• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace

Originally posted by DGoeij
....obvious mistakes that are actually written down, like the 3434 in the Second Age....
I haven't seen that and don't know where it occurs, but it reminds me of a section in the EE when there is an account of the time and effort that they put into making sure that the runes that covered a wall were accurate, even though not one in a million viewers would understand them.
Given vastly expensive attention to detail like that, how do we account for the 3434, and many other glaring mistakes: carelessness and incompetence!
 
Hmm. I guess I don't really know what to say if people don't like statistics. Yes, there are gaffs in the LotR series- and yes people have been able to find them (apparently many of them). A few things to keep in mind about how a movie earns a 'gaff count':
1) multiple viewings- most of these things aren't visible on the first show, so people have to watch the movie multiple times to catch them. In General, this means either the people are sick masochists, or they enjoyed the movie in the first place.
2) viewers with an eye for detail- specifically a critical eye. Viewers for a movie like LotR fits the bill, the teenage female sort that watched Titanic a million times does not.
3) DGoij's formula- I agree, the longer the movie, and the more complex the shooting (i.e., a fantasy setting where half the cast is supposed to be half the height of the rest of the cast), the more 'gaffs' are bound to happen. This is not sloppiness, this is simple law of averages.
What's my point? I guess it's that we shouldn't be surprised that so many gaffs have been spotted in LotR, given the complexity of the shoot, length of the movies, audience, and repeat viewership. Does this mean the movies are poorly filmed, or lack technical merit? I'd say the fact that both films have been nominated in categories such as:
editing
cinematography
production design
and sound; in both the Oscars AND the BAFTAs indicate that the professionals think that these movies are technically pretty good, among the best of their respective years, in fact. I guess I'm just astounded that people can honestly insist that these films are poorly put together. Again, my mantra is that everyone is entitled to their opinion, but that (as far as any statistics can show) the consensus opinion is that the LotR films are technically very good, and they have been very pleasing to both the critics and the 'average' man alike.
DGoeij, I am under the impression that you didn't look at any of the links that I provided. Yes people do enjoy movies like 'Beverly Hills Cop III' and 'Titanic'- that is why both those movies were financially succesful. The links I provided addressed a different question: 'how good do people think these movies were?' to put things in perspective, on IMDB Titanic got a rating (out of 10) of 6.9, Beverly Hills Cop III received a 4.7. The #250th ranked movie on IMDB (after 250 they stop ranking) got a rating of 7.7. Clearly these statistics are independent of box office. If you'd like to know the top 10 rankings, they are:
1 Godfather, The (1972) 9.0/10 (78935 votes)
2 Shawshank Redemption, The (1994) 8.9/10 (99477 votes)
3 Godfather: Part II, The (1974) 8.8/10 (45368 votes)
4 Schindler's List (1993) 8.7/10 (69062 votes)
5 Casablanca (1942) 8.7/10 (46632 votes)
6 Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The (2001) 8.7/10 (103188 votes)
7 Citizen Kane (1941) 8.7/10 (43691 votes)
8 Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, The (2002) 8.7/10 (55822 votes)
9 Shichinin no samurai (1954) 8.7/10 (18986 votes) [Seven Samarai]
10 Star Wars (1977) 8.7/10 (99724 votes)
Again, there is no pleasing everyone, but MOST people will agree that these are ten pretty good movies. It's also worth noting that only three movies are both on the IMDB top 10 and, and the top 10 worldwide gross: Star Wars (#10 on both), The Two Towers (#4 all time Box office, #8 on IMDB), and the Fellowship of the Ring (#7 all time Box office, #6 on IMDB). Think about that- no other film in history has gotten on these two lists, yet FotR and TT did so without even having a 'true' ending to their respective stories- they are just parts of the whole!! To me that is absolutely mind-boggling.
Joxy- about book sales- I can't find any solid figures, but BBC put LotR as the top selling book in Britain in 2002, by a margin of 889,895 units sold to 748,099 for Philip Pullman's 'His Dark Materials' (http://shopping.guardian.co.uk/books/story/0,1587,969501,00.html). How does this compare to the normal selling of the book (i.e. before the movies)? I can't say for sure, but just prior to the release of the movies book sales for LotR went up 400% (http://enjoyment.independent.co.uk/books/news/story.jsp?story=92995). This leaves me relatively unworried that the movies are somehow hurting sales of the books. And I hope you take a look at IMDB- it's great for any sort of movie things you want to know, and it has many user reviews for almost every movie, regardless of nation of origin or size of release.
 
