• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace


Promoting other sites, tsk tsk.
And I must say that, apart from perhaps Star Wars and the HP movies, the hype seems an awfull lot bigger at this side of the pont. I can't find a single person that not went to these movies, especially since if no. 3 is coming out this December, everybody who did not see the first is frantically trying to catch up. The mouth to mouth advertising of these movies is incredible. If that really affects this site I couldn't tell and apparently it would be the first time in any case.

And about the Ents, you might wish to re-read the chapters concerning them and then re-view TTT. The Ents were slow at decision making, not slow-witted as portrayed by PJ. It didn't take Treebeard half his dialogue to decide that the Hobbits weren't orcs, he noticed that first time round.
 


i forgot about Helms Deep for a sec, i apologize for we DID see Aragorn embracing leadership there(no matter how ridicilously he & Theoden charged into the battle)

Gimli has been a joke ever since the company left the Mines of Moria

As opposed to the hasty tree-tribe we saw in the books? You might want to re-read those chapters.

i wasn't talking about their phisical abilities(i see now i should have been clearer), i'm talking about their wits, they seem rather "slow" in more than one way(if you know what i mean)

Are you referring to the fact that Theoden didn't take his 100+ soldiers and ride head-first into the 10,000 Uruk-hai? There's a mile-wide line between prudent and cowardly.

the way i see it when watching the movie is Theoden acting rather cowardice towards the threat, but perhaps i fault him for the faults Peter Jackson made, giving us an army of 12 to 60 year olds(not to mention the constant shots of crying children/women in the middle of the battle when the fact they were scared/in danger had already been established)

I think your bully is the same man who sacrificed his own life for a Hobbit who he had just met (one who had obviously lied to him, at that). I want to meet a bully like that.

my bully is the man placing his sword cleanly on our beloved hobbits chain(i dare not say 'throat') & uses rather excessive force in taking him(i dare not say 'kidnap') him, i know his Book parallell at first wasn't too fond of the Hobbits but this faramir looks just plain evil(even more so than his brother in FOTR)



Alas he makes his "presence felt" with his great evil eye, the shown perfectly in the Fellowship when we only get to see him when our one is wearing the wicked ring, in TTT we suddenly get to see an actual EYE on a tower, i'd rather Frodo mention it in detail or perhaps even Gollum bring it up


i like what Peter is trying to portray, but the actual porttrayal is rather unsettling(i dare not say 'incestuos')



i loved the Dead Marshes scene, not too fond of the Osgiliath one, once again i like what Peter is trying to portray, but it just seems so...cheap( i dare not say 'Hollywood')


i could honestly care less about this LOTR bandwagon everybody seems to be on, lists differ, i have not seen the whole list you refer to but i hope they're not trying to tell me TTT is put above a movie similar to it like say "The Empire Strikes Back"

i don't want it to seem i'm some jealous Star Wars fan who is out for revenge because of the lack of appreciation for the new movies, but the(finished) Star Wars trilogy is the best comparable franchise i can think of now, & i have yet to meet someone who can tell me with a straight face TTT is superior to ESB(FOTR to ANH i can understand, even if i do not agree)

all in all, perhaps when ROTK drops TTT will have more significance(perhaps PJ put things in there us "purists" cannot comprehent without the complete picture) & i will pray it to be so
 
To begin with, raging popularity does not necessarily validate something. Many things that were extremely popular in their time eventually fade when the hoopla dies away. If Jackson remains popular, fine! There are many "popular" things in this culture - especially in the entertainment media - that I do not enjoy although I certainly would not deny others their pleasure.

As for Theoden's cowardice, I was speaking of his refusal to face Saruman when asked to by Gandalf. He talks only of "running for the hills". Eventually, he is forced by circumstance to defend himself, but Jackson's Theoden is a far cry from Tolkien's elderly noble king who chooses to ride into battle against a very strong and wicked foe. If one cannot discern the difference between the two, then it certainly doesn't surprise me that these films are so popular.

