Unfortunately for the character, PJ failled to understand that a nobler man than
Boromir doesn't equal a
Faramir, even if he has the right hair colour, which the movie character does not! And his twisted idea of a noble man is of he who is able to reject
the Ring and lives to tell it: thus Boromir died and Faramir survived.
At least that's what we get not only from the movie but also from PJ's arguments that Faramir was still there, only he decided to make things a bit harder to, in the end he thought, still present
Denethor's son as he trully is..., hence, PJ's idiotic "genius" concluded, Faramir is better than Boromir. Again, unfortunately for the character, not only did PJ failled to grasp the dept of Faramir's nobility, he also failled to produce one who was nobler than his brother.
Why did noble Faramir refused the Ring? If the director had given enough attention to his own work instead of focusing on his hiper-productive ego he would have found several clues in the first movie. There are three characters that reject the Ring, another contradiction to PJ's bogus argument on his changes to Boromir's brother:
Galadriel,
Gandalf and
Aragorn. All of them are lore-wise, at least enough to know what the Ring is, what it does, how it works and why it had to be destroyed: Gandalf shows that when he tells
Frodo why he cannot take it, while Aragorn also knows what he's saying at the
Council of Elrond when Boromir suggests they use it against
Sauron; and Galadriel, well, goes without saying, I guess.
The similarities between
Isildur's heir and Faramir should also be noted: both living memories of
Númenor, both
men of
Numenorean blood. In the book,
Sam tells his captor he sees a look of wizard in him, to which Faramir answers that the
hobbit's probably discerning "
from far away the air of Númenor". And like any good
man of old, Faramir was naturally deep-minded, not to mention his physical traits that sometimes do seem to have a bit of
elvish (1). Also common to both men is the fact that at one point in their lives Gandalf played some sort of role in their education, hence Faramir's close relationship with Mithandir and Denethor accusation to his son that he's a "wizard's pupil" in Book V, chapter IV.
So why was Faramir the kind of man that would reject the Ring right on the spot without a second thought? Because he had the necessary basis to do so: knowledge, wisdom, strengh of will and character, the very things that PJ's Faramir lacks. Like Aragorn he was of Numenorean blood, like Aragorn he knwen the lore and was deep-minded, like Aragorn he had been learned something from Gandalf: if PJ was anything close to coherent, he would have given Faramir that same capacity to resist the Ring he gave to Aragorn at
Amon Hen.
So no, to in the end reject it or regardless of any intention to give the Ring to his father and not to keep it to himself - one of the most riculous arguments I have ever heard - is not enough! Faramir is not in the movie, even if there is a guy with a different hair colour but with the same name, who also claims to be the brother of Boromir and the son of Denethor and in the end refuses to take the Ring, wondering around in the movie. Once more, the resemblances with
Tolkien's story is simply superficial, even if some do prefer to pretend that that's not the case: how people can get so desperate over the production of a movie and are willing to have any over none - even if the
any stinks - is something I find hard to understand. Does their enjoyment and love for Tolkien's work (or its quality) depends on it being made into a movie or not?
(1) - From what I've read some time ago on the internet, it appears that Faramir does have some elvish blood in him, something related to the geneolagy of the
princes of Dol Amroth. Any ideas?