• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace

Evanescence

New Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2003
Messages
6
It is getting tireing reading how everyone hates Peter Jackson and his interpretation. How is it even CONCIEVABLE to do a direct translation from book to film? It CAN NOT BE DONE. What Jackson has created is a masterpiece that deviates from the book for various LOGICAL reasons. These films are better then no films, and (for me) seeing and believing tolkiens universe in a different formant is bewilderating and a priveledge. Thank you peter for all you have done.
 
First off, welcome to the Forum! :)

I'll get to this post before the purists do, possibly save you from a lecturing! ;)

To clarify, I am a movie lover. They are my favorite motion pictures ever. However, nothing is perfect.

Purists don't "hate" PJ, nor do they hate his movies in their entirety. They are not looking for an exact interpretation. For the most part, they are merely annoyed over the parts that PJ changed that really could have been left as Tolkien wrote them. Read that last sentence again as it is the main issue in this endless debate.

Please, don't be unwilling to admit there are unnecessary changes; there are.

i.e.

Good change: Tom Bombadil

Bad change: Theoden

The best way to go is to admit that there are differences, that these movies could have been even better if the real "script" had been followed, but to also realize that they still kick....errr...rear end, shall we say. ;)
 
I've seen the endless debate here and have debated some myself. A few nights ago, I watched the DVD of TTT again, just enjoying it as a movie, not comparing it to the book. It's a really good movie, one of the best I've ever seen, and I was really glad to see it again! One could quibble about Theoden and Faramir, but what's the point. It's a movie, a creative work of art on celluloid.

In the end, "The Lord of The Rings," whether as a book or a film, is just a story. It's a very good story, but it's fiction and fantasy. Neither J.R.R. Tolkien nor Peter Jackson should be worshipped, as some seem to do, though they should be thanked. I for one will enjoy the films for what they are, not what they could have been, because the films have already been made, and in my view, they're works of art, just as the book is!
 
Peter Jackson is definitely NOT a disgrace, he has a very creative mind & keen eye on visual art

i do feel however his adaptations of the Lord of the Rings(mostly TTT) is a disgrace

i understand the impossibility of putting a book of that magnitude on film is huge

but c'mon now,

Aragorn falling off a Cliff ??, i think even the fans of the movies will agree that this was highly unnecessary

Faramir ??, didn't we just sit through 4 hours of Boromir already ? now we get to see him again ?

Arwen ??, one word: Why ?

these are few of the changes that not excusable, i feel it would've been better if Mr. Jackson had created his own movie trilogy instead of Tolkiens

cutting parts out is one thing
changing a few parts another

but adding entire new material is just...nothing, it's void & not supposed to be there

i want to enjoy it but i can't cause i want to watch the Two Towers, not the Two Loves One
 
Originally posted by Gandalf White
Agh, Boromir and Faramir are not alike. This will be explored even more in the EE.
No, indeed! They are not alike in the book: Boromir, though a noble, good and kindly man, is a warrior and little more - unlike both his father and his brother. He has nowhere near the depth of nobility that his brother Faramir has. Indeed, after Aragorn, Faramir is the most noble man in Middle-earth according to Tolkien. The Blood of Numenor runs "nearly true" in him.

And they are not alike in the films either. However, the difference here is that Boromir is by far the more noble of the two. He at least did not act like a bully with Frodo and Sam (and even had the others not been present, one doubts he would have done so anyway!) nor does he use his dagger to dandle the Ring while it is on the chain around the Bearer's neck! Frankly, for the short time we got to see him in TTT, Faramir was a rather hateful fellow only slightly better in character than Wormtongue.

I agree! Boromir and Faramir weren't alike. Not in the book where Faramir was the better man nor in the films where Boromir was decidedly the better man. And so, you see, the problem appears to be that even when Jackson seems to be making some effort to follow Tolkien, he winds up doing the exact opposite.
 
I think that Jackson did the job to the best of his abilities, which is unfortunate.
 
Originally posted by Sephiroth

but c'mon now,

Aragorn falling off a Cliff ??, i think even the fans of the movies will agree that this was highly unnecessary

Well, where was it, crap, I forgot, well, I'll look for it later. But anyway, Tolkien wrote that Warg riders constantly attacked Rohan during the time of FotR and TTT. So, I thought the battle sence between the Rohirrim and Wargs was alright by "Tolkien" but yes, it was dumb to have Aragorn fall off the cliff. Movie wise, it was more drama, it never really changed the story, but yeah, still, dumb......
 
Originally posted by Valdarmyr
One could quibble about Theoden and Faramir, but what's the point. It's a movie, a creative work of art on celluloid.

