• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Greenwood said:
Perhaps your constant denial of the nastiness and bashing that goes on against Jackson and the films is based on your lack of comprehension of the meaning of such words as denigration.
Perhaps your constant accusations of "bashing", and this new accusation of "nastiness" - definition please - are based on your lack of a sense of humour.
My comment on denigration was intended as low humour - just the sort of thing that Mr Jackson obviously loves and regularly throws at us, by way of the innocent channels of Gimli and others, throughout his magnum opus.
 
aragil said:
As long as we're on the subject joxy, what did you think of the charge of the Rohirrim? I thought it was brilliant and followed the books quite well. rs691919 thought otherwise. Mrs. Maggott roundly criticized it before seeing it, then quietly shifted her RotK criticism to Denethor afterwards. What's your opinion of this scene in particular?
aragil,

As with Mrs. Maggott when she was criticizing ROTK, joxy has not yet seen the film. That fact needs to be kept in mind in judging the value of any of joxy's comments about the movie.

Your last post reminded me I had been meaning to expand on my earlier comments on the Rohirrim's "suicidal" charge at the forces of Mordor. I did not mean that Theoden and the Rohirrim charged with the intention of dying. I meant they recognized they were tremendously overmatched in terms of numbers and realistically had little chance of success; it was suicidal in that sense. They charged anyway out of loyalty to their friends and allies and were fulfilling their oaths. This is completely in keeping with a key theme of the book and the movie of resisting evil and doing your best even when you have no realistic chance of success or even surviving. Theoden and the Rohirrim do not charge with the hope or expectation that they will succeed and be spared because they are fulfilling their oaths. They charge expecting the worst, but it does not matter. They are doing their best to fulfill their oaths and loyalty. I think comments Tolkien made in letter 192 of his published letters are applicable here though he was not talking about Rohan. In the letter Tolkien is discussing the events at Mount Doom and Frodo's failure to destroy the Ring, but that the Ring was nevertheless destroyed because Gollum was there as a direct result of Bilbo and Frodo earlier showing Gollum pity and sparing him. Tolkien writes: "In this case the cause (not the 'hero') was triumphant, because by the excercise of pity, mercy, and forgiveness of injury, a situation was produced in which all was redressed and disaster averted. Gandalf certainly foresaw this. See Vol 1, p. 68-9 ["Pity? It was pity that stayed {Bilbo's} hand. Pity, and Mercy: not to strike without need. And he has been well rewarded, Frodo. Be sure that he took so little hurt from the evil, and escaped in the end, because he began his ownership of the Ring so. With Pity."] Of course, he did not mean to say that one must be merciful, for it may prove useful later -- it would not then be mercy or pity, which are only truly present when contrary to prudence." I earlier compared Rohan's charge to the suicidal Charge of the Light Brigade, which was in fact a failure. I suspect I was unconsciously remembering a book I read about a year ago about the Battle of Leyte Gulf in the Phillipines in WWII. During the battle, which happened to take place on the anniversary of the Charge of the Light Brigade, small American escort destroyers and escort carriers charged directly at Japanese heavy cruisers and battleships (including the largest battleship in the world) in an effort to protect essentially defenseless troop ships. It was suicide and the captains of the small ships knew it.


(BTW, I felt as you did that the last line of Theoden's speech in the film was meant as calling down death on his enemies rather than on his own men. But I also think, as I outlined above, it meant that death did not matter to themselves.)
 
joxy said:
Perhaps your constant accusations of "bashing", and this new accusation of "nastiness" - definition please - are based on your lack of a sense of humour.
My comment on denigration was intended as low humour - just the sort of thing that Mr Jackson obviously loves and regularly throws at us, by way of the innocent channels of Gimli and others, throughout his magnum opus.

I can only surmise that your sense of humour is indeed of a very low sort. Nearly every time one of your ad hominem attacks on Jackson is pointed out ("porn artist", "con artist", negative comments on Jackson's appearance) your defense is it was only meant in jest. (For a definition of nastiness see "porn artist", "con artist", comments Jackson's weight, etc.)
 
joxy said:
Perhaps your constant accusations of "bashing", and this new accusation of "nastiness" - definition please -

"bashing" -- gaining unwelcome or invasive entrance by means of Grond or a similar weapon or activity; see also "Trollish behavior"

"nastiness" -- that which would be displeasing to Gollum

"Trollish behavior" -- something with which TTF would be far better off without

... and kindly allow me one more, out of alphabetical order though it be ...

