speaking for a considerable group within the Hollywood establishment - or she wouldn't say it! She is a "follower", not a "leader" for all of her pretense otherwise:

......

I would suggest that FADs read her (and her Hollywood patrons') succinct summation of these films as something "...made for adolescent boys and as a fantasy, will never be remembered like other classic movie fantasies such as "The Wizard of Oz." Tolkien as an author, was far beyond "Wizard" creator L. Frank Baum, nice fellow that he was. Furthermore, "Wizard" was in fact, a children's story and had none of the glorious special effects available to it at the time of its release. So we might suspect that the unfavorable comparison does not lie entirely with the source material but does have something to do with the films themselves. After all, it seems to be a reasonable conclusion, but then when is "reason" a criteria when speaking about these films?

However, you may now rejoice, for this is my last post on the film threads. I know that it's time to go when I get more enjoyment out of transcribing Workers Compensation cases and closing statements than I do participating here.

I think most of us can tell the difference between the author's (JRRT's) intentions and a poster's personal beliefs, my problem with many of your posts is that (IMO) you seem to have great difficulty in separating JRRT's intentions from your personal beliefs.

Liz Smith!!!??? A gossip columnist like Liz Smith is your authority that you are placing over the assembled votes of the Motion Picture Academy of Arts and Sciences??!! You might as well cite Mr. Blackwell as the ultimate arbiter of high fashion.

As for your comments on The Wizard of Oz (yes, a classic) not having any glorious special effects available to it at the time of its release you show a rather complete lack of historical perspective. The Wizard of Oz had some of the most up-to-date special effects of its day, including what was one of the most spectacular at the time -- color!! Ever see the film? Kansas is in black-and-white and Oz is in spectacular color.
 
Greenwood said:
NOT the same observations as Beorn's! The same observations of the many of us!
I misunderstood you then. You were talking about Beorn and anyone like him, and your next sentence was about "a new person who had come on to the forums"; I thought you meant the sort of person we had just been talking about. Maybe quoting postings #numbers would avoid that kind of misunderstanding.
Now to your point, and let's see if I've understood what you're saying this time, about the quotation from Rowan and my response to it. Rowan had come fresh to the forums and had found what "looks like a bunch of people that some how feel threatened by the movies, that somehow the movie adaptations diminish the books in some way". My response was that this impression was, in my opinion, incorrect, and I tried to explain my opinion, as one of those who do not believe that the films are as good as they could have been. As Rowan had mentioned the word "hate", I pointed out that this was normally an inappropriate word here, but that, unfortunately, an exceptional instance had just appeared; and I went on to express the hope that Rowan would accept that this was indeed an exceptional case of inappropriate language. I did not ask for any examples of specific postings which had aroused Rowan's original impressions, or for any further comments on the cause for those impressions; and I don't recall whether Rowan replied to me and offered any examples. I would be interested to know what Rowan's current impressions are of postings, from those of all shades of opinion.
 
Greenwood said:
We have finally found a point of agreement!!!!
....the defense of Mrs. Maggott's constant efforts to treat LOTR as a religious text. :confused:
Agreement indeed, and in an area much more important than most of the topics that get considered here!
To keep the agreement going, can you point me to any instance when I have even mentioned Mrs M's "effort to treat LOTR as a religious text"? I normally make a point of not discussing religion at all - it's an English thing, we don't discuss religion or politics in polite company! - and I don't recall being persuaded to do so by anything from Mrs M, or from anyone else, until yesterday!
 
joxy said:
Agreement indeed, and in an area much more important than most of the topics that get considered here!
To keep the agreement going, can you point me to any instance when I have even mentioned Mrs M's "effort to treat LOTR as a religious text"? I normally make a point of not discussing religion at all - it's an English thing, we don't discuss religion or politics in polite company! - and I don't recall being persuaded to do so by anything from Mrs M, or from anyone else, until yesterday!

Mrs. M's personal view of the religious nature of the "true meaning" of LOTR has been a constant theme of most of her posts and most of her criticisms of the films. Just try a search of her posts using words like "moral" and "morality" and "Christological" and see how many of her posts come up. Of late you have been quite active in supporting her. This certainly lends an appearance of your supporting her core positions. However, since Mrs. M says that she will no longer be posting on the movie forum, in fairness to her, I do not wish to get into a discussion, pro or con, of her positions.
 
Greenwood said:
....the religious nature....words like "moral" and "morality"
and "Christological".
I don't equate "religion" with "morals" and "morality", in either direction!
"Christological" has to join the list of those postings I have sadly missed, and which I can't expect anyone to point out to me, as such things are too much to ask around here. :cool:
 
"Christological" posts of Mrs. Maggott to be found here.

joxy- That's a link- simply click on it and you will be taken to a list of 9 different postings by MM which use the term "Cristological". In three of those posts you will find that you yourself responded within five posts of MM's use of the term.

Perhaps you are unaware of the search engine imbedded in the vBulletin software here. It is quite nice, and a huge improvement over previous versions (though it now appears to be limited to returning 'only' 500 entries). If you have heard reports of anything, you can quite easily check for yourself by using the search engine, rather than asking others to look for you (polite as they might be in obliging you). You are allowed to search on words used in a post, time of a post, user name making the post, or any combination of those three. Using this feature might save exasperation on the part of those who are always asked to point out where you might have missed something.
 

Today's events

Back
Top