Originally posted by aragil
I guess I don't really know what to say if people don't like statistics.
This leaves me relatively unworried that the movies are somehow hurting sales of the books.
I haven't said that I don't like them! I said at first that I wasn't particularly interested in them, though the listing you mentioned which includes a ranking did arouse some interest for me and I will check that out. Of course the significance of any set of statistics depends at least as much on the way the "sample" was "chosen" as upon the actual figures, and I doubt whether any of these surveys are based on "representative" samples.
Obviously, the films will increase book sales; it would be very odd if they didn't, and there's no question of any worry arising on the matter. What I was considering was whether there would have been even MORE sales, if some people weren't deceived into thinking the third-rate mush they had been watching was actually what they would find in the books!
 
Actor Troy McClure =

I remember him from such driver's ed films as "Alice's Adventures through the Windshield Glass" and "The Decapitation of Larry Leadfoot".
 
Parrot- hey, I know that guy.

Did anybody else see my reply to Joxy, or did I delete it before posting?
 
Did anybody else see my reply to Joxy, or did I delete it before posting?
If you're referring to the post joxy made just before Parrot's, no, I don't see an answer from you.

Wow, Parrot, I haven't seen you around in quite a while, it seems!


Now to the point. Once again the Purists themselves prove their dislike of the movies stems only from its horrible quality as an adaptation.

With the wonderful work Aragil has done we see that a majority of people like the movies. Maybe I should say the "vast majority," as this appears to be the case. Regardless, this all but dismisses the claims of "gaping plot holes" etc., merely leaving us with variations from the books.

This has been shown consistently during the last few pages, as Melko specifically mentioned the year 3434. Although this is a careless and needless variation, it does not negatively affect the movie, as a movie. The fact is, most of these variations are needless, yet harmless. Of course, this makes most purists face the fact that they dislike the movies because they differ from the books.

Some may say it is Jackson's filming errors that make it a bad film. Yet these same people applaud the Harry Potter films as great movies. However, even though both HP films are a good deal shorter, the HP film with the least amount of errors has more continuity problems than the LotR with the most! Surely, then, this can not be the problem.

There can be only one conclusion, the reason the films are so picked on is because they stink as adaptations. Their bitterness over this leads them to pick apart every aspect of the film, as I have done with films I am biased to dislike.


Admit it!
 
Originally posted by Gandalf White
If you're referring to the post joxy made just before Parrot's, no, I don't see an answer from you.
Doh! Well, let's just say that it was extremely well-written, and that purists would have instantly seen the error of their ways after having read it. Yeeeaaaah, that's the ticket.
Anyway, most of what I said was in the post of Gandalf White. Other than that I encouraged Joxy to check out IMDB- it really is a wonderful site. In addition to the 100,000+ votes for ranking FotR, there are over 4000 reviews of the movie (length of reviews being left to the discression of the reviewer). Reading some of these gives a pretty good feel for audience reaction (how did non-book readers feel, etc). Of course, not every review is positive (the majority of the first page is negative), but not everybody is perfect. That's about it. Did I mention that my deleted post was really well-written?

ps. Stick around Parrot. We want humor.
 
Originally posted by aragil
Did anybody else see my reply to Joxy, or did I delete it before posting?
Well I certainly didn't see it, I am sorry to say!
I would be interested to know though, how you could delete it BEFORE posting it!
 
This one insists, as he has done all along, that he does NOT "dislike the movies"!
I like a lot of their content, and I dislike SOME of it.
Some parts of both films I dislike because they have nothing to do with the source material that PJ was privileged to work on.
Other parts, and especially of TTT, I dislike because they show PJ as less than totally competent at his job.
It doesn't take much "work" to establish that most people "like" the films - I am one of the majority that likes them! The only point of contention is whether everyone likes them without reservation.
I like them when they are good, and dislike them when they are bad, and I guess that many, or even most others, feel the same way; it's just the relative size of the good and bad parts over which they will differ.
It seems to me to be much more reasonable to express qualified satisfaction, than to claim perfection for a product which most people now agree contains many faults.
 
