aragil said:
My view is that the "hand of
the One" is seldom felt in LotR- perhaps in an event like
Gollum stumbling. If the whole of
events in
Arda are supposed to play out to his glory, then I would not find it very glorifying if he is consistently loading the dice.
True, I can agree that the One is not seen in LotR very much--if by seen you mean that it is not physically present in the text. But we know that
Gandalf has been sent from the West; we know that after his death, he is "sent back", and it is made clear by
Tolkien that he was sent back by
Iluvatar. More importantly, the idea of "happy chance" as you call it, is rejected throughout the text.
Bilbo was
meant to find
the Ring,
Frodo was
meant to bear it, Gandalf was
meant to lead them.
Of course, in the
realm of reality a simple shift of wind or a fifteen minute delay might have changed the unfolding of events. But we are not dealing with reality; we are dealing with literature. And Tolkien--as literary artist (and subcreator)--has the right and ability to sculpt his tale to his own choosing.
Thus, there
is no shift in the wind or fifteen minute delay. The
Rohirrim arrive at just the moment they are most sorely needed, and it is not a matter of happy chance, but the climax of a chain of events set into motion by Gandalf.
aragil said:
I think I agree with the professor's letter in quite a different sentiment than you do- what is striking to me is the non-necessity of the confrontation. Gandalf is there, but the strength of the mortals is enough that the confrontation never develops beyond verbal sparring. Being a
Maia, I'm sure he is quite capable of (again) battling the
Witch King, but it is not his fight. Gandalf inspires the West to fight- he does not combat
Sauron alone.
Again, true. The focus of this letter as a whole is indeed upon the nature of Gandalf, and the manner in which he inspires the West to resist. But it is crucial to the narrative that Gandalf is the being who "has kindled and organized" that resistance--and done it so skillfully and powerfully that he can leave the battle to other hands and focus his efforts to saving
Faramir from the madness of his father.
aragil said:
In that respect I think that the emphasis of the movie is quite correctly placed- the forces of the West (represented by the Rohirrim) in apposition to the forces of
Mordor, NOT Maia vs.
Nazgul.
I could agree with you but for
the simple fact that Tolkien chose to emphasize the confrontation between the two, while the battle is mostly a backdrop. Again, this is partially a literary effect: focus on the characters rather than the massive
armies and their massive
battles. Jackson, not surprisingly, chooses to emphasize the latter--when he could have had both!!
aragil said:
Sidestepping the last line of
Theoden's verse (personally I thought he was chanting for the death he'd unleash on the
Orcs, not his own), in my opinion the horns at cockcrow came through in the movie as they came through in the book- at the lowest point.
You'll have to forgive my imperfect memory of the movie, having seen it only once unfortunately, but my recollection is that the Horns are heard somewhat
in medias res--that is, they are heard as the battle rages on; there is no momentous pause after which the tide of the battle turns in a heartbeat. Is this so?
As for the last line of Theoden's "speech", it is without a doubt lifted from
Eomer's raving after seeing his sister dead on the field. And without a doubt, Eomer (in the book) is calling upon his Riders to lead a charge that will bring ALL to death: "Death, death, death! Death takes us all!" and "Ride, ride to ruin and the world's ending!" If you submit that Theoden's co-opting of that line is now meant to imply death to the Orcs, then Jackson and his writers have taken Tolkien's writing and altered its meaning in giving the line to a different character. That's a notion that has been heavily resisted by many in this forum.
aragil said:
By "sheer scale" I did not mean that the forces of the Rohirrim were so large that they could not be stopped- I meant that however many thousands of Orcs were still no match for a full charge of 6000+ cavalry. That fact is as true in the
books as it is in the film. The initial onset (in the books) catches the Northern half of the Pelannor by surprise, but the momentum of the charge carries through almost to the
Anduin. Even the forces of Mordor that were further to the South, who had time to recover from the surprise of the assault, even they were pushed back from the gates. The only thing that saved Mordor in the books (and in the films) were the
Oliphaunts, which allowed for pockets of troops to hold out against the charge, absorb the energy of the charge, and then slowly force the Rohirrim back with overwhelming numbers.
Ah, but those thosands upon thousands of Orcs were indeed more than a match for the Rohirrim! Again, there is a literary force here at work that alters tactics and strategy in the way that we would usually think of them. The wrath of Theoden--likened to
Orome the Great, fey, battle-fury coursing through his veins--sends the armies of Mordor into total disarray. This disarray, however, is only temporary. The
Haradrim initially rally their forces against Theoden, but his fury is still hot enough to win that encounter. At Theoden's death, then Eomer's fury in turn overthrows the fore of the Enemy's lines. However, as the Haradrim realize they have strength in numbers, they rally around
Mumakil (as you point out). But embedded in the battle tactics is this notion that the "battle-fury" of the Rohirrim twice sends the Enemy into disarray, only to lose strength as the Enemy realizes its strength is the greater. And that is the important fact: the Enemy's strength is greater. It is then the surprise of their onset, coupled with the hotness of their fury, that allows the charge of the Rohirrim to succeed initially.
And even if you will rebuff that notion, there is this final point: in the book,
no Enemy had yet passed under the archway of the Gate of Minas Tirith. The
City, then, stands as a
symbol of the ultimate hope for victory--overthrown, weakened, at the brink of destruction--but in the end utterly indomitable. By allowing Orcs to rampage through the City, Jackson destroys that symbolism, and the arrival of the Rohirrim becomes just another last-second save that we have seen repeated in film with nauseating regularity.