I know this is supposed to be a thread praising PJ, BUT I COULDN"T STAY AWAY!! :)

My question is, aren't we a part of this forum to quibble about these things? What's the point if everyone has the same opinion? I agree with you, Valdarmyr, that the movie is a creative effort that stands apart from LOTR. But does that make it a work of art? I say no...TTT is mostly thoughtless and slapped together. If you believe there are points to argue about Faramir or Theoden, do you think that TTT being a movie justifies the way their characters were altered? The movie could have been just as "good" without drastically changing their personalities. this is all my opinion, of course. Let me know what you think...
 
is mostly thoughtless and slapped together


WHAT!?!?!?!? How could someone create an awesome and amazing film just in the visual sense and you say it is thoughtless and slapped together. Cmon, be realistic, see both sides of the argument and dont be single minded. I agree that Jackson should not have had Aragorn fall of the cliff, and some other issues (faramir being a jerk to frodo for one) but slapped together???
 
Originally posted by Evanescence
is mostly thoughtless and slapped together


WHAT!?!?!?!? How could someone create an awesome and amazing film just in the visual sense and you say it is thoughtless and slapped together. Cmon, be realistic, see both sides of the argument and dont be single minded. I agree that Jackson should not have had Aragorn fall of the cliff, and some other issues (faramir being a jerk to frodo for one) but slapped together???
Awesome and amazing in the "visual sense" does not make a great film. If that were the case, then travelogues would be high on the list of classics.

The trouble with TTT (among other things) is that Jackson was content to "lean" upon his visuals in the hopes that they would "make up" for his mediocre plot and poor editing (not to mention his bastardization of the characters!). They don't. Heaven alone knows why he felt he had to maim Tolkien's characters or why he had to, in his own words, "depart" so far from the book in the second film. There was no cinematic need to do either. However, both were the result of his own judgment as director and therefore he has left himself open to perfectly valid criticism in both instances.
 
Originally posted by Evanescence
be realistic, see both sides of the argument and dont be single minded.

The visuals were incredible, the acting was stellar and there were some fantastic scenes (Gandalf fighting the Balrog, the Black Gate opening, Theoden's transformation)...but around the time Gandalf left to get reinforcements, the merits of the movie left too!
Thoughtless due to the dialogue that doesn't make sense (characters contridicting themselves); making characters act in ways they weren't SET UP TO ACT in FOTR....
Slapped together due to the poor editing (some of the worst being M & P's "conversation" with Treebeard, where dialogue is spliced between scenes), no fluid pacing, and choppy action sequences (also absent in FOTR). So that's my opinion, but I'm always open to hear what others have to say...;)
 
Originally posted by Evanescence
How is it even CONCEIVABLE to do a direct translation from book to film? It CAN NOT BE DONE.
It's EASY to conceive, and it HAS been done.
PJ has done it, in parts of both films. He's done it very well, in those parts.
The massive problem is that he's so inconsistent.
Whether that's because he's incompetent, or because he's perverse, who knows? Isn't he capable of maintaining a high standard, or does he deliberately set about contradicting his abilities?
He IS capable of a near perfect rendition of the material he was privileged to work on, but he either can't or won't remain consistent with himself.
Then to make matters much worse, his technical abilities, which stand up pretty well throughout FOTR, and even improve at the start of TTT, collapse a quarter of the way into TTT, and it becomes, quite simply, a bad film, regardless of its subject.
 
Hmm, well, I'm very dissapointed with some parts of the movie (i.e. Elves at HD, Faramir, Aragorn falling off cliff) But still, come one guys, I've read the books and everthing, and I'm glad there are LotR movies. The movies don't have a bad story at all I think (maybe RotK might it Sauron shows up). The movies still have the same, basic story as the books. The movies will never compare to the books of course, but still, just because something happen the way you wanted (exactly) to happen doesn't make the movie bad. Come on guys, be thankful for it. PJ and crew could have done alot worse. I don't get how TT was a that bad of a film. It is bringing alot of people to the books to.
 
The films follow the essential plot line: hobbit finds Ring; Ring is nasty but hobbit doesn't know it; hobbit gives nasty Ring to nephew; friendly Wizard learns about Ring etc. etc. and eventually Ring is destroyed by the combined efforts of numerous people including hobbit nephew and friendly Wizard. I'm sorry, but simply because the films utilize this plot line does not make them essentially "the same" as the book.

When you change the nature of many of the characters - including some of the most important ones - you have changed the meaning of the work and that's what Jackson has done. Enjoy these films if you will, but don't for a moment believe that they represent an honest and basic recreation of J. R. R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings.
 
Originally posted by Éomond
PJ and crew could have done a lot worse. I don't get how TT was that bad of a film.
They also could, and with $300million dollars to play with certainly SHOULD, have done a great deal better - that's the point.
Just watch the film - you can't miss seeing the sort of blunders that anyone would have managed to avoid in making a home-movie.
 
And this thread takes the way of all threads, winding its way into obscurity, iterating and re-iterating the same ideas of all threads on the movie forums.

We really need to find something new here, people. :rolleyes:
 
Yes, well, we're all sitting around waiting for the other shoe to drop in December. Even the EE of TTT is still 6 weeks away!

It's just that PJ is SUCH a disgrace (well, sort of), it's hard not to talk about it!
 
I did not say the visuals make a great film. I said that for that level of visuals (the best in movies) to have come so far is not slapped sticked together. You need just a little thought behind those visuals... Be thankful.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top