Originally posted by joxy
Well I certainly didn't see it, I am sorry to say!
I would be interested to know though, how you could delete it BEFORE posting it!
Quite simple. Instead of hitting 'submit reply', click on 'preview reply'. Then, don't notice the difference, and close the browser window. Voila!
 
Alas, as I watched - or tried to watch a cable showing of FOTR the other night, I found that much of my joy in the film is gone. This started shortly after TTT even as I fought to hold on to my desire to enjoy the films if not in relationship to the book, then at least as an entirely different story with familiar names. However, I fear that TTT - and even my reminiscences about FOTR (especially seeing it again) have made all the things that "bothered" me the first time but which I was able to "forget" in the excitement of the film as a whole, are now no longer as easily put aside and forgotten. Had TTT been a worthy successor to FOTR, I might have been able to continue my efforts, but it was decidedly not.

And so I look about my home at all the "momentos" of the attempt to film a really first rate version of the book and realize that shortly I shall have to box them up and present them to my daughter who doesn't seem to have the same problems as I. My, this has been a very expensive disappointment....
 
Yes, and this is where you fool most people. Hardly anyone thinks of your posts as "qualified satisfaction," I know it's hard for me to do so. The fact that you enjoy the movies is seemingly never let through in your myriad of posts condemning its faults.

Quite simple. Instead of hitting 'submit reply', click on 'preview reply'. Then, don't notice the difference, and close the browser window. Voila!
Aha, the mystery is revealed! I'm one of the people who only check their post after they've submitted it, for some reason...
 

Indeed I did not. It's just that I didn't have the time at that moment. My side note was a personal experience regarding movie judgement. At leaving the cinema and maybe even for six months after, I felt BHC III was a great movie.
Now I'm 23, and have seen a lot more movies and discussed most of them with a lot of people. Today, to me as a person, BHC III is nothing much, suitable for a slow evening when some friends are around and you feel like talking through a movie a lot. Even though I still have some good memories about it.

And considering the fact that the hype probably isn't even at it's peak, I wonder how much people will be voting for these movies in twenty years time. My guess is the Godfather will still be around and some others will not.
I never said the LOTR's are lousy movies, or that they shouldn't be up in these lists. (I couldn't care less about lists, I prefer people on internet forums I can yell at )I just know what I saw and remember perfectly well what I have been reading for the last ten years. Me as a person, I think that the latest movie could have been better.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Alas, as I watched - or tried to watch a cable showing of FOTR the other night, I found that much of my joy in the film is gone.


And this does surprise you?

Mrs. Maggott, I think it is only natural that you would lose interest in something that you spend so much time complaining about. Like so many things in life, you get out what you put in. By focusing so much on the negative aspects, they grow and grow until they have taken over the entire show and there is no room left for the positive side.

I think you can hardly blame anybody but yourself for this change of heart.

Odo
 
No, that is not so. I "complained" as you call it rather extensively about FOTR when we were discussing its strengths and weaknesses. If you bother to look back, you will see that although I was very disappointed in Jackson's "rewrite" of the characters, I was very positive about many of the things he did in the film and on the whole was extremely optimistic about TTT before its release. I had already intended to view the works as something "other" than Tolkien and had no problems with it in that sense. I simply wished Jackson to maintain the high standards he had set in FOTR in the second film. He didn't. Furthermore, he not only "changed" the characters in TTT, but he made them uniformly worse as people: Faramir - a nasty bully, Theoden - an arrogant coward, Treebeard - dim and clueless. Who cares about such folk in any film? Then when one added the inferior plot themes (Frodo and the Nazgul, cha cha cha), the interminable battle scenes and the insane editing, the whole thing - in my opinion - fell apart. I did not enjoy TTT although I had gone into the theater with every intention of doing so!

