Originally posted by Gandalf White
Agh, Boromir and Faramir are not alike. This will be explored even more in the EE.
No, indeed! They are not alike in the book: Boromir, though a noble, good and kindly man, is a warrior and little more - unlike both his father and his brother. He has nowhere near the depth of nobility that his brother Faramir has. Indeed, after
Aragorn, Faramir is the most noble man in
Middle-earth according to
Tolkien. The Blood of
Numenor runs "nearly true" in him.
And they are not alike in the films either. However, the difference
here is that
Boromir is by far the more noble of the two. He at least did not act like a bully with
Frodo and
Sam (and even had the others not been present, one doubts he would have done so anyway!) nor does he use his dagger to dandle
the Ring while it is on the chain around the Bearer's neck! Frankly, for the short time we got to see him in TTT, Faramir was a rather hateful fellow only slightly better in character than
Wormtongue.
I agree! Boromir and Faramir weren't alike. Not in the book where Faramir was the better man nor in the films where
Boromir was decidedly the better man. And so, you see, the problem appears to be that even when Jackson
seems to be making some effort to follow Tolkien, he winds up doing the exact opposite.