Hmm. I guess I don't really know what to say if people don't like statistics. Yes, there are gaffs in the LotR series- and yes people have been able to find them (apparently many of them). A few things to keep in mind about how a movie earns a 'gaff count':
1) multiple viewings- most of these things aren't visible on the first show, so people have to watch the movie multiple times to catch them.
In General, this means either the people are sick masochists, or they enjoyed the movie in the first place.
2) viewers with an eye for detail- specifically a critical eye. Viewers for a movie like LotR fits the bill, the teenage female sort that watched Titanic a million times does not.
3) DGoij's formula- I agree, the longer the movie, and the more complex the shooting (i.e., a fantasy setting where half the cast is supposed to be half the height of the rest of the cast), the more 'gaffs' are bound to happen. This is not sloppiness, this is simple law of averages.
What's my point? I guess it's that we shouldn't be surprised that so many gaffs have been spotted in LotR, given the complexity of the shoot, length of the movies, audience, and repeat viewership. Does this mean the movies are poorly filmed, or lack technical merit? I'd say the fact that both films have been nominated in categories such as:
editing
cinematography
production design
and sound; in both the Oscars AND the BAFTAs indicate that the professionals think that these movies are technically pretty good, among the best of their respective years, in fact. I guess I'm just astounded that people can honestly insist that these films are poorly put together. Again, my mantra is that everyone is entitled to their opinion, but that (as far as any statistics can show) the consensus opinion is that the LotR films are technically very good, and they have been very pleasing to both the critics and the 'average' man alike.
DGoeij, I am under the impression that you didn't look at any of the links that I provided. Yes people do enjoy movies like 'Beverly
Hills Cop III' and 'Titanic'- that is why both those movies were financially succesful. The links I provided addressed a different question: 'how good do people think these movies were?' to put things in perspective, on IMDB Titanic got a rating (out of 10) of 6.9, Beverly Hills Cop III received a 4.7. The #250th ranked movie on IMDB (after 250 they stop ranking) got a rating of 7.7. Clearly these statistics are independent of box office. If you'd like to know the top 10 rankings, they are:
1 Godfather, The (1972) 9.0/10 (78935 votes)
2 Shawshank Redemption, The (1994) 8.9/10 (99477 votes)
3 Godfather: Part II, The (1974) 8.8/10 (45368 votes)
4 Schindler's List (1993) 8.7/10 (69062 votes)
5 Casablanca (1942) 8.7/10 (46632 votes)
6 Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of
the Ring, The (2001) 8.7/10 (103188 votes)
7 Citizen Kane (1941) 8.7/10 (43691 votes)
8 Lord of the Rings: The Two
Towers, The (2002) 8.7/10 (55822 votes)
9 Shichinin no samurai (1954) 8.7/10 (18986 votes) [Seven Samarai]
10 Star
Wars (1977) 8.7/10 (99724 votes)
Again, there is no pleasing everyone, but MOST people will agree that these are ten pretty good movies. It's also worth noting that only three movies are both on the IMDB top 10
and, and the top 10 worldwide gross: Star Wars (#10 on both), The Two Towers (#4 all time Box office, #8 on IMDB), and the Fellowship of the Ring (#7 all time Box office, #6 on IMDB). Think about that- no other film in history has gotten on these two lists, yet FotR and TT did so without even having a 'true' ending to their respective stories- they are just parts of the whole!! To me that is absolutely mind-boggling.
Joxy- about book sales- I can't find any solid figures, but BBC put LotR as the top selling book in Britain in 2002, by a margin of 889,895 units sold to 748,099 for Philip Pullman's 'His Dark
Materials' (
http://shopping.guardian.co.uk/books/story/0,1587,969501,00.html). How does this compare to the normal selling of the book (i.e. before the movies)? I can't say for sure, but just prior to the release of the movies book sales for LotR went up 400% (
http://enjoyment.independent.co.uk/books/news/story.jsp?story=92995). This leaves me relatively unworried that the movies are somehow hurting sales of the
books. And I hope you take a look at IMDB- it's great for any sort of movie things you want to know, and it has many user reviews for almost every movie, regardless of nation of origin or size of release.