Of course, FOTR now becomes a part of TTT. You cannot watch the first film without knowing what is going to come in the second - and therefore, my enjoyment of the first has been much diminished. Furthermore, having seen what Jackson did to the characters in TTT (Gimli as comic relief, Aragorn continuing on as God only knows what, Frodo as the wilting wuss), certainly affects watching the characters again in FOTR when you begin to see all of this developing (the mood of tragedy being ruined by Gimli's prat fall in Lorien and so forth). Frankly, Boromir was lucky! He died in the good film.

No, my dear Oddo. In this instance, I would say that the viewing came before the critiques and were the result of same, not the other way round. Mr. Jackson's "story" in TTT has cast a pall on not only FOTR, but ROTK as well. I was willing to suspend my disappointment of the fact that a true rendition of Tolkien's story did not appear in the film, but only so long as Jackson's story was worth watching. If TTT is any example, at least as far as I'm concerned, it is not.
 
i gotta agree with Ms. Maggot here, it's like watching Star Wars knowing Darth Vader is in fact Anakin Skywalker & Lukes father, only in Star Wars it breathes new life to the movies, whereas with the Lord of the Rings movies, it's for the worse

the Fellowship is a great movie, forget the adaptation for a minute, it just feels like a great opening chapter in a movie trilogy & it sets everybody up perfectly for the what-would-be even greater sequel

but it never came, what we got is Aragorn yet again running away from his fate, we again get Gimly being the main joke of the movie, we again get Legolas doing oh so kewl moves & being just super-duper rash, we again get Frodo the crybaby, we get the same Arwen/Aragorn conflict

now lets look at the newly introduced characters

we get a tediously slow tree-tribe, a cowardly king, a bully & a ACTUAL eye sitting atop of a tower(c'mon now), we get a rather creepy arwen/elrond scene & i don't know what the return of the Nazgul was supposed to be

the only thing the movie has going for it are Gandalf & Gollum(who are superb i will add)

it's not just a bad adaptation, it's a bad centerpiece of a trilogy & a bad sequel

i hope with all my heart that the Extended will add new dimension to the movie making it at least worthy of its name

i do still have high hopes for ROTK though, but i feel the damage has been done
 
Last edited:
Originally posted by aragil


ps. Stick around Parrot. We want humor.
You mean humor as opposed to intellect, knowledge, conviction, insight, etc., right? I guess I'll take this as a compliment, even backhanded as it is.

I'm around, just lurking. Once ROTK gets closer and the fur really starts to fly again, I'll start posting more often. Hopefully a few more silverbacks will wander back into the fray and things will get interesting around here again.
 
Yes, and the sad thing in TTT most of all was the feeling that Jackson was "marking time" in the Ent/Frodo threads and putting all of his efforts in the Rohan/Helm's Deep part. Unfortunately, that did not translate into a better Aragorn or Theoden (although Grima was all right). Eomer we see not at all and Eowyn - for all of the 'love triangle' scuttlebut - was also a virtual nonentity.

Then you have that rather inane bit of gibberish in the middle with Arwen and Elrond which was apparently put in so that we wouldn't "forget" Aragorn's love interest (which is more than can be said for Aragorn who seems to have forgotten Arwen just about completely after he tells Galadriel in FOTR that he wishes she would go into the West!). That particular scenario was not only strange, but given Jackson's interpretation of a very ambiguous relationship between Elrond and his daughter, I found it to be downright scuzzy. Yuch!

I am glad to see that others have found the same thing: that their delight in FOTR and their hopes for ROTK have been marred by TTT. For a while there, I thought I was the only one who had that problem.
 
I am glad to see that others have found the same thing: that their delight in FOTR and their hopes for ROTK have been marred by TTT. For a while there, I thought I was the only one who had that problem.
Well, if you look hard enough in this world you will find someone who will agree with any certain belief you may hold.

I had already intended to view the works as something "other" than Tolkien and had no problems with it in that sense.
Still I see that what you dislike is in the changes made from the books. True, they were unnecessary and disappointing, yet these very characters didn't detract from Joe Public's enjoyment, it seems.

But I've said all this before, in a seemingly ignored post...
 