Yes, I go back to the characters. I find many (most?) of Jackson's characters unpleasant (and that is on their own, mind you, not in any connection to the book!). I do not care for films that have as their "heroes", unpleasant characters. Maybe this is an age of "anti-heroes" and bad good guys (and good bad guys), but I am from the old school. I like my heroes "heroic". That doesn't mean that they don't have faults, don't make mistakes or don't have times of emotional angst - and Tolkien's characters had all of those things - but their character is true, their nature generous and their person at least relatively pure. Jackson gives us a potpourri of characters, most of whom are far, far darker (and no less believable thereby) than their book personas. There was no reason for this other than Jackson's own "darker" vision of the world which seemingly made him believe that no audience would accept higher and better personal virtues in the films' characters - and that's sad.
 
If you really mean that, then I must conclude that you devote your time on the forum to writing for it, and give no time to reading other posts. I very rarely express total dissatisfaction, and often go as far as admitting, even proudly claiming, that I actually LIKE much of the content of FOTR, and some of that of TTT. That is what I call qualified satisfaction, that is what I have with the films, and that is what I have said, many times. If, as I suggest, you have not taken the time to read the relevant postings then that is your own business, your own loss may I say, but please do not load your thoughts on the matter on to "most people"; let THEM speak for themselves - when they'll get the same answer from me!
I'm not going to make the effort of ploughing through that "myriad", but I'll allow myself to remind you that, after the release of the ROTK preview on DVD, I actually started a thread on the strong possibility that ROTK might actually turn out to be quite a good film!
 
Take it as you will.

If I didn't give time to reading other posts I would have nothing to reply to, it's simple fact. As to your "like" of the movies, this has improved over time, I must say. Although, I still think most people would (incorrectly) agree with me.

Oh, and you forgot to mention the thread you started about TTT, called "Favorite Moments." How's that for not reading, eh?
 

basically, i don't mind dark heros(heck, look at Anakin Skywalker) but this is Lord of the Rings - the books that are undoubtly a part of my life

as much as people say i should look at it as "Peter Jacksons LOTR", i just isn't "Peter Jacksons" as long as it is called "Lord of the Rings:..."

i can't look at Aragorn & accept a new version mainly because it is Aragorn , a person i feel like i've grown up with, the same with all the other characters

i can enjoy the movies, heck, Fellowship of the Ring is a very good movie, i can honestly say i even love it

i can enjoy the Two Towers, but i feel i can't love it & never will(i pray for the Extended Version)

when i watched the new trailer of Return of the King, i felt like a child again, my heart was beating faster & faster, offcourse i cringed at the Narsil/Elrond/Aragorn scenes but i felt hope again

guess ill just have to wait & see
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I am glad to see that others have found the same thing: that their delight in FOTR and their hopes for ROTK have been marred by TTT. For a while there, I thought I was the only one who had that problem.

That makes two of us. I managed to see the Fellowship of the Ring 14 times; I saw the Two Towers twice and that was enough. And I haven't been able to watch the first movie for months now: it's almost impossible for me to do it as I'll then be thinking on how ridiculous the story gets afterwards, which does take away much of the beauty I was once able to see in the Fellowship.

I came here away from a portuguese Tolkien forum were most if not all of the users seemed to be as much fans of Peter Jackson as they were of Tolkien; once in a while it felt as if they were more of the first kind. Sometimes I ended up feeling that to most there the greater work of art are the movies, not the books. It was interesting to see several people defend the movie with great vigour, arguing that it's a good (or even excellent) adaptation, when they themselves admitted that it has been years and years since the last time they read the book: how can such people have any considerable basis for te critical opinion they intended to have is one heck of a mistery to me, but then again, most people today don't seem worried with greater detp in analysis: general and basic, easy to consume things are prefered, though then they often try to make assumptions to which such low knowledge proves to be a weak foundation.