"tongue in cheek" -- how I am currently smoking my pipe :p
 
and so what if it is?

Given the free and open nature of our beloved Forum, I really do have to wonder about all this weak-kneed wailing and gnashing of teeth over who may or may not "dislike" or choose to "denigrate" or even devote himself to heaping scorn as bitter as coloquintida upon the filmic efforts of the Kiwi Kaiser. Lord Peter the Barefoot himself, who has explicitly declared that he and his deservedly derogated duo of scriptwriting accomplices made their movies for "people who read the books ten years ago, not ten weeks ago" (so much for faithfulness and close attention to narrative detail), could quite demonstrably not care less, having his passel of Oscars and a huge pile of cash for consolation, not to mention the prospect of finally getting to wreak his second-hand cinema magic on an epic story that he really loves, an angry great ape and his trip to the city. As for the tender sensibilities of those Jacksonites who apparently take such ongoing offense at the notion that yon joxy doesn't like the film (no matter how often he denies it), or that rs691919 is arrogant in his persistent criticisms (depending at least in part on one's knowledge of Classical Greek), or simply that yer grumpy, obstreporous, and more flint-hearted purists will not, and stubbornly refuse to, be reconciled to the purported greatness of this box-office colossus, all I can say is "Boo-freaking-hoo!" That Mighty Montanan, the most erudite aragil (whom I tease in this fashion only because he knows how much I respect him) can labor away like the best-paid mobbed-up mouthpiece to explicate and justify the movies' numerous alterations, and Greenwood can lament until all the leaves in Eryn Lasgallen turn sere and yellow, but my own heart's mind (what we Chinese call hsin) is adamant and will not be persuaded. The New Line Cinema production of LOTR is indeed a pretty good movie, as overwrought CGI-thrill-ride blockbusters go, and I plunked down my money to see each episode twice in the theater, but it's not even close to being as good a movie as The Lord of the Rings is a book, not within a open league across the plains of Rohan; and everything which distinguishes its merit from that of feebler offerings like Star Wars is due directly ab ovo to the imagination of John Ronald Reuel Tolkien. Not least among the many enduring testaments to the wondrous strength of his Sub-creation is the fact that it survives unscathed by the feckless inventions of Fran, PJ, and Philippa.

Let the haughty gauntlet I here throw down
Be picked up by ye proudly ever-faithful FADs:
Convince some uncommitted & neutral TTF reader
(If such a hypothetical creature can in fact be found)
How Jackson's cinema is in any way an improvement
On that original Tale whose ransacked glories have
Made his present name and considerable fortune.

Eagerly awaiting your edifying and entertaining efforts. . .
 
Aldanil,

I would never attempt to convince anyone that Jackson's movies are better or an improvement on Tolkien's LOTR for the simple reason that I consider the very idea absurd. I personally believe the books will be read long after the movies have become quaint historical examples of the art of film-making at the turn of the 21st Century. I do think the films are great films and examples of current state-of-the-art film-making, but I don't consider them timeless the way I think the books are. I agree with you that most of the best moments in the films are when Jackson most closely follows the books. I take no offense at anyone disliking the films. Anyone has every right to dislike them. I will, however, continue to point out the hypocrisy of denying a dislike of the films, while taking every opportunity to bash them even to the point of criticizing something that hasn't been seen. I dislike hypocrisy about as much as I dislike pomposity and hubris ;) and enjoy holding a mirror up to them. One of the things I most appreciate about these films are the probably millions of people who have been introduced to Tolkien through them. I hate the feeling I get that many of these new discoverers of Tolkien come searching for more information about Middle Earth and Tolkien and are confronted with hypocritical, arrogant, self-appointed defenders of Tolkien purity who imply, or even state, that they are mindless and fools for liking the films. I think these new fans should be welcomed. They can be politely told how the movies are different from the books and helped to a greater understanding of the world of Middle Earth. This is not accomplished through ad hominem attacks, hypocrisy and arrogance. My regrets if I disappoint by being neither edifying nor entertaining. :(
 
need Greenwood regret?

Quite the contrary, noble forest! Your balanced perspective is eminently reasonable, though I think sometimes pomposity -- an accusation of which my own windy and thin-witted manner has never prompted, of course -- is in the ear of the beholder [behearer?], and not everyone enjoys having a mirror thrust in his face. So self-admiring a stylist as myself, in contrast. . .