Originally posted by Parrot
You mean humor as opposed to intellect, knowledge, conviction, insight, etc., right? I guess I'll take this as a compliment, even backhanded as it is.
Humor is the apogee of intellect and insight. A forehanded compliment 'twas. I'll have to see what I can do about bringing more monkeys aboard.

Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I am glad to see that others have found the same thing: that their delight in FOTR and their hopes for ROTK have been marred by TTT.
Now MM, you can't go about disparaging Mr. Jackson's ethics if you're going to take such obvious delight in others' misery!

Originally posted alternately by Sephiroth and Mrs. Maggott
Aragorn yet again running away from his fate
In the TT which I saw, Aragorn was beginning to run towards his fate, becoming a leader of Men (or Elves, as it were).
we again get Gimly being the main joke of the movie
I thought that M&P were the main jokes in FotR, while Gimli was fairly accurate. Can we get a consensus here?
we again get Legolas doing oh so kewl moves & being just super-duper rash
Exactly what was Legolas in the books, that PJ's (or Orlando's) version is so off?
we again get Frodo the crybaby
At what point does Frodo cry in TTT? I think you should keep in mind the fact that Frodo has taken on a job that is too big for him, that indeed is too big for anyone. That he doesn't just chuck the Ring into the river and bolt is the true heroism of his character. His ability to finish the task is severely questioned in TT (as it should be). His resolve to attempt the task never is.
we get a tediously slow tree-tribe
As opposed to the hasty tree-tribe we saw in the books? You might want to re-read those chapters.
a cowardly king
Are you referring to the fact that Theoden didn't take his 100+ soldiers and ride head-first into the 10,000 Uruk-hai? There's a mile-wide line between prudent and cowardly.
I think your bully is the same man who sacrificed his own life for a Hobbit who he had just met (one who had obviously lied to him, at that). I want to meet a bully like that.
a ACTUAL eye sitting atop of a tower(c'mon now)
I don't know what you would have preferred here. Anytime Sauron makes his presence felt in the books, it is through his chosen motif of 'the eye' (the insignias on his henchmen as well as his projection in Frodo's mind). If you wanted to give him a visual presence in the movie, it only makes sense to use this visual (IMO).
we get a rather creepy arwen/elrond scene
Frankly, in the books Elrond was not thrilled with Arwen's choice either. Elrond's description of what would conditionally happen to Arwen if she chose Aragorn is straight out of what actually did happen to her in the books. I for one am glad that they found a way to bring that part of the books into the movie, and I think it was far more effective than having it occur at the end of the third film.
i don't know what the return of the Nazgul was supposed to be
I don't know what to make of this complaint. The overfly in the Dead Marshes was pretty much spot-on from the books, and the scene in Osgiliath was reminiscent (though obviously much changed) of what happened to Frodo at the bridge to Minas Morgul.
Eomer we see not at all and Eowyn - for all of the 'love triangle' scuttlebut - was also a virtual nonentity.
I agree we could have seen more of Eomer, but Eowyn has been given far more character and background than she had at this point in the book. Arwen seems to be very much on Aragorn's mind. When first we see her it is through a flashback of Aragorn's. Then there is the constant 'Evenstar' jewel-motif, which played very importantly when Eowyn sees Aragorn return from the cliff episode. Frankly, the Aragorn that you describe would have ran into the open arms of Eowyn. The Aragorn I saw on screen behaved very differently. I'd even say he behaved nobly, but that might really get the fur flying!

I can't stop promoting IMDB (I'm not under their employ, honest!). They actually do have message boards as well as lists, but of course their MBs are much less personal (and friendly) than TTF. However, I note (with some satisfaction) that their lists seem to be relatively hype-impervious. Titanic, Star Wars ep I, the Phantom Menace, Harry Potter (1&2), Spiderman, Matrix II, Pirates of the Caribbean and Finding Nemo are modern movies which have all received either more or ~equivalent hype/box office, yet except for Nemo at #106 (which IMO it deserves) none of them poke into the top 250 list. Fellowship and TTT are both in the top 10 (hey look, TTT has pulled ahead of Citizen Kane!). If hype had anything to do with getting on the lists, I'd think that some of those 'other' movies would have made an appearance on the top 250 (and Nemo would have moved a lot higher up).
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…