It felt as if people were contemplating a book with some great illustrations, beautiful cover, lovely printing, good quality paper but...little were those that were really reading it in it's dept and detail. To find others that do see behind the fireworks of visual effects and actually do look at details in plot constrution and character working feels almost like a blessing.
 
I am inclined to agree that many of Mr. Jackson's most ardent supporters are little concerned about what has happened to the story in his hands as long as he has produced a "watchable" and exiting film. As long as the names and the general plot line is the same, they believe that he has more than done justice to the story and maybe, even, greatly improved upon it.

And, of course, there are those who know and love the story and love the films simply because its about the closest they feel they are ever going to get to seeing it brought to the screen. They are therefore willing to overlook what Jackson has done to it as long as they can bathe in the "atmosphere" of Middle-earth. Unfortunately, for me, all the "visuals" do not a LOTR make.
 
Originally posted by Gandalf White
....you forgot to mention the thread you started about TTT, called "Favorite Moments." How's that for not reading, eh?
Actually I, with all due modesty, deliberately failed to mention it!
So, thanks for pointing it out, and I hope it goes a little way towards alleviating your thought that "The fact that you enjoy the movies is seemingly never let through".
I did mention though the one about the optimism arising from the preview of ROTK, and I stick by that as much as I still do about the favourite moments.
I DO like PARTS of the two films so far!
 

And that's the truth of the whole matter isn't it? I sometimes feel that the candy-diet, Hollywood fluff has won out over a truly good storyline and deep characters. Unfortunately, most people would rather see a fluff movie with lots of action and ignore the rest. They obviously have not internalized and really viewed Tolkien's book for what it is: a masterpiece of storytelling, history and mythology.

It is these supporters that bother me because they then criticize those of us who have grown up with, and internalized LoTR that expected a truer version that adheres to the standard more than it did. To justify their meagre knowledge of what ME's characters and storyline should have been, they say foolishness like, "You all want an exact representation, well that's dumb", and "Be thankful with what you got", all the while missing what Jackson's movie has been missing from the start: that a poor screenplay, modified characters and fight scenes galore to cover the mess, do not make a good movie from a masterful book.

The answer from these folks?: Who cares! Bring on Xen Arwen! She's a hotty!"
 
I tend to agree that many who find no problem with Jackson's "reinvention" of the characters did not really "digest" them in the book. They saw Aragorn as a sort of Middle-earth Superman, untempted, unchallenged and virtually undefeatable. However, when one reads the book (and assorted commentary, including the author's) one realizes that Aragorn is anything but a 'superman'; that he is filled with self-doubt - including doubts about his "worthiness" to take Gandalf's place as leader of the Fellowship - and many other "internal conflicts" besides. It isn't until he meets with Eomer that he begins to present himself as what he is: the legitimate heir of Elendil and Numenor. He changes after Parth Galen (and Boromir's death) from Strider to Aragorn, but it is hardly a seamless or painless transition. If Jackson had taken the time and trouble, he would have found a character of infinite worth and depth. He didn't have to "invent" a conflicted, "anti-hero" in order to have a character with some "reality". Furthermore, in Mortensen he had an actor who could have given Tolkien's character the three dimensional portrayal that would have done him justice. Sadly, however, Jackson opted for modern psychobabble and soap opera angst.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....in Mortensen he had an actor who could have given Tolkien's character the three dimensional portrayal that would have done him justice.
This reflects one of the sadder aspects of the whole enterprise: that so many talented - and expensive - actors have been given so little that is worthwhile to do.
Certainly Tolkien's Aragorn, Eomer, Boromir, and Faramir, would have given their portrayers the opportunity to show their talents and skills. And surely McKellen and Lee must have expected
to be given better opportunities than hobbit-cuddling, orc-birthing, and mutual wizard-swinging?!
 
