Originally posted by aragil
I can't stop promoting IMDB (I'm not under their employ, honest!). They actually do have message boards as well as lists, but of course their MBs are much less personal (and friendly) than TTF. However, I note (with some satisfaction) that their lists seem to be relatively hype-impervious. Titanic, Star Wars ep I, the Phantom Menace, Harry Potter (1&2), Spiderman, Matrix II, Pirates of the Caribbean and Finding Nemo are modern movies which have all received either more or ~equivalent hype/box office, yet except for Nemo at #106 (which IMO it deserves) none of them poke into the top 250 list. Fellowship and TTT are both in the top 10 (hey look, TTT has pulled ahead of Citizen Kane!). If hype had anything to do with getting on the lists, I'd think that some of those 'other' movies would have made an appearance on the top 250 (and Nemo would have moved a lot higher up).
As opposed to the hasty tree-tribe we saw in the books? You might want to re-read those chapters.
Are you referring to the fact that Theoden didn't take his 100+ soldiers and ride head-first into the 10,000 Uruk-hai? There's a mile-wide line between prudent and cowardly.
I think your bully is the same man who sacrificed his own life for a Hobbit who he had just met (one who had obviously lied to him, at that). I want to meet a bully like that.
I don't know what you would have preferred here. Anytime Sauron makes his presence felt in the books, it is through his chosen motif of 'the eye' (the insignias on his henchmen as well as his projection in Frodo's mind). If you wanted to give him a visual presence in the movie, it only makes sense to use this visual (IMO).
Frankly, in the books Elrond was not thrilled with Arwen's choice either. Elrond's description of what would conditionally happen to Arwen if she chose Aragorn is straight out of what actually did happen to her in the books. I for one am glad that they found a way to bring that part of the books into the movie, and I think it was far more effective than having it occur at the end of the third film.
I don't know what to make of this complaint. The overfly in the Dead Marshes was pretty much spot-on from the books, and the scene in Osgiliath was reminiscent (though obviously much changed) of what happened to Frodo at the bridge to Minas Morgul.
I can't stop promoting IMDB (I'm not under their employ, honest!). They actually do have message boards as well as lists, but of course their MBs are much less personal (and friendly) than TTF. However, I note (with some satisfaction) that their lists seem to be relatively hype-impervious. Titanic, Star Wars ep I, the Phantom Menace, Harry Potter (1&2), Spiderman, Matrix II, Pirates of the Caribbean and Finding Nemo are modern movies which have all received either more or ~equivalent hype/box office, yet except for Nemo at #106 (which IMO it deserves) none of them poke into the top 250 list. Fellowship and TTT are both in the top 10 (hey look, TTT has pulled ahead of Citizen Kane!). If hype had anything to do with getting on the lists, I'd think that some of those 'other' movies would have made an appearance on the top 250 (and Nemo would have moved a lot higher up).
If you really mean that, then I must conclude that you devote your time on the forum to writing for it, and give no time to reading other posts. I very rarely express total dissatisfaction, and often go as far as admitting, even proudly claiming, that I actually LIKE much of the content of FOTR, and some of that of TTT. That is what I call qualified satisfaction, that is what I have with the films, and that is what I have said, many times. If, as I suggest, you have not taken the time to read the relevant postings then that is your own business, your own loss may I say, but please do not load your thoughts on the matter on to "most people"; let THEM speak for themselves - when they'll get the same answer from me!Originally posted by Gandalf White
Yes, and this is where you fool most people. Hardly anyone thinks of your posts as "qualified satisfaction," I know it's hard for me to do so. The fact that you enjoy the movies is seemingly never let through in your myriad of posts condemning its faults
Take it as you will.Originally posted by joxy
If you really mean that, then I must conclude that you devote your time on the forum to writing for it, and give no time to reading other posts. I very rarely express total dissatisfaction, and often go as far as admitting, even proudly claiming, that I actually LIKE much of the content of FOTR, and some of that of TTT. That is what I call qualified satisfaction, that is what I have with the films, and that is what I have said, many times. If, as I suggest, you have not taken the time to read the relevant postings then that is your own business, your own loss may I say, but please do not load your thoughts on the matter on to "most people"; let THEM speak for themselves - when they'll get the same answer from me!
I'm not going to make the effort of ploughing through that "myriad", but I'll allow myself to remind you that, after the release of the ROTK preview on DVD, I actually started a thread on the strong possibility that ROTK might actually turn out to be quite a good film!