I too welcome the notion of millions of new readers being introduced to Middle-earth by the enormous commercial success of these movies, although I have been on numerous occasions troubled by the comments of those, even on this Forum, who don't seem able or willing to recognize that abiding superiority of original over adaptation that you (so rightfully, IMNSHO) acknowledge. The moderator, for example, who characterizes grumpy old Tolkien as the ultimate Nit-Picking Weenie, "worse than Mrs. Maggott and joxy combined"; more than enough to make a fellow blow lembas, if you ask me. Luckily, no one has!
 
Greenwood said:
....joxy has not yet seen the film. That fact needs to be kept in mind in judging the value of any of joxy's comments about the movie.
Which is what I was about to say in response to Aragil's polite request to me.
As I mentioned not long ago I make few comments on ROTK, and when I do make them they relate specifically to reports I have seen here from people who have seen the films, reports which I am happy to believe to be truthful. The value of those rare comments is therefore directly related to the value of those reports, which I am happy to rate highly.

Greenwood said:
1> I personally believe the books will be read long after the movies have become quaint historical examples....
2> I agree with you that most of the best moments in the films are when Jackson most closely follows the books.
3> I take no offense at anyone disliking the films. Anyone has every right to dislike them.
4> I will, however, continue to point out the hypocrisy of denying a dislike of the films, while taking every opportunity to bash them even to the point of criticizing something that hasn't been seen.
5> I hate the feeling I get that many of these new discoverers of Tolkien come searching for more information about Middle Earth and Tolkien and are confronted with hypocritical, arrogant, self-appointed defenders of Tolkien purity who imply, or even state, that they are mindless and fools for liking the films. I think these new fans should be welcomed.
6> They can be politely told how the movies are different from the books and helped to a greater understanding of the world of Middle Earth.
7> This is not accomplished through ad hominem attacks, hypocrisy and arrogance.

1> That's so generous and condescending of you. Are you related at all to Lady Catherine de Bourgh?
2> And I agree with you that they are. I've often said so, as well saying that I also like some of Jackson's inventions.
3> See 1>
4> If there was any "bashing", and if commenting on factual reports rather than on first-hand viewing was a flawed procedure, then I would accept your gratuitous accusation of hypocrisy. However I refute the conditions, and therefore decline the appellation.
5> Many more conditions here: if the "defenders" were "hypocritical" and "arrogant", if their being "self-appointed" were relevant, if they made implications or statements that those who like the films - in which group of people they themselves are included - are "mindless" and "fools", then your "hate" - a most inappropriate emotion for such a trivial matter - for the feeling you experience might be justified.
6> Certainly we, all of us, may offer that specific help, of pointing out the differences between the films and the books, though again I detect a whiff of superiority in the idea of helping "towards a greater understanding of the world of Middle earth".
7> Let's take these one at a time:
"ad hominem" and "attacks":
Is that "relating to a particular person" or "directed against a person rather than the position they are maintaining"?
Are comments about a person and his abilities automatically "attacks"?
Mr Jackson is a public personality, a celebrity, obviously and quite rightly proud of the fact. He chooses to behave in certain idiosyncratic ways, and to present a certain idiosyncratic personal appearance and mode of behaviour. Those factors of his personality are therefore in the public domain, and are open to comment. I am sure that, rather than resenting such comment,
he would welcome it.
"hypocrisy": see 5> and also please note the comment I have to repeat yet again - that to dislike part of something is not to dislike all of it - that's logic, or common sense, not hypocrisy.
"arrogance": like charity, begins at home.
 
Last edited:
Aldanil,

I agree pomposity is in the eye/ear of the beholder, but I think a beholder is more likely to perceive it (perhaps incorrectly) in opinions that are expressed with extreme arrogance.


joxy said:
As I mentioned not long ago I make few comments on ROTK, and when I do make them they relate specifically to reports I have seen here from people who have seen the films, reports which I am happy to believe to be truthful. The value of those rare comments is therefore directly related to the value of those reports, which I am happy to rate highly.
joxy,

You constantly make a point of believing reports that you say are truthful, but the point is not one of truthfulness. The point is accuracy. Since you have haven't seen the film you have no way of judging the accuracy of the reports you base your comments on. For example let's look at the "grievances" listed in the post that started this thread.
Beorn said:
1. Saruman? Who's that?
2. ...At least we know for sure now that Eowyn killed The Witch King
3. Frodo broke up with Sam
4. The Shire wasn't scoured
5. Lothlorien wasn't sacked
6. Eowyn cut off a Nazgul's head (retracted)
7. There are only 6 levels of M.T.
8. The white tree wasn't replaced
9. Denethor went flying like his own molotov cocktail...
Taking the "grievances" in order:

1. False. Saruman is dealt with in ROTK, even if he does not appear.
2. True. But she killed him in the book also, so this is only about 50% accurate.
3. True.
4. True.
5. True. But Lothlorien wasn't sacked in the book either, so this is only about 50% accurate.
6. False. So false it was relatively quickly retracted.
7. False. A forum member posted a still showing this was false.
8. False. Well, sort of true in that the tree is not shown being replaced, but it is shown in bloom at the coronation. I'll be generous an give it a 25% accurate rating.
9. True.

Thus, the "grievances" have an overall accuracy of less than 50%. That is the problem with basing one's criticisms on secondhand reports. Also it is irrelevant how "few" comments you make on ROTK. You followed exactly the same pattern on TTT of complaining about it for months before you actually saw the film. In fact I can't even tell from your complaints if you have ever seen the theatrical release of TTT. Certainly some of your complaints are only relevant to the EE.
 
Greenwood said:
....opinions that are expressed with extreme arrogance.

You constantly make a point of believing reports that you say are truthful, but the point is not one of truthfulness. The point is accuracy. Since you have haven't seen the film you have no way of judging the accuracy of the reports you base your comments on.

For example let's look at the "grievances" listed in the post that started this thread.

....it is irrelevant how "few" comments you make on ROTK.

You followed exactly the same pattern on TTT of complaining about it for months before you actually saw the film. In fact I can't even tell from your complaints if you have ever seen the theatrical release of TTT.

Was that to me? :confused:
It takes one to make one - if I'm arrogant what are you? Actually the word doesn't fit you OR me.

Truthfulness and accuracy are two separate distinct different points? You've lost me there.

I'm talking about simple facts: facts such as that the confrontation with Saruman does not open ROTK as PJ promised in the TTT EE that it would, that Frodo tells Sam to go home. Were those who reported those facts here not truthful; were they not, equally, accurate?

I have commented only on factual matters, and yes, on very few of those.
I have not commented on matters in which there is room for disagreement between viewers on matters of interpretation, such as the details of the battles which you have been discussing, and on which Aragil requested my thoughts - I shall reply to that in six weeks time!

I've said before that I place no reliance on the originator of this thread as a source of factual material; I simply don't take him seriously.

The fact that I make few comments on ROTK IS relevant; it's the point of this discussion.

I saw TTT not long after its release, and own two copies of the TC, and one of the EE. Any comments I made on it before I saw it were again based on factual reports from contributors in its area of the forum.

I really don't get your point about why I can't rely on what people here describe.
 
joxy said:
Was that to me?
No, it was not.

joxy said:
Truthfulness and accuracy are two separate distinct different points?
Yes, they are totally separate, but you are the one who keeps trying to equate them. As I and others have pointed out when one bases criticisms on second-hand reports there is no way to know if those reports are accurate. No one is questioning the honesty of the reporters, but as I demonstrated in reviewing the first post of this thread the accuracy is not necessarily high. You continually ignore the issue by trying to make it a question of truthfulness instead of accuracy.

joxy said:
I'm talking about simple facts: facts such as that the confrontation with Saruman does not open ROTK as PJ promised in the TTT EE that it would, that Frodo tells Sam to go home. Were those who reported those facts here not truthful; were they not, equally, accurate?

I have commented only on factual matters, and yes, on very few of those.
I have not commented on matters in which there is room for disagreement between viewers on matters of interpretation, such as the details of the battles which you have been discussing, and on which Aragil requested my thoughts - I shall reply to that in six weeks time!
Facts are not necessarily the simple things you claim. It is a fact that Saruman does not appear in ROTK; it is not a fact that Saruman is not dealt with. In fact ;) , Saruman is dealt with in a way that JRRT himself suggested if the Scouring of the Shire is left out of a cinematic version. From the famous letter (#210) of Tolkien's about a treatment for a projected animated version of LOTR:
If Z wants Saruman tidied up (I cannot see why, where so many threads are left loose) Gandalf should say something to this effect: as Saruman collapses under the excommunication: 'Since you will not come out and aid us, here in Orthanc you shall stay till you rot, Saruman. Let the Ents look to it!' (emphasis added)
Would you care to give kudos to Jackson for coming up with a solution that Tolkien seemingly would have approved of?