I also have had a hard time enjoying the FOTR (a great movie)since I saw TTT...much like the new "Star Wars" affected my feelings towards the two wonderful movies that preceeded it ("return of the jedi" not included)...


I think the new version of Aragorn is so hard to accept because Viggo, although a good actor (as i know Mrs. M will agree ), is WRONG FOR THE PART. He doesn't have the presence or kingly quality of Aragorn....he's a character actor for a reason! I think even PJ senses it, and that's why so much screen time is devoted to PROVING to us (again and again) what a great leader he is. Combined, of course, with PJ's inability to show Aragorn's indecision and vulnerabilities. Two of A's most telling moments (IMHO) in LOTR are when he...
1. talks to Frodo about wanting friendship and his lonliness
2. pushes the company at breakneck speed out of Moria because he is so distracted about being in charge without Gandalf

Both of which PJ dropped.

As far as ROTK, am I the only one who doesn't see much hope in the preview? It seems PJ is picking up the same main ideas of how to proceed from TTT... Aragorn (getting his sword was MOST of the preview!) and Arwen (stretching her "acting" limits in 30 seconds... not to mention Elrond) and big battle scenes... Besides Shelob and Eowyn, importance given to all the wrong themes.

But I still cling to hope for TTT EE and ROTK, darn it!
 
I DO think that Mortensen could have been "courageous" and kingly - had he been given the chance. Even in the book, Aragorn is loathe to take Gandalf's place as the leader of the Fellowship since he wished to go with Boromir to fight for Gondor. Furthermore, he had little or no confidence in his ability to accomplish the quest since he did not really believe in it (as noted in his conversation with Gandalf before they attempted the Redhorn Gate).

Physically, Mortensen was a real winner! Remember, in FOTR, Tolkien refers to Aragorn's "strange, eager face". He was not "elven fair" and looked extremely disreputable as Strider the Ranger. It is only in glimpses we see his nobility physically: at Cerin Amroth, before Eomer etc. Mortensen could have acted that way but he was/is a victim of his material and not the other way round.
 
Originally posted by simbelmyne
But I still cling to hope for TTT EE and ROTK, darn it!
IMO even as a staunch purist, the FoTR EE fully redeemed the movie in my eyes as a (somewhat) faithful adaptation. The EE only had the Arwen/Ford fiasco and Aragorn's reluctance to claim his title to work around and the EE did that quite satisfactory despite the annoying nuances throughout.

Unfortunately, TTT has strayed even further from the source and already has to compensate for the changes/additions made in FoTR. Nothing added to TTT EE can help the horrible damage already done to Faramir's bullish attitude and taking the ring to Osgiliath, Treebeard's being 'tricked' into attacking Isengard by Merry and Pippin, and cowardly Theoden.

FoTR EE added extra scenes that had nothing to do with the changes (other than Aragorn's reluctance) but in other areas that fleshed out the poor editing and made the story more cohesive. Despite all the book stuff concerning Ents that will be thrown in, it doesn't change the false fact that ultimately, Treebeard initially doesn't want anything to do with attacking Isengard. TTT EE has to work around massive changes in character that cannot be erased, nor forgotten. Even if the background information of Boromir, Faramir, and Denethor DOES shine some light as to movie Faramir's motives behind his actions, it doesn't help the fact that he DID what he did when he shouldn't have done it. If the EE justifies those actions, that means that movie Faramir's motives and actions are totally different then Tolkien! The fact is, is that the TTT can't follow the book, but must follow the deviations made in FoTR for proper continuance in the flow of the trilogy.

Therefore, it is only logical to predict that RoTK will have to follow the same format: to work off the changes from FoTR and TTT. With this occuring, we can see a further moving away from the source. It is kind of like making a photocopy of a photocopy of a photocopy while ignoring the initial source. Eventually the quality you get is fairly poor compared to the original.