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
There was no reason for this other than Jackson's own "darker" vision of the world which seemingly made him believe that no audience would accept higher and better personal virtues in the films' characters - and that's sad.
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I am glad to see that others have found the same thing: that their delight in FOTR and their hopes for ROTK have been marred by TTT. For a while there, I thought I was the only one who had that problem.
Actually I, with all due modesty, deliberately failed to mention it!Originally posted by Gandalf White
....you forgot to mention the thread you started about TTT, called "Favorite Moments." How's that for not reading, eh?
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I am inclined to agree that many of Mr. Jackson's most ardent supporters are little concerned about what has happened to the story in his hands as long as he has produced a "watchable" and exiting film. As long as the names and the general plot line is the same, they believe that he has more than done justice to the story and maybe, even, greatly improved upon it.
This reflects one of the sadder aspects of the whole enterprise: that so many talented - and expensive - actors have been given so little that is worthwhile to do.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....in Mortensen he had an actor who could have given Tolkien's character the three dimensional portrayal that would have done him justice.
Originally posted by Sephiroth
i can't look at Aragorn & accept a new version mainly because it is Aragorn , a person i feel like i've grown up with, the same with all the other characters
when i watched the new trailer of Return of the King, i felt like a child again, my heart was beating faster & faster, offcourse i cringed at the Narsil/Elrond/Aragorn scenes but i felt hope again
IMO even as a staunch purist, the FoTR EE fully redeemed the movie in my eyes as a (somewhat) faithful adaptation. The EE only had the Arwen/Ford fiasco and Aragorn's reluctance to claim his title to work around and the EE did that quite satisfactory despite the annoying nuances throughout.Originally posted by simbelmyne
But I still cling to hope for TTT EE and ROTK, darn it!
Originally posted by simbelmyne
I also have had a hard time enjoying the FOTR (a great movie)since I saw TTT...much like the new "Star Wars" affected my feelings towards the two wonderful movies that preceeded it ("return of the jedi" not included)...
"Look, it is one of the hobbit's belts," or something like that.my main annoyance is Gimli, can anyone seriously give me one line from the movie where Gimli is being serious ?
Originally posted by Sephiroth
my main annoyance is Gimli, can anyone seriously give me one line from the movie where Gimli is being serious ?
For any keeping score, that is nineteen serious (at least what I thought were serious) lines, vs. seventeen comedic lines (I didn't count various grunts and affirmations, and I combined some lines which had no intervening dialogue). A near thing, though eleven of the seventeen comedic lines came either during the Warg battle or Helm's Deep, and to be fair Gimli was fairly funny in the books at Helm's Deep. Of course, I didn't tally in the physical humor ...Gimli: <pauses in his steps and huffs> Three days’ and nights’ pursuit. No food. No rest. And no sign of our quarry but what bare rock can tell. <Runs after his companions.>
...
Gimli: Give me your name, Horsemaster, and I shall give you mine.
...
Gimli: But there were two hobbits. Did you see two hobbits with them?
...
Gimli: It’s one of their wee belts. {close enough, GW}... We failed them.
...
Gimli: Fangorn. What madness drove them in there?
...
Gimli: <Spits> Ptui! Orc blood.
...
Gimli: The air is so close in here.
...
Gimli: Gandalf!
...
Gimli: You’ll find more cheer in a graveyard.
...
Gimli: <Growls> I would stay still, if I were you.
...
Gimli: Helm’s Deep! They flee to the mountains when they should stand and fight. Who will defend them if not their king.
...
Gimli: <Standing over the dying Orc> Tell me what happened and I will ease your passing.
...
Gimli: <Going up to Éowyn> My lady... He fell...
...
Gimli: <Pushing his way through the crowd.> Where is he? Where is he? Get out of the way. I’m gonna kill him! <He sees Aragorn.> You are the luckiest, the canniest and the most reckless man I ever knew! <He hugs Aragorn.> Bless you, laddie!
...
Gimli: This is no rabble of mindless Orcs. These are Uruk-hai. Their armor is thick and their shields broad.
...
Gimli: Most have seen too many winters.
...
Gimli: <Puts a hand on Legolas> Let him go, lad. Let him be.
...
Gimli: Well lad, whatever luck you live by, let’s hope it lasts the night.
...
Gimli: The sun is rising.
Originally posted by Gandalf White
Still I wouldn't call the movie a "bad" middle, merely inferior to FotR, and hopefully far inferior to RotK.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?