Facts can also be manipulated. Yes, Frodo tells Sam to go home in the movie, but Frodo does essentially the same thing in the book. So where is the problem? :D


joxy said:
I saw TTT not long after its release, and own two copies of the TC, and one of the EE. Any comments I made on it before I saw it were again based on factual reports from contributors in its area of the forum.
In comments on the ROTK review thread (a movie you haven't seen :p ), you said:
joxy said:
In TTT, aren't Theoden and Denethor PJ's characters rather than Tolkien's?
The comment about Denethor had me scratching my head since I didn't remember Denethor ever appearing in TTT, but then I remembered he does appear in the EE of TTT, not the theatrical release (correct me in I am wrong -- I only own the EE). Since you were not specifying what edition you were referring to I began to wonder if you ever saw the theatrical version. We already know that you have absolutely no reservations about commenting on things you have no personal knowledge of.


joxy said:
I really don't get your point about why I can't rely on what people here describe.
Because you don't know what is accurate and what isn't. And, because of your bias, you tend to assume any negative comment is accurate.


BTW, congratulations on being the subject of my 1,000th post! Whoopee!!!!! :) :)
 
Greenwood said:
1> Yes, they are totally separate, but you are the one who keeps trying to equate them.
2> Facts are not necessarily the simple things you claim. It is a fact that Saruman does not appear in ROTK; it is not a fact that Saruman is not dealt with.
3> Frodo tells Sam to go home in the movie, but Frodo does essentially the same thing in the book. So where is the problem?
4> Since you were not specifying what edition you were referring to I began to wonder if you ever saw the theatrical version.
5> We already know that you have absolutely no reservations about commenting on things you have no personal knowledge of.
6> Because you don't know what is accurate and what isn't. And, because of your bias, you tend to assume any negative comment is accurate.

1> "Truthfulness and accuracy are totally separate". I'll have to have that made into an illuminated manuscipt and framed. I DO equate them, when referring to matters of fact. I've specified two facts: the Saruman confrontation not being in ROTK TC; Frodo telling Sam to go home. Those facts are truthful and they are accurate, or are they not?

2> I said nothing about Saruman not being "dealt with; I was quite specific in my reference, to the fact that the confrontation with him is not the first scene of ROTK as PJ said, at one stage, that it would be. That he changed his mind doesn't alter the fact; it confirms it.

3> I didn't say there WAS a problem; I joined in a discussion of the matter, of THAT fact.

4> Now we have to specify editions? OK, I have the TCs of FOTR and TTT, and the DVD EEs of FOTR and TTT. Next month I shall have the TC of ROTK.

5> Correct: I have "no reservations about commenting on things I have no personal knowledge of", IF I have been told about the facts of those things from a source or sources that I consider to be reliable. I am quite happy to comment on the Grand Canyon, the surface of Mars, the interior of an atom, and ROTK, purely on factual reports I have received about them.

6> I assume that all statements of fact that I see here are accurate. Do you have a problem with that? I have NO bias in the matter, and have been as pleased and interested to hear of the high points of ROTK as I have been less than pleased but equally interested to hear about the low points. I assign equal accuracy to ALL reports of matters of fact.

I feel more like the OBJECT of your 1001st post, rather than its SUBJECT. :D
Did you borrow that sense of humour, or is it yours to keep now? The latter I hope.
 
joxy said:
1> "Truthfulness and accuracy are totally separate". I'll have to have that made into an illuminated manuscipt and framed. I DO equate them, when referring to matters of fact.
Thank you for providing a fine example of my point. Your statement above is truthful in that it conveys the essence of what I posted, it is however, completely inaccurate since I never posted the phrase you have placed in quotation marks. Quotation marks generally imply that the word inside them are exactly what someone said. In this case your quotation is not accurate. (When you frame that illuminated manuscript please be sure to accurately attribute the quote to yourself. ;) :) ) On the other hand lots of people (politicians come to mind) can be entirly accurate in their statements, but use those "accurate facts" to completely mislead. I would not consider that being truthful. I make no charges of that being true of any TTF member, I merely point it out as a reason why truth and accuracy are not the same thing.


All of your protests ignore the point that when one looks at the list of grievances on the post that started this thread we only have about a 50% accuracy rate. I say nothing about Beorn's truthfulness. I assume he is a truthful person. I certainly have no reason to question his truthfulness. The accuracy of his complaints, however, is another question entirely.
 