However, the EE can only help the poor theatre version to become more cohesive.
 

really ?, for me it's the opposite

in a (modernday) weird way the prequels actually turned my StarWars "liking" into a "fascination", maybe it's because i never really was a fan of the old movies but after the prequels(especially Attack of the Clones) StarWars has perhaps even overcome my love for LOTR

but anyway, i have unwillingly caught wind of a "Sauron/Aragorn" confrontation waiting to happen. I thought it weird when Elijah said he watched TROTK's "Vader vs.Luke" rehearsals but i never thought PJ would go as far as changing that much

i bought the Two Towers on digital video yesterday & watched it after a years passing from when i watched it in theaters

my main annoyance is Gimli, can anyone seriously give me one line from the movie where Gimli is being serious ?
my kid brother(conflicted over being a "SW geek" or "LOTR nerd" as he calls it) pointed out even Jar Jar Binks had his purpose/serious moments in his movies, regardless of how little i like PJs Faramir/Aragorn, at least he has made them serious characters with purpose, watching Gimli was like the continuos ringing of a mobile phone - i just could not keep on ignoring it

i didn't mind the Aragorn/Arwen scenes but right after that there's the infamous "death" of Aragorn, i have read that this was to symbolise the death of Strider the Ranger/Birth of King Aragorn, but if PJ seriously intended for that - i must admit he failed horribly

of course Legolas looks like a reject for the recent Matrix sequel(revolution i think)

i have spent enough time discussing Frodo/Aragorn/Faramir/Ents/Sauron(an actual EYE, c'mon now)/Elrond to do so again, but i cannot remember how i felt watching Gimli in the theaters - maybe it just flew past me

i actually like the movie more than when i first saw it but it is still a bad center/sequel for a trilogy

tonight i will watch the extras to see if PJ has some explanations/add ons that will perhaps make me understand his movie more
 
my main annoyance is Gimli, can anyone seriously give me one line from the movie where Gimli is being serious ?
"Look, it is one of the hobbit's belts," or something like that.

Gimli was rather overused as comic relief, perhaps PJ's interpretation of dwarves.

Still I wouldn't call the movie a "bad" middle, merely inferior to FotR, and hopefully far inferior to RotK.
 
Originally posted by Sephiroth
my main annoyance is Gimli, can anyone seriously give me one line from the movie where Gimli is being serious ?

For any keeping score, that is nineteen serious (at least what I thought were serious) lines, vs. seventeen comedic lines (I didn't count various grunts and affirmations, and I combined some lines which had no intervening dialogue). A near thing, though eleven of the seventeen comedic lines came either during the Warg battle or Helm's Deep, and to be fair Gimli was fairly funny in the books at Helm's Deep. Of course, I didn't tally in the physical humor ...
 
what about all the comedic lines from Treabeard..... should count that in with the Gimli ones
 
Originally posted by Gandalf White

Still I wouldn't call the movie a "bad" middle, merely inferior to FotR, and hopefully far inferior to RotK.

not necessarily "bad", to my suprise i actually liked the movie pretty much when i watched it on DVD

it just nags me to be reminded of (the infamous words of Ms.Maggot)what could have been

the part of Sam/Frodo/Gollum didn't actually advance except for terms of phisical distance, when we see them walking off they're practically the same as when the movie opens with them, Gollum is still(or yet again) evil, Frodo still struggling, Sam still watching out for him, the whole "Frodo choosing Gollum over Sam" is interesting, but not on a large scale since it was basically established in one scene

Gimli is still mainly a joke, Legolas is still a posterboy

watching the extras gave me a better understanding of PJ's Aragorn though, although i(&others) prefer Book-Aragorn over this one it is interesting to see what he has done with him(showing the "Boromir" side in Aragorn as PJ calls it)

i was surprised to see Nothing whatsoever on Faramir on the extras but perhaps the EE will conjure up something

all in all, it's more of a "average" centerpiece than a "bad" one, good movie though

i shall go back & watch the extras from FOTR EE just out of pure curiosity now
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…