Greenwood said:
Where it appears in Tolkien's writing is relevant. From the two mentions of the Valar in LOTR there is no way to know who or what the Valar are much less that they are resident in the Far West. There is certainly no way for any reader of LOTR to associate them with Gandalf. The point here is your seemingly total inability or unwillingness to separate your knowledge of Tolkien's mythology from the film. Your criticisms of the film are merely a laundry list of differences between the books and the films; in many cases inconsequential or even non-existent differences. Your dislike of the films (and it is your right to dislike them) is completely based on the fact that they are not Tolkien's LOTR to the letter. (And as we have seen you sometimes can't even distinguish LOTR from other "writings" of Tolkien.) Every incident in the books that is changed in the movies now takes on great meaning in the book (no matter how minor the incident was in the book), as a way of showing how badly the movie portrayed the books. When someone demonstrates how closely the movies follow the book the charge becomes: "No!, those things are all superficial! The real plot and meaning of the book is in these other incidents" (most of which are really relatively minor and inconsequential). Rather than just stating your dislike of the films is based on their not being Tolkien's LOTR (which I could respect) you feel the need to "prove" how terrible they are by denigrating them as films. You have no interest in actually discussing them as films despite all your claims to the contrary. You say that you want to know why others enjoy the films, but as soon as they mention anything about the films they like you merely say no, these things were really terrible. It is of course impossible to carry on any meaningful discussion when one side knows their opinions are the Truth.

Tut, tut. Not a single "in my humble opinion". Such hubris.

Anyways, as I stated above, I initially responded to aragil's comment that this particular scene followed the books closely; therefore, it is obvious that in regards to this scene, my primary intent is to argue that the scene does not follow the books. And no, not every change from book to movie takes on great significance. Some alterations, like those done to Farmir and Denethor, are rather obvious. Some are more subtle, and often it is these subtle changes which alter the thematic content of the text in more significant ways.

Many, however, do not have any bearing on the heart of the tale: they are either mechanical changes (made in order to move the story along) or they are wholly arbitrary.

As to my inability to separate the mythology from the movies, I have already stated that when watching the movies as movies (and separate from Tolkien's writing), I find them lacking original substance. My indifference towards the movies as movies depends little upon the alterations to the book, and much more upon my distaste as a filmwatcher for the Hollywood norm.
 
aragil said:
My view is that the "hand of the One" is seldom felt in LotR- perhaps in an event like Gollum stumbling. If the whole of events in Arda are supposed to play out to his glory, then I would not find it very glorifying if he is consistently loading the dice.

True, I can agree that the One is not seen in LotR very much--if by seen you mean that it is not physically present in the text. But we know that Gandalf has been sent from the West; we know that after his death, he is "sent back", and it is made clear by Tolkien that he was sent back by Iluvatar. More importantly, the idea of "happy chance" as you call it, is rejected throughout the text. Bilbo was meant to find the Ring, Frodo was meant to bear it, Gandalf was meant to lead them.

Of course, in the realm of reality a simple shift of wind or a fifteen minute delay might have changed the unfolding of events. But we are not dealing with reality; we are dealing with literature. And Tolkien--as literary artist (and subcreator)--has the right and ability to sculpt his tale to his own choosing.

Thus, there is no shift in the wind or fifteen minute delay. The Rohirrim arrive at just the moment they are most sorely needed, and it is not a matter of happy chance, but the climax of a chain of events set into motion by Gandalf.



aragil said:
I think I agree with the professor's letter in quite a different sentiment than you do- what is striking to me is the non-necessity of the confrontation. Gandalf is there, but the strength of the mortals is enough that the confrontation never develops beyond verbal sparring. Being a Maia, I'm sure he is quite capable of (again) battling the Witch King, but it is not his fight. Gandalf inspires the West to fight- he does not combat Sauron alone.

Again, true. The focus of this letter as a whole is indeed upon the nature of Gandalf, and the manner in which he inspires the West to resist. But it is crucial to the narrative that Gandalf is the being who "has kindled and organized" that resistance--and done it so skillfully and powerfully that he can leave the battle to other hands and focus his efforts to saving Faramir from the madness of his father.

aragil said:
In that respect I think that the emphasis of the movie is quite correctly placed- the forces of the West (represented by the Rohirrim) in apposition to the forces of Mordor, NOT Maia vs. Nazgul.

I could agree with you but for the simple fact that Tolkien chose to emphasize the confrontation between the two, while the battle is mostly a backdrop. Again, this is partially a literary effect: focus on the characters rather than the massive armies and their massive battles. Jackson, not surprisingly, chooses to emphasize the latter--when he could have had both!!

aragil said:
Sidestepping the last line of Theoden's verse (personally I thought he was chanting for the death he'd unleash on the Orcs, not his own), in my opinion the horns at cockcrow came through in the movie as they came through in the book- at the lowest point.

You'll have to forgive my imperfect memory of the movie, having seen it only once unfortunately, but my recollection is that the Horns are heard somewhat in medias res--that is, they are heard as the battle rages on; there is no momentous pause after which the tide of the battle turns in a heartbeat. Is this so?

As for the last line of Theoden's "speech", it is without a doubt lifted from Eomer's raving after seeing his sister dead on the field. And without a doubt, Eomer (in the book) is calling upon his Riders to lead a charge that will bring ALL to death: "Death, death, death! Death takes us all!" and "Ride, ride to ruin and the world's ending!" If you submit that Theoden's co-opting of that line is now meant to imply death to the Orcs, then Jackson and his writers have taken Tolkien's writing and altered its meaning in giving the line to a different character. That's a notion that has been heavily resisted by many in this forum.

aragil said:
By "sheer scale" I did not mean that the forces of the Rohirrim were so large that they could not be stopped- I meant that however many thousands of Orcs were still no match for a full charge of 6000+ cavalry. That fact is as true in the books as it is in the film. The initial onset (in the books) catches the Northern half of the Pelannor by surprise, but the momentum of the charge carries through almost to the Anduin. Even the forces of Mordor that were further to the South, who had time to recover from the surprise of the assault, even they were pushed back from the gates. The only thing that saved Mordor in the books (and in the films) were the Oliphaunts, which allowed for pockets of troops to hold out against the charge, absorb the energy of the charge, and then slowly force the Rohirrim back with overwhelming numbers.


Ah, but those thosands upon thousands of Orcs were indeed more than a match for the Rohirrim! Again, there is a literary force here at work that alters tactics and strategy in the way that we would usually think of them. The wrath of Theoden--likened to Orome the Great, fey, battle-fury coursing through his veins--sends the armies of Mordor into total disarray. This disarray, however, is only temporary. The Haradrim initially rally their forces against Theoden, but his fury is still hot enough to win that encounter. At Theoden's death, then Eomer's fury in turn overthrows the fore of the Enemy's lines. However, as the Haradrim realize they have strength in numbers, they rally around Mumakil (as you point out). But embedded in the battle tactics is this notion that the "battle-fury" of the Rohirrim twice sends the Enemy into disarray, only to lose strength as the Enemy realizes its strength is the greater. And that is the important fact: the Enemy's strength is greater. It is then the surprise of their onset, coupled with the hotness of their fury, that allows the charge of the Rohirrim to succeed initially.

And even if you will rebuff that notion, there is this final point: in the book, no Enemy had yet passed under the archway of the Gate of Minas Tirith. The City, then, stands as a symbol of the ultimate hope for victory--overthrown, weakened, at the brink of destruction--but in the end utterly indomitable. By allowing Orcs to rampage through the City, Jackson destroys that symbolism, and the arrival of the Rohirrim becomes just another last-second save that we have seen repeated in film with nauseating regularity.
 
Last edited:
aragil said:
As for the confrontation scene, again I have no idea why it was removed.

Yes, it is interesting, isn't it? Here we have a scene which most readers of Tolkien would agree is one of the most important and moving in the book. Many would agree that it is a highly dramatic moment, and the tension is very great: it is a scene that would naturally translate well to cinema.

Yet Jackson chose to take it out of his movie. Given his penchant for "ramping up the tension" (as he repeatedly declares in the commentaries of FotR and TTT), it is odd that he deleted this tension-filled scene. Why did he do it then? Was it an arbitrary decision? Did he think he could do it better? Was it to satisfy a lust for watching rampaging and pillaging Orcs heaping death and destruction on the poor souls of Minas Tirith? Or was it to shift the thematic focus of the scene?
 
Greenwood said:
Thank you for providing a fine example of my point. Your statement above is truthful in that it conveys the essence of what I posted, it is however, completely inaccurate since I never posted the phrase you have placed in quotation marks. Quotation marks generally imply that the word inside them are exactly what someone said. In this case your quotation is not accurate. (When you frame that illuminated manuscript please be sure to accurately attribute the quote to yourself. ;) :) ) On the other hand lots of people (politicians come to mind) can be entirly accurate in their statements, but use those "accurate facts" to completely mislead. I would not consider that being truthful. I make no charges of that being true of any TTF member, I merely point it out as a reason why truth and accuracy are not the same thing.

Your phrase (#751): "Yes, they are totally separate....". What were your "they"?
My phrase: "Truthfulness and accuracy are totally separate".


Obviously when words within quotation marks are attributed to a name, they are meant to be "exactly what someone said".
I devised the words by substituting its referrers for your pronoun "they", and put them within quotation marks to indicate that they made up the phrase which I intended to be the substance of my hypothetical framed wall plaque. The quotation was "from" that hypothetical plaque, not from you.
The words were more precise than "conveying the essence" of your reflections, but I made no attribution of them to you.

Of course we all know about politicians, and all manner of other people, twisting accurate facts into untruthful arguments.
That's where truthfulness and accuracy begin their dichotomy.
None of that applies in the two specific cases I have given: the Saruman confrontation and Frodo's dismissal of Sam. There is no doubt, is there, that those are accurate facts? I have not made any attempt to twist them into anything, untruthful or otherwise; I have merely contributed to discussions about them, as accurate facts.

In some cases accuracy can be twisted away from truth; in this case it hasn't been.
 
Last edited:
rs691919 said:
Anyways, as I stated above, I initially responded to aragil's comment that this particular scene followed the books closely; therefore, it is obvious that in regards to this scene, my primary intent is to argue that the scene does not follow the books. And no, not every change from book to movie takes on great significance. Some alterations, like those done to Farmir and Denethor, are rather obvious. Some are more subtle, and often it is these subtle changes which alter the thematic content of the text in more significant ways.
That may be your intent but I find your argument unconvincing. Aragil, and to a lesser extent I, have shown that the movie version does follow the book fairly closely except in relatively minor points. You are taking a single scene in that battle (one I would have loved to have seen and I can only guess at why Jackson didn't include it) that in the book takes up six short paragraphs in a part of the book that spans three chapters and about fifty pages of text and elevating it to one of the single most important moments in the entire story. Admittedly, it is possible for such a short passage to be that important, but as exciting as this scene is I don't see it rising to that level of importance. There is a about to be a confrontation between two powerful characters in the book and it doesn't happen. You argue the fact confrontation doesn't happen makes the scene that much more important. I don't buy it. I see it as great story-telling that keeps the reader enthralled. It is also in keeping with the limits Tolkien has placed on Gandalf in that even though he is an immensely powerful being (Gandalf the White at one point describes himself as the most powerful being in Middle Earth after Sauron), Tolkien rarely allows Gandalf to use or display any of that power, even the fight with the balrog is only told in flashback. This is in keeping with one of the main themes of the book that it is now the time of men and that even the seemingly smallest and weakest individuals can triumph against great evil if they are true to their oaths and their friends. Thus Sauron's most powerful servant is vanquished not by the West's most powerful being in Middle Earth but by the combination of a hobbit and a young woman who are defending someone they love.


rs691919 said:
As to my inability to separate the mythology from the movies, I have already stated that when watching the movies as movies (and separate from Tolkien's writing), I find them lacking original substance. My indifference towards the movies as movies depends little upon the alterations to the book, and much more upon my distaste as a filmwatcher for the Hollywood norm.
And once again, since you do not make it clear you are referring to what you think is the "Hollywood norm", but rather state it as if it is a universally recognized "Hollywood norm", I will point out that all the evidence is that the movies do exceed the "Hollywood norm". :D ;)
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
I will point out that all the evidence is that the movies do exceed the "Hollywood norm".
Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence". It can be no more than a matter of opinion.
That opinion may come from the celebrated award-presenters, from the famous reviewers, or from you; or it may come from aragil, from rs, or from me. All will have equal value, and none of them will prove the point.
 
Wait a minute joxy, if a norm can be objectively quantified, then evidence can be presented as to whether or not something exceeds that norm. You may not want to quantify the norm, but others might. You might disagree with the quantification/definition of the norm, but giving reasons why you disagree would be more productive than simply stating that "norm" is a fundamentally subjective standard.
 

Today's events

Back
Top